12 ms·
That's because - and everyone but the uninformed or idealists know this - it's an investment product. It's simply not suitable as a currency, because one, infla
by Cthulhu_ 9y ago
That's because - and everyone but the uninformed or idealists know this - it's an investment product. It's simply not suitable as a currency, because one, inflation / instability, and two, it can only do what, a dozen transactions a second, if that? That's not nearly enough to become a viable currency.
- TomMarius 9y agoWhat do you mean, what inflation?
- piqalq 9y agoI think he means the volatility/instability of it.
- Balero 9y agoBitcoin has no inflation, there are only a given number of total bitcoins in existence, which many (myself included) would argue makes it a poor currency.
- TomMarius 9y agoI know, that's why I'm asking what does the commenter mean with inflation in their comment.
- emodendroket 9y agoProbably meant deflation.
- mkirklions 9y ago> there are only a given number of total bitcoins in existence, which many (myself included) would argue makes it a poor currency. I have always question who says this. What makes you think deflation would be bad? My conspiracy is that governments require inflation to print themselves out of bad policy. Without government abilities to do this, the government performs poorly. Common citizens do not lose 2-4% of their income in inflation.
- jonknee 9y ago> What makes you think deflation would be bad? Literally economics 101. Investment grinds to a halt and progress along with it.
- snikeris 9y agoDoes investment really grind to a halt though? I'm thinking people would just demand a higher return on their investments before they parted with their cash. Recently, many countries had negative interest rates. So I suppose people were being incentivized to find "investments" that would return 0% on their money. Was that a good thing? Also, inflation means everyone needs to be investors or the money they worked hard for evaporates. Why should we force Joe Sixpack into being an investor for the good of the economy? He should be able to focus on earning money from his trade without having to worry about investing due to inflation being forced upon him.
- mundo 9y ago> Does investment really grind to a halt though? Well, it's discouraged, but yes, basically. Under inflation, you need to invest money just to stay even. The lower inflation is, the less urgent the need to invest. With deflation, you're somewhat incentivized not to lend. A fixed money supply guarantees deflation, so yes, this would significantly reduce lending and the economic growth that lending stimulates. > Also, inflation means everyone needs to be investors or the money they worked hard for evaporates. Why should we force Joe Sixpack into being an investor for the good of the economy? If Joe Sixpack lives paycheck-to-paycheck he can ignore inflation entirely, it doesn't affect him a whit. Once he gets some savings, if he doesn't like risk he can buy bonds or something and continue ignoring inflation. But since you brought it up and since this seems to be a point of confusion for a lot of people, yes, let's see how a fixed money supply would affect Joe Sixpack. If the government stops printing money, we are guaranteed to get deflation any time the GDP grows, right? With money supply held constant, "The US currency deflated by 2% last year" is equivalent to saying "The US GDP grew by 2% last year." And what makes the GDP grow? Joe Sixpack and his friends, out there mining ore or building furniture or otherwise increasing the amount of value in the world. 2% deflation also means that anyone with savings sees the buying power of their savings increase by 2%. If Scrooge McDuck has $5M in his mattress, his inflation-adjusted net worth increased by $100,000. He can retire and spend the rest of his life living very comfortably on the equivalent of $90k/year, and despite him doing no work, despite him incurring no financial risk, somehow every year he'll get a little wealthier. How is that possible? Who's paying for his life of luxury? Joe Sixpack. Deflation is quite literally a tax by capital on labor. As long as the GDP is increasing, arguing for deflation is tantamount to saying, "I think some of that GDP growth created by workers should go to anyone with money." AFAIK this is universally understood to be a Bad Thing (tm) by virtually everyone.
- acdha 9y agoInvestments need to have intrinsic value. Under the new spin that bitcoin isn’t intended to be a currency, it makes little sense as an investment because there’s no value in any particular set of random numbers. If nobody is using it except for speculation, where’s the incentive to pay to keep that network running?
- blueprint 9y agoI'm not disagreeing with you on the distinction between an investment and a speculative position, but know that the value is in the confirmations of old transactions piled up which make it extremely difficult to retroactively mutate the ledger. Lots of people don't understand that well yet.
- hisabness 9y agoi think the value is also the ability to transfer value relatively quickly without having to sit at a bank for 30 minutes to do so.
- acdha 9y agoBitcoin transaction times aren’t much better - I see recent times in the 15-80 minute range on average, well in the thousands range earlier this year. It’s also odd not to acknowledge that banks have had electronic transfers for decades. You wait seconds for a card transaction and almost every financial institution allows you to do transfers without visiting a physical office.
- gamblor956 9y agoI can transfer value within seconds using Zelle, Venmo, Paypal, Square, etc., for free right where I'm sitting now. Nowhere near a bank. AFAIK, Bitcoin takes a minimum of 10 minutes assuming that I wish to pay the going transaction fee, or as long as 3 days (or even never!!!) if I use a de minimis fee. And that's assuming a significant risk that the value of the value transferred will not have the same value by the time the transaction actually goes through.
- 9y ago
- mkirklions 9y agoSpeak for yourself. I use bitcoin all the time for payments. Peer to peer using coinbase(email) for free and instant to friends. Shift card for free and instant at merchants. Bitcoin is beyond blockchain, companies have built products to trade BTC instantly, free, using the infrastructure already existing. The transaction time 'problem' doesnt really exist if you are into crypto, you know how to use it. And I dont trust USD like I trust BTC. Historically Fiat currencies are awful.
- jonknee 9y ago> Historically Fiat currencies are awful Fiat has ushered in an absolutely amazing period of global growth that has made us unbelievably wealthy. But there is inflation, so why not go with the thing that has no history?
- mkirklions 9y agoWe've had gold, and it was a massive equalizer between major powers. If someone overspent, they had to be smarter until they regained their wealth. Inflation has destroys savings for the masses who keeps cash more than investment. We've seen this a half dozen times in the last 100 years.
- spookthesunset 9y ago> We've had gold, and it was a massive equalizer between major powers. The gold standard was one of the worst fiscal policies ever. Its use was directly responsible for the destruction of millions of lives. Arguing to bring it back shows incredible nativity and a severe lack of history. I suggest you read up on how horrible of an idea the gold standard was before you spout this kind of nonsense.
- mkirklions 9y ago> Its use was directly responsible for the destruction of millions of lives. Oh please, war happens for land, population, and resources. Gold is one of the resources. Anyone want to send this kid the link to 'We invaded Iraq because Saddam wanted to use Euros/RMB to trade oil?'
- wpietri 9y agoI agree it's not an effective currency. But I disagree that it's an investment. I think the correct technical term is speculation. Investment is where you find something producing value in the real world and then buy and hold a piece of that. You're expecting a long stream of returns from the value being produced. Speculation is where you are making a bet on price movements in a way where economic productivity is irrelevant. When people buy and sell commodities and currencies, they're speculating. They don't care about utility. There's no economic value being created, so one's investment doesn't grow during the time you hold, say, gold. Instead, it's a zero-sum activity: considering all participants together, wins and losses are equal. (Well, technically, losses are larger than wins, because there are always overhead costs.) Bitcoin is easy to mistake for an investment, because it's meant to be deflationary. (It was even easier to mistake for one during the period where it only went up.) But I don't think holding Bitcoin means you own a slice of an economically productive asset. I think it's just a bet that the commodity price will go up, in the same way you bet if you buy gold or euros. [1] Warren Buffett has talked about this distinction a lot, over the years. E..g: http://www.businessinsider.com/warren-buffett-investors-versus-sepculators-2016-3 http://www.businessinsider.com/warren-buffett-investors-vers...
- charlesdm 9y agoBy that reasoning, investing in gold is also speculation. Because it only has minimal industrial uses and most of its value comes from the fact that people say it has value. And a piece of art is not a productive asset either. Yet, it can and will have value. I don't think there is anything inherently wrong with that. I'm happy to invest in things that I believe are likely to go up in value, whether those are companies, mineral rights, art, watches, Bitcoin, or water deposits.
- dragandj 9y ago> By that reasoning, investing in gold is also speculation. What else? However, gold has some utility as jewelry etc. Cryptocurrencies are (currently) pure speculation.
- 9y ago
- gwbas1c 9y agoAnd what exactly is the investment in?
- aje403 9y agoIt's not an investment product, it's a ponzi scheme
- spookthesunset 9y ago> it's a ponzi scheme The beauty of Bitcoin and the whole crypto "space" is that they are more than just mere ponzi schemes. Don't let the pedants get to you--the crypto space transcends the entire gamut of frauds, scams and schemes. They're not only ponzi schemes but pyramid schemes, MLM scams, a pump & dump scams, exit scams, exchange scams, securities fraud, and a bunch of other named and unnamed scams you'd find in wikipedia. Often times these scams are deeply layered, with scammers scamming other scammers. Sometimes just best to simplify the whole thing as "a scam" instead of iterate through every single sub-scam, sub-fraud and sub-scheme that exists within the entire ecosystem. The whole thing is really quite remarkable and would be much more enjoyable to watch if it wasn't such a massive drain on earth's resources.
- jsutton 9y agoYour view seems to be to throw out the baby with the bathwater. The crypto space is full of scams, PnDs, etc. The crypto space is also full of world-changing technologies that will affect our economies and societies significantly. Both are true, and you'll be remiss to ignore that part.
- aje403 9y agoLet's translate your spiel into English: "I, spookthesunset, am invested in bitcoin" You're right though, it is more than just a mere ponzi scheme: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heaven%27s_Gate_(religious_group) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heaven%27s_Gate_(religious_gro...
- jel9392mdke 9y agoUninformed As if you have some secret wisdom of divine nature You’re using words and language that have been repeated to you over and over by those you perceive to have some authority Let’s not wrap this in mysticism to continue satisfying your headspace
- coldtea 9y ago>As if you have some secret wisdom of divine nature Doesn't take that to be informed. Studying a subject for example will do. In fact in this case, to reach the same conclusions, all it needs is common logic. >You’re using words and language that have been repeated to you over and over by those you perceive to have some authority Or he made up his own mind -- ever thought of that possibility?
- jel9392mdke 9y agoProve that’s possible since we have yet to even define what consciousness is. How can we know we made up our minds when we don’t know where such a capacity to do so starts and ends? If I study reading tea leaves I am simple informed in nonsense Studying economics is studying bartering habits of the people that control the bartering system It’s not hidden knowledge. It’s watching culture norms and encoding those in daily behavior It’s more religion than science
- zby 9y agoIt is a store of value. I would not call it an investment - because it does not really produce anything. It is like gold - but digital: https://medium.com/@zby/proof-of-work-8d8265def194 https://medium.com/@zby/proof-of-work-8d8265def194 I don't think it is a very good store of value - we mostly need store of value in the special cases of wars, extreme crises, and similar stuff - for normal times we can invest our money into businesses that really produce something. But bitcoin does not seem to be very usable in these circumstances. It is not well tested. It is also in danger of being replaced by some other cryptocurrency. And I don't thing there is space for more than two or three of them - just like money gravitated into gold and silver.