9 ms·
Google Duplex will call salons, restaurants, and pretend to be human for you
- chaoticmass 9y agoI don't need software to pretend to be human for me as I am already human and do not need to pretend. Corrected title: Google Duplex will call salons, restaurants for you, and pretend to be human.
- op00to 9y agoYES FELLOW HUMAN I AM ALSO HUMAN HUE HUE HUE HUE PLEASE INSERT GIRDER
- barftransit 9y agoPlease don't post funny jokes on HN.
- mikestew 9y agoBy all means, post funny jokes. But don't make the same mistake as op00to and post jokes that aren't even remotely funny.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chipperyman573 9y agoDuplicate https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17022963 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17022963
- fsiefken 9y agoThat is unethical, the human on the other side should be made aware that he's talking to a machine instead of a human.
- Someone1234 9y agoCan you explain your views on the ethics? I think it is a little creepy, but ethically? You're conducting the same activity in the same way you would have done yourself, but now more conveniently. The recipient still has the same experience either way. My biggest concern about this is that it could be used at scale for "evil" (e.g. junk calls).
- ksk 9y agoI don't know if its completely unethical, but I do think its a little dehumanizing to deny someone human interaction, when using means that only humans can employ. i.e. If it sent a clearly marked automated email its one thing, but imagine having this contraption call your mom to wish her on her birthday...
- bertil 9y agoI don’t think that Google has plans to train that system on individual’s voice. I’m not sure what the scale for doing that reliably would be.
- michaelt 9y ago1. Making automated, unsolicited robocalls is unethical. 2. This is an automated, unsolicited robocall.
- wyldfire 9y agoWhy do you describe the calls as "unsolicited"?
- mywittyname 9y agoExactly. Calling a business for the purposes of buying their product is the definition of solicited. That's literally the reason they have phones.
- michaelt 9y ago
- crunchlibrarian 9y agoAnyone else think it's kind of silly that half the front page of HN is google press releases today? And about 1/4 of those are dupes. We get it, there are a lot of googlers on here.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Anyone else think it's kind of silly that half the front page of HN is google press releases today? I count exactly 1/3 that concern Google, most of which are not press releases (or other direct-from-Google stories), though the news articles may be heavily based on press releases. But, no, it's not surprising we tend to get a lot of that on I/O keynote day. MS and Apple dev conferences also produce a lot, especially on the day of the keynote.
- aaomidi 9y agoIt's google IO. So no. It's not silly.
- mikestew 9y agoIn the whole eight days that you've had an HN account, you might not have noticed that every time Google/Apple/Microsoft/et. al. have a dev conference, the front page of HN is loaded with $COMPANY_WHO_IS_HOSTING_CONFERENCE news.
- Jach 9y agoNot to mention things like $famous_ceo_died, or $gov_conspiracy_theories_validated_by_leak.
- motohagiography 9y agoFrom the tone deaf product org that brought you google glass and whatever wave was, comes a solution that does not so much pretend to be human for you as it does simply dispense with the need for you pretend you possessed any humanity whatsoever at all. Next, google Snap! A robot that snaps its fingers at service people to get their attention...
- pknopf 9y agoWell put. 100% spot on. edit: Google Glass has it's uses. The problem was that Google marketed it to consumers instead of businesses.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoIt was never "marketed" except to devs and status signalers. The only one I ever saw in the wild was from a PHB with no use for it.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoFWIW, it was great as a status signal! I was in a Panda Express with it once and got asked if I wanted a job by another customer who worked in a nearby building! I wore it for about a year, I still think it was way better at notifications and stuff than the current smartwatch trend. But the main problem was the company making it and it's insistence on first party control. It didn't become possible to get non-Gmail email notifications on it until near the end of it's life.
- ksk 9y agoAt some point both sides of the conversation will be done by AIs...
- rtkwe 9y agoEh, more likely the AI phone reservation system will also plug into something like OpenTable or it's descendants and Duplex and it's descendant will just check there first.
- dewiz 9y agoA bot calling for you and a bot answering for salons/restaurant. Both pretending to be human. It’s like having a client/server application speaking English with an accent, without versioning, schema nor content type. What could go wrong.
- lucb1e 9y agoWell that sounds exactly like humanity. We all know how that turned out.
- Waterluvian 9y agoThat's a good point. We don't suffer from all those things mentioned. We have a living API that's meant to be very flexible and adaptive.
- CobrastanJorji 9y agoWe suffer from it all the time. There's a beautiful and tragic poem called "The Charge of the Light Brigade" about the results of a failure to communicate orders well. There's a statue in Rome depicting Moses with horns.
- base698 9y agoAlso the plot of Her.
- eb00 9y agoI read that as Saloon at first and now I am so disappointed.
- ohiovr 9y agoYour own personal robocaller. Your droids we don't server their kind here.
- denverkarma 9y agoGoogle is so creepy.
- bertil 9y agoThat product reminded me of Facebook’s M, a Messenger-based assistant that wasn’t able to scale. I guess Fb didn’t have two years ago the tech that Google has now. M’s key uses cases are probably going to prove essential here: aside from the usual flowers-for-my-wife-on-our-anniversary and other difficult-flights-to-book, basically busy executive stuffs, the massive potential was to deal with painful cancellation processes for your ISP, bank, gym, etc. If Google (or a developper using this API) can handle the intentionally convoluted interactions that those imply, this could be very powerful and make using Assistant the best way to handle some painful cases. Imagine applying for a loan, refinancing, switching to a better phone contract whenever there is a good offer: this technology could advise people to move between services with significant usability moats much faster, and greatly improve competition and our experience.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]