3 ms·
I'm just a naive guy, I guess. And I'm puzzled how new money plus hand waving can "leave some investors with nothing". Is it just that their investments had esc
by mirimir 9y ago
I'm just a naive guy, I guess. And I'm puzzled how new money plus hand waving can "leave some investors with nothing". Is it just that their investments had escape clauses? Or is this something like bankruptcy?
- georgeecollins 9y agoIf the alternative is a bankruptcy in which the investor gets nothing and ill will, the investors can agree to a deal where they get nothing and the entity remains intact.
- mirimir 9y agoI get that. But damn, it'd suck if Birchbox does become successful, and the new investors get all (or most of) the benefit. I guess that it's like poker. The initial investors could have increased their investments, to meet Birchbox's operating losses, but they didn't. And that's like folding on a hand.
- mathattack 9y agoIt’s a matter of who gets paid first. To oversimplify... Let’s say I have a company with 100M in debt. If the company is sold for 150M. The first 100M goes to pay debt. The other 50M goes to the owners. If it’s sold for 300M, then 200M goes to equity. They get all the upside. On the flip side if the company sells for less than 100M, the all the money goes to the debt holder. What’s going on is debt holders trade upside for downside protection. Equity holders give up downside protection to get equity. Life is a little more complicated (some equity holders have more protection than others, and some equity holders may be debt holders) but usually it’s just trading off upside for downside or vice versa.
- mirimir 9y agoOK, thanks. So in this case, are you saying that the initial investors had equity, but held little or no debt? So they retain equity, but the company has no equity, so they have nothing? And the new investors are paying off debt to service providers etc? And also getting some equity?
- mathattack 9y agoWhen companies are worth less than their debt obligations, the debt holders get all the claims. This means all the revenue in a sale, or they can wind up owning the company. (This is oversimplified but directionally correct) With Birchbox, one equity investor later provided debt. Others didn’t. When the company dropped in value, the debt holder wound up owning the whole thing. Sears seems to going through something similar at a larger scale.