53 ms·
>Put on your best unsurprised face: Unroll.me, a company that has, for years, used the premise of ‘free’ but not very useful ’email management’ services to gain
by Barrin92 9y ago
>Put on your best unsurprised face: Unroll.me, a company that has, for years, used the premise of ‘free’ but not very useful ’email management’ services to gain access to people’s email inboxes in order to data-mine the contents for competitive intelligence — and controversially flog the gleaned commercial insights to the likes of Uber — is to stop serving users in Europe ahead of a new data protection enforcement regime incoming under GDPR, which applies from May 25.
[...]
>"We may share personal information we collect with our parent company, other affiliated companies, and trusted business partners. We also will share personal information with service providers that perform services on our behalf. Our non-affiliated business partners and service providers are not authorized by us to use or disclose the information except as necessary to perform services on our behalf or comply with legal requirements".
If that's going to be the sort of business that the GDPR makes unprofitable and unworkable then I'm very proud to be a European citizen.
- apexalpha 9y agoExactly! On their website you have to go to 'FAQ' on the bottom of the page and then to the bottom of that to find: >When you sign up for Unroll.Me, Unroll.Me uses your data to provide you email management services, and for other purposes described in Unroll.Me’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. Unroll.Me is a part of Slice Technologies, whose market research organization Slice Intelligence provides the world’s leading brands, retailers, and marketers e-commerce insights to help them better understand market and consumer trends. In accordance with Unroll.Me’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Service, Unroll.Me shares information from your commercial and transactional emails with Slice. Slice’s technology automatically extracts purchase information from these emails and uses that information to build anonymized market research products for its clients. Slice’s market research products do not include your personal information. I think it is safe to say that 99% of the users using unroll.me have no idea how much data they are handing over. If your business model is incompatible with GDPR then your business model in not compatible with how we want (our data) to be treated. Companies complaining about GDPR goes into the same category as companies complaining about minimum wage for me.
- fossuser 9y agoI think you're probably right - the nice thing about Unroll.Me though is that it works really well and the people that need to use it are probably in a bad situation with their data anyway. I ended up using it to clean up my mom's email inbox because she was subscribed to nearly a thousand marketing emails and it was the only service I found that could actually fix that without at least a day's worth of manual effort.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoOut of curiosity: Was your mother fully informed of how much data about her you were giving to Unroll.me, and did she understand the implications of it?
- pulse7 9y ago<sarcasm>Of course: the time gained by using Untoll.Me - "at least a day's worth of manual effort" - can be used for reading their Privacy Policy and Terms of Service, for analysing, understanding and explaining all the implications...</sarcasm>
- fossuser 9y agoThis was prior to their bad press so it was not obvious to me at the time. I think I saw they used anonymized data from commercial emails which seemed like a reasonable tradeoff given the state of things. My mom does not use email for personal data - it's primarily just subscriptions and the account had become unusable.
- s17n 9y ago> Companies complaining about GDPR goes into the same category as companies complaining about minimum wage for me. It's more like complaining about any other compliance cost. Consultancies are making probably billions of dollars off of the General Electrics of the world preparing them for gdpr compliance. Then you've got the legal fees. And in the end it feels like you have just burned all that money, because in most cases, regulation doesn't actually accomplish anything. But hopefully it is all worth it for the cases where it actually improves people's lives.
- downandout 9y agoIf that's going to be the sort of business that the GDPR makes unprofitable and unworkable then I'm very proud to be a European citizen. This is the sort of business that GDPR makes unprofitable and unworkable - but unfortunately it's not the only sort. Normal, everyday services - sites that you might use and enjoy - will also have to close to EU traffic simply to avoid the liability. At my company, we do nothing nefarious with user data. We have a combined total of a few million visitors per month across a handful of sites. After consultation with experts, we had to make the decision to either spend high six/low seven figures to hopefully comply and buy special liability insurance that would help pay any fines (this law is subject to unique interpretations in 28 distinct countries, so nobody can actually know what "full" compliance is), or simply block EU traffic. We chose the latter, and many thousands of other sites that have no intention of doing anything nefarious with your data will as well.
- Barrin92 9y agoI do understand that it might also hit legitimate business models that many users enjoy and that it can be stressful for businesses who deal with userdata in best interests, but on the other hand there really is no way to overhaul important regulation like this without any kind of friction. The laws need to be broad enough to apply to everyone and have the intended effect, which means that especially in the early stages with a lack of clarity and guidelines it's goig to be a little messy. But I look at it like I'd look at a 20th century environmental regulation. Yes, it might impact genuinely good businesses, but at some point you have to do it if you want to advance user interests. I don't really see a better point than now.
- downandout 9y agoWhat will happen is that the EU will just have access to a dramatically smaller array of sites on the Internet - like a self-imposed Great Firewall. The only services that can even afford to attempt to comply and have the necessary liability insurance against fines are massive companies - think Facebook and Google. The problem with that is that if your data is in the hands of a few large players, and you have limited choices for the services they offer, the whole concept of "affirmative consent" is pointless because you have few choices about whom you give that consent to. So it isn't businesses that GDPR hurts (except for those that rely on EU traffic, who will make up for GDPR costs somehow - at your expense), it's actually the EU itself. Consumer choice is a good thing, and this law will dramatically limit it.
- DINKDINK 9y ago>If that's going to be the sort of business that the GDPR makes unprofitable and unworkable then I'm very proud to be a European citizen. You would you be equally proud if we sprayed weed-killer chemicals everywhere to wipe out dangerous plants ("If Water Hemlock is the type of plant that RoundUp kills, then I'm very proud to be a Monsanto stock owner") while killing scores of non-harmful plants? Your scope is narrowly framed and misses the big picture.
- matthewmacleod 9y agoWhat’s the big picture? What business models are being rendered non viable by GDPR that we should support?
- dogma1138 9y agoAny business model that has any interaction with anything that the GDPR specified as personal data. Here is an example: I’m a ukulele maker from Argentina I sell 50 ukulele‘s a month to the EU via my webshop and I use PayPal as my payment processor. I collect the following information from you that is considered PII under the GDPR. IP address. Name and Address. Phone number. EMail address. I don’t need to do anything nefarious with that information to have a huge headache and a potentially huge liability under the GDPR if my data leaks or I don’t comply with a request by a EU customer. I’m also out of luck if my local legislation contradicts the GDPR since unlike EU member states I don’t have a DPA and my local laws mean squat to the EU.
- gerdesj 9y agoLeaking data is generally considered shit so quite right - get a grip on your security. Complying with a request to be forgotten is surely not too hard and also you still have a right to hold on to probably all Ukelele sales related data for your reasonable accounting purposes. IP address - maybe not unless you use an IPSEC VPN for support 8) It really is not as bad as you imply. Bear in mind these regs are designed to be complied with by EVERY SINGLE BUSINESS (BIG OR SMALL, TECHNICALLY SOPHISTICATED OR NOT) IN THE ENTIRETY OF THE EU. You are a HN commentator with ~9500 karma - you are probably not stupid and will cope fine. Its not really a bad idea to take a long look at the data you hold and consider its lifecycle in your org. If it helps, I (UK IT business owner) am not frantically removing IP addresses from logs. I am however enjoying the thought that some bloody stupidly large email accounts will become indefensible, post 25 May. Also the stupid "archives" of old customer docs can damn well get deleted, rather than cluttering up my file servers.