6 ms·
I'm surprised that many people don't realize that Optane to SSD for consumer computers is similar to SSD to HDD. Consumer computers don't run workloads with QD
by vbezhenar 9y ago
I'm surprised that many people don't realize that Optane to SSD for consumer computers is similar to SSD to HDD. Consumer computers don't run workloads with QD 32. Their workloads are overwhelmingly low-threaded, so random performance for low queue depths is what matters. And Optane beats even best SSDs by a large margin.
I guess that modern SSD are just so fast, that going faster is not that big deal. But if you want the best SSD for non-server workloads, Optane is a way to go.
- erik 9y agoHave you used one in a desktop? Can you feel the difference in speed between Optane and NAND they way you can feel the difference between a SSD and a HDD?
- Makepio 9y agoIf you think it's a bit odd. the reason maybe is : Another PCM like memory killer application is Persistent memory(pmem). If you only use PCM like memory to implement pmem, the demand is rare and it maybe isn't economic. But if you also sell them as SSD or something block device caching, then them could contribute the demand for PCM to support another real killer application.
- chacham15 9y agoIm not sure this is true. Looking at the graph, the 970 outperforms the optane for sequential reads whereas the optane outperforms in the 4k random read/write range. So, it would seem that cases which are more sequential than random which include watching/streaming video/assets would run faster on the 970. So video game enthusiasts would still prefer the 970. If you're running a database, that 4k random read rate would seem to boost performance by quite a margin. Or am I missing something?
- olavgg 9y agoSequential read/write is usually optimized for burst workloads on consumer ssd's. The Intel 900p can sustain its peak read/write performance for hours. Anyway, the big difference with Optane is that its performance is more similar to having more system memory. I have not benchmarked this, but I believe a system with just 8GB ram + Optane will run better than a system with 16GB ram and Samsung 970 pro for workloads using up to 16GB of ram. There is a reason Intel announced its memory drive technology for Optane DC4800x https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/software/intel-memory-drive-technology.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/software/intel-memor... EDIT: adding a link to lwn.net article explaing the use of swap/memory overcommit https://lwn.net/Articles/704478/ https://lwn.net/Articles/704478/
- wtallis 9y ago> but I believe a system with just 8GB ram + Optane will run better than a system with 16GB ram and Samsung 970 pro for workloads using up to 16GB of ram. No, not even close. PCIe is still way slower than DDR4. Once your working set grows beyond available RAM, the Optane SSD will be a better swap device than any flash-based SSD, but you still notice your system slowing down drastically from all the swap activity. Intel's Memory Drive Technology is really intended for situations where you have multiple Optane SSDs, and a workload that wants a large amount of total RAM but seldom has a true working set larger than actual DRAM capacity.
- eloff 9y agoNothing will beat a workload requiring 16GB of RAM, than a system with 16GB+ of RAM. You don't even need to benchmark to know that much.
- walrus01 9y agofor comparison, write speed to RAM on DDR4-3200 is somewhere between 50000 to 60000MB/second on a fairly normal skylake workstation platform.
- dimensi0nal 9y agoPCIe latency is probably the bigger issue.
- dogma1138 9y agoThis. Which is why Intel is working on Optane DIMMs. Traversing the root complex can take upto 100 cpu cycles each way.
- Makepio 9y agoyep but Optane DIMM /NVDIMM is not for client product. It is on data center product list. Persistent Memory isn't just a concept on the textbook. It be realized now.
- edgineer 9y agoVideo game loading is not improved past SATA SSD speeds, so there would be no difference between a 970 and Optane there. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ecCA0gx_eZk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ecCA0gx_eZk
- paulmd 9y agoNVMe doesn't have much of an advantage over SATA SSDs at QD=1 in the first place. It really shines when you have higher QD or on sequential transfers, which are not typical consumer desktop workloads. On the other hand, Optane does have a big advantage at QD=1, which is the point people are making here. Looking at NVMe as an indication of Optane performance is the wrong approach since it has very different performance characteristics. https://img.purch.com/r/711x457/aHR0cDovL21lZGlhLmJlc3RvZm1pY3JvLmNvbS9QL1YvNzIyODAzL29yaWdpbmFsL2ltYWdlMDA1LnBuZw== https://img.purch.com/r/711x457/aHR0cDovL21lZGlhLmJlc3RvZm1p... (of course you're not incorrect that games aren't really using access patterns that are optimal for superfast SSDs)
- vbezhenar 9y agoSamsung outperforms Optane in sequential read by 15-20% and loses at random read by 3-4x (at low queue depth). And watching video won't show any difference, you can watch 4K video from HDD. I know nothing about streaming, though, but I would be surprised if it makes any difference. Typical database load is an example of big queue depths. You have dozens of queries executing simultaneously and you're interested in throughput. So Samsung SSD is fine there (and raids are even better), unless your database is not typical and serves only a single client with low latency requirement.
- olavgg 9y agoA typical db may do index scan on disk, which requires several times as many io operations per 8kb (Postgresql/Oracle size) page compared to seq scan. These are executed with low queue depth.
- cptskippy 9y agoOne of the reasons SSDs felt so much faster than HDDs was the massive improvement in 4k r/w. If Optane is considerably faster in that space then it would definitely be a consideration as your primary/swap drive.
- jhasse 9y ago> One of the reasons SSDs felt so much faster than HDDs was the massive improvement in 4k r/w. Also because that was a bottleneck. Now the CPU is often the bottleneck, so I doubt you'd notice Optane (most people can't even notice NVMe vs. SATA).
- paulmd 9y agoNormal consumer workloads are heavily biased towards 4K random performance (especially read). Sequential performance is largely inconsequential, both because it's rare (how often do you really suck in a full 20+ GB file at a single go?) and because consumer SSDs are fast enough at sequential performance that it's not really a bottleneck. 500 MB/s sustained is really fast enough for most users. Streaming video from the internet does not use the SSD at all, and a high-quality 1080p video file is maybe 5-10 MB/s of bitrate, you can easily pull that off a spinning HDD that was manufactured 20 years ago. Video editing at 4K or 8K is one of the few use-cases where NVMe's sequential performance does provide a big benefit... assuming you are not editing using proxies. Optane's QD=1 random-4K performance does present an opportunity for big speedups on consumer use-cases. But Intel really has to get the prices down if they want to see consumer adoption, right now there is an obvious benefit to cheaper SATA SSDs that allow you to get more data off spinning-rust drives vs a smaller, massively expensive Optane drive (even if it is incredibly fast).
- coolspot 9y agoI think GTA V or another AAA title could suck up 20Gb from disk to RAM/GPU in one go to load all assets (models, textures, audio).
- defap 9y agoBut not necessarily as a sequential read.
- paulmd 9y agoI'm a little doubtful, on the basis that it would take HDD users about three minutes to load into the game (probably 4, by the time you start doing something with all those assets). I know HDDs are slow, but 4 minutes of loading is extremely excessive by any standard. Also, on PS3 it runs in less than 256 MB of RAM... where is it loading these assets to? Most games have RAM consumption on the order of 4-8 GB in most situations, not all of that is assets, and not all of that is read sequentially.
- 9y ago
- bitL 9y agoMost people probably didn't see benchmarks how abysmal the real-world performance gains were between SSDs running SATA-1, SATA-2, SATA-3 and M.2 PCIe. They don't understand that throughput is not the main factor what made SSDs being so snappy, but the latency comparing to HDDs.
- rl3 9y ago>I'm surprised that many people don't realize that Optane to SSD for consumer computers is similar to SSD to HDD. Funny enough, I skipped over SSD entirely, and upgraded to Optane from HDD. It was like trading in a Model T for a Model X.
- daxfohl 9y agoMy old plasma TV is 600 Hz and I can't get $20 for it. Sometimes fast enough is fast enough.
- arthurfm 9y agoIsn't that due to the very high energy consumption [1] than refresh rate? Who would want a TV that consumes ~300-600 watts per hour? [1] https://www.treehugger.com/gadgets/plasma-tvs-suck-electricity.html https://www.treehugger.com/gadgets/plasma-tvs-suck-electrici...
- Buge 9y ago>300-600 watts per hour Watt is a measure of energy/time. It doesn't make sense to say watts per hour.
- Tsiklon 9y agoElectricity consumption is traditionally metered per kilowatt hour, that is the amount of energy used sustained over the course of an hour. I believe this is what the GP was referring to - the sustained usage of 300-600W over the course of an hour. Thus being very expensive to run for long periods of time. In my area I’m charged at 16.56 pence per kilowatt hour, meaning at an average consumption rate of 450w - that television would cost me in the region of £13.41 a month to run, assuming 6hours usage per night. Which is quite expensive.
- arthurfm 9y ago> It doesn't make sense to say watts per hour. Perhaps, but that doesn't change the fact that Plasma TVs are generally more expensive to run than modern LCD or OLED TVs. [1] Pioneer's 9th generation Kuro KRP-600A had an operating power consumption of 478 watts. [2] [1] https://www.rtings.com/tv/learn/led-oled-power-consumption-and-electricity-cost https://www.rtings.com/tv/learn/led-oled-power-consumption-a... [2] https://www.whathifi.com/pioneer/krp-600a/specs https://www.whathifi.com/pioneer/krp-600a/specs
- muro 9y ago
- Improvotter 9y agoAfaik Optane is limited to Intel (whether that is support on motherboards or manufacturers) and I would rather have us all adopt a standard where there are more suppliers and not a single company that holds the strings for everyone else.
- vbezhenar 9y agoAFAIK Optane is an ordinary SSD. There are some Intel-only technologies, like using Optane for HDD caching, but if you just need fast SSD, you should be fine.
- benchaney 9y ago> There are some Intel-only technologies, like using Optane for HDD caching That isn't intel only either[0], although IIRC their hardware implementation is intel only. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dm-cache https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dm-cache
- Makepio 9y agoThere is a bit difference between Optane and ordinary NAND SSD. Optane is PCM like memory, it is a byte addressable flash. So the sellman said it maybe have longer wearout time than normal NAND SSD. They cooperate with Micron to implement this economic system . They can use optane demand to help persistent memory to thrive too.
- echlebek 9y agoAs someone who writes server-side software, I'm very excited about this product. Having the ability to handle a large volume of random writes, relatively cheaply, makes building reliable, fully restartable software much simpler. Many storage engines that I make use of are B trees or LSMs these days. These engines are usually selected because they provide very good read performance, and acceptable write performance. Improved random access writes only make these engines more attractive and performant. For instance, boltdb, which is similar to LMDB, requires 2 iops to perform a durable write. In the benchmark for 4K random writes, Optane achieved 180,000 iops. This gives us 90,000 writes per second, sustained. Possibly more at peak, since presumably that's how they get the claimed write iops of 550,000. That's a phenomenal number of writes. It makes in-memory stores like redis irrelevant for a wide range of applications that would have required it not long ago.
- Rafuino 9y agoHave you been able to get access to / test the server version of Optane? Looks like Facebook and Stanford did some research with it as a DRAM replacement in MyRocks DB: https://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=3190524 https://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=3190524
- echlebek 9y agoI haven't had the opportunity to test it myself, but I'm certainly looking forward to it.
- slavak 9y agoFWIW Redis Labs already offers a Redis-on-Flash solution, which also happens to work really well with Optane: https://redislabs.com/blog/redis-enterprise-flash-intel-optane/ https://redislabs.com/blog/redis-enterprise-flash-intel-opta... Full disclosure: I work for Redis Labs.
- echlebek 9y agoThat's very cool, and I didn't know about this. Thanks!
- ComputerGuru 9y agoIt’s not true. I bought the previous model and it wasn’t anywhere near the expected step up from the 960 NVMe (which is admittedly stupid fast already).
- sundvor 9y agoI'm pretty happy with my 950 PRO NVME. It hits 2.5GB/s read (256KB), 1.5GB/s write (128KB) in ATTO. Random (IOPS) are 276k read, 95k write as reported by Samsung Magician. And these numbers are all with a fairly full drive. My biggest issue is that it's only a 512, the biggest available at time of purchase (mid 2016; I only replace my systems every 5-6 years or so; 6850k/32gb mem was my limit then). Also, doing benchmarking stresses loads up the thermals and when it hits 70c after a little while perf is throttled down somewhat; this doesn't happen in normal use, but nevertheless I've ordered a NVME heatsink which I hope will be good for it. I see the Optane is a PCIE solution. Seeing as my m2 slot is filled, and noone makes u2 drives (the only other spare slot for such things my motherboard has), that'd make it the perfect upgrade extension for myself if I can fit it in between the GPU and SB card - hopefully it'll come down in price a bit over time.