3 ms·
Open-source licenses have nothing to do with trademarks ... and articles from daringfireball.net have zero insight while being biased to extremes. Why do peopl
by bad_user 16y ago
Open-source licenses have nothing to do with trademarks ... and articles from daringfireball.net have zero insight while being biased to extremes.
Why do people read it? Probably because most people search for approval, maybe?
The conditions were pretty clear from the start ... if you want to use the Android trademark and have access to its marketplace, you have to play by Google's rules, which are actually pretty relaxed and many people complain that Android is too open, allowing mobile carriers to load crap on it.
This is the Achile's heel of "Free Software", and GPLv3 won't solve it because you need the cooperation of the mobile carriers / phone makers.
I actually think that personal computing is were it is today because Microsoft/IBM commoditized hardware, with all personal computers running the same OS.
Google is copying the same recipe.
No matter how good iPhones get, people have different needs and different styles. There are always going to be pinkish phones around or phones with physical keyboards, or cheaper phones that you can buy for $100 without a contract.
Creating an OS that attracts phone makers, which in turn drives customers attention towards software, which in turn lowers prices on phones, which in turn sells more Android devices, which in turn makes Google's search engine ubiquitous for mobile phones ... Google is practically solving the chicken/egg problem here :)
- jacobolus 16y ago> I actually think that personal computing is were it is today because Microsoft/IBM commoditized hardware, with all personal computers running the same OS. That’s a vacuously true statement. The question is whether “where it is today” is better (possibly cheaper) or worse (less innovative) for Microsoft’s/Intel’s bullying. Any answer to that is of course completely speculative. Personally I find the speculation behind the “worse” answer most compelling. Having a super cheap/free software platform ultimately discourages innovation in software platforms (why spend a ton of resources competing with something free and “good enough”), and so I hope that projects like Palm’s, Apple’s, Microsoft’s, etc. continue for a good long time, if only to keep the pressure on Google, a company well known for abandoning projects.
- bad_user 16y ago> The question is whether “where it is today” is better (possibly cheaper) or worse (less innovative) for Microsoft’s/Intel’s bullying I should have expanded on that. I think it is better because computers got cheap and universal and a standard. A PC used to cost thousands of dollars, and now you can get one for a couple of hundred. I know first-hand what this meant, as I live in Eastern Europe and I could only get one after I found something cheap. Yeah, it sucked that Windows wasn't particularly innovative, but the software running on top was innovative with lots of competition going on. The hardware running on top was competitive too ... even Intel faced stiff competition. So there are both good and bad parts about this ... and the environment is certainly a lot better than the waled garden the mobile carriers are keeping us in.
- joe_the_user 16y agoWhy do people read it? Probably because most people search for approval, maybe? Reading the Apple FUD is important, give you an idea of what might be appearing more aggressively a months down the line...
- rimantas 16y agoand articles from daringfireball.net have zero insight while being biased to extremes. Why do people read it? Probably because most people search for approval, maybe? Perfect example of the comment upvoted by people searching for approval. Articles from daringfireball.net have zero insight? Biased to extremes? Really? Did you even bother to read any of the articles? if you want to use the Android trademark and have access to its marketplace, you have to play by Google's rules That's exactly the point of the article: Google acts this way but claims otherwise.
- bad_user 16y ago> That's exactly the point of the article: Google acts this way but claims otherwise. What are you talking about? Both the compatibility definition (CDD) and the compatibility test-suite (CTS) are public ... http://source.android.com/compatibility/index.html http://source.android.com/compatibility/index.html Devices that are Android-compatible (by the definition above) have to license the Android Market client software separately, complying with the terms available here: http://www.android.com/market/terms.html http://www.android.com/market/terms.html The Android branding is subject to these rules: http://www.android.com/branding.html http://www.android.com/branding.html Here is were they can twist your arm so to speak. Nothing prevents you from taking their OS, modify it and selling it with your own devices ... surely certain Google properties like the Marketplace will be out of reach, but that was known from version 1.0. So where does Google claim otherwise?