5 ms·

Citation needed. A small minority maybe. Dishonesty can be hard work.

by gpvos 9y ago

pbhjpbhj 9y ago
I'm not saying it's widespread, nor necessarily that easy (I don't know) but every few weeks I'm looking at our local news online and there's a story of someone claiming jobseekers, housing benefit, disability or attendance allowances, and they're working (and paying taxes it seems, so it should have been easy to catch them). 5s Google - http://www.4ni.co.uk/northern-ireland-news/243195/other-news-in-brief http://www.4ni.co.uk/northern-ireland-news/243195/other-news..., some guy claiming whilst working. Assuming not all cases are found - and stories I've seen in the past have been of people caught after well over a year of false claims - then it seems perfectly doable for those who are dishonest (through necessity or otherwise).
- DanBC 9y ago
  The rate of fraud on benefits is really low. Yes, it does happen, and a few people do get away with it for a long time. But it's wrong to suggest that it's widespread, and doing so causes harm because it encourages the Hostile Environment stuff. Looking at your link, these people were caught reasonably quickly. One of the people in your link managed to claim just £231. At his age he'd be getting £73 per week, so he fraudulently claimed less than a month. It's harder to work out the other person, because they were also claiming housing benefit. He lived at Ballysillan Crescent, Belfast, which is a B14 post code. Local housing allowance rates are https://www.nihe.gov.uk/index/benefits/lha/current_lha_rates.htm https://www.nihe.gov.uk/index/benefits/lha/current_lha_rates... Here's that street on Google maps: https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@54.6291805,-5.9663763,3a,75y,30.48h,92.66t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sj1TywIFqVppVVd7--wbgOQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@54.6291805,-5.9663763,3a,75y,... Let's take the one bedroom rate of £86.16 per week, plus £73.10 per week = £159.26 per week. (this assumes he claims as a single person, and it lowers the weekly amount. I do this because I want to maximise the time he claimed for as a worst case). £4,114 / £159 = = 25 weeks. So, about 6 months. If he was claiming the 2 bedroom rate, or was claiming JSA as a couple he would have got more moeny per week, and so was caught much quicker. You'll find similar in the other cases. People try it and they usually get caught within a year.
  - pbhjpbhj 9y ago
    I don't think I said it was widespread, or anything to indicate that? I've been on Jobseekers and am likely to be again: yes we should guard against creating a hostile environment and assuming everyone is on the make, but pretending there's no fraud at all is surely not the way. Are few people dishonest, or are most dishonest people caught. My concern is if the system encourages moral compromise for survival and what this means for our society as a whole.

Citation needed. A small minority maybe. Dishonesty can be hard work.

by gpvos 9y ago

Citation needed. A small minority maybe. Dishonesty can be hard work.

I'm not saying it's widespread, nor necessarily that easy (I don't know) but every few weeks I'm looking at our local news online and there's a story of someone claiming jobseekers, housing benefit, disability or attendance allowances, and they're working (and paying taxes it seems, so it should have been easy to catch them). 5s Google - http://www.4ni.co.uk/northern-ireland-news/243195/other-news-in-brief http://www.4ni.co.uk/northern-ireland-news/243195/other-news..., some guy claiming whilst working. Assuming not all cases are found - and stories I've seen in the past have been of people caught after well over a year of false claims - then it seems perfectly doable for those who are dishonest (through necessity or otherwise).

DanBC 9y ago
The rate of fraud on benefits is really low. Yes, it does happen, and a few people do get away with it for a long time. But it's wrong to suggest that it's widespread, and doing so causes harm because it encourages the Hostile Environment stuff. Looking at your link, these people were caught reasonably quickly. One of the people in your link managed to claim just £231. At his age he'd be getting £73 per week, so he fraudulently claimed less than a month. It's harder to work out the other person, because they were also claiming housing benefit. He lived at Ballysillan Crescent, Belfast, which is a B14 post code. Local housing allowance rates are https://www.nihe.gov.uk/index/benefits/lha/current_lha_rates.htm https://www.nihe.gov.uk/index/benefits/lha/current_lha_rates... Here's that street on Google maps: https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@54.6291805,-5.9663763,3a,75y,30.48h,92.66t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sj1TywIFqVppVVd7--wbgOQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@54.6291805,-5.9663763,3a,75y,... Let's take the one bedroom rate of £86.16 per week, plus £73.10 per week = £159.26 per week. (this assumes he claims as a single person, and it lowers the weekly amount. I do this because I want to maximise the time he claimed for as a worst case). £4,114 / £159 = = 25 weeks. So, about 6 months. If he was claiming the 2 bedroom rate, or was claiming JSA as a couple he would have got more moeny per week, and so was caught much quicker. You'll find similar in the other cases. People try it and they usually get caught within a year.
- pbhjpbhj 9y ago
  I don't think I said it was widespread, or anything to indicate that? I've been on Jobseekers and am likely to be again: yes we should guard against creating a hostile environment and assuming everyone is on the make, but pretending there's no fraud at all is surely not the way. Are few people dishonest, or are most dishonest people caught. My concern is if the system encourages moral compromise for survival and what this means for our society as a whole.