3 ms·
To put it bluntly: fuck the shareholders. The question being asked shouldn't be "are the capital owners getting paid", but "is this company improving lives and
by andrepd 9y ago
To put it bluntly: fuck the shareholders. The question being asked shouldn't be "are the capital owners getting paid", but "is this company improving lives and delivering benefit". It's after all, what they're here for, not just to make money. No matter how much money I can make selling heroin, they're not gonna let me because, you guessed it, I'm doing damage by doing it.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoWhat about countless of other, not censored, services delivered from the same network? Do they not "improve lives" and "deliver benefit"? Collateral freedom is akin to placing your guerilla command center in a hospital, in a gamble that the other side will leave you alone instead of risking extra harm to innocent civilians. In this case, the hospital decided to disallow guerillas to use it as cover.
- nasredin 9y agoThis is either the worst possible example or the best. Russia BTW bombs civilian targets like hospitals and they killed their own bank sites when they tried to block Telegram recently.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoWhich teaches you about effectiveness of "collateral freedom" against states that Just Don't Care.
- Dylan16807 9y agoIn theory, in some case, it could be like that. In this case it's just like being in a city. They're not trying to take advantage of any particularly sensitive institution.
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> They're not trying to take advantage of any particularly sensitive institution. They are. Amazon. And previously, Google. The worst-case consequence is not people losing access to Amazon store, but losing access to anything that's powered by Amazon cloud. People operating all kinds of services hosted on Amazon servers are the patients and hospital staff from my example.
- Dylan16807 9y agoAmazon servers are an entire city. There is a vast gulf between the equivalent of "being in a city that has a hospital" and the equivalent of "locating a base inside a hospital".
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThen it's even worse, because the picture you're trying to paint implies that it's either leave guerillas alone, or nuke the entire city. A ban of a cloud service affects everything else that depends on it. The more popular a service, the more damage. That's the point of "collateral freedom". (Note the name of the term. It's no accident. It comes from "collateral damage".)
- Dylan16807 9y agoBlock the road, not nuke the city. But if they were going to nuke the city? Fuck them, don't negotiate, it is absolutely not the fault of any group that is merely located somewhere inside the city.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI feel we're talking past each other because of a spatial analogy. My point is - by employing domain fronting against censorship, you bet that the adversary will not ban the service you're using as a front. But they very well might just do that. At this point, everyone else using the service suffers. So that service, by refusing to be used as a domain front, is not just protecting its own interest - it's protecting interests of all the others who depend on it. You, on the other hand, are unilaterally putting those other people at risk. This does not make you a hero, it makes you a villain (even if a lesser one).
- analognoise 9y agoThis. People don't realize doing stuff like this is just going to make lives worse once these regimes block Amazon/Google/whatever.