6 ms·
So if any one of those conditions isn't the case, you are an employee under the law. I see people in this thread wondering how it'll affect companies like Uber/
by CamperBob2 9y ago
So if any one of those conditions isn't the case, you are an employee under the law. I see people in this thread wondering how it'll affect companies like Uber/Lyft/whatever
'B' is downright apocalyptic for contract developers in all sorts of roles. Sounds like massive judicial overreach to me. If your summary is accurate, I wouldn't expect that particular guideline to survive appeal.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Sounds like massive judicial overreach to me. If your summary is accurate, I wouldn't expect that particular guideline to survive appeal. It's a California state law issue and this is a decision of the California Supreme Court upholding the decision of the Court of Appeals, which had upheld the Superior Court. This has already survived the whole chain of appeals.
- CamperBob2 9y agoIt's a California state law issue and this is a decision of the California Supreme Court upholding the decision of the Court of Appeals, which had upheld the Superior Court. This has already survived the whole chain of appeals. So you're saying it can't possibly raise any (US) constitutional questions? As an example, consider what happens when one of the affected contractors is in another state. That makes it a Commerce Clause issue. You can wave your hands and sputter indignantly all you want, but Wickard and Filburn are going to wave right back at you.
- rtpg 9y agoIf you are an IT company and all your work is done through contract developers, perhaps you _are_ going against the spirit of the law. Labor law is meant to protect those in the employer <-> employee relationship, and most contractual work explicitly weaken this relationship a lot. So contractual work really shouldn't be the norm in a business. If you can't provide your main business without this set of people, then those people are probably your employees?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> If you can't provide your main business without this set of people, then those people are probably your employees? This doesn't make any sense. Farmers are not employees of grocery stores. Factory foremen are not employees of drop shippers. Amazon warehouse staff are also not employees of drop shippers. Comcast cable layers are not employees of YouTube. You think farmers aren't employees of grocery stores because the stores could buy the same food from different farmers? That's just as true of the IT company and its contract developers.
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoBut that is wildly different. A farmer provides goods that hold value for almost anyone. Once they have produced a bushel of apples, that bushel can be bought by anyone. On the contrary, once a software developer has produced some code, it only holds value for the specific company that order this specific piece of code.
- dgacmu 9y agoNot always. Consider two scenarios: (1) adding a feature to an existing product that the company sells. (example: writing a better grammar checker for MS word). (2) contracting with the developer of a small open source embedded database to add a specific SQL feature that you wanted to use in your web backend.
- rtpg 9y agoThis is a pretty big simplification. Grocers buy produce from the farmers, not their time. This matches some conrractors, of course. But it also extremely doesn't match many contractor developers. Are you required to be online 4-6 hours a day? Do some of the companies employees not even know if you are actually a contractor? Are you the one picking up the metaphorical phone when the company's client is calling with a support issue? You might actually be an employee If you show up with a deliverable , can go on vacation without clearing it with anyone, and are actually your own boss... Well that's different of course
- knuththetruth 9y agoAppeal to whom? This ruling/guidance was provided by the California Supreme Court about how independent contractors are classified by the state.
- mark212 9y agoYeah exactly. This is a question of state law and the Cal SC is the final word on what state law means. The only exception is if the USSC agrees that the state law violates some provision of the US Constitution and that’s extremely rare. Not going to happen.
- umanwizard 9y agoStill, that would be a case about federal law (the Constitution).
- hardwaresofton 9y agoI should have posted this earlier, but buried in the bloomberg is the decision: https://www.bloomberglaw.com/public/desktop/document/Hargrove_v_Sleepys_LLC_220_NJ_289_106_A3d_449_2015_Court_Opinion?1525151421 https://www.bloomberglaw.com/public/desktop/document/Hargrov... I honestly am not 100% sure of the ramifications, but I am sure that these companies are going to act in their best interest, and with the current imbalance in the labor market (some might argue that the markets are right where they should be), I'm relatively certain that will mean employees being turned into contractors, or worst case they'll take the walmart route and make everyone work "part-time", drivers will think they're pulling a fast one by working for more than one company but they'll really just be driving their own wages and benefits down.
- twblalock 9y agoOf course companies are going to act in their best interest. But this ruling does not change that, because companies have been acting in their best interest all along. If anything, this makes it easier for contractors to prove they ought to be employees.
- hardwaresofton 9y agoWell, you've rehashed what I said -- That was meant to be to all the people wondering how this ruling would affect companies like Uber/Lyft/other gig economy companies. The answer is it won't affect them, because they'll do what it takes legally to act in their best interest, like they have always done (and have had way more resources than the average worker to do). So nothing will change, outside of a likely reduction in lawsuits for companies most able to navigate the new legal climate.
- icebraining 9y agoThe answer is it won't affect them, because they'll do what it takes legally to act in their best interest But how does that follow? You're essentially saying that no law can ever affect them, since they'll always "do what it takes legally to act in their best interest".
- mark212 9y agoJudicial overreach? Someone has to interpret the law. The original standard was judge-created and the refined over several decades. It was a mess and gave conflicting results in quite similar cases. This, no matter what you think of the outcome, is unquestionably a giant leap forward in clarity.
- kahnpro 9y agoHonestly, most contracting developers are actually employees, and this position is just used as a way to skirt tax and labor laws. The abuse here isn't from the court, it's from devs and businesses. Devs don't care simply because the pay is high enough and there are a ton of jobs available.
- eecc 9y agoSomewhat true, but to me what matters as a freelance is that I get to make the call when I’ve had enough of a particular contract, or choose whether to wait for a more interesting project, or just sign up to whatever conference I feel it’s important to my own career plan. When I was an employee I always had to beg to do anything, as well as suck up whatever shite projects the accounts would figure out would mean a sweet billability streak... dammit, the humiliation...
- kahnpro 9y agoThat's great if you're working as an actual freelancer. But most that I've seen don't get such freedoms. Another good test is, are you allowed to subcontract your work or not?
- eecc 9y agoEh that’s a good question, practically never. But there’s some good reason for it, in that development is not a routine job where you are completely interchangeable. There’s - thankfully - a certain amount of creative skill and professional judgement that makes me the hire and not a sub of my choice. Several years ago Italy introduced CoCoCo contracts to capture this concept of temporary professional employment, between an employee on your payroll and a butcher you buy a stake from. Eventually companies abused it and applied it to completely subordinates such as call center operators. It was - rightfully, given the circumstances - repealed. I wonder if we could have something like that again, it would be easier than this pantomime.
- geofft 9y agoSee my comment at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16966621 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16966621 ; I think B is misreported here. It's about type of work, not place of work. That said, my (non-lawyer, pre-coffee) reading of what B actually says is that while it won't turn consultants into employees of the place they consult for, it will turn specialists into employees, whether or not they work on site. If a company occasionally submits patches to an open-source project they use, and then they hire a maintainer full-time for a few months, that sounds like B would require them to hire the maintainer as an employee.