11 ms·
YouTube Is Removing Some Nootropics Channels
- kristofferR 9y agoThis is really scary. People who warned of the slippery slope of censorship were definitely right.
- pboutros 9y agoThere's a difference between "removing false/misleading videos that perpetuate a scam" and Fahrenheit 451
- jerf 9y agoDepends on who gets to decide what "false/misleading" is. I'm not sure how this could be any less transparent. I personally see less than no reason to trust YouTube's judgment in these matters.
- maxerickson 9y agoSo should it be illegal to run a curated platform?
- emodendroket 9y agoIt certainly presents problems when all the most popular channels for communication are controlled by a handful of companies.
- Caprinicus 9y agoAnd that they grew to this point before imposing this "curation". It seems to be a recurring theme with these companies to grow to a monopoly with a place for relatively free discourse and then to do this as soon as they feel safe.
- emodendroket 9y agoThe incentives are aligned that way... once you're big the biggest thing is protecting your position.
- merinowool 9y agoTo be fair information is a weapon and there should be no free reign for anyone. If you are on purpose suppressing some information to fulfil political agenda - that should be a criminal act.
- maxerickson 9y agoSo what's a political agenda? Is the promotion of cats a political agenda? Can allcats.com take down videos of dogs?
- RoyTyrell 9y ago> Can allcats.com take down videos of dogs? Sure. Why shouldn't a private entity be able to determine what kind of speech they allow on their own property?
- girvo 9y agoBecause if they have a huge defacto monopoly, and also a outsized impact on our culture, the impacts of them doing so are far more far-reaching than, say, LiveLeak removing some video (trying to think of a competitor for YT is surprisingly hard).
- s73v3r_ 9y agoOk, but what about the opposite: What if you are, on purpose, constantly disseminating false information to fulfill a political agenda?
- vkou 9y agoAny time you open the paper, turn on the TV, crack open a book, or visit Hacker News, you are trusting some curator, gatekeeper, editor, or censor's judgement. Even bazaars like 4chan are moderated.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoAnd the unmoderated spaced of before don't exist any more (Usenet), because companies didn't make money on it. Or worse, because it violated some company's "right". Now, in order to speak, you nearly have to go through one of Their gateways. If you piss off FAMGA (Facebook, Apple, Microsoft, Google, Amazon), you're gone off the net. Some of those gatekeepers are big scripts with no human intervention for your level. If you fall between the cracks, then you have no recourse, other than find a place like HN and beg publicly - lest you get shitcanned by the HN gatekeepers.
- s73v3r_ 9y ago"If you piss off FAMGA (Facebook, Apple, Microsoft, Google, Amazon), you're gone off the net." No, you're not. Not even close. The Daily Stormer is still online; you will be too.
- musage 9y agoI don't see why the burden to "make ends meet" in a totally scorched landscape should be on those not scorching it, with those looking the other way preaching to them from a supposed moral high horse. Stuff like the right to confront your accuser is totally lost with these companies as well as on HN. But don't worry, even being on the wrong side of history you'll still be in history.
- vertexFarm 9y agoIt's interesting. I think we're at a strange period in history where personal speech can reach such a huge audience, thus new ways of suppressing speech are being invented. Youtube is a private service, thus they can remove content as they wish. Of course, most forms of historical media have also removed or suppressed controversial content. But in the old days it was preemptive. There was only so much room in a newspaper, you had to own presses and a distribution network, and they didn't hire just any schmoe to write columns. It was a proactive system of censorship. They got people invested in a career of finding the proper stories and promoting what was acceptable to the establishment. Obviously common people could say whatever they like in their daily lives, but their freedom to put content into a newspaper or television show for all to see was extremely limited. We have enormous freedom in self-publishing mass media today. So much content is being created that no mortal person can serve as gatekeeper and pick and choose what gets published like a newspaper editor could. So on one hand, we're living in a utopia of free speech. But new ways are being devised to automatically manage content all the time. And even though human moderators don't catch everything, but they slowly do what they can. There are some genuinely harmful ideas out there, of course. Some things that ought to be restricted. Who gets to decide? Is it right for a private company to choose? I doubt it, but private companies have always been choosing what gets into media. In the past their decisions were much more totalitarian than today.
- colordrops 9y agoThere are plenty of political videos being removed or demonetized as well. We are not as far off as it may seem.
- noetic_techy 9y agoThe problem is, the status quo likes to label the people on the periphery who often may be on to something "a scam".
- fmihaila 9y ago> There's a difference between "removing false/misleading videos that perpetuate a scam" and Fahrenheit 451 reply Where does that leave Alex Jones, then? It's called a slippery slope for a reason.
- s73v3r_ 9y ago"False/misleading videos that perpetuate a scam."
- fmihaila 9y ago> "False/misleading videos that perpetuate a scam." You seem to be implying that Jones' videos are truthful/informative and totally-not-a-scam, while the videos in the article, which actually contained educational content, were false, misleading, and perpetuating a scam. Meanwhile, Jones has a supplement business that pulled an estimated $15 mil over two years (some estimate $25 mil) [1]. Here is a sampling of reviews from an independent lab that tested the substances: - "Both of these products are most likely safe, but ineffective." - "This product is a waste of money. The claim that 'Anthroplex works synergistically with the powerful Super Male Vitality formula in order to help restore your masculine foundation and stimulate vitality with its own blend of unique ingredients' is fluff on multiple fronts." - "This product's claims related to 'nascent oxygen' also have no real basis in science." - "We tested this product on the chance that it might be potassium iodide or sodium iodide, which it wasn't. Survival Shield is just plain iodine." etc. This is a guy who "... repeatedly asserted the Sandy Hook shooting was staged and the parents were liars and frauds who helped in a cover-up" [2]. So, what's your definition of false and/or misleading? [1] https://www.buzzfeed.com/charliewarzel/we-sent-alex-jones-infowars-supplements-to-a-lab-heres?utm_term=.fpY4PnLXD#.obaDbw2ay https://www.buzzfeed.com/charliewarzel/we-sent-alex-jones-in... [2] https://globalnews.ca/news/4149778/sandy-hook-sue-infowars-conspiracy-alex-jones-defamation/ https://globalnews.ca/news/4149778/sandy-hook-sue-infowars-c... EDIT: it seems I misread the intent of the post above mine. My apologies. I'll leave my response up for reference.
- detaro 9y agoI believe you are reading the parent poster the wrong way around.
- kristofferR 9y agoThe channels in question aren't accused of containing false/misleading videos, they're accused of containing disallowed facts. Noone disputes that modafinil promotes wakefulness or that magnesium makes many sleepy.
- atomical 9y agoFacts, lies, or unproven?
- joew42k 9y agoWebsites have always been allowed to decide which facts to allow on their site. Right now, if I visited an anti-vaxxer forum, and posted "vaccines don't cause autism" in the comments, I'm sure it would be removed. So why is youtube any different?
- kristofferR 9y agoOf course YouTube have a right to remove every pro vaccination video from their site, I'm not disputing that. I'm just saying that they shouldn't.
- joew42k 9y agoI agree with you. They shouldn't. I'm playing devils advocate to make a point. You can't expect websites to treat all opinions as equal. Even 4chan has moderators. Youtube only differs from other websites in scale. They are moderating content as we see fit. We can disagree with their reasoning behind moderation. But it's silly to act like they didn't have this right all along (And that's what I see in this comment section. Comments like "why should youtube say what I can and can't watch?" I'm pointing out that those arguments are a dead end.)
- JamesBarney 9y agoBecause youtube has a de-facto monopoly on online video viewing.
- wnoise 9y ago
- 21 9y agoSo it would be fine by you if YouTube removed a video titled "Python is the best programming language in the world" because it is misleading.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoThat is definitely not ok. However if the title was "PHP is the best programming language in the world", then the account should be banned, and they should possibly forward the authorities the offenders IP Address so they can get the crazy person on a watch list.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- akvadrako 9y agoIt's not - just don't use youtube.
- LoSboccacc 9y agosure, feel free to use any of these alternative services that offer a large potential reach and allow easy monetization of user content:
- s73v3r_ 9y agoNone of the alternative services will get there if no one is willing to use them. There is always the old fashioned way of getting sponsors yourself and hosting the video on your site.
- akvadrako 9y agoand it's not like youtube pays out very well - it's 90% towards google at the minimum.
- musage 9y agoWhich makes their behavior in relation to ElsaGate -- how long they ignored reports and pleas, and how they either did or published zero serious investigation of the issue -- even more disgusting. They could donate the ad money they made from videos aimed at abusing children, knowingly or not, to charities helping abused children, or something like that. But no, instead they used the occasion to brag and pat themselves on the back. Observe how they treat the defenseless, and how they treat those with clout. It speaks volumes.
- kirykl 9y agoin the US you have a right to free speech, not mass reach
- girvo 9y agoThen that definition of free speech ignores the changes in culture and communication, no? (I’m not even disagreeing with you, I’m more curious here. This article and discussion has brought up interesting points I think)
- LoSboccacc 9y agoyep, but the tide is changing. my last comment on the slippery slope and youtube didn't go minus fifteen as usual, so at least the tech community around here is coming to term with the issue being real.
- wagecuck 9y agoNasim was a hero.
- codepig 9y agoNasim was a hero and she did nothing wrong.
- erickhill 9y agoI had to Google what a Nootropic even was. TL;DR It is suggested they improve cognitive function (memory, focus, etc.). They are not fully regulated and you can find examples for sale on Amazon. As such, no idea if short or long-term usage is safe but it's interesting product if you simply read what the labels claim.
- chrisseldo 9y agoIt's also a pretty decent album released in 2012 by Lower Dens.
- deelowe 9y agoNootropics aren't really products in and of themselves. Caffeine is a nootropic for example. There's a pretty broad range from herbals all the way to perscriotion and illicit drugs.
- akvadrako 9y agoThis type of comment should really be somehow differentiated from the rest. It's about defining a common idea (within large subsets of society), that if you don't know, you can't really talk about intelligently.
- xstephen95x 9y agoWho is YouTube to decide what I can and can't watch?
- butterfi 9y agoThe owners of the platform. They are not a public service nor to they have to pretend to be one.
- politician 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privately_owned_public_space https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privately_owned_public_space YouTube essentially has a monopoly on video. Monopolies and other actors can be forced to comply with public space laws or to respect principles that normally apply only to the government.
- foota 9y agoQuoting from that article: These spaces are usually the product of a deal between cities and private real estate developers in which cities grant valuable zoning concessions and developers provide in return privately owned public spaces in or near their buildings.
- akvadrako 9y agoThey don't have a monopoly - what an absurd idea. You can just publish videos on your own site.
- politician 9y agoMicrosoft didn't abuse a monopoly on Windows in the 90s either, as you could just run a Linux distribution on your own machine. Right? Wrong. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor.... Just because someone can run a small-time operation out of their garage, doesn't mean another company doesn't have a monopoly.
- kristofferR 9y agoYouTube will probably remove fitness videos soon, since some people invariably are stupid and will hurt themselves with the exercises on display, a completely analogous situation.
- atomical 9y agoExercise is much different from research chemicals. One difference is you don't need to buy exercise from shady sites that will eventually be shut down by the FDA.
- kristofferR 9y agoYou didn't bother to read the article, this isn't about research chemicals. And even if it was about RCs - talking about them and sharing experiences should be allowed, censorship of information only aids misuse.
- atomical 9y agoMany research chemicals are sold as nootropics. We are allowed to discuss things that are related. But not sell them, which is what YouTubers do indirectly through affiliate links.
- 2_listerine_pls 9y agoTIL calcium supplements are research chemicals.
- atomical 9y agoDid you?
- 2_listerine_pls 9y agoIt was a joke...
- jerf 9y ago"Cronin’s YouTube channel was up to about 22,000 subscribers when he received a notice from YouTube about one of his videos, “Relax and Improve Your Sleep with Natural Calm Magnesium.” The notice said the video had been removed for violating YouTube’s community guidelines, but didn’t specify further." Magnesium isn't even a nootropic. That is, while it may have some ability to boost cognition, it isn't a substance primarily ingested for that reason. It is a substance primarily ingested so that the person ingesting it will stay alive. A quick cruise around Duck Duck Go suggests that while science isn't saying you should use magnesium for sleep per se, it isn't necessarily a crazy idea in desperate need of being censored. Certainly the idea that magnesium is generally deficient is widespread, with estimates around 50% not meeting the US RDA for magnesium in the US, and while magnesium may not be a good solution for insomnia qua insomnia, it can be a good solution for many things that may be causing you to be "unable to sleep"[1], whether or not that is "insomnia". [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnesium_deficiency_(medicine)#Signs_and_symptoms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnesium_deficiency_(medicine...
- jrhurst 9y agoProblem is medical claims are highly regulated in the West. So there is a likely legal liability for youtube in the US and in the UK. In fact, they might have already had pressure from regulators.
- jerf 9y agoThat would make sense. It would help if YouTube would say so. I'm not sure Google's usual total opacity is going to play to their favor here. As I said in another comment, I personally see no reason to trust their judgment in these matters, but if they said "Hey, we're getting regulatory pressure from X about Y and we need to remove your stuff" that would be a step in the direction of restoring my trust. (I've got other reasons I'm very unlikely to ever trust them very much overall, but I am capable of nuance, so I have no problem saying I would at least trust them more.)
- vertexFarm 9y ago“Nothing illegal, no medical advice offered, I've always been incredibly careful about this.” The article then goes on to name several videos with titles like "increase energy," "improve concentration and memory," "improve sleep," etc. Are there any lawyers around who know of a legal definition for "medical advice" or "medical claims?" Because these videos sound a lot like medical advice despite his insistence that they aren't. Youtube censorship sucks sometimes, but this guy experimenting on himself is not nearly rigorous enough to figure out what's really happening when he is taking these supplements. When a person sets out to improve themselves with drugs, test the process on themselves, and interpret and analyze those results themselves, it's a viper's pit of biases. Obviously the experimenter has a huge personal stake in the experiment (arguably the largest; his person is the experiment!) and that generally is great for motivation but bad for science. I like playing with nootropics but I'm also relatively healthy and I can't imagine how damaging it might be for a seriously ill person who is taking advice from youtube in a desperate and futile attempt to improve their condition and survive. The ethics are pretty complex, above my pay grade for sure.
- wcunning 9y agoThe question I have about this, gun related content and anything else that is "A violation of our T&C" is this: when does YouTube/FB/whatever stop being a safe harbor according to the DMCA? Which special interest group (NRA?) is going to bankroll the law suit against Google for hosting copyrighted content without permission and that they are entirely liable because they're exercising editorial control? Or is the safe harbor provision toothless because Google is a giant?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- newnewpdro 9y agoWithout having watched any of this stuff, my assumption is these videos are not clear enough in disclaiming any confirmed medicinal or FDA-approved effects. If the content is tantamount to advertising on the level the supplement manufacturers are prohibited from (and careful to avoid) doing themselves, it's probably appropriate for YouTube to close down the channels. Especially if these YouTubers are somehow generating income from the "product reviews".
- awakeasleep 9y agoI bet this is close to the real issue here. All this guy's videos were hawking products from specific manufacturers. Anyone know whether he disclosed that he was being compensated by the companies?
- logfromblammo 9y agoIf you derive a significant portion of your income from streaming video content, you should probably be using hosting sites like YouTube and Vimeo only to mirror your self-hosted content and drive traffic back to servers you control if you can. You never know when companies like Alphabet or Facebook or Amazon or Apple will pull the rug out from beneath you and yank away that source of income, so don't stand on their rugs. If you let someone stand between you and your money, there will be someone standing between you and your money. And as there is no way they could possibly review all uploaded videos with actual humans, much of this enforcement is done by machine detection and automated processing, and you will never get any explanation from a human, unless you are in the top 1000 accounts ranked by how much money they make for YouTube. Not that this sort of content needs to be in video form, anyway. If I feel the need to learn about new, unregulated, or misregulated drugs, I'd prefer reading text, with as few still images as is possible to convey the needed information.
- sometimelydat 9y agoThey will not stop at nootropics, nor psychedelics; They will stop at nothing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- weego 9y agoI mean, I think you'd find they would stop at content that was suitable for their ad partners to run profitable ad campaigns on. That is after all how they keep the lights on.
- myko 9y agoIt would be good for YouTube to remove these and other scam videos.
- wagecuck 9y agoNasim did nothing wrong.
- lostgame 9y agoI run an independent music label in Toronto, and our group has been considering for some time to create a semi-serialized web series but one of the big prohibiting factors in us actually getting it done is that nobody wants to use YouTube. If we generate a serious following that is dependent on the platform we're giving up a tremendous degree of creative control and direction for our fans. Not to mention the serious lock-down on live-streaming musical content, and copyright restrictions. If so much as five seconds of the wrong song is playing in the background, the whole episode gets pulled. Can we do a cover of 'x'? Other people have, but will ours get pulled? Here we have an instance where hundreds of other similar videos and channels exist, yet these three individuals were singled out. If there was at least consistency in the censorship and copyright stuff, or a proper channel for communication, the platform would still be viable. But, like the Apple iOS App Store, you can produce an entire project, upload it, and, if it even gets up there to start, you've basically just gotta cross your fingers and hope it stays there, because the right to pull it at any time is there. tl;dr: at least if YouTube, Apple, etc, were consistent with censorship and offered proper channels of communication they would be much more viable platforms.
- joew42k 9y agoMy advice would be to use https://indieweb.org/POSSE https://indieweb.org/POSSE That approach might be more agreeable with your label-mates. I wouldn't put covers in the videos at all. You're right, that's a legal minefield. Just use original music that you have the rights to.
- avoutthere 9y agoThe timing suggests that this might be related to GDPR.
- jstandard 9y agoIn what way do you think this relates to GDPR?
- 2_listerine_pls 9y agoThere may be a Greek woman named Calm Calcium.
- josteink 9y agoWhile it seemed against the times when I, in the age of YouTube, Spotify and Netflix, decided to start to build my media library with Plex... ...with artists suddenly withdrawing their music from streaming services... ...and Netflix constantly upping their price while enforcing ever more stringent HW-requirements for “good enough” DRM throughout your media rig for “premium” content... ...and YouTube happy to censor anything not approved by the Sanfran extreme left... I have to say I really start appreciating having a personally curated, persistent library of media which is mine to own, and mine to decide where and how I use. Everything old is new again, I guess.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoThat's a bummer. But I guess Google knows better, or something. Pardon me, while I go watch "Peppa Pig Goes to the dentist crying Elsa". It's been on YT since Feb 2017. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NVx4hA0Tcdo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NVx4hA0Tcdo Aside the snark, its time to regulate how our data is used, what decisions are made upon it, and a proper grievance for companies that do that. The GDPR is a good start, to be honest.
- pasbesoin 9y agoHere's part of the deal: Take YouTube, a large commercial interest. Add their lobbying, that is participating and influencing a limited, largely invitation-only discussion of what video distribution is and will be on the Web. (I say largely invitation-only, because 10's and 100's of thousands of us can mount campaigns "of the masses" without moving the needle, or generating only a temporary reaction until the powers that be can slip their changes through another avenue or after simply wearing us out.) Now, they are no longer "just" a commercial provider, free to choose what they wish to host. They are defining the very nature of Web video (and, more broadly, content) distribution -- to suit their own purposes. THAT's why you worry when big players start doing stuff. Because it tends to become "the law".
- joew42k 9y agoYoutube is a private company and can do whatever they want with their own website. Nobody's stopping makers of these videos from hosting the videos themselves. This is not censorship in the way we have traditionally understood. It only feels like it because Youtube is where the biggest audience is. It's the same whenever Facebook penalizes a post in the timeline, or whenever Google hides content from the search results. They feel like a the phone company or the post office - neutral platforms where people expect the right to free speech. In reality, they are publishers that exercise editorial discretion. If we had focused on building decentralized platforms with interoperability and open standards, this wouldn't be an issue. Instead, you all wanted to make money. (Understandable) My proposal - the government should recognize that network effects produce defacto monopolies, and use existing anti-trust law to break up these behemoth platforms, or force regulation on them. In the mean time, I'll shout "i told you so" from my lonely, facebookless, linux-powered compound.
- vertexFarm 9y agoThere should be a social network for lonely, security-obsessed linux people who refuse to partake in social media. Maybe we should start raising homing pigeons and send little notes to each other. I need to get my ham license one of these days.
- joew42k 9y agoNot until we can have independent audits of the pigeons and the freedom to distribute forked pigeon breeds.
- Analemma_ 9y ago> There should be a social network for lonely, security-obsessed linux people who refuse to partake in social media. Where do you think you are? ;)
- jdietrich 9y agoI'm sure you'll get on famously with Diaspora's user.
- 9y ago
- kawfey 9y agoNew Ask HN thread: where are creators migrating to in lieu of YouTube? Vimeo? Twitch? Facebook? Metacafe or Dailymotion? There are also also already dozens of dapps for streaming like dtube, lbry, viewly, lino, flixxo....(etc, just see https://www.google.com/search?q=decentralized+youtube https://www.google.com/search?q=decentralized+youtube), but I don't see any particular venue rising above the rest, as a lot of creators seem to choose "all of the above" as an answer, syndicating content across as many domains as possible.
- JackCh 9y agoAFAIK nothing. From what I've seen nearly everybody is remaining on youtube and is counting on using alternative monetization platforms such as patreon or selling merchandise. This gives them a security net if youtube decides to demonetize their videos (or simply if their youtube revenue drops off), but doesn't help them if youtube just starts deleting their videos or bans them from the platform. For instance Cody's Lab has a patreon page which doubtlessly helps with falling revenue from youtube, but it doesn't prevent youtube from giving him various community guideline strikes and locking his channel for videos that were considered acceptable years ago when they were uploaded but are now retroactively in violation. (Some specific 'genres' of content creators have alternative platforms. For instance gamers have twitch, and gun channels have full30. But I've not seen any alternative platform becoming popular that targets the full range of youtube content) (Incidentally the ubiquity of patreon makes me wonder if it too will shape up to be considered a harmful monopoly one day in the not so distant future.)
- tanilama 9y agoThey talk about it, but they never leave. There is NO true alternative, that can make real money other than YouTube
- 21 9y agoThere is nowhere to go, no platform wants to host polarizing videos, which will alternatively be attacked by both the far left and the far right (mostly by the left today since tech companies employees mostly sympathize with them thus they get more favorable outcomes)
- yladiz 9y agoI remember when I was in high school, I got onto Something Awful and saw some posting about nootropics and was interested in the possible effects, like improved memory and sharper concentration, so I got some (I think piracetam). In the instructions it said it would take some time to work, like a week or two, and after a few days of feeling the same and seemingly having no effects I stopped taking them and the only benefit I got afterwards was selling the remaining pills to my friend since they apparently make the high from pot more intense. Beyond the anecdote I don't think this is censorship from Youtube, it's likely the creators were either venturing into advertising/selling products as the primary purpose of their videos, or giving some kind of medical advice about how they can improve your life/body, or both, both of which I think are against Youtube ToS. Given that it's a story from Motherboard we're probably just getting a partial part of the story and the article is just making it seem like Youtube is censoring something they shouldn't, rather than putting the creators at fault.
- enginaar 9y agoSo a creator trusts the guidelines provided by youtube and invests in a business to find out later youtube can actually shut that business down without a tangible reason. I don't understand how being a private entity gives youtube the right to make a false advertisement and treat their creators as fools. Is it clearly stated that youtube can remove your videos just because? (considering, claiming it's not fitting guidelines is as vague as claiming it is bad for the environment)
- mynameisvlad 9y agoOf course it is. Almost every single sharing service has some sort of clause in their ToS that they can remove any content at their discretion.
- enginaar 9y agoI get that. I wish I emphasized "clearly" because it seems common practice to create a false perception of justice/security/privacy with almost every single online service now. I just don't understand how this practice can be the "right" of any entity not just private. This sounds like an excuse for people who know to despise others for not knowing.
- digitalneal 9y agoWould be interesting to know if these "silenced" channels have monetization turned on.
- ComputerGuru 9y agoYouTube has a monopoly on free online video and this is what monopoly looks like. When Google bought out YouTube, as those that were online back then can attest, there were dozens of not hundreds of competing sites. None of those could hold a candle to the resources Google’s cash could buy, and they quickly dropped out of the running. The only site still around is probably vimeo, and only because they were smart enough to not target the masses and instead pick a niche to serve.
- mike00632 9y agoThe few video sites that have managed to compete with YouTube all have interesting angles. There is DailyMotion, which is popular in France and seems to play fast and loose with IP laws. Tudou for when you're behind the great Chinese Firewall. Facebook videos, which compete in view counts with YouTube by force of their own monopoly on social media. And Twitch which carved out a niche in video game streaming. Maybe we should consider Twitter videos too. RIP Vine.
- RIMR 9y agoLook, I know there are plenty of people here who will sing the praises of their chosen Nootropic stack, but quite honestly, the majority of the videos I have seen on the subject online tout over-the-counter supplements as miracle pills with limitless-esque possibilities. 9/10 pieces of advice I see on Nootropic use amount to dangerous and misinformed medical advice. I can understand why YouTube would want to avoid looking complicit in all of this, especially with more than one popular Nootropic supplement sending users to the hospital in recent months.
- nyrulez 9y agoI wasn't aware YouTube is liable for any advice on it's platform. Is that the case?
- dawhizkid 9y agoMy curiosity about nootropics was the only reason I bought Bitcoin in 2014 so I could buy them online.
- eulers__number 9y agothere needs to be a decentralized YouTube
- retox 9y agoBig pharma are untouchable on TV (the silence around mass shooters and prescription meds is deafening) so my guess is you will soon see more pharma ads on YouTube etc. Can't upset the sponsors now.