6 ms·
Neither of you are really using supporting evidence in this discussion, you're both just two sides of a value argument increasing in volume. On the one hand, t
by komali2 9y ago
Neither of you are really using supporting evidence in this discussion, you're both just two sides of a value argument increasing in volume.
On the one hand, the other guy is legally correct - gdpr's purpose is to legally give individuals control over data about them (pictures they upload, addresses they input, whatever). That control is responsible on a site to site basis - if a person's naked picture is leaked online, every single IP address that hosts it must take it down if requested, or violate gdpr.
You're making a functional argument - if a person's nudies are leaked online, they don't functionally have control over that data. Morals and laws be damned, that picture is staying on the internet.
You can both disagree about the morality of this but simply restating both of your points with more "full stops" is pointless. If you're both really having trouble understanding each other's positions, step back and try to defend the opponent's decision.
- jimktrains2 9y ago> You're making a functional argument - if a person's nudies are leaked online, they don't functionally have control over that data. Morals and laws be damned, that picture is staying on the internet. Which is my point. You no longer retain any control over it. A law saying you have control over it is silly, because it's worse than worthless: it makes me think I have control over something I don't have control over. Laws cannot magically manufacture things which cannot ever be created. Moreover, the gdpr doesn't prevent any of the problems that have caused data breaches in the past. The way that Target and Equifax (both of which could easily claim the data they had was essential to their business: Target with credit cards and Equifax being used by banks to coordinate information) are both equally likely under the gdpr and both equally unpublishable. As for Facebook and Cambridge Analytica, how would this have been prevented? Facebook can just ask you to opt in to their usage of your info to use their service. Facebook can share information with other entities that claim to be gdpr compliant. Other entity then shares information with other people outside of Facebook's control. I just don't see how the gdpr changes a fundamental fact: you no longer control something someone else has. Laws cannot change that. Laws can give you recourse, but they cannot change it. I actually believe that it's dangerous to believe that I have control over things I don't: it's a false sense of security.
- victorNicollet 9y agoIs there an example of "control" that is not of the "you have legal recourse" nature ? Outside of crypto, I can't think of any.
- jimktrains2 9y agoYes, not giving ownership away to a party with no contractual obligations to you.
- chii 9y agoYou'll find living this way to be difficult and frustratingly annoying.
- che_shirecat 9y agoSo what's the point of your argument? Should we scrap GPDR because it isn't 100% effective in curbing personal data misuse? You could argue along similar lines that almost any law gives you a false sense of security - why do copyright laws exist, do they give the music industry for example a false sense of security that their audio files can't possibly be copied or shared? No, but they do provide legal recourse and they do set up a framework for acceptable use. If facebook shared your information with another entity without your consent, that would be a violation of GPDR and you would again have legal recourse.
- jimktrains2 9y agoPerhaps the public could be forced to realize that they are responsible for what data they share and with who?
- cyphar 9y agoAnd now we're back to the argument that we shouldn't protect the public against systemic unethical behaviour, and rather we should protect the bad actors while blaming the public for not being educated enough. Wanting better education is a fine goal (and one I agree with), but the reason why we have seat-belts (as well as driving lessons) is that sometimes you also need other protections for the public. The same logic applies for consumer laws. We don't blame the public for not doing enough research to know that their new phone charger blows up after 3 months -- we blame the manufacturer. Also there's the fact that companies can end up sharing data to other parties, or a company can be acquired and change their mind about what the data will be used for (which is allowed because of the originally nebulous scope of their T&C which was specifically designed to allow for expansion without asking for user consent explicitly when usage changes). GDPR provides methods for users to be protected in both of those cases -- while just enforcing education does not. Not to mention that if education was mandatory, then the same companies complaining about GDPR today would be complaining about educating users how their services abuse their dignity. Cutting Google/Amazon/Facebook/etc slack for making hundreds of billions from users' personal data and creating "Big Brother"-esque profiling systems for their billions of users doesn't really seem rational to me.