4 ms·
This to me is one of the biggest proofs that the Torah (first part of the Bible) wasn’t just a bunch of legends written by man. It says that Abraham’s children
by EGreg 9y ago
This to me is one of the biggest proofs that the Torah (first part of the Bible) wasn’t just a bunch of legends written by man.
It says that Abraham’s children will be as numerous as the sand on the seashore and the... stars in the sky.
After all, as far as ancient people knew, there were millions (possibly billions) of sand grains by the sea, and ... maybe 5,000 stars?
I am sure Greek astronomers would have laughed at any Jew who said that the number of stars is in the millions and billions.
Yet these days with modern science we have found out that there are as many if not more stars than sand grains.
Now, an atheist would say “that was just an expression”. But who really uses stars as an example of millions, just like sand grains, over and over repeatedly, if they really thought there weren’t that many? It must have been one lucky guess!
There are other proofs but this to me is one of the hardest to explain away.
* EDIT: lots of militant atheists on this site I see, wielding that downvote button rather than engaging in substantive argument
- skummetmaelk 9y agoA broken clock is right twice a day.
- verbify 9y agoAre you serious? 1) Surely the Bible is just making the same mistake I make when looking at the sky - imagining that I'm seeing millions instead of just 9k. 2) If it wasn't just an expression then there are an estimated 300 billion stars in the milky way alone. Astronomers put current estimates of the total stellar population at roughly 70 billion trillion (7 x 1022). I don't see that many descendants of Abraham. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. A figure of speech that uses the stars as a reference to a huge number is not extraordinary evidence.
- EGreg 9y agoQuadrillions https://www.npr.org/sections/krulwich/2012/09/17/161096233/which-is-greater-the-number-of-sand-grains-on-earth-or-stars-in-the-sky https://www.npr.org/sections/krulwich/2012/09/17/161096233/w...
- throwa_way_ 9y agoThis is what counts for a "proof"?
- jacquesm 9y ago> lots of militant atheists on this site I see, wielding that downvote button rather than engaging in substantive argument If you want substantive argument you have to start off with a position that is ground in something that could be reasonable. Your position is starting out by extrapolating god from the fact that someone made a wild guess about the number of stars in the sky. That does not seem to invite substantive argument, it merely proves that you have a tendency to leap to - probably - wrong conclusions.
- lostgame 9y ago>> lots of militant atheists on this site I see, wielding that downvote button rather than engaging in substantive argument > If you want substantive argument you have to start off with a position that is ground in something that could be reasonable. Thanks for saving me the trouble of having to explain this. :P
- eesmith 9y agoYou wrote "I am sure Greek astronomers would have laughed at any Jew who said that the number of stars is in the millions and billions." Why do you think that? Plato, who lived until 347 BCE, wrote in Timaeus (39b-d) (quoting https://www.ellopos.net/elpenor/physis/plato-timaeus/time.asp?pg=3 https://www.ellopos.net/elpenor/physis/plato-timaeus/time.as... ): > Mankind, with hardly an exception, have not remarked the periods of the other stars, and they have no name for them, and do not measure them against one another by the help of number, and hence they can scarcely be said to know that their wanderings, being infinite in number and admirable for their variety, make up time. A Greek astronomer living at the same time that the Torah was written down would agree that numbers were uncountable. It was a poetic metaphor or hyperbole to mean "uncountably many." Eg, https://www.bibleandscience.com/bible/books/genesis/genesis1_numberstars.htm https://www.bibleandscience.com/bible/books/genesis/genesis1... points out that an Akkadian inscription from around 1280 BCE - which is around the same time that tradition says that the Oral Torah was given to Moses at Mount Sinai (1312 BCE) - says "Thereupon, the land of the Kuti, whose numbers are countless as the stars of heaven" Or from around 1018 BCE: "In his first year the city of Suru of Bit-halupe rebelled. Assur-nasir-pal captured the city and said, "Öhis heavy spoil, which like the stars of heaven could not be counted, I carried off"" Thus, the account in the Torah appears to be in line with what the Greeks and what others in the Middle East believed - that the number of stars in the sky was beyond counting. On the other hand, a Greek astronomer after Hipparchus or Ptolemy might have laughed, as their catalogs counted about 1,000 stars. But that was several hundred years after the Torah was written down. This is what we would expect if the authors of the Torah drew from the general cultural understanding of their era, and does not require some special or hidden connection to a non-human source. You further posit "who really uses stars as an example of millions, just like sand grains, over and over repeatedly, if they really thought there weren’t that many?" As I believe I have demonstrated, it wasn't until Hipparchus's star catalogue from about 135 BCE that people in that region of the Earth had the idea that the visible stars might actually be countable. Until then it was used metaphorically to mean "could not be counted." The Greeks also used the number of grains of sand as a metaphor for "uncountable". For example, Pindar's Olympian 2 ("For Theron of Acragas Chariot Race 476 B. C.") ends "Since the sand of the shore is beyond all counting, who could number all the joys that Theron has given others?"; http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.01.0162%3Abook%3DO.%3Apoem%3D2 http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%... . There are other metaphors for uncountable. In Olympian 12 the same author uses "I would not know how to give a clear account of the number of pebbles in the sea." Could you explain what "militant" means? Are you militant? Do you think I am?
- checkyoursudo 9y agoI don't get it. There are not a number of Jews equivalent to the grains of sand nor the stars in the sky (100 billion stars x ??? trillions of galaxies?), either today or in total whom have ever existed. There will never exist a number of Jews equivalent to the number of stars in the universe. There will never at any point in the future exist a total number of people, much less just Jews, who have ever lived to match even close to the number of stars in the universe. Why are you taking this passage in the Torah to say millions, except for the fact that that's a magnitude that is relatively close to the number of Jews? You're seeing a fit that doesn't exist. If a Greek astronomer said there were 5000 or 9000 stars, and a Jewish astronomer said there were millions, or even billions, of stars, they would both be as far away from 10^24 (or more) by almost the same magnitude. The Torah is not giving correct guesstimations of any of these quantities. It's vague and no more accurate than your Greek dude saying, "dunno, maybe 10,000?" It's just saying, "man, you'll have a lot of descendants." If someone told me I'd have between 5000 and 9000 descendants, I'd probably think that was quite a lot. This doesn't strike me as particularly convincing. If it's good enough for you, then by all means. But it is anything but proof.
- SmellyGeekBoy 9y ago> lots of militant atheists on this site I see, wielding that downvote button rather than engaging in substantive argument I don't see you "engaging in substantive argument" in the replies here...?
- bloak 9y agoI think perhaps the random-like distribution of the stars (position and brightness) suggests a huge number of them, even if you can't see them all. In other words, even without modern cosmological theories you guess that there are many fainter stars which you can't see.
- lopmotr 9y agoMake sure your claim is falsifiable. What would prove it wrong? Maybe finding that the number of stars was different from the number of grains of sand. But how different? If you don't establish the criteria for rejecting the claim, then it's pointless to try and prove it because you'll always find a way to make it look like it's true. If you're not going to think scientifically, then your conclusion is as worthless as any other religious belief.