10 ms·
'We're doomed': Mayer Hillman on the climate reality no one else dare mention
- tim333 9y agoSounds like "the climate reality no one else will dare mention" is unmentioned because it's nonsense. Solar / wind are dropping Moores law fashion, governments could crank up action if doom looked likely, the earth has had far higher co2 in the past. 100 million years ago it was about 5x what it is now but life wasn't wiped out.
- titzer 9y agoDid you actually read the article? You are being downvoted because you repeat canard with no real data, and nothing is topical in your comment.
- tim333 9y agoI skimmed it and edited a little. I guess I'm more optimistic about tech fixes that the author. Does anyone sensible think we're actually doomed?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Antimachides 9y agoAh yes, tech fixes.
- lozenge 9y agoThe excess CO2 in the atmosphere, with a volume of 400,000 Empire State Buildings, is ripe for disruption! Source: http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0081648 http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal....
- realusername 9y agowe will need a lot more than "tech fixes" with the current situation.
- mirimir 9y agoWell, I'm personally doomed, as are we all, sooner or later. So far, anyway. I agree that industrial civilization is very likely doomed. Or at least, except for the wealthy. There's just too much momentum from CO2 already in the atmosphere. Even if no more were released, starting today. And then there are all the potential, arguably likely, positive feedbacks. Such as melting of permafrost in northern Canada and Siberia. But I disagree about the mass extinction aspect. Earth is in the midst of an anthropogenic mass extinction. But collapse of industrial civilization will mitigate that, I suspect. Climate change will drive some species extinct, but overall diversity will do better without so many people. As you say, CO2 levels were higher in the past. But damn, when they were, the Earth was a tropical hothouse. But what's bad about rapid CO2 increase is that evolutionary change can't keep up. Species, even entire ecosystems, will get sucker punched. And even so, having less people will help. I doubt that humans will go extinct, either. We're tough bastards. Maybe there's a population bottleneck coming, but that's often a good thing, in the long term.
- crispinb 9y ago> Does anyone sensible think we're actually doomed? It's been at least 2 decades since I've met or heard from one who didn't.
- dredmorbius 9y agoDoes anyone sensible think we're actually doomed? https://duckduckgo.com/?q=scientists+letter+warning&atb=v64-5_a&t=cros&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=scientists+letter+warning&atb=v64-... "Thousands of scientists issue bleak 'second notice' to humanity" https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/speaking-of-science/wp/2017/11/13/thousands-of-scientists-issue-bleak-second-notice-to-humanity https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/speaking-of-science/wp/2... "16,000 scientists sign dire warning to humanity - CNN" https://www.cnn.com/2017/11/14/health/scientists-warn-humanity/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2017/11/14/health/scientists-warn-humani... "20,000 Scientists Sign "Warning To Humanity" Letter About ..." https://trofire.com/2018/03/18/20000-scientists-sign-warning-to-humanity-letter-about-environmental-destruction/ https://trofire.com/2018/03/18/20000-scientists-sign-warning... https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Gish_Gallop https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Gish_Gallop
- whataretensors 9y agoI think we'll be fine. The earth just needs a brain to heal itself, or to plan to heal itself. I don't agree at all with the half-assed expensive solutions proposed so far.
- lucideer 9y agoThe article is similarly data-free. The only references are to known/well-accepted figures that everyone is mentioning, e.g. the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change predictions. The so-called "climate reality no one else will dare mention" isn't really explored, and certainly isn't referenced, save for fairly spurious lines like: > A small band of artists and writers [...] have embraced the idea that “civilisation” will soon end in environmental catastrophe but only a few scientists [...] have suggested as much. So both the number of artists and writers, AND the number of scientists supporting this are apparently small. And, again, unreferenced. I won't defend the commenter here directly, but their comment is certainly no worse nor less valid than the article.
- lozenge 9y agoWatch some lectures by Kevin Anderson, he is probably the best person to put the point across. > governments could You're ignoring the tragedy of the commons, and democracy. Would the population pay 10x more for flights because of a tax? Would a government give its own industry a competitive disadvantage for the environment?
- dredmorbius 9y agoAnything specific (and preferably concise) you'd recommend?
- lozenge 9y agoNo, all his lectures are basically the same, with just a few updates. If an hour is too long, just watch it sped up a little! If it has to be written, he had a letter to Science on BECCS iirc.
- dredmorbius 9y agoThanks. I've just listened to (mpsyt) this talk, 27m with (surprisingly good) Q&A. https://youtube.com/watch?v=skilmEHMsMc https://youtube.com/watch?v=skilmEHMsMc
- dredmorbius 9y agoThe key element of this piece is its recognition of the social, political, institutional, model-and-frame, and epistemic roadblocks to addressing the hyman predicament. People, writ large, don't want to hear this. Happy stories are far more compelling. Complex stories with unhappy endings, not so much. And all systems stories are complex. (They don't all have to have bad endings, though many do.) Politics, particularly large-scale democratic systems, hew away from intellect and sophistication. Aristphanes wrote of this in ancient Greece, The Frogs. One of the most accessible and concise developments I've seen is H.L. Mencken's 1926 essay, "Brayard vs. Lionheart", on the Coolidge-Cox U.S. presidential race. Highly recommended. https://amomai.blogspot.com/2008/10/hl-mencken-bayard-vs-lionheart.html https://amomai.blogspot.com/2008/10/hl-mencken-bayard-vs-lio... Our institutions, cultural, governmental, commercial, and otherwise, can address the situation at best poorly, and often directly contribute to the problem. I don't have a handy argument as to why, though I'm thinking much on that. The "P Literature" -- Parkinson's Law, the Peter Principle, Putt's Law, and Stephen Potter's Gamesmanship seem to form part of a core. I'd add the Jevons paradox, Gresham's Law, and John Gall's Systemantics as well https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Putt%27s_Law_and_the_Successful_Technocrat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Putt%27s_Law_and_the_Successfu... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systemantics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systemantics Broken models and frames -- theory and ideology -- contribute hugely. I've been focusing particularly on economics and its general failures to properly address both costs and value. (The realisation that "cost", "price", and "value" are three distinct, and frequently only tenuously-related concepts, is a breakthrough in understanding.) And failures of understanding, communication, and processing of information -- our epistemic system -- are another wrench thrown in the works. Not trivially addressed, and perhaps best considered a fundamental system constraint rather than a bug.
- CalRobert 9y agoThanks for that. I submitted this because, although environmental issues come up here relatively often (the collapse of civilisation will, of course, affect tech), I have seen very little with regards to the long-term consequences of our anemic approach to the situation (even the Paris accord is like a band-aid on a shotgun wound). It was nice, for the most depressing value of "nice", to see someone who has shown prescience to just come out and say that there is not much reason to think that we'll get out of this one with an intact civilisation, and to address that Teslas and reusable grocery bags aren't going to fix this. I also thought the mention of focusing on music and love and the things that used to mark a well-lived life as opposed to greater economic extraction might be the best approach. We've been taking out loans from the atmosphere for a couple centuries without too much trouble, but nature is eventually consistent.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoSocial scientist != actual scientist. Read up on current state of the data and modeling done on oceanic thermocline, it will cheer you up.
- vosper 9y agoThe first part of this comment is a blanket statement and it's needlessly dismissive and unfair. But for the second part, can you link any of the research you're talking about or explain why it should make me feel better?
- ppod 9y agoHere's the part that I don't get (and I would be afraid to admit to this in a non-anonymous setting among my peer group). I completely accept the evidence and the consensus that human action is causing global carbon levels and therefore temperature to rise. The part I don't get is what exactly happens to the planet, our species and other animals given say, a 2C rise by 2200. Say that's a 2 metre sea level rise. Ecosystems and societies are pretty robust to that level of change over 200 years. There would be very bad effects on some low-lying coastal cities, and the areas of the earth that are productive for different kinds of agriculture and habitats would change. This is bad and we should work to avoid it, but I think that we lose credibility when we speak of the end of civilisation, or even major threats to our normal way of life globally.
- arnoooooo 9y agoIt's much more than a 2C rise and that will happer much faster than 2200. Even 2C is half an ice-age in magnitude, and it would be happening much faster. You can read my attempt at a primer, which details some of the consequences here : https://climate.btmx.fr https://climate.btmx.fr
- ThomPete 9y ago2C is the popularized number. In reality it's a range (0.8-2.6 for 2050 and 1.4-1.4-5.8 for 2100) and it's not certain how much humans can do about it or have to do with it (we are probably affecting it but how much is still an open question) We have been figthing to survive nature from the start. Ex. sea rise is not a problem that can't be solved just look at Holland. http://www.ipcc.ch/ipccreports/tar/wg2/index.php?idp=29 http://www.ipcc.ch/ipccreports/tar/wg2/index.php?idp=29
- lozenge 9y ago> it's not certain how much humans can do about it or have to do with it (we are probably affecting it but how much is still an open question) What is your point in saying this? Everything always has uncertainties, but scientists and economists are in agreement there is enough known that we need large changes in energy use (which affects all sectors of the economy). That is found in the latest version of the report you linked to, or even the version you linked. The idea that Bangladesh can "solve" sea level rise because Holland can is laughable. Just look at these maps: http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2015/08/bjorn-lomborg-just-a-scientist-with-a-different-opinion/ http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2015/08/bjorn-...
- caf 9y agoAs someone who was actually around in the industry and saw the massive efforts that were made to successfully fix things, it shits me to tears when people talk about the Millenium Bug as some kind of crying-wolf moment. I saw some of the awful bugs that were fixed first hand. I have no reason to doubt that my experience wasn't replicated in important "legacy systems" right across the industry. Things only passed so smoothly because of that effort.
- DanielBMarkham 9y ago"...Instead, says Hillman, the world’s population must globally move to zero emissions across agriculture, air travel, shipping, heating homes – every aspect of our economy – and reduce our human population too..." That's quite breathtaking. "Reducing human population" is a phrase that can only have so many meanings: controlling reproduction, removing access to healthcare, or killing people. There are no other options I'm aware of. You can go to just about any physics site and see lists of things physicists still don't understand. Some of them are so far out in the woods that they're even debating the role of empiricism and the scientific method. (If the math looks good, and we could never perform an experiment, isn't that good enough?) Yet here we have an expert in the social sciences suggesting we do something about having too many humans. Hillman has had a fine career. I wish him the best in his continued efforts. Articles like this exist to praise people of note, also to poke at folks like me who might find some of their statement a bit over-the-top. Better to generate controversy and readership. But we really need a more serious discussion on climate. Not pandering to the end-of-world folks, not pandering to the "nothing to see here, folks". Something substantive. There's a lot of religious and magical thinking in climate science, many times by people who would consider themselves uber rationalists. (They're the worst). The vast majority of the public has had about enough of the extremists and self-promoters. There may be an opportunity to start a reasoned discussion.
- FranzFerdiNaN 9y agoThere won't be a substantive discussion about it (at least not by the people who can actively do something about it), because capitalism won't allow it until it's too late. Sure, politicians will talk a lot about how we should really, any day now, start reducing our carbon output, but ask them to actually implement strict measures and the silence is deafening. Then we have corporations, like oil companies, who for many decades suppressed information and actively tried to distort public discussion about climate change. We have politicians who are either in the pocket of corporations or who support an ideology that opposes them even acknowledging the existence of climate change (or denying the role of humans), as that would hurt stock markets and shareholder profits in the short term. And we have consumers (people aren't really citizens anymore, but consumers first and foremost thanks to capitalism) who are bombarded daily with things they should buy to improve their lives, and who thus refuse to give up things like flying or meat or cheap clothes from the other side of the world. Combine it all and you get the frog that's being slowly boiled (except the frog is smart enough to get out in time).
- jbond23 9y agoThe future doesn't stop at 2100. There are people being born now who will see it. We are starting to badly need some narratives for the 22nd Century and beyond. As for Pinker; the techno-optimists don't seem to get that the Limits to Growth forecasts predicted substantial exponential growth. The huge success and progress we've seen and celebrated by them doesn't invalidate LtoG. The lesson is not that they didn't or can't happen. It's that they can't continue for ever and will inevitably result in over-reach, peak and crash. And that's the part that Pinker et al won't accept. They're attempting to portray and an unlimited rosy future without really looking at all the implications.
- ThomPete 9y agoThats a bit of a straw man. Most people even Pinker would agree that there are limits to growth they just don't agree that we are currently at the limit.
- dredmorbius 9y agoJulian Simon. Herman Kahn. John Maddox. William Nordhaus. Thomas Piketty. Paul Krugman. Milton Friedman. Christine Lagarde. M.A. Adleman. Robert Rubin. Robert Bryce. Stewart Brand. Ray Kurzweil. Michael Lynch. Robert L. Bradley. Peter Huber. Milton Friedman (Nobel Prize in Economics, 1976, also awarded the National Medal of Science (1988), the Presidential Medal of Freedom (1988), and the John Bates Clark Medal (1951)), in "The Energy Crisis: A Humane Solution", 1977: You will all recall ["Limits to Growth"] was a report in which engineers were saying we have finite resources -- a finite amount of coal, a finite amount of space, and so on and so on; things grow at exponential rates, and so long as things grow at exponential rates they are ultimately going to become infinite; and since resources, are finite, we're going to bump into it and therefore we are faced with a terrible future in which sooner or later we are going to run out, of steel or coal or whatever you want to name. We're going to run out, and we really have to adjust our sights; we can no longer take the view that we can have growth forever; we must recognize that there are, in their title, limits to growth and reconcile ourselves.... Now this approach, whether adopted by the Club of Rome or by Mr. Schumacher or by the CED, is completely wrong. The plain fact is that from an economic point of view the volume of resources available to us is larger today than it has ever been in history. We are less dependent today on natural resources than we have ever been. http://0055d26.netsolhost.com/friedman/pdfs/other_commentary/BP.1978.1.pdf http://0055d26.netsolhost.com/friedman/pdfs/other_commentary... (I've made a small hobby of collecting all the action figures: https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=cornucopians&restrict_sr=on https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=cornucopians&r...)
- hutzlibu 9y ago'We're doomed' I kind of grew up with that phrase. It was all over in my childhood climate nature science books etc. But the real world today looks far from it. I mean we have many problems, sure. But doomed? So maybe that's why I can't really take people serious who start with that phrase. "He believes that accepting that our civilisation is doomed could make humanity rather like an individual who recognises he is terminally ill. Such people rarely go on a disastrous binge; instead, they do all they can to prolong their lives." And I rather believe that really doomed people don't care anymore about long-term cancer risk when they allready are full of it. Optimistic people who want to live long and prosper care about that. I mean, we are all going to die anyway, yes. But usually our children live on. But if I would believe the world is doomed, how can I possible raise children with good hearts? But if I and everyone else, stop raising children - then we are indeed doomed.
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoHave you read the article? It talks about what will happen in 100 years and what, based on the data we currently have, is inevitable if we don't take drastic changes (which is unlikely to happen until it's way too late).
- ThomPete 9y agoThe data we currently have predicts between 1.4-5.8 and is based on estimates of global population between 7-15 billion people. Thats the official data and it's not as certain as many would like to make it. http://www.ipcc.ch/ipccreports/tar/wg2/index.php?idp=29 http://www.ipcc.ch/ipccreports/tar/wg2/index.php?idp=29
- gaius 9y agoReally? No one else dare mention? No one dares not mention more like...
- throwaway84742 9y agoHorseshit. Given the exponential nature of technological progress I’m almost certain we will see a technological solution to global warming in my lifetime. Fusion powered carbon capture or reflective stuff in the upper atmosphere etc. Who knows what form it will take. But nobody will just sit idle and watch billions of people die. The major flaw of the current suggestions is that they either aren’t affordable, or lower the standard of living, or both. Outside the 1% bubble it’s been less than 100 years since people had a decent standard of living to begin with, so quite understandably they prefer to drive huge trucks, buy large houses, and fly to Hawaii every year. Shit if it’s ok for Al Gore and Leo DiCaprio to fly private to climate change summits, surely the hoi polloi can partake as well.
- tallanvor 9y agoAnd yet we sit by while at least 9 million people die from hunger every year ( https://www.mercycorps.org/articles/quick-facts-what-you-need-know-about-global-hunger https://www.mercycorps.org/articles/quick-facts-what-you-nee... ), and some groups estimate the number is much higher. People can, unfortunately, easily ignore problems that aren't right at their door, and most of the people who are affected the most aren't in North America or Europe.
- throwaway84742 9y agoBzzzt, wrong answer. A lot fewer people die from hunger now than even a decade ago. And the number is much less than that overall. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malnutrition https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malnutrition
- tallanvor 9y agoFirst, please be polite. Second, the Wikipedia article you link to doesn't provide clear information. The number my source cited was from 2016, which is still quite recent. If we're down from 36 million in 2006, that's good news, but it still means that millions still die every year due to starvation and malnutrition.
- lmm 9y agoThe Guardian loves to blame everything on "capitalism", but the reason there are a lot of e.g. flights isn't so much capitalism as people liking to go places. Indeed capitalism provides the most practical mechanism for resolving things like carbon emissions: if we agreed a cap-and-trade system (like we previously did for sulphur dioxide emissions) then carbon impacts could be priced into the costs of things like flights. As the article says, individual and even national action is as good as futile - we need to act on an international scale, and markets are the only coordination mechanism that can work at that level. Of course even zero emissions may not be enough, and it's good to see that getting acknowledgement - if we have a consensus that we're past the point where we could stop global warming by reducing emissions, then we can start looking at active measures to counteract it (i.e. geoengineering). It won't be easy, or cheap, or safe, but there are no safe options any more.
- nickik 9y agoTypical example of Anti-Humanism. The same idiotic believes people have been peeling for 200s of years. From Malthus to the Nazis to modern Environmentalist moment all the same idiotic believes. First of all, while climate change can be disruptive, it will absolutely not wipe out humans or anything even close to that. The changes are gradual enough that continues adoption will resolve the waste majority of problems without much issues. Fossil fuels cause climate change, but the also cause that people went from 30 to 70 years of avg live. Far more people live in China because they have energy from coal. Denying people cheap energy because of climate change will be MORE harmful to them then climate change. The poorest people on the world who die the earliest are those that don't have access to energy. Starving our-self of energy is not in efforts to consume less, is a futile effort and will never solve anything. We should be concerned and adopt solutions and think about the future, but this sort of pessimism is totally unwarranted. > Hillman doubts that human ingenuity can find a fix and says there is no evidence that greenhouse gases can be safely buried. The cycle for carbon is understood and we could put carbon into lime stone and put them into the ocean again. Its just an energy problem.
- sametmax 9y agoFirst, calling anything idiotic is not going make you gain much credibility here. It's not facebook, we expect you to come up with argument, not name calling. Secondly, you make a lot of assumptions on which you base you reasoning. What if the changes are not that progressive ? What is there is a tipping point ? Then you also assume thzt we couldn't have done overwise, that our lifestyle and how we achieved it was not only inevitable but the only way it is worth it. Your part about self starving is espacially revealling of a narrow view deeply rooted, not only in materialism, but also in rejection of the idea anything else would be good for the human specie. Now i do appreciate the confort of our modern life, but ignoring the price of it, denying the usefulness or even the possibilities of alternatives and promoting the statu quo is very limiting.
- nickik 9y ago> What if the changes are not that progressive ? What is there is a tipping point ? Maybe there is maybe there is not. His point is that there is no hope, and that is false. > Then you also assume thzt we couldn't have done overwise Please tell me all the cases in human history where large amounts of people voluntary restricted their energy use? Carbon growth comes from the developing world, and we can do nothing to restrict that. > Your part about self starving is espacially revealling of a narrow view deeply rooted, not only in materialism, but also in rejection of the idea anything else would be good for the human specie. If you want to voluntarily starve yourself of energy, go ahead have fun. However suggesting it as a solution for a global problem is a non-starter. Even a western person starving himself of energy will still use many X more then most Indians. An most Indians would like to use as much energy as westerners. > Now i do appreciate the confort of our modern life, but ignoring the price of it, denying the usefulness or even the possibilities of alternatives and promoting the statu quo is very limiting. I have never denieded the usefulness of alternatives. All I have said about the status quo is that it is actually saving millions of peoples lives and giving them a higher standard of living. That is often ignored and it should not be, because it misses literally the biggest improvement in human welfare in world history.
- spodek 9y agoThe article recounts Hillman predicting many problems and suggesting solutions, but not getting them implemented. If we want to solve environmental problems we have to separate science and engineering from leadership. Scientists' and engineers' training and skills make them effective at collecting data, analyzing it, and making predictions. They rarely have training to influence people, especially billions of people. JFK's speech advanced us more to the moon than the work of any single scientist or engineer. Hillman recognizes that we all have to change our behavior. His track record implies he is unskilled at leading others to change their behavior so he conclude's we are doomed. I don't think looking to scientists or engineers for leadership will help. Data, predictions, implementation plans, yes. Leadership, no. I believe leadership in the style of Mandela, King, Gandhi, and Havel, suitably adjusted for today's needs, is essential to reduce environmental problems.
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoThese new leaders would a hard time doing their work. Imagine having everybody against you. Almost all industries, media, lobbyists, and most of all - ordinary people who depend on burning fossil fuels (directly in transportation or having someone burn them for most daily-used products). It really seems impossible until some terrible things already start happening.
- gnode 9y ago> While the focus of Hillman’s thinking for the last quarter-century has been on climate change, he is best known for his work on road safety. It seems to me that Hillman's position on climate change follows from his background of opposition to car usage, not the other way around. I think that a primativist approach to solving climate change is bound to fail. The reality is that motor vehicles offer a convenience that drivers (and voters) are unwilling to sacrifice. If we genuinely want to solve climate change, we should focus on changing our technology rather than our way of life. I believe that if we're to make a genuine difference, it will be from shedding our energy's dependence on fossil fuels, not from shedding our dependence on energy.
- stankypickle 9y agoSocial Scientists gives doomsday proclamation on runaway climate change. Why don't we consult Snoop Dogg on his speculations of the existence and smoothness of solutions to Navier–Stokes? Seems logical to me.