4 ms·
> When overwhelming majority of people speak Russian and Russia is the most important trade partner, I think that it's only logical to have Russian as one of th
by adventured 9y ago
> When overwhelming majority of people speak Russian and Russia is the most important trade partner, I think that it's only logical to have Russian as one of the official languages in the country
It makes perfect sense if you want to move away from Russia to dramatically broaden your national potential over time. Russia has a very modest economy versus its population size. Canada and South Korea have overtaken it, and next up Spain, Australia, Mexico and Indonesia will do the same.
There's no hint Russia's economic backwardness is going to change soon. Putin has entirely failed to develop the nation's potential outside of energy. Their GDP per capita has fallen below much of Eastern Europe, including Croatia, Romania, Poland, Hungary, Czech, Slovakia, Slovenia (as well as Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania). Russia is ranked around #60 in the world on GDP per capita.
It would be wise of Kazakhstan to limit their dependency on trade with Russia and look to far larger opportunities globally.
The only future Russia can offer Kazakhstan is one of weak dependency, a future in which Russia dreams perpetually of re-acquiring its former empire territories.
- bitL 9y ago> Their GDP per capita has fallen below much of Eastern Europe I think that was the product of the 90s and you can see it still in full swing in Ukraine (African level of GDP). Since those crazy times of societal collapse their GDP PPP per capita actually rose up to the level of Turkey IIRC; without sanctions they would probably be even a bit higher and become even more threatening, which might not be in US+EU's best interests.
- disordinary 9y agoBefore all the international sanctions Russia was briefly considered a high income country from 2012-2014. They were doing well, and wages in the European part in particular were quite respectable by Eastern European standards, they've gone backwards a lot recently.
- LifeLiverTransp 9y agoThose dreams of glorious pasts are usually very self-defeating (lots of costly police actions in former colonys) with no visibile reward - and thus not half as dangerous as internalized past injustices. Nazi Germany, Japan, and alot of other countrys got drunk on the injustices of the past and used them to justify atrocities in neighbouring countrys. If it were not for the nukes, alot of those nationalist movements would turn into the same pyro-clastic streaming movements we saw in WW2 spilling over borders and running away with civilization. I raise my glass to the post los alamos world order. To a lid on the kettle, forcing dictators to thread littly on there neigbhours and house in the dragons they unleash.
- Max-q 9y agoI don't know what that means - Dr. Temperance Brennan
- drharby 9y agoDr. Brennam, bonecall...something...about a bone?
- wavefunction 9y agoI downvoted you for simply quoting a fictional TV character as your reply. That's more appropriate for other Internet forums, as HN seems to value substantive discussions rather than pop-culture references and one-liners.
- kingofhdds 9y ago>Nazi Germany, Japan, and alot of other countrys got drunk Isn't it the Godwin's Law in action? I seriously doubt that getting out of Russian influence means something apocalyptic. Estonia, for instance, does well, and I'm old enough to remember Russian newspapers predicting its collapse without Russian "big brother".
- paulryanrogers 9y agoDid you mean "tread lightly"?
- usrusr 9y agoBut whenever dreams of former glory set the agenda, they are promoted as an injustice of the past: "history cheated us out of an empire, let's take back what we are owed". ww2 Japan seems to be the rare exception (unless I am missing some former expansion phase and contraction cycle)
- vbezhenar 9y agoYou can move away from Russia as a person. You can't move away from Russia as a country. Those countries are just next to one other, their border probably longer than Europe's perimeter. You have to think for hundreds of years when you're talking about breaking relationships between nations. Putin will die in max 30 years, probably earlier. He's extremely unlikely to be the next Russia's President. Russia might turn 180 degrees in 5 years. Many things might happen. That's even if yours words are true, which I don't fully support.
- shmerl 9y ago> You can't move away from Russia as a country. Russia pretty much caused Georgia and Ukraine to do it, thanks to the absurd aggression of the Russian mafia government. So surely you can, if there is enough will for it. First major step should be reducing economic dependency.
- Mike90 9y ago"...Russia pretty much caused Georgia and Ukraine thanks to the absurd aggression of the Russian mafia government..." whatever you say western troll https://consortiumnews.com/2016/09/12/pushing-nato-to-russias-southern-flank/ https://consortiumnews.com/2016/09/12/pushing-nato-to-russia...
- dang 9y agoPlease don't attack others or use HN for political battle, no matter how wrong another comment is, and regardless of which side you favor. All that is what we're trying to avoid here, so we'd appreciate it if you'd read the site rules and follow them when posting to HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- kolinko 9y agoMany countries did - see Estonia, or Poland. My parents' generation in Poland used to speak and read Russian, have Russian friends and so on. The majority of "trade" was also with Russia. Nowadays, everyone learns English, the new generation doesn't read cyrylic. The trade between us and Russia is a weak shadow of it used to be. Feels kind of like breaking up with an abusive partner, who kept you under lock for many years, telling you they are the best that can ever happen to you, and that you'll never be happy with anyone else ;) Changing the alphabet is one of the steps towards building trade and relationships with English-speaking world. Good for them.
- RomanPushkin 9y ago> Russia is ranked around #60 in the world on GDP per capita. Nonetheless, GPD rank is ~12 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nominal) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nomi... Per-capita rating of countries like India, China is lower (~100). But these are apparently strong economies.
- dmoy 9y agoRight but India and China have solid gdp growth for decades, and have been educating hundreds of millions and pulling them out of poverty while Russia: https://tradingeconomics.com/russia/gdp-growth https://tradingeconomics.com/russia/gdp-growth Three decades ago Russia had a literacy rate of like 99%++, while China was at like 60-70%. There was a lot of "free" growth to be had in China (obviously not free) by lifting the population. China's still got room to grow there. Like a lot of things in economics, trajectory is important (maybe too important, idk).
- xvilka 9y agoExactly, though best thing they can do - better relationship with China.