8 ms·
Stuck: Why the rent and mortgage-burdened don’t always move to cheaper pastures
- notadoc 9y agoMuch of it is about what is trendy, what is the cultural mecca of the moment. Unfortunately the overcrowded west coast continues to dominate the trendseekers mindset, which is why you have ridiculous housing prices all over, a severe homeless crisis, terrible traffic, and rampant overcrowding. Make the midwest, south, and NE "cool" and trendy, and all the trendseekers who endlessly trucked out to the west coast will suddenly discover how "amazing" and "cool" - and ridiculously affordable - Columbus Ohio, Shreveport LA, Rochester NY, or Madison WI are. The price of a downpayment in any west coast state will buy the entire home - cash - in those locations, and in many cases you'll have money left over.
- kolpa 9y agoCA is the most desirable geography in the USA. The homelessness problem isn't because CA is trendy. CA has been the destination for the USA's disenfranchised and opportunity-seekers for decades because it's the best place to start a new life and not die over the winter. That might be ending now that CA is "full".
- komali2 9y agoThe OP might have meant less "disenfranchised" and more "people with money, jobs, and the means to move." I, for example, wasn't exactly disenfranchised when I moved to SF (poor, broke, sure, but with enough credit to get a loan and float on credit cards until I got a job). For me, I chose SF because I was confident I could learn to program and then get a job here, and having an in to cheap housing for Chinese immigrants I knew I could do it without completely bankrupting myself. Opportunities like that don't necessarily exist in Madison, WI, as local culture makes the place a bit more traditional and resistant to, say, bootcamp-educated programmers.
- bazooka_penguin 9y agoIs northern California that much worse in the winters? Or the less popular areas of California? Because whenever we hear about homelessness being a booming problem it's usually to do with SF or perhaps L.A.
- emodendroket 9y agoSF is in Northern California, so I don't understand the question. If you mean to ask why the homeless don't go to Nowheresville, CA, it's probably because there are no social services available for them there.
- prewett 9y agoI'd say SF is more mid-California, compared to what's north of Sacramento. North of Sacramento is pretty rural, full of people wanting to implement the State of Jefferson. But you're right, there isn't much in the way of social services in northern California, due to the population. The only real population centers are Chico and Redding. I haven't spent any time in Chico, but Redding has quite a few homeless, and there isn't much in the way of social services. The City of Redding doesn't have money to burn like SF apparently does, so the homeless pretty much have to fend for themselves. I get the feeling that a lot of Redding's homeless population is on their way somewhere; Redding is kind of a midway stop along I-5 or to the coast.
- emodendroket 9y agoI'm on the East Coast, but Wikipedia describes San Francisco as "the cultural, commercial, and financial center of Northern California."
- prewett 9y agoYeah, and it's understandable why they would say that. Realistically the only places people care about in California are Los Angeles and San Francisco (and to some extent Sacramento and San Diego), and compared to LA, SF is definitely north. Culturally and politically, though, north of Sacramento is quite different from SF. I mean, you see lots of signs supporting the formation of Jefferson State (and seceding from CA). I've had California natives talk about how SF wasn't really northern CA. And geographically, it actually is kind of mid (on the northern end of mid, but still).
- cimmanom 9y agoPeople don't move places because they're trendy. They move places and stay there because that's where the jobs are.
- moate 9y agoAnd because they're safe, and because they feel a sense of community with the people they've met there, and because they're able to indulge their hobbies and because they have family that live there and told them it's great, and because... The reasoning is vast and wild. Job markets are one factor, but there's a huge pile of reasons that factor in. Sometimes that includes being trendy.
- cimmanom 9y agoSure, that's why you move from one place with a decent job market to another with a decent job market. But people an aggregate move towards places that offer economic opportunity and away from those that don't -- hence the waves of migration from rural to urban areas and away from dying cities like Detroit. The only people (not quite that absolute, but close enough) who move from a place with plentiful opportunity to one without opportunity are those who a) have no choice (or feel they have no choice) -- be it due to being priced out or having to take care of an aging parent; or b) aren't subject to such economic pressures (work remotely or are financially independent).
- jonknee 9y agoIf tons of high paying jobs suddenly open up in the Midwest it will not continue to be ridiculously affordable. Good jobs are trendy and will never go out of style.
- salmonfamine 9y agoIt's much more complicated than that. Weather is a huge factor. Network effects are not so trivial or easily displaced. Walkability and public transit are major factors that contribute to those network effects and establish a city's culture -- which is a very difficult thing to reproduce. Not to mention politics. It's easy to say "just move to Shreveport!" But many, many people would feel very uncomfortable moving to these locations due to their religion, sexual orientation, gender identity, or whatever. And maybe the city itself is much more liberal than its surroundings. However, there are still genuine political concerns that many individuals would have for policy decisions made at a state-level that would directly affect their well-being. The major argument people from the midwest or the south give in favor of their locations is lower house prices. Many of the "trendseekers" have no interest suburban tract homes. I think the people advancing this argument should understand that a home is, for many, just one factor amongst many in determining where to live, and in many cases is not the strongest. Shreveport, LA is not "uncool" because of some accident of trendiness. It's uncool because it's uncool. There are no strong networks there, no extensive public transportation systems, no walkability, no political protections for marginalized groups -- etc., etc. It's a lot more than just trendiness. I say this as someone who has never lived on either coast. Just keep in mind that much of America seems unappealing or unfriendly to people who are not from here for legitimate reasons.
- emodendroket 9y agoPlus, I mean, the elephant in the room is jobs. I'd probably be pretty happy in Upstate New York, but the options for work are far fewer than they are near major, booming cities.
- salmonfamine 9y agoYes, absolutely. And those network effects I mentioned above significantly contribute to high-skill job markets in many cases.
- Domenic_S 9y agoJust how many jobs do you need? It only takes one good one that pays the appropriate amount, right?
- emodendroket 9y agoLooking at Boston or NYC suggests the problem isn't that the Northeast isn't cool enough.
- komali2 9y ago>But talk to just one individual who’s gotten stuck (or even chosen to stay) in an expensive home they couldn’t afford, and all that Econ 101 vocabulary starts to fall short. Or at least, you’ll find fairly quickly that no one’s housing decisions are governed neatly by the laws of supply and demand in the housing market alone. And that's because all of us — as consumers and as human beings — are part of infinite markets with infinite feedback loops, not all of which are easily predictable. I struggle to understand why people who argue for rationality, i.e., people who I know are very very smart and extremely rational, turn around and expect rationality from populations. I've talked to highly intelligent bankers who are surprised when a market turns volatile/irrational, doctors who can't comprehend why their patients make irrational/poor health decisions, teachers who have difficulty accepting the disconnected nature of students whose very future depends on them doing well in a given class. Politicians who have this expectation that people will not break the law, or pull themselves up by their bootstraps, or whatever other things that require rigid rationality. Maybe it's a problem with empathy? Of "putting yourself in someone else's shoes?" Maybe it's not even possible for extremely intelligent, relatively rational people, to adopt the mindset of people who (by choice, culture, or means well outside their control) live more emotional, instinctual lives. Even more insidious is when these exact people fail to recognize the irrationality present in themselves, inherent to the fact that they're human. When I studied Anthropology, I'd even come across professors that didn't necessarily believe that human culture is irrational / arbitrary. There may be traits that continue to exist because natural selection promoted them (a religion that resisted the eating of pork and promoted evangalising happens to survive through dark ages because nobody is getting stomach parasites and because it replicates), but there's nothing inherently rational about that. TLDR my big word-salad rant -> I strongly believe, and have horded anthropological evidence to support this belief, that humans at scale are completely irrational, and to expect otherwise is foolish and irrational. One should plan for irrationality. Obviously moving away when rent is too high is the "right" choice, the "rational" choice, but being human is just too messy for something as simple as that. Like the article says, there are just so many reasons that get all tripped up, some rational, some not, all just as powerful an influence on a human "decision tree" (again, too logical a structure to describe human choice-making). I made such a dumb long post because I want to be challenged on this. If you take the time to reply with why you disagree with me I will be very grateful.
- test6554 9y agoI'm surprised nobody is considering a family unit consisting of three equal (adult) partners rather than the standard two-adult nuclear family. Two workers and one homemaker could cover all the bills and allow for the care of the home and children. Given the financial circumstances many Americans are living in, I can't imagine nobody's thought of it.
- tobyhinloopen 9y agoAre you suggesting 3-person “marriage”? Polygamy? That is evil! Only the devil marries multiple people! /s Ill ask my GF if I can look for a 2nd (working) lady to cover some financial issues
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- test6554 9y agoYes, but obviously not legally married as that is not currently possible.
- logfromblammo 9y agoIn which case the obvious solution is to incorporate the family and write the articles and by-laws like a pre-nup. Some use of the civil marriage system might also be required to realize a subset of the benefits enjoyed by traditional marriage partners.
- bawigga 9y agoIf we don't hear back from you in 2 days, we'll send help!
- woolvalley 9y agoIt's the room mate problem. That arrangement is usually 2 adults & grandma, which creates an entire new bunch of problems. The other alternative is to have someone live rent free in exchange for doing the household chores, also known as a live in maid. That is like living with a room mate as a couple, not the most fun. You used to be able to live on one income in america with just a high school education and buying a house in your early 20s. Not so much anymore.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoJose didn’t have a job lined up in Missouri. They certainly didn’t have the money for the moving costs; those would have to go on credit. Not to mention the fact that he’d also be leaving his home, his friends, and almost everything he knew behind in Colorado. I moved someplace cheaper to get off the street. I did that in part by developing an online income under very challenging circumstances. I was able to make the move shortly after paying off my student loan. On the one hand, we need more affordable housing. On the other, I see a lot of potential for reducing our current problems by providing more support for developing portable, flexible income via the internet. What I did is not easy to arrange. It took me several years and I am certainly not in the lap of luxury yet. I do get frustrated when people act like there is no housing crisis, there is plenty of cheap housing. Yeah, sure but it mostly isn't near employment centers. If you don't have an income, you can't afford housing, no matter how cheap it is. The way to promote that idea without being a butt about it is to provide support for people to develop an online income instead of acting like they are just stupid or lazy that their life isn't working.
- joe_the_user 9y agoOn the other, I see a lot of potential for reducing our current problems by providing more support for developing portable, flexible income via the internet. The problem is any online business involves competing with everyone on the Internet. Maybe the skills of fluent-in-American-English or leadership or persuasion or math or programming allow a few to make a decent income selling that unique thing. But any skill that can be mastered is going to have a flood of people learning it from all around world, reducing it's price online.
- notyourday 9y agoIn 10-20 years, sure. So for those 10-20 years we should encourage it.
- gtirloni 9y agoI think that's already the reality today. Many comments here on HN talk about how hard it's to find any decent paying gigs on sites like Upwork due to global competition.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoFor me it’s jobs. I move to a cheaper place for a while, and it was great, until I couldn’t find a job in my industry. Then it was really bad.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoBecause moving takes money, and moving doesn't mean you'll be able to find a job when you get there.
- overcast 9y agoWhat happened to finding a job prior to moving? How many people in this country just pack up all their personal belongings into a horse drawn carriage, and trek across the Oregon trail for a better life?
- s73v3r_ 9y agoNot every career path allows for doing that. If you're not working a white collar job already, odds are you're not going to have the time to go out to the new area to interview, let alone be able to afford to get yourself out there.
- overcast 9y agoI would guess most people aren't working 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. There are plenty of online resources for finding jobs. My father worked in a steel mill for 20+ years, managed to go back to school as a much older adult, and get a job in an entirely new field(medical tech).
- s73v3r_ 9y agoNo, but if you're working two jobs, your time for doing that is extremely limited. Double so if you have a family. Your dad probably was not working more than 8 hours a day. A lot of people that the article is talking about are those that have to work much more than that.
- overcast 9y agoMy father worked double shifts most of my childhood, on rotation shifts no less. Dude worked his ass off, and still had time to build our house, advance his career, and was always around for baseball practice. No excuses.
- pascalxus 9y agoIt's quite simple, really. The main reason they don't move to cheaper pastuers is: Jobs. The cheapest place in the US won't help much if you don't have any source of income. We really need to start encouraging companies to put jobs in places where people can live. Or build places people can live near jobs. One or the other, or Both.
- metalliqaz 9y agoCompanies won't put jobs in places where they can't find good candidates. It's a circular problem. There are many factors and therefore many aspects to a solution, but I think one certainty is that education is required. Investments in public education and job re-training could go a long way to making those low-cost places more attractive to employers. Another thing to keep in mind is that people who have choice will often pay more to live in places that have benefits other than available jobs. People want a safe place with a good social scene and stuff to do. Just ask Connecticut. Employers there are struggling to find candidates because everyone wants to leave the boring state. Conservatives love to blame the state's high taxes, but the high-value employees are so often moving to places like NYC and Boston where the taxes and living costs make CT look downright cheap.
- scarface74 9y agoOne problem is easy to solve - not wanting to move because your house is under water. It's called "strategic default" walk away from the house, stop throwing good money after bad and three years after your foreclosure you can buy another house. I did it when my house was $60K under water and I was "prequalified with a contingency" to start the process of getting a house built a month before I was officially qualified to get an FHA loan. The day I was qualified, the lender submitted my loan application. I had no moral qualms about it. It was strictly a financial decision.
- girvo 9y agoI’m curious about the moral qualms bit. I suppose I was raised differently (and in NZ/Australia, too) by my parents, but I read an article recently that was on HN about a man who lost maybe $110,000 servicing an underwater mortgage that was due to the GFC. Where do those “morals” stem from?
- scarface74 9y agoSome people think it's a moral responsibility to pay back a debt to the bank. The banks had no qualms about taking taxpayers money and paying people millions in bonuses. The mortgage was a simple contract. If I didn't pay the mortgage they had the right to take the house. They exercised their right.
- girvo 9y agoExactly. The banks can and will screw you over, and they caused the damned issues in the first place! Morals have no place here, I think.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoThat's definitely an option if your house is in a non-recourse state (which is barely a third of them from what I can tell). If your house in one of the other 33 states and you walk away from an underwater mortgage, the lender can make you pay whatever is left-over on the mortgage after they get the proceeds from the foreclosure sale. That is a tough pill to swallow, because not only do you lose your house, you have to keep paying a big chunk of your mortgage with nothing to show for it, and because a foreclosure auction is not the most favorable way of selling a house, you might end up even worse off than if you did a short sale.