4 ms·
This is one of the most unabashedly sinister first-world articles I've read in a while. Microsoft's argument hinges on two damages: Either, they didn't get to
by unethical_ban 9y ago
This is one of the most unabashedly sinister first-world articles I've read in a while.
Microsoft's argument hinges on two damages: Either, they didn't get to charge a convenience fee to customers, or they were losing revenue by people unexpectedly extending the life of their computers.
Foolish judges and evil lawyers putting a decent person away for 13 months.
- gambiting 9y ago>> The judge said he disregarded Weadock’s testimony. “I don’t think anybody in that courtroom understood what a restore disk was,” Lundgren said. There's the problem.
- DoctorOetker 9y agoI think Lundgrens analysis is closer to the truth: “I got in the way of their agenda,” Lundgren said, “this profit model that’s way more profitable than I could ever be.” On average judges defend the nation, money must flow up. The nation's tax income on Microsofts exploitation are bigger (or so thinks the judge) than the tax income on Lundger's (preventive) recycling business. Your taxes represent your bullying/fleecing strength. When one tithe collector gets in an argument with another tithe collector, the goverment tends to agree with the tithe collector that brings the biggest tithes... The population needs to be fleeced. The natural order of things and so on. So it is!
- whatshisface 9y agoJudges do not actually think about maximizing federal tax revenues when making their decisions. There might be something else that is going on to result in that, but judges have absolutely no incentives in that direction.
- cptskippy 9y agoNo, this is an unabashedly sinister misinformation campaign by someone who didn't read the article or understand what this guy was doing. He wasn't distributing restore disks with refurbished PCs. He manufactured 28000 Restore Disks containing Microsoft Windows and was selling them. He justified his actions by saying they were only to be used on licensed machines. That's like me selling a backup copy of your Book and "you're only allowed to read this if you bought the book legitimately."
- unethical_ban 9y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but those restore disks only work if the machine is already licensed. You can go download Windows 10 ISOs from microsoft.com right now, but you can't install it without a key. To use your analogy, it would be like you redistributing an encrypted book file that the publisher had emailed me when I bought my hard copy, but I couldn't open it anyway unless I had the key from the back cover.
- cptskippy 9y agoWindows can be installed without a license but must be activated online using a valid license within a certain time frame (128 days?). Windows 10 activation is done by device fingerprinting to match a license which is different from how windows was activated in the past. With previous versions of Windows you activated by providing a product key. Restore and Recovery discs are different form standard installation media, the kind you can download for free from Microsoft. R/R discs are custom builds from the OEM, who is required to have a software distribution license from Microsoft, and don't usually prompt for license activation. They circumvent the need for the user to input a key by either storing it on a recovery partition, in the BIOS, or hardcoding it on the media. > To use your analogy, it would be like you redistributing an encrypted book file that the publisher had emailed me when I bought my hard copy, but I couldn't open it anyway unless I had the key from the back cover. Not just distributing, selling without permission of the publisher and decryption keys are widely available online.
- kickopotomus 9y agoNo, not at all. It is more akin to you selling a backup copy of the book that is bound by a lock. The people that buy your version of the book must either already have the key to unlock it or buy it separately.
- cptskippy 9y agoOr do a quick google search for a copy of the key. The point is, he doesn't have permission to distribute the software. If I was selling "recovery" Kindle eBooks but only to people who pinkie swore they already purchased the book, do you think Amazon or the Publishers would mind? How is this different?