3 ms·
I'm not familiar with this trial specifically, but my guess is that the reason for limiting it that way is to focus on the most plausible kind of welfare progra
by joe_the_user 9y ago
I'm not familiar with this trial specifically, but my guess is that the reason for limiting it that way is to focus on the most plausible kind of welfare program in the group most likely to benefit in a large way (the unemployed) and get as much certainty out of the data as possible.
The question is; "is this a welfare program or isn't is??"
I mean, if the program is structured to provide benefits for the unemployed and if we're looking how much the unemployed benefit, then it is a welfare/unemployment program.
The article mentions that the participants also saw this as an unemployment program and it seems logical that given this, they'd react to it in the fashion that we already know people tend to react to unemployment. There are already some unemployment programs that promise to taper off benefits rather than abruptly ending them and these don't have much difference from other welfare programs.
The sell of basic income is - "everyone benefits, everyone maintains an interest in working, the reduced bureaucracy provides more money to give people." Those together aren't saying "this is program to get more people working" and if it just gets reduced to that, the original plan is basically lost.
Which again, isn't saying basic income would work. But it seems reasonable to avoid letting the discussion just degenerate to debates on standard welfare.
That said, I guess I could accept one argument against basic income - "it will never work because in practice, the waters are always going to be muddied by these studies (done by the same old welfare bureaucracies) until the discussion becomes just a discussion of welfare strategies."