5 ms·
Even in developed countries IPv6 is barely deployed (my UK ISP - BT - pretends that they rolled it out but half of the time my modem tells me IPv6 is not availa
by cm2187 9y ago
Even in developed countries IPv6 is barely deployed (my UK ISP - BT - pretends that they rolled it out but half of the time my modem tells me IPv6 is not availabled until I force it to reconnect, and no sign of IPv6 on mobile networks).
Was looking at whether it was more economical to buy a small address block vs rent it from a datacentre. A /24 address block seems to cost around $4,000 upfront but then you need to pay €2,000 signup + €1,400 per yr RIPE membership fee. On the other side IPv4 is not going away and the price is only going to go up given the failure of IPv6 to deploy. Is there any way around the RIPE membership? Like owning an IPv4 address block through a proxy / broker?
[edit: RIPE fee]
- JaiR8hiK 9y agoHave you tried using a linux-based router? ISP-provided CPE is notoriously bad on average, especially in the IPv6 area.
- cm2187 9y agoIt's a brand-new BT router so I would be surprised if that was the case. I suspect the non IPv6 connectivity rather come from which node I connect to on the network.
- philjohn 9y agoIf you're on VDSL try grabbing an HG612 from ebay and using that instead, with a decent router behind it. I was running a dual stack setup like that for over a year without issue, before moving over the Virgin Media and having to rely on a HE.net tunnel.
- chrisper 9y agoHetzner allows you to have a block, but it requires you to be a Hetzner client.
- comboy 9y agoAlso you need to provide a reason why you need it and how are you going to use it.
- chedabob 9y agoAh I thought I'd imagined the BT router saying it supported IPV6. By the time I'd enabled DHCPv6 on my Mikrotik hardware, it had disappeared from the HomeHub dashboard.
- philjohn 9y agoWorks fine on the superhub, or on the HG612 standalone VDSL modem.
- Libre___ 9y agoYou need to make the distinction between PA(provider allocated) and PI(provider independent) objects, as well as the distinction between LIRs(members of the RIPE NCC) and end-users. PA can only be held for further assignment in their networks by a LIR that is a member of the RIPE NCC, received in two ways: maximum of one IPv4 allocation /22 with proper justification, or acquisition through merger with another LIR. The membership fees are as you mentioned. PI resources are assigned to end-users in the region, that do not need to be members of the NCC. They do however need a valid end-user agreement with a LIR, and each(unless they are allocated on the same date) object entails a 50€/yr fee, billed to the LIR. PI IPv4 is no longer being assigned from RIPE, but existing ones are openly traded. My guess would be that the nets you were looking at were PI networks, so no, you do not need to pay the membership fee. The document ripe-680 covers basically everything you need to know: https://www.ripe.net/publications/docs/ripe-680 https://www.ripe.net/publications/docs/ripe-680
- sofaofthedamned 9y agoAndrews & Arnold do a tunnel that supports ipv6 - their support and network is awesome, too.
- KJKingJ 9y ago> and no sign of IPv6 on mobile networks Not quite true - EE (so one of the 'big four' providers rather than a small MNVO) has IPv6 support. Right now, my phone has an IP address assigned out of EE's 2a01:4c8::/29 netblock and I can connect to IPv6 only websites. My phone isn't super modern either - a 2016 era OnePlus 3 running Android 8.0.
- cptskippy 9y agoSupport for IPv6 is weird. Comcast's IPv6 implementation is rock solid and faster than IPv4 most of the time. I've been running publicly accessible IPv6 HTTP hosts over it for several years now. The last two Motorola Modems I've had came with IPv6 support and were provisioned by Comcast out of the box. Access Points from D-Link will autoconfigure via SLAAC but DNS has to be hardcoded. It's 2018 and yet Ubiquiti's UniFi enterprise networking gear only has alpha support. IPv6 on Tomato just works and has for years, IPv6 on Raspbian not so much. Windows just works seems to fuck with nonWindows clients so Enterprises disable it via Group Policy. Android devices seem to forget IPv4 if they catch a wiff of IPv6 on the network.
- merb 9y ago> Windows just works seems to fuck with nonWindows clients so Enterprises disable it via Group Policy. well I've seen most enterprise networks with no IPv6 support. (mostly admins thing that this beast is hard to work with) Also Kubernetes has limited IPv6 support (mostly on the documentation site) (of course it's easier to support a IPv6 only cluster, because heck you wouldn't really need BGP or some wierd overlay networks (sadly it still is not there yet)). In Germany IPv6 within "Deutsche Telekom" is just good. But sadly on the consumer side you still won't get any fixed IPv6 (due to privacy concerns!)
- ahjaiM7r 9y agotelekom has some IPv6 routing issues every now and then that I did not encounter with other ISPs. I believe it is because they peer more selectively at de-cix instead of having open peering.
- OoooooooO 9y agoThey finally peer on DE-CIX?
- gsich 9y agoprivacy is not the issue. Selling business plans is the real reason.
- adventured 9y ago> Even in developed countries IPv6 is barely deployed For reference, the list of currently leading and trailing countries by IPv6 adoption (from Akamai's August 2017 numbers): Belgium 46%, US 40%, India 36%, Greece 32%, Germany 25%, Switzerland 20%, Finland 20%, Brazil 19%, Canada 18%, Norway 16%, Japan 15% Portugal 13%, UK 12%, France 12%, Australia 8%, New Zealand 8%, Sweden 8%, Netherlands 7%, Mexico 5% Israel 3%, South Korea 2%, Ireland 1%, Denmark 1%, Russia 1%, Spain 0.7%, Italy 0.5%, China 0.3%, Colombia 0.1% The way some of these nations are lagging is bizarre.
- gioele 9y ago> Italy 0.5% Yet Italy was home to Tinet, part of Tiscali and the largest IPv6 network of the world until 2009. More saddening than bizarre.
- philjohn 9y agoIt doesn't help the UK that one of the largest ISP's, Virgin Media (the only cable supplier) don't yet support IPv6. They're talking about going with DS-Lite, which carries its own problems. Once they go live, expect to see the UK climb significantly.
- zaarn 9y agoOVH doesn't properly deploy IPv6 either. pfSense is also being weird (if you only get a /64 you need SLAAC or else you can't configure the LAN with it for some bizarre reason and OVH doesn't SLAAC properly) Though thanks to HE/tunnelbroker.net I deployed a /48 on my network and all is good now (and easier).