5 ms·
The surgeons and Johns Hopkins volunteered their services, which would otherwise have cost hundreds of thousands of dollars and wouldn't have been covered by ve
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
The surgeons and Johns Hopkins volunteered their services, which would otherwise have cost hundreds of thousands of dollars and wouldn't have been covered by veterans benefits or insurance, they say. (because it's still experimental)
Hats off to the team of 11 surgeons involved in this (no doubt grueling) 14-hour surgery without being paid. Wow.
Sources:
https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/04/23/605054470/veteran-receives-penis-transplant-to-repair-war-wound https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/04/23/6050544...
http://time.com/5250397/penis-transplant-johns-hopkins-university/ http://time.com/5250397/penis-transplant-johns-hopkins-unive...
- sitkack 9y agoThat is just the surgery itself, prep was hundreds of additional hours.
- ec109685 9y agoShameful veterans benefits doesn’t cover this. Clearly, if enough of these surgeries are done, the cost then will come down.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoOff the top of my head, my recollection is that lung transplants cost a cool half million on average in the year they occur, plus add ongoing expenses to care for the rest of your life. An article I googled earlier suggests similar costs for other transplant surgeries: http://www.nationalkidneycenter.org/treatment-options/transplant/affording-a-transplant/ http://www.nationalkidneycenter.org/treatment-options/transp... The figures given in this article don't appear particularly more than or out of line with other, more established transplant surgeries.
- bayesian_horse 9y agoAny kind of health insurance or health system has to draw the line somewhere. Not covering novel, risky and expensive "elective" surgeries is relatively easy to justify, compared to other stupidities in American health care.
- stochastic_monk 9y agoI spoke to several of my friends about this. People of both genders I discussed the surgery with have said they'd seriously consider suicide if their genitals were destroyed. I'm not saying this to make light of the situation; my point is that I would expect the risk of suicide caused by this kind of injury to make such a surgery of medical importance. Compare, for example, that several governing bodies consider gender reassignment surgery to be of medical necessity for transgender individuals who want to transition because of the dramatic reduction in suicide.
- bayesian_horse 9y agoI'd consider gender reassignment surgery to be less elective, less expensive and less risky. There is a condition called gender dysphoria, and for a lot of patients hormones and living their gender identity doesn't alleviate it. I'm "cis", so I can't fully understand the situation transgender people are in, but I would hope that we can get to a point where genitalia matter less for gender identity. Easier said than done, probably. It also depends on how much of your sense of self worth or identity is entangled with your sexual "functioning". I believe I wouldn't opt for such a surgery. Of course, I'm not in this terrible situation. And I can imagine other people having enough of a problem with these parts missing. Speaking just about the costs, intensive psychiatric and therapeutic care should be more cost effective, and it's necessary in most cases, anyway.
- hood_syntax 9y ago> self worth or identity Wow, that's rich. Is it really beyond your comprehension that someone might be deeply hurt by losing the capability to engage in sexual relations with their significant other? I know you say you 'can imagine other people having enough of a problem' but I'm not sure you really do when you word it that way. I agree that it's more expensive and more risky than gender reassignment but I don't understand why someone trying to return to a fully functioning body is considered "elective".
- spacehome 9y agoNo it's not shameful. Better to pay veterans more and let them decide how they want to spend the money, including any health insurances.
- NKCSS 9y agoI can't help but think of the series Grey's Anatomy, where most surgeons would be more than happy to scrub in on a chance like this, maybe even pay for the privilege.
- solatic 9y agoIt's not like they aren't paid in reputation though. Because it's a novel surgery, they're now the world's leading experts on applying this surgery successfully, and that makes them the first phone call for anybody with deep pockets who wants to make it happen. Not to mention being published, talking about the surgery in conferences, etc. The patient may not have paid in money, but they did pay in taking a very significant risk of unforeseeable complications. It's not so clear cut.
- thecatspaw 9y agothe one time "do it for the exposure" is justified
- icelancer 9y agoThis is often the case. Building a website for someone's portfolio for free is nonsense. But things like this come up all the time, and demanding payment in the form of money is often very stupid. I got the chance to film alongside ESPN using experimental cameras and technology that I've pioneered, and didn't request payment (just all expenses covered). Gaining networking contacts at ESPN and on-air mentions of the tech are worth far more than I could reasonably bill, and in the case of billing them, you lose out on extracting favors for doing it for "free." Being a good business operator requires not relying on platitudes you hear from the freelancing community.
- csomar 9y agoThat might not do justice to a number of doctors/surgeons/scientists doing it for science and medicine. I was in the medical field and it was ripe with predators doctors. But there was really people interested in advancing science. Also surgeons at these level are probably too well off to care about money for one operation.
- onetimemanytime 9y ago100% true, probably would have doctors running over each other to do such thing--first case, ever. But still, we can't dismiss it like that. They did a great thing and they deserve our kudos. Plenty of doctors take charity cases, some even go to Africa or poor areas in USA.
- Beltiras 9y agoI imagine that they spent a hefty multiple of those 14 hours preparing for the operation.
- IncRnd 9y agoI hope it works out well for the patient, enabling the hoped-for quality of life.
- sandworm101 9y agoThat they did not bill does not mean they were not paid. Papers came from this. Lectures will be given. They did not take pay cuts from day jobs when they committed hours to this project. Doing experimental things like this is part of being a top doc.