7 ms·
Theories like this one do not explain how it is that immigrant groups do reasonably well. The history of the USA is filled with people who arrive with no money
by btilly 9y ago
Theories like this one do not explain how it is that immigrant groups do reasonably well. The history of the USA is filled with people who arrive with no money, poor language skills, sometimes traumatized - and yet wind up doing well within a generation or two.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_United_States_by_household_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_U... is a good starting point to think about. Look at groups such as Vietnamese and Cambodians. They mostly arrived in my lifetime. Everything is against them. Poor language skills, widespread PTSD from what they witnessed, no savings - pretty bad picture.
And yet, look where they are today versus blacks. How did that happen?
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> And yet, look where they are today versus blacks. How did that happen? Some might interpret this uncharitably. To defray that potential, would you mind giving us a hint as to what you've found / are suggesting?
- RussianBot 9y agoI didn't hear a dog whistle. I heard an actual question.
- 40acres 9y ago> And yet, look where they are today versus blacks. How did that happen? Generally I don't like to compare the struggles amongst minorities in America. There is a multitude of factors that come into play when analyzing these types of things.. But when you look at the history of discrimination vs. black people in America you need to go back and consider the effects all the way back from slavery, to Reconstruction/Redemption, Jim Crow, discriminatory housing policy, discriminatory lending, discriminatory policing, discriminatory criminal "justice", disenfranchisement on multiple levels, lynching, etc. etc. etc. This is 400+ years of compounding discrimination against black people. I'm not saying the Vietnamese and Cambodians (and for good measure the Irish & the Italians) did not have it bad.. but I think we need to look at this with a broader lens.
- Clanan 9y agoYou're focusing on a single variable. The above poster is recommending a multivariate approach. If a similar minority group can start from a worse position (not even knowing the language!) and advance to a better position in a single generation, then your single variable is lacking. The response of "go back 400 years" does not explain away the discrepancy. The common-sense approach is to consider other factors too.
- 40acres 9y ago> If a similar minority group can start from a worse position (not even knowing the language!) and advance to a better position in a single generation, then your single variable is lacking. I can't agree with this sentence. I agree, not knowing the language puts you in a bad spot, but I think you are really underestimating the level of discrimination vs. blacks in America if you think simply "not knowing the language" is enough to put some immigrant group in a worse position than blacks in America. I'm not sure what other variables you'd like me to use in this analysis but I think if you look back over the history of America you see that others have used one variable to levy their discrimination and it's always been race.
- SlowRobotAhead 9y ago>I can't agree with this sentence. Whether you do or don't doesn't really matter. Post after post has made the point that you are focusing on a single variable and it is clear that it's not explicit causation for the effects like you claim.
- 40acres 9y agoLike I said earlier: I'm not sure what kind of variables you'd like to include within this variance but I'd LOVE to to hear any suggestions.
- sp527 9y agoThere are at least two variables he's missing that matter a lot: (1) Selection bias. The pool of immigrants who make it to America in the first place likely skews well above average. (2) Culture/ecosystem problems in black communities, even if it's politically incorrect to argue it. Black neighborhoods are plagued by gang culture/violence, drugs, patriarchal absenteeism (estimates vary, but roughly 50% seems likely), intergenerational educational deficit (if parents are illiterate/undereducated, their children are likely to be so as well), and various other more generic issues that stem from chronic poverty.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wavefunction 9y ago>And yet, look where they are today versus blacks. How did that happen? All blacks? Methinks you've tipped your hand. I'll indulge you though and wonder, bemusedly, if immigrants have different social structures and expectations of a country than a formerly enslaved ethnic minority whose social cohesion and family structures have been systematically dismantled and obliterated. Whose social traditions and cultural ties have been intentionally wiped out for centuries? Could an immigrant's cultural identity and ties to other immigrants with shared goals and expectations allow for a beneficial cooperative framework wherein alternative banking and lending structures are available to the newly arrived? Could a society that still murders members of its citizenry disproportionately due to their ethnic and historical legacy (and a legacy no fault their own) really offer a framework beyond simple survival to such a minority? Could the difference between being a foreigner in your new home and a "foreigner" in your own actual home country encourage different outcomes? All these questions...
- guildenstern 9y agoYou’re comparing a massive group of people with a comparatively tiny group of people that have self selected for only the most willing and capable of abandoning everything and building a new life from nothing after qualifying to enter the United States. Of course those people are going to be more successful. That alone discredits the point you’re making.
- infosample 9y agoSeems like false equivalence to me. A better comparison would be American blacks who immigrated to Canada or Europe. Perhaps you can imagine the benefit of a fresh start. Instead, American blacks have had a long continuation from slavery. Consider a financial metaphor - American whites: compound interest American blacks: compound debt American immigrants: reset (bankruptcy if poor) It is easy to continue momentum, hard to dig out of a hole, and nice to start over.
- SlowRobotAhead 9y ago>American whites: compound interest >American blacks: compound debt >American immigrants: reset (bankruptcy if poor) Can you explain this? Why would compound debt exist for blacks but not for anyone else? Why would poor American whites be labeled under "compound interest"? That seems like generalizing based on skin color.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eanzenberg 9y agoI think the idea is, poor whites don't need to pass through institutional racism like poor/rich black do. Of course poor whites have it worse than rich whites but they have more/easier opportunities to break through.
- infosample 9y agoAgain, it is a metaphor, don't take to too literally. Blacks were slaves, whites and immigrants were not. Can you picture slavery as digging out of a hole (debt)? Until breaking even, you are subject to compound debt. Yes, immigrants do well within a generation or two. Blacks have only had civil rights for a generation. White males not only have always rights but made them. Yes, I'm generalizing based on skin color. That is literally what race is.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ericmcer 9y agoThe constant among Vietnamese, Cambodian, Japanese, Korean and other cultures is a really strong family unit. Family owned businesses, parents working hard to educate kids, parents holding high expectations for children etc. Both political parties in this country seem to undermine black families, Conservatives through thinly concealed racist policies and the war on drugs, Liberals through social programs that foster dependence on government rather than elevation to independence.
- dpkonofa 9y agoThere's a pattern that you see emerging in "late-stage" immigrants that are no longer found amongst other minorities in the United States. I believe that this pattern, where minorities share risk to bring about equal success and growth, stems completely from the racial divide that other minority groups in the US have had to fight against. An excellent example of this is immigrants who come to the US, ally with others of the same minority, share housing (even sometimes to the point of breaking the law), start businesses (while breaking several laws along the way), and then bring more immigrants in to help grow the business and then distribute that wealth to those involved. It's very similar to what happened in early European immigration to the US except that these "late stage" immigrants now know exactly what to avoid. They're able to take in all the advantages of being an immigrant while ignoring/offloading the risks associated with breaking the law. There's a reason that a stereotype exists regarding Vietnamese nail salons and, however inaccurate the stereotype may be, it started from this pattern of Vietnamese immigrants moving to the US, starting up nail salons, and bringing in hundreds more Vietnamese immigrants to grow these businesses while sheltering illegal practices that could be hidden by the growth of the business. Minorities that are already in the United States don't have the ability nor the structure to make this a reality.
- azernik 9y agoWho arrived with no money, poor language skills... and were not pushed into redlined neighborhoods, were not denied credit, and were not rewarded with dropping property values around them as soon as they bought a house and the white folks left. Immigrants (especially non-White) faced their own challenges, but not those ones.
- mikeash 9y agoThat link shows Laotians and Cambodians at a significant disadvantage.
- imatworkyo 9y ago> How did that happen? Outside of the false equivalence - as posted to great fanfare yesterday : https://i.redd.it/1j5ek052qit01.jpg https://i.redd.it/1j5ek052qit01.jpg
- RhysU 9y agoAnyone know what that looks like if showing person-years instead of years? Curious the effect that integrating over population would have. Could imagine integrating over some inflation or return measures too.
- spicymaki 9y agoI hate how statistics are used to bludgeon people. Anytime an article comes out about economic inequality is posted I see the same familiar pattern. Issue is presented, black people are compared to everyone, shit on, dick measuring about how everyone else is killing it in SV (and of course everything (status-quo) is okay), rinse and repeat. In the mean time: ecology is in decline, trust in science is on the decline, democracy is in decline, wealth inequality is increasing and accelerating. The emperor has no clothes. Wake up!
- danans 9y ago> Everything is against them. Poor language skills, widespread PTSD from what they witnessed, no savings - pretty bad picture. A lot against them, but a lot of important factors working for them too. For one thing, their family and community structure remained intact, allowing them to build community capital. Also, because they are Asian, they benefit from the beneficial stereotypes of Asian Americans in educational and business environments AKA "the model minority" myth, and don't experience the presumption of criminality that blacks are often subjected to to this day. As others have stated, they were also a self selecting group who were fleeing a single acute experience of trauma due to the war vs the intergenerational and normalized trauma of slavery and segregation that blacks face. And to add to that, they arrived with a strong work ethic, but at a time when many immigrant groups landing in the US were doing well. They weren't redlined. Their children weren't excluded from white neighborhoods and schools. I, as an Asian American, grew up in in a 90% white city with excellent schools, but with a conspicuous lack of black people around. No segregation for me, but it was there if you were black. None of this is to say Vietnamese and Cambodians had it easy at all. In fact, they are still poorer on average than other immigrant groups who arrived around the same time with better circumstances, like Indians, Taiwanese, etc. That's who you should be comparing them to to understand the effects of disadvantages.
- ggg9990 9y agoIt’s because the Cambodians here are a self selected of people who were willing and able (whether money, family support, or hustling skills) to start their lives anew. The blacks are descendants of people forcefully abducted, who were selected mostly for physical traits.