11 ms·
Gerontopoly: Homeownership, wealth, and age
- 40acres 9y ago> Is the “dream” of homeownership really just a massive, intergenerational wealth transfer? Yes & it has been this way since the inception of government backed loans. I've recently been digging into the history of housing discrimination in the US and how it relates to the racial wealth gap between blacks and whites. In my opinion there is a clear line from redlining, blockbusting, white flight & loan discrimination to the massive wealth gap among races we see today. It's quite clear to me that one of the best ways to build generational wealth is by the older generation passing off homes to the younger ones.
- nostromo 9y agoWouldn't white flight followed by re-urbanization favor people of color in terms of home value? I know in my city the neighborhood that historically had high black homeownership levels now has a million-dollar entry fee. Meanwhile the suburbs are undesirable and cheap.
- illumin8 9y agoNo, because what do you think those white people fleeing to the suburbs in the 80s and 90s did? They didn't sell homes to minority homeowners because the banks wouldn't give minorities loans. They either sold to other white landlords, or became landlords themselves. So, the million dollar apartments are owned by wealthy white landlords who have realized 100% of the appreciation, while systematically pushing poorer minorities, who are almost 100% renters, out to even worse ghettos.
- nostromo 9y agoHome ownership by people of color did rise during white flight (and dramatically so). https://wp.zillowstatic.com/1/ThenAndNow_Race-Final-594696-1024x664.jpg https://wp.zillowstatic.com/1/ThenAndNow_Race-Final-594696-1...
- 40acres 9y agoThis is a tricky question for me to answer because I've been doing more research on the "back end" aka why minorities weren't getting housing as opposed to what's happening now w/ re-urbanization. Part of it is that many homes sold during the white flight and blockbusting era did not go to minorities, there were explicit causes in the sale to prevent this. Another part of this is the fact that minorities who did buy bought "on contract" which means that they did not owe a mortgage to a bank but to an individual (who most likely was a blockbuster) they did not build equity (wealth) and were subject to very harsh loans. I don't know what percentage of homes sold to minorities during this era were "on contract" so it's hard to quantify the effect. Based on an anecdote it's definitely true that some amount of minorities benefited from re-urbanization.. I was in NE Portland a few weeks ago and had a very interesting conversation w/ a local Uber driver who lamented the fact that his family had sold his grandmothers place in the 90s, this home has probably appreciated at least 3-4x since then.
- flanbiscuit 9y agoThere's a good NPR podcast series that goes into this. First season is about NYC, second is about L.A. https://www.npr.org/podcasts/555340969/there-goes-the-neighborhood https://www.npr.org/podcasts/555340969/there-goes-the-neighb...
- 40acres 9y agoThanks for this. I've been really interested in learning about housing policy and trends lately & wanted to come across a podcast about it.
- tropo 9y agoThe reality is that the house is sold to cover the cost of a nursing home, or that a reverse mortgage is used to convert that value into living expenses, or that the older generation dies with home equity loans that were taken out to cover expenses.
- illumin8 9y agoI've said it before, but the millennial generation will not be kind to boomers when the history books are written. Our parents have basically fucked us over in a million different ways, but especially with housing. I see a ton of boomers who have basically shredded the economy by creating multiple bubbles in the stock market and housing, destabilized the middle east and thrust us into many unwinnable wars, blown through all the home equity they had with home equity credit lines, never saved for retirement, and now expect to be taken care of by social security and medicaid during retirement. This is apparently what happens when you have a strong cultural revolution during the 60s, but everyone grows up and gets greedy. Although I'm not too optimistic the millennial generation won't do the same exact thing when they turn 40... edit: forgot to mention wars...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rubicon33 9y agoYea, this article is really not surprising to anyone who isn't a boomer. I look around and see smart, hardworking people with some of the "best" jobs in the nation (doctors, lawyers, programmers, etc.) who can't afford to buy a home. Between student debt, the cost of living, nearly 50% taxation (and rising in CA), wage stagnation, and real estate greed... it's nearly impossible even for those young people who are doing well. If you ask me, the boomer generation certainly left it (far) worse than they found it. Thanks, boomers, for de-regulating banks, leading to financial instability that continues to this day. Thanks, boomers, for the 2007 Great Recession. Thanks, boomers, for buying up homes in 2008 at a discount, and selling it back to the next generation at an exorbitant price. Your "investment" is literally why we have a housing crisis. Thanks, boomers, for the massive mismanagement of federal, and local governments. Thanks for the wars, boomers. Thanks, boomers, for some historical wage stagnation. It's no surprise that people are struggling to afford a home, and waiting to start a family.
- Lionsion 9y ago> Yea, this article is really not surprising to anyone who isn't a boomer. I look around and see smart, hardworking people with some of the "best" jobs in the nation (doctors, lawyers, programmers, etc.) who can't afford to buy a home. Between student debt, the cost of living, nearly 50% taxation (and rising in CA), wage stagnation, and real estate greed... it's nearly impossible even for those young people who are doing well. If you ask me, the boomer generation certainly left it (far) worse than they found it. Is this a national problem you're seeing, or one specific to CA/NYC/etc.? I suspect it much be a local problem, since I can't see doctors, lawyers, and programmers having a hard time affording a home outside a few very specific locations.
- btilly 9y agoTheories like this one do not explain how it is that immigrant groups do reasonably well. The history of the USA is filled with people who arrive with no money, poor language skills, sometimes traumatized - and yet wind up doing well within a generation or two. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_United_States_by_household_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_U... is a good starting point to think about. Look at groups such as Vietnamese and Cambodians. They mostly arrived in my lifetime. Everything is against them. Poor language skills, widespread PTSD from what they witnessed, no savings - pretty bad picture. And yet, look where they are today versus blacks. How did that happen?
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> And yet, look where they are today versus blacks. How did that happen? Some might interpret this uncharitably. To defray that potential, would you mind giving us a hint as to what you've found / are suggesting?
- RussianBot 9y agoI didn't hear a dog whistle. I heard an actual question.
- 40acres 9y ago> And yet, look where they are today versus blacks. How did that happen? Generally I don't like to compare the struggles amongst minorities in America. There is a multitude of factors that come into play when analyzing these types of things.. But when you look at the history of discrimination vs. black people in America you need to go back and consider the effects all the way back from slavery, to Reconstruction/Redemption, Jim Crow, discriminatory housing policy, discriminatory lending, discriminatory policing, discriminatory criminal "justice", disenfranchisement on multiple levels, lynching, etc. etc. etc. This is 400+ years of compounding discrimination against black people. I'm not saying the Vietnamese and Cambodians (and for good measure the Irish & the Italians) did not have it bad.. but I think we need to look at this with a broader lens.
- ucaetano 9y ago> In my opinion there is a clear line from redlining, blockbusting, white flight & loan discrimination to the massive wealth gap among races we see today Yes! And due to inheritance, wealth propagates within racial lines. White families build wealth subsidized by the government and have white kids, who have a huge advantage over non-whites due to the historical wealth accumulated. It is a self-reinforcing and self-propagating process, and now, old whites use zoning laws to extract value from younger generations, particularly non-whites and poor whites, whose families don't own real estate.
- madengr 9y agoIt’s all the white mans fault!
- SlowRobotAhead 9y agoOut of curiosity... forgetting rates for a moment and just checking on numbers of people, aren't there more white people in abject poverty than black people entirely in the USA? Seems if the argument is that white wealth propagates - that there should be few poor white people anywhere. There has been no racism towards them, and lots of time to build up the "subsidized wealth". I'm not crazy about all this generalization based on skin color.
- ucaetano 9y ago> Out of curiosity... forgetting rates for a moment and just checking on numbers of people, aren't there more white people in abject poverty than black people entirely in the USA? Yes, but that is irrelevant. Poverty rate is 9% for whites, 22% for blacks. > Seems if the argument is that white wealth propagates - that there should be few poor white people anywhere. There has been no racism towards them, and lots of time to build up the "subsidized wealth". There are fewer poor white people. The problem is that racism isn't the only factor in play here. Bad education, healthcare, etc. contribute to inequality. There are issues in play both intra and inter races. As outright racially-driven policies were revoked, whites turned to using wealth as a way to block blacks, resulting in the side effect of punishing poor whites as well. > I'm not crazy about all this generalization based on skin color. This isn't generalization. Read the redlining maps. Look at household wealth broken by race, the difference is even sharper than income: https://www.epi.org/blog/the-racial-wealth-gap-how-african-americans-have-been-shortchanged-out-of-the-materials-to-build-wealth/ https://www.epi.org/blog/the-racial-wealth-gap-how-african-a...
- davidw 9y ago> In my opinion there is a clear line from redlining, blockbusting, white flight & loan discrimination to the massive wealth gap among races we see today. Yes. See: "The Color of Law" - https://amzn.to/2JlHvRT https://amzn.to/2JlHvRT extensively well documented. It's depressing reading though.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thetrumanshow 9y agoI think once you factor in property taxes for all of those years, it’s pretty close to a wash.
- koverda 9y agoWhat if you factor in rent on the other side of the equation?
- prewett 9y agoThere was a detailed article and discussion on that yesterday, and it isn't so straightforward: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16899541 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16899541
- mikeyouse 9y agoRenters still pay property taxes -- they're imputed in the cost of renting a house.
- thetrumanshow 9y agoI’m not comparing it to the cost of renting, I’m simply saying that when I sell my home for $200,000 having bought it in the 1970s, at best it will be nearly break even.
- dlp211 9y agoNo, because you are not calculating imputed rent into your equation.
- prewett 9y agoBut you also have to calculate the opportunity cost of having a bunch of money sunk in an asset that (apparently) didn't perform spectacularly. By renting he could have invested that $200k in an S&P 500 index fund. Assuming he bought his house today in 1978, the S&P 500 increased over 27x ($97 on 4/23/1978, and $2670 today), plus he would have got about 2% dividends. I'm guessing his house didn't cost $7400 in 1978 (not to mention the 1 - 2% "dividend" he paid the government in property taxes), so I'd say renting isn't obviously worse. Depends on the rent.
- rifung 9y ago> As we’ve pointed out at City Observatory, there’s an inherent contradiction between the goals of promoting housing affordability and using homeownership as a wealth building strategy. Affordability requires that housing be stable in price; a good investment needs to appreciate. If housing is a great investment, its because its becoming less affordable. If housing stays affordable, it is, by definition, not an investment that generates gains. I have thought about this before and really think we should stop treating home ownership as an investment. However, I can't think of a way to do that which is fair to those who bought homes already..
- Eridrus 9y agoRelaxing zoning rules is an "easy" one. It doesn't deprive anyone of a home. Alternatively, if you want to get a bit more radical we could turn all property ownership into 99 year leases from the state, as is the case in Singapore, potentially reducing the length of time on leases over time to spread out the pain. Though it would be a long process. I would also support legislation that reduces transaction costs on buying/selling homes, which actually suppresses the price of homes because it takes a longer term commitment for buying to make sense.
- eecsninja 9y agoYes, this is unfortunately one of the great mistakes (or intentional deeds, depending on how you look at it) of US economic policy of the last few decades. > I have thought about this before and really think we should stop treating home ownership as an investment. However, I can't think of a way to do that which is fair to those who bought homes already.. Correction: fair to those who bought homes recently, rather than 20 years ago and are sitting on top of unrealized capital gains.
- elyobo 9y agoLevy solid capital gains taxes retrospectively, use that money to compensate recent buyers. Those that made a killing are still ahead (although less so), those that made losses are compensated.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago
- hardtke 9y agoTo be fair, the people who have massive housing equity generally bought their houses when interest rates were sky high. In the 1970's, when you could buy a decent house in Palo Alto for $50,000, the interests rates were 15-20%. As rates have gone down, the prices have gone up. Mortgage payments as a fraction of income have gone up much less dramatically than the sales prices.
- Qworg 9y agoHow'd that interest rate fare in the face of A) being able to refinance and B) inflation/rising wages? The principal/down payment is the first problem - interest rates just increase the cost of money, but get eaten away by time.
- drchiu 9y agoI once made the observation that much of the older generation’s net worth is tied intimately with their homes. That if we exclude home equity, the resulting net worth is very little — demonstrating a pattern of poor savings habit and investing. Unfortunately, for the younger generations, they will have to be much more diligent savers and investors as they are now fighting asset price inflation — a problem previous generations didn’t have as much.
- hndamien 9y agoOr currency debasement/ asset price inflation.
- ethn 9y agoIt's great, it use to be the opposite. For centuries prior the elderly were subjugated to the mercy of the young (like many Asian economies and as one could imagine in primate hierarchy groups), due to physical labor being the largest source of wealth. In contemporary society, the contrary is true given that physical labor has been a diminishing source of wealth. Today's economy is one where experience and knowledge triumphs, as physical labor is rapidly replaced through automation. Society is still far from it, but as close to a meritocracy as it has ever been.
- Fauntleroy 9y agoExcept over time the young will find it less and less likely that they'll be able to afford a home, up until it's impossible or the system breaks entirely...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ethn 9y agoOr what the article and research by AEI and Thomas Sowell has implied: you'll be able to afford a house when you're older since nowadays you become more valuable the more knowledge you gain.
- so33 9y agoFor many centuries, land ownership was (and in fact still is) the largest source of wealth. Historically, it conferred not only wealth but also power. This was the key characteristic of the feudal system.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ethn 9y agoLand is a store of wealth, that's not the source of wealth. If we look at the Forbes top 20 richest people compilation, we would be hard pressed to point out anyone who made the majority of their wealth through land.
- mevile 9y agoPutting the contradiction of an "affordable investment" aside and looking at the high prices: couldn't local governments change zoning laws to encourage building more homes to lower prices? More supply lowers prices right?
- MrMorden 9y agoThey could, but they don't want to.
- bendmorris 9y agoThey certainly could, but they'd be fighting the, generally very politically active, current homeowners every step of the way. Increasing supply will reduce their property values. Proponents of building more housing need to step up their political activism to match the NIMBY crowd.
- so33 9y agoRegulations like mandatory minimum lot sizes and density restrictions make it a lot harder for younger people to buy their own piece of the ownership pie, which creates scarcity, which in turn causes property values to skyrocket even further. I can’t help but see this as a form of regulatory capture.
- listenallyall 9y agoAn extended low-interest rate environment is a (the?) major factor in increasing income inequality. Assets become much more expensive, benefiting owners (in this case, of houses and real estate) and hurting those who strive to own. Further, savers are generally barely breaking even with inflation, which leads to less saving. Low interest rates "stimulate the economy" which means those who already have (applicable to both people and companies), can borrow more and multiply their assets much more rapidly than those who don't have, can catch up.
- mancerayder 9y agoSure, but high interest rates make money more expensive, meaning less people can afford less house. A factor that impacts people who need to borrow the most (the non rich). So what's better, high asset prices or high borrowing costs? Something tells me they both even out painfully.
- listenallyall 9y agoNot true, as home prices key around monthly payment, so high rates put downward pressure on prices to keep the monthly payment relatively constant. When long-term risk-free rates are exceptionally low, capital seeks excess return, much of which gets invested in real estate, increasing demand and prices. When the risk-free rate is 7, 8, 9% on a 10Y bond, then messy, illiquid, physical real estate is far less desirable as an investment. The original article was about income inequality -- when average Joe can easily borrow $300k for a house, the average company can easily borrow $300 million or $3 billion to get larger, buy competitors, execute LBO's, etc... all of which consolidate power and capital among the wealthiest and ultimately reduce labor opportunities for everybody else.
- mancerayder 9y agoNot true, as home prices key around monthly payment, so high rates put downward pressure on prices to keep the monthly payment relatively constant. When long-term risk-free rates are exceptionally low, capital seeks excess return, much of which gets invested in real estate, increasing demand and prices. When the risk-free rate is 7, 8, 9% on a 10Y bond, then messy, illiquid, physical real estate is far less desirable as an investment. That's just one factor. Another is this. When interests rates go up, the reason why price pressure is down in the first place is that fewer buyers can afford fewer houses; in other words, sales go down. This is already happening today (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-25/are-rising-mortgage-rates-a-threat-to-u-s-housing https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-25/are-risin... <-- today's article). When sales go down, sure, there's downward price pressure. But by that time, contrary to what you seem to be suggesting, the little guy doesn't necessarily benefit (because borrowing costs can be out of reach). And worse: if they go down far enough, it could bring some people underwater, which as we saw from the last cycle disproportionately impacted the lower middle class. And even worse: any home equity line of credit that has a balance is going to be more expensive to pay back. The original article was about income inequality -- when average Joe can easily borrow $300k for a house, the average company can easily borrow $300 million or $3 billion to get larger, buy competitors, execute LBO's, etc... all of which consolidate power and capital among the wealthiest and ultimately reduce labor opportunities for everybody else. Yes, the original article was about income inequality. And I've addressed these above, using different factors than the ones you've honed in on (capital concentration). I have news for you, capital concentration still leads to inequality during times of cheaper housing. You're making a mistake by thinking higher interest rates will make a big dent here: Blackstone and American Homes 4 Rent have sources of cash that you and I don't have (IPOs, bonds, to name some, I am sure there are many more).
- MekaiGS 9y agoSlight off topic but the graphs are terrible on the site, could someone smarter than me explain what the blue/red splits on the graphs represent?
- nmca 9y agoHomeowners are, disproportionately, voters. Politicians set the policy that determines supply and demand of housing. I strongly believe these things are causally linked, but do not know how to empirically test it.
- stevenwoo 9y agoI think it's more those with more money can influence lawmakers to make rules more hospitable for making more money. That would explain something like this happening for a long time, that would not be explained by a high percentage of home owners being voters (when it's one big company that owns a lot of homes): https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2018/04/rent-to-own-redlining/557588/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2018/04/rent-to...
- aj7 9y agoThe price of a house goes up. It’s called appreciation, but it mimics inflation much more. Except in certain volatile areas, housing has not been an inordinately good investment, but it is an inflation hedge. Housing is illiquid, does indeed depreciate, and often must be relinquished to be “spent.” Lack of savings or income so low it precludes savings are more important than housing as a source of inequality.
- awat 9y agoThis! The inflation hedge also makes the wealth gap exponential for those without the capital to get in the real estate game for lack of a better term. The capital needed to get into a home with traditional financing seems to go up by the month and is essentially moving the finishing line for those millenials saving for homes.
- kbutler 9y agoThis seems to ignore confounding factors: - divorce/single head-of-household rate. Over 75 probably has a much higher marriage rate than younger. If you divide that wealth into two households, how does it look? - shift to private ownership of retirement accounts. In 1989, pension plans, etc., were much more common. These wouldn't count as personal wealth as they are income-maintenance, rather than an asset.
- wintom 9y ago> “Homeownership is a gerontopoly. Most housing wealth is held by older Americans.” So what? They worked hard for that, that is in fact how wealth works. You work hard for a long time to build wealth and by the time your old you hopefully have something. This whole article shits on older people and effectively blames them and home ownership for wealth inequality. It is the most obvious study ive seen but blaming people will not fix anything. I will likely get downvotes for this but that is fair. We will all get old at some point and if we don’t have anything at that point we didn’t do it right. Just stop blaming others for shit, get to work this is the best time on the history of the earth to get wealthy. Better than any other period of human history. Just get it done.
- barrkel 9y agoWhat you musn't lose sight of is the effect of the prolonged low interest rate environment on asset prices. Money is cheaper to borrow so zero-sum competition for things like good schools drives prices up. The beneficiaries of this are older people who owned property before the low interest rate environment. The people who'll pay for it are those who are buying now, and will continue to pay well into the future. Thus the inter-generational transfer of unearned wealth.
- madengr 9y agoSo why are housing prices rising? Maybe it’s the young people willing to pay ever increasing prices. Maybe they are responsible for shooting themselves in the foot?
- gnarcoregrizz 9y agolow interest rates + rising wages. it seems like people will buy as much home as they can afford. so yes, in a sense, people are collectively shooting themselves in the foot by leveraging their homes as much as possible, but then again you need a place to live.
- pascalxus 9y agoIt all comes down to supply: why is this such a hard concept for people to understand. It's not old people's fault, unless they're the voters who keep preventing housing from being built. When you limit supply, prices MUST go up: there's no other way it can go. The other big problem is fundamentally: regulations that drive up costs for developers: everything from impact fees, to zoning, etc. We need to start working with developers to drive down costs and increase competition: that, plus vast amounts of building will drive down costs.
- taurath 9y agoCurrent homeowners are incentivized to always vote for their property values to go up - so they always vote to prevent new housing to be built, in the name of neighborhood character.
- azernik 9y agoAnecdotally, they are the voters who keep preventing housing from being built.
- bcohen5055 9y agoWhere I live in Southern California the problem is that supply is kept down by people renting out their first home and buying a 2nd. The houses appreciate at 4% per year and the rent increases at nearly 8% so it's win win for owners. On the flip side renters continue to spend their money renting and paying the mortgage of their landlords. The 2010 census reported Irvine was nearly 50% rentals [1].. In one of the largest planned communities in the US that is a problem. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irvine,_California https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irvine,_California (see census data for 2010)
- digi_owl 9y agoOne claim about homeownership that i ran into is that "homeowners do not riot". Thus homeownership is pushed as a kind of pacification of the urban population.
- nostrademons 9y agoMuch of this is predicted by classical economics. When you have an asset with minimal elasticity in supply (such as housing in areas where building more is difficult) that is nevertheless needed for survival, owners of that asset will be able to capture most of the productive capacity of the people who need that asset. In areas with high productivity and high incomes - like around rich coastal cities - that's manifested by skyrocketing housing prices. In areas with lower productivity and lower incomes, prices still go up, but not as much, and the effect is felt as an inability to get ahead or even make ends meet even when you work hard. The wealth generated by younger laborers is transferred to older asset-owners who own the necessities of life, simply because they continue to own them. Similarly, classical economics predicts a substitution effect for these goods: as they become increasingly less affordable, buyers will try to bypass the market entirely. That's behind nearly all the social changes and huge tech businesses of the last two decades. Can't find a place to live? Rent in a tiny apartment instead of buying a house. Live out of a van. Move to cheaper locales while working remotely. Can't get a job because that's yet another scarce resource monopolized by an older generation? Drive people around in your car with Uber. Sublet your rental on AirBnB. Blog for advertising revenue. Sell your crafts on Etsy. Start a new service business and advertise on Facebook or Google. Take funding from YCombinator and try to start the next great marketplace. The last couple years have brought even more radical examples, eg. Bitcoin is basically an attempt to setup a shadow financial & monetary system and opt out of the dollar-denominated economy entirely.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fbonetti 9y agoThis isn’t predicted by classical economics. This is the result of the housing supply being artificially constrained by zoning laws. If developers could build a 40-story high rise next to a single family home, housing would be dirt cheap. On top of this, rent control further disincentives developers from constructing new properties. AirBnB and Uber aren’t “bypassing the market”, they’re bypassing local laws and ordinances. The reason why AirBnB is cheaper than hotels and Uber is cheaper than taxis is because they don’t incur the cost of regulatory compliance. Real estate would also be cheaper if developers didn’t have to comply with zoning regulations.
- kazinator 9y agoIt's just so wrong, man! People should all get as rich as they will ever get by around age 23. Their savings and assets should stop growing at that point; for the rest of their lives, year over year, they should spend every penny they earn, and they should spend it on consumable items and recurring expenses --- not anything that has resale value. How much you have should in no way reflect how long you've been here and how much of that time you've spent laboring at something. And when you're no longer able, you should beg in the streets.
- pattrn 9y agoI must be missing something in this article. It seems to say that older generations have more net worth than younger generations. Its graph depicting net worth by age scales almost linearly. Isn't this how it's supposed to work? If I encounter someone who has spent a year digging a hole, another person who has spent two years digging a hole, and another person who has spent ten years digging a hole, I suspect that each respective hole's depth would be roughly proportional to the length of time spent digging it. The same concept applies to years making income. Clearly this isn't ubiquitous, since it's only possible to gain wealth if you make enough money to save wealth, but one could argue using this data that it's actually the norm. What am I missing?
- rabidrat 9y agoPeople should start spending their retirement at some point. The article points out that in the 80s, the 45-65 group had the most money, more than the 65+ group. But apparently older people are now hanging onto their still-appreciating homes, and only when they die will they pass on their homes to their (also now aging) children.
- RickJWagner 9y agoThe secret to wealth is easy. Spend less than you earn, and invest in the market. Over time, wealth will surely (surely) accumulate. There is no unfairness. You can read the same thing in books that are many decades old.
- rland 9y agoHousing is both mandatory and the largest expense for nearly everyone. It's a tremendous damper on "spending less." If the secret to wealth was easy when those books were written decades ago, it is much less easy now.