3 ms·
Hypothesis: it’s not so much the content of the genes that’s brittle, as that there are very few proteins as “smart” in how they walk the genome as CRISPR is (a
by derefr 9y ago
Hypothesis: it’s not so much the content of the genes that’s brittle, as that there are very few proteins as “smart” in how they walk the genome as CRISPR is (and even it’s no Einstein.)
There are likely cellular genetic repair mechanisms—especially in “small” genebases that don’t use fancy tricks like methylation/acetylation—which “hardcode” assumptions about gene number, gene size, positions of important proteins, etc.
Just because DNA itself is a robust data-structure (with features like start-stop tags, commented sections, etc.) doesn’t mean that all the algorithms (proteins) that have evolved to utilize that data-structure query or mutate it in equally-robust ways.
Imagine a codebase started off by a brilliant and strict engineer... and then followed on by a million forks-of-forks-of-forks, all done by average Joes just “scratching their own itch.” That’s the type of software encoded in 99% of the DNA on Earth. The codebases where “every line counts” and has been carefully selected for are far fewer—mitochondria, certainly, but i hesitate to name any other clear candidate.
- ynonym00s 9y agoWould you mind explaining what you mean by 'commented sections' in DNA? I have a very basic understanding of DNA.
- atrexler 9y agoThe proteins that organize DNA, called histones, can be chemically modified in a variety of ways. The modifications have the effect of turning on/off stretches of the DNA simply by modifying its physical structure (the way the dna is arranged and packed around the histones). There are tons more mods that can happen which have a variety of effects (for example, tune the amount that a gene is expressed). This is called epigenetics if you want to google more. If you've heard of those studies where if your grandparents experienced a famine it makes some difference in your genetics, one hypothesis is that its caused by this.
- nonbel 9y agoThis doesn't sound "commented" at all. It sounds like you are talking about conditional statements/loops.
- vanderZwan 9y ago> Imagine a codebase started off by a brilliant and strict engineer... and then followed on by a million forks-of-forks-of-forks, all done by average Joes just “scratching their own itch.” I would be careful with that example, before you start to sound suspiciously creationist. At least, the Christians I know that deny evolution tend claim everything was created perfectly and since has only slowly degenerated over time.
- cwbrandsma 9y agoAs you meet more Christians you will find more variation in what they believe. All should consider themselves "Creationist", but there are MANY competing ideas, from Ken Ham "5000 years old or bust", to Catholic "could be billions of years", and a lot of version in between. For instance, a friend of mine is a biology professor at the local university, his PHD is in fish evolution, and is a very conservative Christian.
- Canadauni 9y agoFrancis Collins is a well documented example of a Christian who very much contrasts Ken Ham as the current head of the NIH and director of the Human Genome Project. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Collins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Collins
- jhawk28 9y agoIt comes down to what you hold to be true. If you believe Genesis is historical fact, then the interpretation of the science facts are wrong. If you believe the Bible is true and that the interpretation of science facts are true, then you see Genesis in a figurative interpretation. If you reject the Bible, then you will see the narrative of the Bible as false and the scientific interpretation as true.
- tessierashpool 9y agoyou kind of need to follow your own advice there. "all should consider themselves Creationist" would be considered pretty silly, or at least absolutely debatable, in the church I grew up in (a very unremarkable suburban Presbyterianism). the Bible itself contains two contradictory creation stories. I think the overwhelming majority of Christians fit into the "the two mutually contradictory creation stories in Genesis could not be taken literally even if they didn't contradict each other" camp that I'm most familiar with, or, at most, are nearer the "could be billions of years" end of your spectrum. edit: after a little Googling, it looks like 51% of US Christians accept a "but it was God's idea" version of evolution, i.e., evolution is how it works, God set evolution in motion. and we probably all know that the US is the only technologically advanced nation with such a high percentage of evolution skeptics. but if it's about all Christians, worldwide, evolution skeptics could be the majority, given that technologically non-advanced countries may contain the majority of the world's Christians.