3 ms·
> It's somewhat ironic that free trade was apparently okay when Germans and Austrians were buying up Eastern European banks, or when the Spanish were buying up
by adventured 9y ago
> It's somewhat ironic that free trade was apparently okay when Germans and Austrians were buying up Eastern European banks, or when the Spanish were buying up mines, or the Americans buying steel plants, but is suddenly worrisome when the Chinese want to renovate railways.
China doesn't believe in free trade. They never have. The trade that exists today between the EU and China, or the US and China, is very far away from being free trade.
The looming scale is probably the biggest concern. It appears China's economy is going to continue getting a lot larger, doubling in size in perhaps just the next 12 years to ~$26 trillion. It'll be far larger than the EU economy at that point. If China's activity in Europe is already at this scale with a $13.x trillion economy, what will it look like in another decade or so?
Being under the economic foot of a Communist dictatorship that is very aggressively rolling back human rights, and Germany or Austria buying some Eastern European banks, are two dramatically different things. Germany and Austria are fairly liberal, democratic nations, with solid respect for human rights.
- vkou 9y ago> China doesn't believe in free trade. They never have. The trade that exists today between the EU and China, or the US and China, is very far away from being free trade. No country in the world actually believes in free trade. If they did, open, tarrif-free markets would be the default, as opposed to a patchwerk of five thousand different exemptions carved out in dozens of different treaties. What the West (And the United States in particular) believes in is 'Free' trade - which looks an awful lot like colonialism, by another name. Developing countries are free to sell their resources, or low-value-add, high-labour, low-IP goods, and and are free to import high-value-add, low labour, high-IP goods. 'Free' trade is a moat that protects this sort of arrangement. For some reason, when China adopts this same model, everyone gets into a panic.
- opo 9y ago>...What the West (And the United States in particular) believes in is 'Free' trade - which looks an awful lot like colonialism, by another name. No, that is really a misrepresentation of the history of trade. While it is unfortunate the amount of tariffs, restrictions, quotas, IP transfers, joint ownerships, unneeded inspections, etc. that countries use to manipulate trade, overall trade takes advantage of comparative advantage. >...Developing countries are free to sell their resources, or low-value-add, high-labour, low-IP goods, and and are free to import high-value-add, low labour, high-IP goods. 'Free' trade is a moat that protects this sort of arrangement. This sounds more like a conspiracy theory than anything else. A poor undeveloped country can hardly be expected to start out as a major manufacturer of MRI machines, but that doesn't mean trade with western countries is a conspiracy to prevent poor countries from selling high value goods. The example of Taiwan since WW II is as illustrative as any. >...Except for a few coal mines, which are thousands of feet underground, and limestone for cement plants, there are almost no valuable mineral deposits in Taiwan. The availability of arable land is also a problem. The existing amount of cultivated land, around one-third of Taiwan’s total area, cannot be increased. http://www.nber.org/chapters/c6927.pdf http://www.nber.org/chapters/c6927.pdf Taiwan started out exporting only textile and other labor intensive products and now machinery, electrical equipment and computers are more than half of their exports and textiles are now a tiny part of their exports. Since WW II, international trade has not impoverished Taiwan - on the contrary it is usually credited as a reason for the large growth of the GDP in Taiwan. This growth in GDP can be seen here: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RGDPNATWA666NRUG https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RGDPNATWA666NRUG