11 ms·
What’s Not Included in Facebook’s “Download Your Data”
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago"But 'Download Your Data' hardly tells you everything Facebook knows about you. Among the information not included: - information Facebook collects about your browsing history; - information Facebook collects about the apps you visit and your activity within those apps; - the advertisers who uploaded your contact information to Facebook more than two months earlier; - ads that you interacted with more than two months prior. Download Your Data is particularly spotty when it comes to the information Facebook taps to display ads." --- TL; DR When you get too close to their business model, Facebook clams up.
- textmode 9y ago- the data that Facebook collected about you from various other sources, e.g., data brokers Mr. Zuckerberg and other Facebook staff assert: "We do not sell data." Does Facebook acquire/purchase data about people from other sources, e.g., data brokers, and then combine it with (a) the highly personal data people voluntarily submit to Facebook and (b) the highly personal behavioural data people consent to allow Facebook to collect from their use of the Facebook website, Facebook app, and websites hosting Facebook anchors. Is Facebook allowing users to download all the data Facebook has on them?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- richardfeynman 9y agoPSA: Facebook looks at what websites you visit in an incognito window, provided that the incognito window is open the same time as a regular browser.
- tlb 9y agoHow does it do this?
- richardfeynman 9y agoApparently, incognito mode uses the same temporary cookies folder as regular chrome, so FB looks at this folder if incognito is open in one window while FB is being used in another.
- JoshMnem 9y agoAre you sure about that? Wouldn't it mean that all third party trackers could continue to track you while in incognito mode? How could it be called incognito mode if sites can still read your non-incognito cookies?
- richardfeynman 9y agoI'm 95% confident. And yes, I think it does mean that. The trackers have to be active in a non-incognito window for it to work. It reads the shared temporary cookie folder.
- JoshMnem 9y agoIf incognito mode is that broken in Chrome, and still allows sites that are open in normal tabs to track you, that would be very newsworthy.
- richardfeynman 9y agoagreed
- JoshMnem 9y agoI had to know the answer, so I wrote a quick script to test it. It appears that incognito windows can't read cookies from normal windows. I've linked to the source code there. If I've missed anything, let me know. https://cookiechecker.netlify.com/ https://cookiechecker.netlify.com/
- throwawaymanbot 9y ago.... is the groveling apology from Mark..
- notimetorelax 9y agoI’m thinking, GDPR is not live yet. They might expand the type of data they export in a month.
- Silhouette 9y agoIn theory, GDPR doesn't change very much in this area. Data subjects already had similar rights to access personal data about them under existing law in much of the EU. The potential fines for non-compliance may be much bigger, though. There is also some expansion in what constitutes personal data under the GDPR, which might be relevant if we're talking about areas where you could have tried to argue they didn't count before but they're going to be explicitly covered in the new scheme.
- thisisit 9y agoIn case, anyone is wondering how to get to the "Your Categories" option on Facebook. Go to Settings -> Ads and the tab will appear. I have always been paranoid about sharing information on social media. So, this section has only Facebook access information - 4G, Ipad etc. Couple of categories are even incorrect.
- lamename 9y agoThis 'Download Your Data' tool is highlighted every few years when ire toward facebook is renewed, but while appealing it's never seemed more than table scraps to me looking at the data. Even without looking, the idea that a data broker would just willingly give us all the information it has is unbelievable. The scale is so large, how would you even know?
- cromulen 9y agoThey don't have a choice under GDPR.
- 01001010 9y agoTo what extent will GDPR require them to include the information they have to serve and target you ads? Does anyone even know yet?
- r3bl 9y agoNot only will it require them to include the info they're using to target you with ads, but also their source for that info (if it wasn't submitted by the user itself), the existence of automated-decision making, and "meaningful information about the logic involved". https://gdpr-info.eu/art-15-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-15-gdpr/
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoThat's yet to be seen. Can you imagine the ire when Europeans are able to download a rich set of information on how they're being tracked and so on, whereas Americans and the rest of the world has no access to that information? I can't. What is more probable is tha FB will try a legal trick claiming they are an American company and they follow the laws of California, not EU, even if they gladly accept European advertisers's money via Ireland.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> What is more probable is tha FB will try a legal trick claiming they are an American company and they follow the laws of California, not EU This would be an enormously stupid move. It guarantees not only failure but an acidic backlash.
- randomsearch 9y agoNot covered here: it does not really export your social graph. Just a list of names. No way to easily import that into contacts etc. This is making quitting Facebook time-consuming, but I'm getting there. Similarly with birthdays, although it's quite easy to work around that via their calendar link.
- Lionsion 9y ago> No way to easily import that into contacts etc. This is making quitting Facebook time-consuming, but I'm getting there. Also, IIRC, all the photos are resized smaller and recompressed, while the full-res versions are still accessible through the Facebook website. This also makes it harder to quit if 1) you don't have the original photos and 2) don't want to live with the unnecessary sacrifice of quality. Facebook really ought to include the best versions it has of the data you've uploaded, even if it makes the archive size enormous. The option to shrink things should be a non-default option only, since the download might be a prelude to an irreversible account deletion.
- shakna 9y ago> since the download might be a prelude to an irreversible account deletion. Is it not one of their aims to make it always reversible?
- amelius 9y agoAn important omission is the data that Facebook collected on you using browser fingerprinting. Since a fingerprint is like a hash, it is theoretically impossible for Facebook to determine if the data really belongs to you, or to someone else who happened to have the same browser fingerprint. This means that if Facebook is legally obliged to offer a complete user data download, then the practice of fingerprinting is illegal.
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoDo they really have to use browser fingerprinting? With everyone giving them everything they want hey have no reason to use more complex tehchniques.
- rock_hard 9y agoThat assumes that they collect such finger prints
- Spivak 9y agoI don't think fingerprinting in the interesting target here -- it's whether anything derived from somoene's data is part of their data and if so where the boundaries are. * Can I use differential privacy? Can a user request a correction to such a dataset? * If I train a ML model on some user data what responsibility do I have with acquisition or deletion? * Can I anonymize my data-sets? * How do I handle aggregate statistics?
- NietTim 9y agoFunny that the website is entirely unusable for me unless I turn off ghostery.
- spraak 9y agoWell, not very surprising
- mtremsal 9y agoThought experiment: if after 5/25, I download my data, then revoke consent and delete my account, then a while later reactivate my account and log back in -- if any of my previous personal data is tied to my "new" account, have I proven that my personal data wasn't entirely deleted since Facebook could still uniquely identify me?
- fredley 9y agoYes. I'm waiting to delete my account until after the 25th because: * There's slightly more of a chance they'll actually delete my data * If they don't, I'll be entitled to be a part of any class-action.
- maaark 9y agoSame, and I'll be encouraging others to do so.
- killjoywashere 9y agoWhat timezone are we using for this? Is it midnight Zulu on the 25th, the 26th?
- sleavey 9y agoWhy not just wait till the 27th?
- 21 9y agoFFS, just delete it on 27
- killjoywashere 9y agoSorry, I'm not hip to most of this stuff. I just thought it would be a fun event. Perhaps it's already on the social media calendar, complete with a cat logo?
- 9y ago
- mxuribe 9y agoI'm not familiar with FB's APIs...do they allow for programmatic download of your data with the same set as via the manual download tool? Because if they do, then a neat little script - leveraging their API - could be used periodically to download one's data to at least address the issue with 2-month expiration on the ad data.
- ikeboy 9y agoIn my experience it doesn't have your comments, posts, etc in groups.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoOne thing is clear. If they delete my data upon my request, they do not,for obvious reasons, delete it's contribution to any ML that was trained with it. Also, when deleting data, I wonder whether they delete any derived scores based on my data.
- alex_hitchins 9y agoThis is a very good point and one that I've been wondering but not seen much discussion of.
- fortythirteen 9y ago> Wikileaks, Julian Assange, and alt-right provocateurs recommend giving it a whirl. Classic guilt-by-association propaganda technique.
- 908087 9y agoI really can't even figure out what posessed the writer to put that line in there. It has absolutely nothing to do with the story, and kind of comes out of nowhere.
- josefresco 9y agoThe author linked to Tweets from said individuals who were mentioning the tool. So it's relevant, however a bit odd they chose those specific examples when I'm sure they're are other "celebrities" who also linked to the tool. Maybe the author thought of these people as those most interested in data privacy?
- fortythirteen 9y agoI'm not so sure, considering how their coverage of the DNC lawsuit read like a press release, with zero journalistic objectivity. It treated the currently unproven claims of a civil suit as if it was already assumed fact.[0] It contains this gem of a paragraph: > The leaks continued steadily from there, as the suit details. Guccifer 2.0 struck again on June 27, June 30, and July 6. On July 22, WikiLeaks took the wheel, releasing nearly 20,000 internal DNC emails. The following day, according to the suit, multiple DNC employees received an email that said: “I hope your children get raped and murdered. I hope your family knows nothing but suffering, torture, and death.” All evidence suggests, as Wikileaks has maintained, that their emails came from a physical source, and not Guccifer 2.0. I think there is a larger editorial bias at play at Wired. [0] https://www.wired.com/story/dnc-lawsuit-reveals-key-details-2016-hack/ https://www.wired.com/story/dnc-lawsuit-reveals-key-details-...
- 908087 9y agoIt seemed like both an attempt to associate Assange/Wikileaks with the "alt-right", and an attempt to associate the desire to find out what Facebook has on you with the same. It felt forced and awkward in the context of the article.
- kdot 9y agoHow complete is this data? Does it include content like comments? It'd be nice to download my data and import it into a competing social network.
- bengale 9y agoNot long now ... https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/nightmare-letter-subject-access-request-under-gdpr-karbaliotis/ https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/nightmare-letter-subject-acce...
- AnnoyingSwede 9y agoThe irony to see the "Would you like to login using facebook"-popup on the wired article..
- not_that_noob 9y agoThere is a potentially disastrous blow to FB's business model in the GDPR that relates to this sort of profiling. It is forbidden under GDPR, unless the user grants explicit consent (opt-in). See [1]. Without this, FB's targeting abilities for ads just evaporates. It is going to be interesting to see how this pans out. [1] https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/individual-rights/rights-related-to-automated-decision-making-including-profiling/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da...
- macintux 9y agoDespite never enabling location services, Facebook once (briefly) gave me a weather forecast when I was traveling. Spooked me quite a bit. The best I could figure is that I temporarily enabled access to my camera roll so I could post a few photos (ordinarily I just copy/paste them to keep Facebook out of my photos), and either it scanned the photos' exif data during upload or directly from the roll once I enabled it. I wasn't remotely surprised to find that particular piece of location data wasn't part of the data download.
- k_lander 9y agoMakes me wonder how many "features" considered internally at FB, Google, etc are being scrapped only because it would not be worth the risk of potential backlash by spooked out users even though they have in their possession all the necessary data.
- Peyphour 9y agoCould just be IP geolocation
- macintux 9y agoGeo IP location is possible but unlikely: the location was very precise and accurate, and I would assume Verizon (wasn't on wifi) wouldn't be handing out IPs with that level of specificity. Plus it only ever happened that once.
- gregsadetsky 9y agoin addition to that, wouldn't it have access to the MAC addresses of the wifi networks around you, and more importantly, be able to do a geo-ip check?
- macintux 9y agoWouldn't have access to MAC addresses. Geo IP location is possible but unlikely: the location was very precise and accurate, and I would assume Verizon (wasn't on wifi) wouldn't be handing out IPs with that level of specificity. Plus it only ever happened that once.
- whyever 9y agoI'm surprised this article does not mention Max Schrems, who requested all data Facebook had on him in 2011: > He later made a request under the European "right to access" provision for the company's records on him and received a CD containing over 1,200 pages of data, which he published at europe-v-facebook.org with personal information redacted. (See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Schrems. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Schrems.)
- vageli 9y agoJust a heads up, your Wikipedia link doesn't work.
- whyever 9y agoYeah, unlike most sites, HN includes the dot in the link for some reason...
- DoreenMichele 9y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Schrems https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Schrems
- supercarsw 9y agowhy people still uses facebook ? how much you want to disclose your life to them ?
- andrewshadura 9y agoThe zip file Facebook provides doesn't include full resolution photos I uploaded, only heavily compressed low-resolution low-quality previews. Useless.