12 ms·
The Categories Were Made for Man, Not Man for the Categories (2014)
- Afforess 9y agoThis is why I find movements like HBD so disgusting, despite their "scientific" origins. They start with a conclusion, the justification of race, and seek evidence to prove it. Of course, they find such evidence. Anyone looking to prove any conclusion can find evidence - even scientifically strong evidence. Heck, even psychics and supernaturalists have scientific evidence on their side! [1] No matter the evidence though -- Categories aren't facts. > “If you call a tail a leg, how many legs does a dog have?” And the answer: “Four – because a tail isn’t a leg regardless of what you call it.” Categories are useful _caches_ of information. We define "limbs involved in the movement of the center of mass of a body" as _legs_ because the concept is useful as a cached "leg". If the concept stops being valuable, we will eventually purge it from the cache. The danger lies in mistaking the cached concept for the original value. [2] Race doesn't predict anything; nowadays, the cached value, crime/success/happiness, is substituted for race, and the results are a reinforcing cycle. [3] More relevant to HN, categories are why "adversarial" effects on many neural networks are so strong. NNs are training to categorize to exacting strategies - strategies not at all in mind by their creators. The apocryphal tank NN meme - that dataset bias led algorithms to detecting sunny skies instead of tanks -- comes to mind. [4] The story is made up, the moral somewhat muddled in the telling, but the surprise survives. What we reward and what we desire are separate things, and in the difference, the whole world lies. [1]: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/04/28/the-control-group-is-out-of-control/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/04/28/the-control-group-is-ou... [2]: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/05/02/causal-models-at-work/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/05/02/causal-models-at-work/ [3]: https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/3/27/15695060/sam-harris-charles-murray-race-iq-forbidden-knowledge-podcast-bell-curve https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/3/27/15695060/s... [4]: https://www.gwern.net/Tanks https://www.gwern.net/Tanks
- lopmotr 9y agoRace absolutely does predict things but it predicts group properties accurately and individual's only probabilistically. That's bound to happen no matter how you categorize people. Every category has to have a different mean height, weight, etc. from the others because those are continuous variables. It turns out that for some useful properties, race is a better classification than random groups. Of course, it is a human invention, just like planets and fish, but it's one with predictive power, just like those other examples.
- aetherson 9y ago"Better classification than a random group" is a fairly low bar.
- lopmotr 9y agoI'm trying to counter the claim that race doesn't predict anything. More than nothing is something. How much? I haven't quantified it but neither has the OP.
- andrewprock 9y agoIt's not bad at predicting what race people will think someone is. Outside of that, it's of marginal utility at best. At worst, it's used for systematic oppression on a global scale.
- alanbernstein 9y agoIf the goal is to counter that oppression, how can it help to dispute or ignore the categories?
- bordercases 9y agoYou're saying a lot of things which are true without mapping them to explicit implications; this is creating a smokescreen by assuming that your 'technical nuance' makes your conclusion self-evident. As far as I can tell, what you're trying to imply is that the definition of terms are driven by their use, and the use of the term race is disgusting, because it makes people feel like they can't change their situation or inflate the ego of other people with all the trappings that go along with it, which is bad, so we shouldn't use it and race doesn't exist. Yet so-called "human biodiversity" doesn't go away just because the way some decide to use the information is bad. Genetic variation exists, we can count it, and we know it's unevenly distributed. But even through this uneven distribution we can assemble models that track the migration of genes through human beings and notice pools of genes in certain populations. Consider k-clustering: it's a way of bootstrapping features, approximate categories. The process is parameterized so that you can create distinctions as great or as fine as you want. Bioinformaticians do this kind of analysis all the time and can assign each person their own label if you like. But it isn't as useful and so we get haplogroups which track variation of genotype much more robustly and compactly. Geneticists and evolutionary anthropologists didn't invent their fields to oppress people. A lot of them were just trying to do science to see where the genes are. You're shooting the science when it's policy makers who are responsible for the "disgusting" use of such information. And if someone has maladaptations, that's no one's fault in particular except the random accidents of Nature; the moral impetus is made more urgent by the acknowledgement of our genes rather than their denial.
- spacehome 9y agoThat's a strange argument to make on this article. Sure, races are an attempt at categorization of something much more complicated than the categories can encode. As such, there's differing perspectives about how many racial categories there are, how to draw the boundaries, and no matter what, there will be people who don't fit into any of your categories. None of this detracts from the fact that racial categorizations are useful and predictive for the overwhelming majority of the Earth's population, just as the questionable status of Pluto doesn't interfere with research on extra-solar planets. By HBD, I assume you're referring to differences in intelligence between races, but please correct me if you're referring to something else. It's always a bad idea to start with the conclusion you want and work backwards. However, in the US, amongst the present-day population, there is OVERWHELMING evidence that there are average IQ differences between races. The open question is what causes these differences in the averages. We know IQ is partly genetic, and we know races differ in allele frequency of many genes. It's possible, though exceedingly unlikely, that genetic differences between races contribute precisely zero to average IQ differences. And there seems to be some circumstantial evidence that genetic differences between races do account for some of the average differences. This is a question that is at least amenable to study, by correlating genes with IQ, and matching this against allele frequency in groups. HBD is not unscientific, and the comparison to psychics is unwarranted. HBD is an attempt to explain an observation (IQ deltas) with a hypothesis.
- jonnybgood 9y agoWhat races are you referring to? Irish, German, English, Spanish? What’s their average IQ? And what genes play a factor in IQ?
- bordercases 9y ago> what genes play a factor in IQ? All of them play a little bit (majority of quantitative differences) and some of them play a lot (when there are significant qualitative differences). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eVSbFAcBAyw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eVSbFAcBAyw
- vixen99 9y ago
- lopmotr 9y ago> They start with a conclusion, the justification of race, and seek evidence to prove it. Of course, they find such evidence. Anyone looking to prove any conclusion can find evidence - even scientifically strong evidence. Can you point to scientifically strong evidence of anything which is also known to be false? I mean evidence which is still accepted as scientifically strong, not something that's been discredited. If not, then I think you've just argued that we can't use science to explain anything because it lets us choose any conclusion we want. I don't think you're trying to promote an anti-science ideology, so can you clarify that?
- nailer 9y agoDo you find movements that discuss commonly accepted neck-down differences between races disgusting too?
- forapurpose 9y agoTheory is a useful servant but a bad master, liable to produce orthodox defenders of every variety of the faith. We ought always to set light to theory and be on the look-out for ways of improving it - Harry Guntrip (attributed)
- elsherbini 9y agoThe article was very interesting, and I know this isn't the main point of the article, but this is an interesting fact I like to share- > "Fish generally ... are in a certain part of the phylogenetic tree." Fish are actually paraphyletic[0], meaning they are in multiple "parts" of the tree of life. To try to use fish as a phylogenetic term is useless because the clade that contains everything we call fish also includes reptiles, birds, and humans. Try explaining that to King Solomon... [0] http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/glossary/gloss1/phyly.html http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/glossary/gloss1/phyly.html
- adrianratnapala 9y agoCheers to you and Scott! "Whales are not fish" annoys me more than a true statement really should. I think it's because the characters in Moby Dick sometime whales fish. It's not as if those guys were ignorant. They knew perfectly well what whales are -- more viscerally (!) then you or I could. And if they chose to call them fish, well perhaps they had good reasons.
- coldtea 9y agoThe problem is having a single name for sea creatures with fins and similar attributes and sea mammals with fins and similar attributes. The intuitive name is better for 99% of the population for most intends and purposes than the genetics or whatever scientific classification name.
- dghf 9y agoIIRC, Moby Dick has an entire chapter where the narrator debates whether or not whales are fish, coming down on the "yes they're fish" side for largely the same reasons as this article's Solomon.
- ludston 9y agoI believe that this essay is an example of the practical application of the Principle of Charity[0]. This is laudable as it is practically a prerequisite that at least one side does this in a useful debate. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity
- rusk 9y agoPerhaps also pertinent on these lines is the principle of "Unconditional Positive Regard" [0] it is easy to infer the worst possible motives when somebody does something bad, but it can be helpful to assume that they did in fact mean well, when attempting to step into their shoes. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unconditional_positive_regard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unconditional_positive_regard
- bordercases 9y agoSounds like an excuse to be lead on. When do you know when to stop being charitable?
- unit91 9y ago> If God wants to call a whale a big fish, stop telling God what to do. Exactly. If God wants to call a man a man, why should I tell him "no she's a woman"? "But who are you, O man, to answer back to God? Will what is molded say to its molder, 'Why have you made me like this?'" Romans 9:20
- cortesoft 9y agoI have yet to see any religious text that defines a man as a person having a Y chromosome.
- DuskStar 9y agoReligious texts defining a man as someone born with a penis and testicles are presumably much more common, however.
- red_admiral 9y agoIndeed, but even these texts take into account that it's not always "binary": https://judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/34058/how-is-gender-halachically-determined https://judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/34058/how-is-gen...
- dwaltrip 9y agoYou can tell god whatever you like... Have fun determining if anyone received the message.
- _bxg1 9y agoThis is one of the best articles I've read on here.
- DuskStar 9y agoIf you enjoyed this article, there's probably quite a few more on Slate Star Codex you'd find interesting! I personally rather enjoyed (and recommend) "I Can Tolerate Anything Except the Outgroup" [0] for the insight, "...And I Show You How Deep The Hole Goes" [1] for the hilarity, and "All In All, Another Brick In The Motte" [2] as an interesting introduction to a debate style I think we've all seen at some point but not been able to describe properly. [0] https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anythin... [1] https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/06/02/and-i-show-you-how-deep-the-rabbit-hole-goes/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2015/06/02/and-i-show-you-how-dee... [2] https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/03/all-in-all-another-brick-in-the-motte/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/03/all-in-all-another-bri...
- mbrock 9y agoNietzsche's text "On truth and lie in a nonmoral sense" expresses a lot of the same ideas. > When someone hides something behind a bush and looks for it again in the same place and finds it there as well, there is not much to praise in such seeking and finding. Yet this is how matters stand regarding seeking and finding "truth" within the realm of reason. If I make up the definition of a mammal, and then, after inspecting a camel, declare "look, a mammal" I have indeed brought a truth to light in this way, but it is a truth of limited value. That is to say, it is a thoroughly anthropomorphic truth which contains not a single point which would be "true in itself" or really and universally valid apart from man. It also has one of the greatest opening paragraphs: > In some remote corner of the universe, poured out and glittering in innumerable solar systems, there once was a star on which clever animals invented knowledge. That was the highest and most mendacious minute of "world history"—yet only a minute. After nature had drawn a few breaths the star grew cold, and the clever animals had to die.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- asdfjk123456890 9y agoThe comparison between someone having a hair dryer in the passenger seat of their car and "giving them cheap natural hormones" is ridiculous. A serious discussion about taking hormones would consider a metric, perhaps rates of self-harm before and after treatment. This post is not a serious discussion. Scott is "... writing ... because [he] just finished accepting a transgender man to the mental hospital".
- wyattpeak 9y agoI don't see that the article says we /should/ give hormones to transgender people at all. Just that dismissing the idea on the basis of (1) maleness being trivially categorisable or (2) transgender being a psychological disorder are baseless. Whether or not it's the right solution is, obviously, a much more complicated question (and one that is probably rather better left to experts than armchair psychiatrists on discussion boards). But it's also an entirely separate question.
- draw_down 9y agoWell, I guess there is something to be said for getting to the point. The counterfactuals posed here are not a fun read, I must say. (Who thinks southern people talk like that?!?)
- rusk 9y agoJust on the topic of silliest athiest argument, the silliest theist argument I've heard is that since Bananas are the perfect size and shape for the human hand they must have been designed by God for humans. Never mind the fact that actual natural bananas are nothing like that they're more akin to a small yellow pomegranite. Or that in some countries (Australia in my experience) you can get Bananas the size of cucumbers. Or even, that all commercial bananas are actually cloned (by way of transplanted cuttings) from a single Banana, which was probably selected "by man" based on various aesthetic, and practical parameters such as "it fitting perfectly in the hand".
- rusk 9y agoSorry, on further recollection this was actually more specifically an argument against "evolution", so in a weird way they were right ...
- coldtea 9y ago>Just on the topic of silliest athiest argument, the silliest theist argument I've heard is that since Bananas are the perfect size and shape for the human hand they must have been designed by God for humans. Never mind the fact that actual natural bananas are nothing like that they're more akin to a small yellow pomegranite. That's not a real counter-argument. God, in all his wisdom, guided humans to breed the perfect-sized bananas we have today. So what the "natural bananas" are is irrelevant.
- rusk 9y agoI hear what you're saying, and your interpretation is more plausible. In fact it is an approach to reconciling creationism and scientific progress that's often employed, even recently by the Pope himself. However that is not how they were casting it. They were presenting the literalist more facile argument.
- comex 9y agoWell, the original argument wasn't just "according to our beliefs, God was involved in this"; it's implying that bananas would be unlikely to be the perfect size and shape for humans by chance, i.e. unless they were designed for that purpose. Which means there has to be a designer (who cared about humans), which for natural phenomena would have to be God, or at least some sort of god. That is, if you exclude evolution and other natural optimization processes; those are known to be able to simulate the appearance of intelligent design, but in theory could be excluded if there weren't a plausible mechanism for something to have evolved in response to humans, e.g. because they haven't been around for that long in geological terms. (Except that plenty of other animals with opposable fingers have existed for longer, but – details. I'm not saying the argument would actually be valid, even if bananas' current appearance were entirely natural.) On the other hand, artificial breeding provides an explanation that doesn't require God in any way, so it does invalidate the argument. The only way to salvage it is to say that God is responsible for it being possible to breed bananas into such a form, but that's obviously much weaker.
- red_admiral 9y agoThis was the article that got me hooked on Scott's writings. The other Scott (Aaronson) has a good blog too and they occasionally reference each other. There is a response to this article titled "The Categories were made for Man to make Predictions" which you can find with your favourite search engine. I'm not saying I agree with everything in the response, but if you're the kind of person who likes Scott Alexander then you might also enjoy reading opposing points of view without immediately wanting to pick up a pitchfork.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- golemotron 9y agoIt's a great essay but you get to the same place from here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Map%E2%80%93territory_relation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Map%E2%80%93territory_relation
- rusk 9y agoThis is an excellent article and has actually helped me to redraw my own boundaries with regards to the matter of substance that it covers. I have one nagging boundary issue that remains however and that is with regards to where the boundary be drawn when applying such an effective therapy to minors.
- bmm6o 9y agoDefining terms is important, but defining sets much less so. Arguments about "is X a Y?" often have little to no value in the abstract. There are exceptions, but these are when the definitions are the most precise and can be evaluated objectively. E.g., a square is a (type of) rectangle and therefore its area is length * width. As the article shows, "is a whale a fish" has no value in the abstract. It depends on if you want to hunt it or know about its evolutionary path. Is a tomato a fruit or a vegetable? It depends on if you are a chef or a botanist. The botanists have the more rigorous definition, but I wouldn't call the chefs wrong. What about a pumpkin? Is a strawberry a berry? (https://imgur.com/gallery/pfEnXNT https://imgur.com/gallery/pfEnXNT) You probably saw the memes go around a while back about what is a sandwich, according to D&D alignments. Good for a laugh and a debate. But let's say you settle the question "is a hotdog a sandwich?" Now what? What did you get from that effort? It doesn't tell you anything about a hotdog that you didn't already know.