17 ms·
Why Invest in Cities? There's Always Another Boise
- pm90 9y agoThis article misses an option I've seen used by the city which I live in: Austin, TX. Instead of building a serious mass transit system, the city encouraged the greenfield development of high density urban clusters outside the downtown region. So the companies moving in now have option to be located in the Downtown or the "New Downtown" (called the Domain). I think this has been a very successful strategy. But it depends on whether you can convince enough people/companies to move to the alternate high density development.
- bradknowles 9y agoThe “new downtown” is not the Domain. It’s Round Rock. And the developers have not done any favors to Austin by building all the massive high rises near the river so that no one else can see any part of the river. Nor have they done any favors to Austin by continuing to build out massive cookie cutter developments so that they can try to become the next Steiner Ranch — meanwhile causing very grave harm with the massive increased traffic on 183, Mopac, 360, 2222, etc....
- nikofeyn 9y agoi think you’re being generous calling austin’s city development and urban design even a “strategy”. austin for a long time didn’t want to grow at all, so they did everything to basically discourage it. then growth was forced on the city, and they’ve had to scramble to try, unsuccessfully, to catch up. that’s why there’s a double decker highway that doesn’t really help the traffic, an expensive highway that goes around the city that no one uses, a highway with practically no exits that goes through people’s backyards, an expensive train that no one uses and is almost pointless, no way to get across the city quickly, hardly any bike lanes in a city where bicyclists are plentiful, and more and more. austin is a poster child for how to not design and develop city infrastructure.
- StudentStuff 9y agoThe train is expensive cause no one bothered to land bank for it, ditto for the freeways running through people's backyards. The lack of planning I saw when I visited Austin was astounding, but it is cultural at this point. Just look at transit in Austin, its nearly a mile to get to a damn bus stop from the Apple campus, and even at peak service is spotty and extremely slow. Busses need to have priority, and be set up to feed your rail system (which is extremely small and needs serious expansion). The current system in Austin will never approach 70% ridership like Seattle or anywhere near it without major changes.
- hueving 9y agoDon't forget traffic worse than silicon valley.
- bytematic 9y agoWhere does Chicago fit into this? Interesting it was left out.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- iambateman 9y agoCali is 30x bigger than Idaho... if 100,000 people move to Idaho, 3,000,000 people need to move to Cali to keep pace in terms of percent growth. Obviously it’s not sustainable for California to be a top growing state forever. As someone who lives in a city with about the same pop as Boise, cities that size can be quite nice.
- Buge 9y agoThe difference is whether you're talking about numeric growth or percentage growth. Idaho is #1 in percentage growth but not in the top 10 in numeric growth. California is #3 in numeric growth, but not in the top 10 in percentage growth. https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2017/estimates-idaho.html https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2017/estimate...
- metei 9y agoIf Boise is happy to deal with an influx of Californians, they can have at it. I'd rather they go there than migrate up the West Coast, bringing their far right politics with them. A year or so ago I was near San Diego, and turning on the radio I got an earful about how finding a new strongman to head the police department was the #1 duty of the city. Seemed absolutely ridiculous to me, but the culture down in Cali is that of beating down on the dirty poors, then acting surprised with the consequences like the hepatitis outbreak: https://www.cnn.com/2017/09/14/health/hepatitis-a-outbreak-san-diego-county/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2017/09/14/health/hepatitis-a-outbreak-s...
- taurath 9y agoI’ve heard a lot of things about California transplants (being one myself), but being far right is one I haven’t yet heard.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jonathankoren 9y agoCalifornia is a big a diverse place, and a lot more reflective of America than places that typically talk about how they’re “Real America.”
- sin7 9y agoHorseshoe theory in action.
- StudentStuff 9y agoMost of the Californians who went to Oregon in the 1980s lobbied for right wing policies in the new places they moved to (which created a number of issues), hence the fear of those disillusioned with California leaving and bringing destructive political views with them that could seriously harm wherever they move. Edit: Downvoting me doesn't make the long term effects of what ex-Californians did to Eastern Oregon go away, small towns in Eastern Oregon are still hamstrung by policies and decisions implemented in that era by ex-Californians.
- diminoten 9y agoFrom a logistical standpoint, does Boise have a glut of available jobs for these migrants, or are they taking their jobs with them? That's the first thing I think about when considering a move; can I work there?
- _virtu 9y agoIf you're in tech, yes. There are a lot of tech related jobs that Boise has a huge deficit for. You won't be compensated at the same rates that you would be in California, but the cost of living would make up for it.
- opportune 9y agoWould it? From my experience, if you’re coming from a place like Google/FB/well paid smaller companies it’s still not worth it. You have to be making on the mid/lower end for the COL changes to account for the reduction in salary - in part because places like Boise simply don’t have jobs that are comparable to some of the better ones in the Bay, Seattle, and NYC
- CydeWeys 9y agoAs an example, I moved from the DC metro area (itself already a high CoL area) to NYC to take a job at Google. I'm currently making 'exceeds expectations' L5 money, which is way more than you can make at basically any tech job in the DC area. And yet there are tens of thousands of engineers here in NYC making that much, at Big 4 and fintech companies. Yes, the cost of living went up a bit, but it's utterly dwarfed by the salary gains. I'd have to somehow achieve a significantly negative cost of living for it to be worth moving to somewhere like Boise, where cracking six figures for a software job is significant.
- pm90 9y agoGenuinely happy to hear that it worked so well for you. I think what you may be overlooking is that the vast majority of SEs don’t have the experience or talent to be at your technical proficiency ( trying not to sound classist here, just stating facts).
- jeffdavis 9y agoWhat is happening in Boise? The article doesn't really say.
- lotharbot 9y agoBoise is absorbing a lot of people who either can't afford to live in California any more, or don't like California's political environment. Boise is currently the fastest growing metro area in the US. This is happening in a lot of mid-sized cities in the western US. California's economic / housing policies result in very high cost of living, which causes a significant migration of poor people out of the state and into places like Boise, Denver, Las Vegas, Beaverton, Fort Worth, and so on. You can frequently find articles like http://www.vvdailypress.com/news/20180203/packing-up-and-moving-out-people-are-leaving-california-in-droves-including-some-high-desert-residents http://www.vvdailypress.com/news/20180203/packing-up-and-mov... from those places.
- jonathankoren 9y agoThe impression I got from the article was that he was using a recent WSJ article[0] about Boise as an impetus to bash urban development. The WSJ article is basically, that it’s cheaper to buy a house in Boise. Sure it is, but there’s nothing about what these people moving to the Boise metro area (population 700k) are doing. The two Californians they talk to are, a CEO who bought a second house, and a soon to be retiree. As it is, this is more of a cutting indictment of California, than Fort Lauderdale is of NYC. Yes, the housing in the desirable parts of California is too high, but at the same time, it’s high because it is desirable. It’s cheap to live in places where no one wants to live. If I wanted, I could move back to where I grew up and a buy a house for $27,000[1], but then I’d be Royalton, Illinois. [0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/boise-idaho-feels-the-growing-pains-of-a-surging-population-1523793600 https://www.wsj.com/articles/boise-idaho-feels-the-growing-p... [1] https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/209-5th-St-N-Royalton-IL-62983/115623873_zpid/ https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/209-5th-St-N-Royalton-IL-...
- _virtu 9y agoAs someone who's currently looking to purchase a first home in Boise after living here for the last 9 years, all I can say is "meep". There's nothing like the crazy stupid money that Californians are brining in to the housing market to make we wish articles like this would stop shining the spotlight on Boise. The housing market has been nuts this season and I can't help but think that it's all the Californians coming in and buying houses off of the market in cash. I don't mind more people coming in to our city. I don't care where you're from. Boise is a lovely place and I would love to have more culture and different perspectives help contribute to the current lifestyle of Boiseans. I just wish it wasn't to the detriment of the current lifestyle of the people who already live here.
- StudentStuff 9y agoFinancially speaking, what good paying jobs are in Boise? I have cousins out there who both graduated with solid degrees, yet can't find work outside retail, and have learned the hard way that becoming management in retail has massive downsides (esp. on one's family).
- _virtu 9y agoMainly tech. I work in tech and have had no issue looking for work. > 7,000 science, technology, engineering and math jobs went unfilled in Idaho in 2017, double the number from the year before. Sources: [1]: http://www.idahostatesman.com/news/politics-government/state-politics/article195422434.html http://www.idahostatesman.com/news/politics-government/state...
- StudentStuff 9y agoWhat companies are creating these positions? What is considered a "high" wage? In my eyes, that could be $58k a year or maybe a touch less depending on the authors perspective, which is a far cry from what similar talent would make in Portland or Seattle, let alone SoCal.
- throwawayjava 9y ago
- cylinder 9y agoMy general view after travelling to Denver is that one of America's biggest issues is underpopulation. There is so much land in these areas and actually lots of infrastructure relative to population. It all stood out to me how white these areas remain. I saw a handful of non whites and no Asians the entire time. Shocking how the whitest areas are the most anti immigrant. What are they so angry about?! Bringing in migrants and capital to these areas could really set the US economy on fire. But since the country turned away from openness in the 1920s economically it's been declining on the growth side (carried by the productivity economy which is tech).
- golemiprague 9y agoPeople want to live with similiar people as them, nothing wrong about it and it works much better than all the diversity propaganda they try to push on us. It is not like in other cities people live together, on the contrary, people pay huge amount of money to be segregated from blacks or hispanics, the fact that you see them all mixed in the downtown is a situation imposed on people, not deliberately intentional.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoDenver is 30% Latino, 11% Black, 5% Asian. Not sure how you only saw a handful of non-whites.
- hueving 9y agoConfirmation bias or lives somewhere with a much smaller white population.
- lotharbot 9y agoOverall Denver is less white than the US as a whole, but has some neighborhoods that are almost entirely white (take a look on https://demographics.virginia.edu/DotMap/index.html https://demographics.virginia.edu/DotMap/index.html ). You can hang out in, say, Cherry Creek or Wash Park and see almost entirely white people. Go to Park Hill or south Feds and you see very few white people.
- 9y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoI wonder if this trend will result in further stratification of American society. I mean, we've always had enclaves where rich people lived and poorer people lived, but they generally used to be at least nearby each other in large metros. Now, though, this city stratification feels like a multi-layer sieve. E.g. San Francisco is still a super-desirable city to live, if you can afford it, so the people who can't get pushed to mid-tier cities, and then in those mid-tier cities poorer people get pushed out as the city gets less affordable. The whole SF Bay Area -> Austin -> (now still less expensive cities like Chattanooga, Pittsburgh, etc.) fits this pattern.
- hueving 9y agoIt's always been this way. People didn't go west because they had a good life on the east coast.
- bilbo0s 9y agoBy the time the "GENT-rification" reaches Chattanooga and Pittsburgh though, it's become something more akin to "SQUIRE-ification". The people moving in are not nearly as wealthy, so people are not really being pushed out in the numbers that they are pushed out in places like Manhattan or San Fran. It's the difference between a few thousand hundred-thousandaires moving in, as opposed to a few thousand millionaires and billionaires moving in. There really is a material and nontrivial difference in the housing market ripples resultant from these two hypothetical immigrant waves. Far fewer people, if any, wind up displaced in the third and fourth tier cities that the hundred-thousandaires move into. Developers operating in these cities simply can't afford to remake the markets the way you can in the larger cities. The numbers typically don't allow for it. Whereas in the first tier cities, the market in entire swaths of these cities can be remade and become astronomically unaffordable in a matter or 5 or 10 years. And the numbers in that large market make it very profitable for a developer to do so.
- closeparen 9y ago>"The people moving in are not nearly as wealthy, so people are not really being pushed out in the numbers that they are pushed out in places like Manhattan or San Fran." Backwards! Third-tier cities have contracted from their 20th-century peaks, so easily commutable lots and even homes are simply vacant. They're affordable to mere hundred-thousandaires because they're drowning in supply (though it might need some work). Displacement doesn't happen as much because abundance means you can get your own spot without taking someone else's. The crappiest apartments in the San Francisco neighborhoods that time forgot are still insanely expensive next to national norms. No development is necessary for sufficiently high migration (against sufficiently low housing stock) to create a capacity crunch, and you're just as evicted when you're outbid by $500 vs. $5000.
- aclimatt 9y agoNot the crux of the article, but: > This doesn't mean that they, or the even higher-cost, more congested coastal metros, will adopt Manhattan or Tokyo-style density and transit patterns. Instead, Austin and San Antonio might be the new Houston and Dallas. My goodness, can we /please/ stop this false dichotomy that a city either has to be a Tokyo megalopolis or a suburban sprawlfest? I don't think any reasonable person is advocating to turn San Francisco into Manhattan, even though that seems to be what everyone is scared of. Clearly the OP has never left the US. Average density in Paris: ~6 stories. Barcelona: ~4 stories. Most cities in Germany: 3-5 stories. Moscow: maybe 6-7 stories. Maybe those aren't perfect by a story or two, but point being, there IS a sustainable growth model, and it's a lot more than SF and LA's paltry 2 story average height, and certainly less than the skyscrapers of Midtown Manhattan that everyone is so scared of. You only have to look across the ocean to see it, and until the US realizes this, Boise et al. will just become another congested, sprawling, expensive suburb with an increasingly poor quality of life. If you want to live in the not-countryside, then density is the only sustainable model. EDIT: And to respond to what I think the crux of the article actually is, that we'll never invest in sustainable urban planning because there will always be another inexpensive 100k population town that we can ruin instead, well that sure is a losing attitude. There probably is some truth there, and it makes me sad. Sure, it'll take a while for the coasts to get their act together, but let's continue to promote a vision of what a viable and sustainable solution looks like for America's cities. Any comparisons with Tokyo or the next Manhattan is just furthering a destructive narrative which, for the record, is what got San Francisco in this mess in the 1980s in the first place.
- pm90 9y agoI don't see what stops cities from planning keeping some kind of growth in mind though. Rail, Bus systems are expensive but how about changing building codes to make it easier to build higher density near the downtown areas of these cities? And then maybe acquire land (at least) for a future mass transit option (monorail, subway etc.). For Gods sake don't be like Austin, which totally ignored the problem and is now scrambling to get it together with some very very expensive options (likely to be even more expensive in the future).
- rayiner 9y ago
- Spooky23 9y agoWhy is this a bad thing? I live in a midsize city. High quality housing is $110/sqft. I can walk to my kids school, shopping, library and dining. My kid can take a bus to malls and parks, and my commute is approximately 7-10m, and few commutes around here would exceed 20-30. I can be in NYC or Boston in <3 hours. NYC by train is an option. Why would you want to move from such a place to NYC or SFO?
- akhilcacharya 9y agoNJ?
- cko 9y agoCan’t be NJ, it’s 1 hr from NY and 6 hours from Boston. Maybe near Hartford?
- jcranmer 9y agoHartford can have some bad traffic, so few commutes being over 30min seems unlikely. New London is another possibility--it's the largest city on the Amtrak line between Providence and New Haven.
- jonas21 9y agoIf "NYC by train is an option," but Boston is not, I'd guess upstate NY, maybe Albany.
- amorphid 9y agoI'm guessing Springfield, Massachusetts.
- quickthrower2 9y ago> Why would you want to move from such a place to NYC or SFO? For the career or business opportunities, I imagine.
- lmm 9y ago
- Splendor 9y agoAs a result of the recent growth Boise now has the 7th largest income gap in the nation[0]. And the median home price recently shot up $11k in one month[1]. [0]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-19/migration-from-pacific-coast-drives-boise-wealth-gains https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-19/migration... [1]: http://www.idahostatesman.com/news/business/article208855154.html http://www.idahostatesman.com/news/business/article208855154...
- niftich 9y agoThe article's point is that the churn of spillover-boomtowns will continue: once the current crop of towns starts getting built out and accumulating problems like unaffordable housing, nightmarish traffic, lack of easy greenfield land to develop with cookie-cutter houses on tiny lots and giant office parks, the developers will find the next wave of towns to exploit, probably long before most of the human misery materializes in the one they just left behind. Boise/Meridian/Nampa may be the flavor of the day now, but by the time you're commuting from Fruitland because you couldn't afford a home in Boise, the region will have become just another dusty built-out suburban disaster buoyed by but a handful of overinfluential employers -- like Tucson -- and you'll be reading articles about whatever buzzword is being used for the new generation moving to Hermiston and Hickory and fortunately-placed small towns no one has never heard of. This is not at all different from the cycle of suburbs that plays out within every metro [1][2][3]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11880084#11880734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11880084#11880734 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13665669#13666473 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13665669#13666473 [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16744401#16746390 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16744401#16746390
- Rapzid 9y agoIt's interesting how much blame you attribute to the developers. I would lay this squarely at the feet of city planners and voters; they hold all the keys.
- niftich 9y agoIt's both. City planners are constrained to their own jurisdiction, so they're trying to come out ahead by ensuring that the next wave of growth doesn't leave them behind. They're trying to solve a local optimization problem, where their competition is often the neighboring localities with whom they will share the wider trend of whatever the future may bring, but the resulting wealth will be allocated depending on exact settlement and zoning patterns. It's a prisoner's dilemma. Meanwhile, developers -- as a loose cohort -- are absolutely the executors for the nationwide phenomenon. Their loyalty is to not to the land or their products, but to the cycle of plan, build, and profit. Wherever they are, they're deeply entangled in local politics, and lobby the local officials to let them build homes on farmland to be upzoned. They leave behind subdivisions that don't actually generate enough revenue to the town to make up for their hookups to utilities and services, but the population growth looks good for the town in reports that businesses look at to expand or relocate. Just like a B-roll of the cities now scrambling to attract Amazon, these suburbs are hoping they'd be picked instead of the town one over when some company with national pockets wants to build a 200-job call center, data center, or distribution warehouse. In mainstream America, these tiny battles between neighboring towns are fought and lost thirty, fifty jobs at a time.
- baron816 9y agoThe sad thing is that trying to increase density in places like SV isn’t just about taming housing inflation, denser places are also better places to live. I think there are lot of people out there who would like living in a place like Brooklyn Heights, where you have 3-5 story row houses (small enough for a single family) that are connected together along a tree lined block, with shops, restaurants, and bars within walking distance. Governments won’t even allow you to build a neighborhood like that anymore.
- amyjess 9y ago> denser places are also better places to live For you, maybe. But not for me or for everyone. I like my low-density suburban sprawl, and I intend to continue voting to keep my city [0] the way it is. [0] Not SV, but in Texas.
- DannyBee 9y agoYeah, part of the underlying problem here is a strong view that anyone who likes low-density must be NIMBY or just trying to protect their property value. It's the typical "no one who knows what i know could possibly have a different perspective and value system than me" attitude.
- hycaria 9y agoOr just doesn't care about the wellbeing of the majority and prefers pollution with cars, sprawled cities, pushing people with low incomes always further from the center (where they might still work), yada yada. It's a terrible stance for both ecological and social matters.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DannyBee 9y agoYou demonstrate a perfect example of that self-sure self-righteousness. I'd strongly suggest you maybe try to understand the perspective of other people more, instead of trying to paint it into a story that you can oppose.
- dmode 9y agoThe fundamental problem with American cities is that Americans failed to recognize them the core engine of growth and prosperity as they are. Instead cities are viewed through a political lens. This NYC's problems are to be solved by the city/county and San Francisco's are to be solved by their local city/county politicians. The Federal government, which takes in 30% of income, chips in a very limited manner. Investing in cities such as these are often viewed as "helping a blue city" and this Fed infrastructure money is spent on building Army bases in rural areas that doesn't provide any return for that investment. Similarly many city dwellers do not recognize the economic importance of the city they live in and the role of the cities in driving growth, reducing poverty etc. Thus they hang on to things like "neighborhood character" and height limits to reduce growth. This is very different in many other countries, and especially Asian countries. There Central governments realize the value cities bring to the national economy and thus investments are prioritized. Look at China and how much investment the Chinese government puts in their big cities. Same with Japan, Korea, Taiwan, UAE, India etc. Indian government prioritized building expressway link between it's megacities. They also funded the Delhi Metro project.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoI think part of the difference is that the USA has a lot more "Tier 1" cities than other countries would have for their size. Australia really has 2 major cities (Sydney and Melbourne), and two second tier cities (Perth and Brisbane). I think it's also in part to how separated the federal government is from local governments. In Australia, tax money is collected by the federal government and then disbursed to the states (bit of a simplification). There's less of a clear delineation between "federal money" and "state money".
- adventured 9y agoIt is slightly unusual. Germany is somewhat similar, as is China (scaled to their population). The Tokyo metro is famously 30% of the population of Japan. It'd be like LA having nearly 100 million people. The Moscow metro is 11% of Russia. The NYC metro is 6% of the US by comparison. Germany's two largest metro areas - Berlin and Ruhrgebiet - have a comparable share of its population to NYC at around 6%-7%. Stockholm is 23% of Sweden. London is nearly 21% of the UK. Paris is 18% of France. Toronto is 16% of Canada. Mexico City is 16% of Mexico. Madrid is 14% of Spain. Amsterdam is 13% of the Netherlands. Bucharest is 12% of Romania. Rome is 12% of Italy. Jakarta is around 11% of Indonesia. Lagos is 11% of Nigeria. São Paulo is 10% of Brazil. Amazingly, the Shanghai and Beijing metro areas are close to or sub 2% of China.
- tptacek 9y agoWhat I don't get about this is: why Boise? Are people just moving there for the scenery? There are major US metros with affordable housing and much better job markets. There's a sort of implied dichotomy in this article: major metros are too expensive, so people will move into a succession of mid-sized towns. But, no: a couple major metros are too expensive. Others, like Miami, Chicago, Cleveland, Atlanta, DFW, and Houston are comparably affordable --- several of them are cheaper than Boise!
- francisofascii 9y agoYou are right. Guessing they picked Boise because it is fast growing.
- niftich 9y agoThey absolutely did, and that's the entire point: the growth-begets-growth tautology of land (and job) development in the US; a subtly-hyped gold rush for milquetoast everymen wherein people tired of high costs of living are trying to catch their lucky break by moving to the handful of areas at the exact right time where you can still buy a big house and snag a semi-rare high-paying job. They read 'metros with the highest rates of income growth' and they think their incomes, but strangely not their costs, would grow too. People do want this, because they've done it with Raleigh, Nashville, and Boulder, and Austin before that, and Portland before that; and the article's point is that there's always another metro somewhere where growth can be jumpstarted for a few years before it fizzles out. Established and mostly well-functioning metros like Chicago and DFW don't qualify in their entirety, because individual suburbs or exurbs within them fulfill the same role that Boise now plays. Boise is being used here because it's remote from other cities of comparable size, so it's riding solely its own coattails, and the failures of regions far away that draw people in.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoWeather is a big factor. Personally, if I'm going to live somewhere cold, there better be some nice skiing options, and there are none in the eastern or middle states. Also looking to minimize humidity. Government finances are also a concern, many of the east and middle cities are also loaded up with tons of debt from years ago. I also think being outdoors-y is in vogue with tech and other high earners, which is also better on the west coast. It all comes down to quality of life and the type of people you want to be around, which I guess the other cities you mentioned can't compete in.
- noobermin 9y agoI mean, may be eventually? Just because Boise is the fastest growing city doesn't mean San Fran and LA have negative growth. The answer of whether Boise will stifle city planners' dreams will come down to the actual numbers over time which in general is hard to predict. People saying "SF is over" or "Seattle is over" seem to only look at the second derivative and ignore the fact that these cities are still growing today.
- jellicle 9y agoIdaho's entire population fits comfortably in a small segment of any of the nation's larger cities. When three people walk into the state, it leads in percentage growth. It's extremely silly to draw some conclusion from the fact that a tiny state managed 2.2% population growth while dozens of larger states managed 2.1%.
- blhack 9y agoJust to highlight the cost difference: I was just in a small city (Boise, actually!) for a work event. We rented a very nice house from airbnb for the stay. It was >4000 square feet. The master bedroom was probably 4-500 square feet itself. It bad high ceilings, a private, gated, massive yard, mature trees etc. Recently listed for $600k and couldn't find a buyer at that price. Just absolutely insane compared even to Phoenix, where I live, and which was the last "Californians flee hiding prices" city.
- hueving 9y ago>Just absolutely insane compared even to Phoenix, where I live, and which was the last "Californians flee hiding prices" city I'm not sure what you are suggesting. Here is a house for less money in Phoenix at that square footage range: https://www.redfin.com/AZ/Phoenix/1908-E-Vista-Dr-85022/home/27893023 https://www.redfin.com/AZ/Phoenix/1908-E-Vista-Dr-85022/home...
- blhack 9y agoA homes value is a lot more than the square footage. The house in Boise was modern, had a very large yard, was a private, gated lot etc. Very different than the house you linked.
- ausjke 9y agoThe sad part is that, after so many California exodus arrived, they will turn Boise to yet another CA city that they just left, as seen in other cities, by then they will move elsewhere I guess.
- ajcodez 9y agoIt’s easy to say “just move somewhere cheaper” but how do you put together a list of places? How many people who can’t afford rent can afford flying around the country trying out new cities? How do you find a new job if you don’t know anybody? What companies are working on economic relocation? It sounds like something difficult and valuable.
- quark33 9y agoOne aspect the article ignores specific to Boise is the increase in enrollment and reputation of Boise State University. There have been numerous studies showing how universities in small towns can drive economic growth such as this one from economists from Stanford. https://tomprof.stanford.edu/posting/1381 https://tomprof.stanford.edu/posting/1381 As higher quality human capital moves to the city, they are more likely to accept jobs and stay in the area, which could be driving the growth of the young adults living and working in the city.
- farmerni 9y agolive on a farm and content yourselves
- farmerni 9y agolive rural and be happy. small farm,commute to work if you can't work remote,go to local town once a week for supplies. sorted.