23 ms·
A blockchain is a specific set of choices suitable for a narrow set of use-cases
- _bxg1 9y agoThank you. This is what I've been telling people forever. Blockchain technology is revolutionary for a very specific and narrow set of use cases, and outside of that it ranges from a crappy solution to completely irrelevant.
- snissn 9y ago> I have a hard time finding people in the distributed systems platform community who believe that blockchain is even remotely as significant as the hype wants to make us believe. Right here! Take eBay or Amazon for example, the entirety of their business can be run as decentralized smart contract software. The blockchain is a distributed ledger whereby storing information is incentivized. It's unbelievably significant. The scale problems will be figured out and reliable and auditable databases will be the defacto choice.
- KirinDave 9y agoWe already have reliable databases. Blockchains purport to offer trustless consensus. If that were true, it'd be a big deal. It's not clear that they do. But why would eBay want a trustless consensus? Their entire business model is around being that trusted arbiter and broker. Even off in darkweb land, companies exist to service and broker transactions that then fall back to the blockchain to reconcile payment. So presumably if you were correct we'd see that model emerging. I've looked, but the inside of Tor is a big place. Maybe you've seen an example I haven't?
- snissn 9y ago> We already have reliable databases. not in the way that a blockchain maintains the final state and a clean audit log of every transaction.
- KirinDave 9y agoGit does this, doesn't it? (Not that people here appreciate my contention that GitHub is a "white label blockchain company")
- snissn 9y agoYeah that's true, and Github is really popular, I use it every day.
- KirinDave 9y agoWell then: Git is a blockchain with proof of ownership for commits and it doesn't need multiple miners or anything and you use it every day with what I guess is acceptable risk.
- Scarblac 9y agoBecause it uses trust. I trust that only I can access my local Git repositories, and that Github's authorization does its job. Which is absolutely great, but nothing new and not what people mean when they hype about "blockchain".
- KirinDave 9y agoI find most folks don't mean anything they think they mean when they hype about blockchain, so I like to try and inject reality.
- return1 9y ago> the entirety of their business only part of their business. their consumer-facing business is building trust, and issuing refunds.
- snissn 9y agoso the non technical parts?
- IncRnd 9y agoWhy would eBay or Amazon want to change over to decentralized smart contract software? They already have working computer systems, so there needs to be great benefit to move to a slower less reliable system that will open them up to additional hacks as well as remove them from the intermediary positions of profit.
- snissn 9y agonow we're going down an irrelevant path. it doesn't matter why an established company or bank would want to or not be based on a blockchain.
- IncRnd 9y agoYou're the one who said those two companies can use blockchains, so asking you why you would say something so bizarre was a perfectly reasonable question. No established company will use a blockchain for a database, when there are real databases they already use. That was the point. Other than speculation, nobody really uses blockchains, and certainly not for mission critical work handling real money or real customers.
- snissn 9y agoi mean another company besides amazon or ebay could, they wouldn't change anything
- ajkjk 9y agoHow is that significant? You can also run eBay or Amazon on filing cabinets full of paper; is that significant? in both cases the costs and complexity are insane.
- snissn 9y agoNo you can't. You'd need a person or people + filing cabinets full of paper.
- ajkjk 9y agoYou can't run a blockchain without miners either; we're both omitting things from our models.
- snissn 9y agoyou need the post office too - don't see your point
- snissn 9y agomy original point is that there are distributed database engineers who are excited about the technology behind blockchain, hi!
- stjohnswarts 9y agoIf that is true what happens when all the bitcoins are basically mined out? That doesn't seem to jive.
- Scarblac 9y agoThen miners need to recoup their costs entirely by transaction fees, or they stop mining and the network will be (even more) vulnerable to hostile takeover.
- acdha 9y ago> Take eBay or Amazon for example, the entirety of their business can be run as decentralized smart contract software. What advantage would that offer? How would that handle scams, and what reason do we have to think it would be cheaper? Reliabky recording and auditing transactions has been a solved problem for a long time so a key question would be how a proposed solution would be cheaper or more reliable in a human-meaningful manner. As an example, a common non-answer is fraud but with smart contracts that requires a trusted third party so it’d be important to show that this would be cheaper than paying Amazon to fill that role.
- CryptoPunk 9y agoThere would be no way to raise fees or otherwise exploit their market position for rent-seeking once they had attained market dominance.
- acdha 9y agoCan you explain why you believe that would be true? The system can’t prevent normal economics from functioning and while competition can act as a check, that’s equally true now – eBay and Amazon both have tons of competition.
- CryptoPunk 9y agoBecause the fees, and other properties of the platform, can be encoded in immutable smart contracts where they can't be changed.
- acdha 9y agoThat doesn't really answer the question: that prevents you from changing a contract after accepting it but it doesn't prevent someone else from saying that they will no longer sign contracts at old rates. This is good because otherwise the system would be completely unworkable in the real world where prices and exchange rates change over time — for example, suppose that a shipping partner increases their rates to handle fuel price increases — you'd need a way to charge more for shipping as soon as that happens. The same would apply to anything involving cryptocurrencies with their wildly-fluctuating exchange rates which don't match the real money either side will need to use.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- KirinDave 9y agoWhat exactly is the specific use case where Proof of Work blockchain are appropriate? Consensus in that design is: 1. Perhaps the single most expensive consensus algorithm ever designed. 2. Deliberately one of the slowest. 3. Does not actually provide trustless consensus once 1/3 of the miner nodes decide to collude. Other than "our data is a merkle tree but you have to trust us to submit transactions to it", and "a currency system with a failed promise to deliver either scale or trustless consensus" what, is the proper application?
- dozzie 9y ago> Consensus in [proof of work blockchain] design is: > 1. Perhaps the single most expensive consensus algorithm ever designed. It's like arguing that bubblesort is one of the most expensive graph traversal algorithms. It's not, because it's a protocol for document timestamping, not establishing a consensus. > 2. Deliberately one of the slowest. Indeed. It was designed so verification of the timestamps is much, much faster than producing them. In previous work, with trusted third party operating a timestamping service, it was enough to control a single service, so there was no need to design this into the very data structure. > 3. Does not actually provide trustless consensus once 1/3 of the miner nodes decide to collude. Indeed it does not, because it was never designed as a consensus protocol. > [...] what, is the proper application [of blockchain]? When you need to establish an order in a sequence of related documents, like with trade contracts. Outside of this very narrow purpose, blockchain is pretty much useless.
- KirinDave 9y ago> Indeed it does not, because it was never designed as a consensus protocol. What exactly do you think a distributed ledger is other than a normal ledger and a trustless consensus protocol?
- dozzie 9y ago> What exactly do you think a distributed ledger is other than a normal ledger and a trustless consensus protocol? There is no such thing among cryptographic protocols as "distributed ledger". The ledger is implemented on top of document timestamping and while required for Bitcoin, it doesn't exist for blockchain data structure. It's like calling HTTPs a cryptographic protocol for serving files. About this "trustless consensus" part, how do you define "consensus" and how does it relate to what computer science calls "consensus" with its most prominent problem of Byzantine generals, especially with the impossibility proof (the one that talks about 1/3 traitors)?
- jernejzen 9y agoHere's my case. I have problems trusting any centralised cloud service out there that is significant for my privacy. I have problems with Pocket, because it knows what I read. If data would be stored on the decentralized nodes and accessible over the smart contracts, my zen would be way closer.
- alanfalcon 9y agoIs IPFS for you?
- kevinwang 9y agoBut wouldn't that change your data being readable by Pocket to your data being readable by everyone? I fail to see how that's better. And if encryption is the solution, there could be encrypted centralized or decentralized apps.
- crispyporkbites 9y agoReadable by everyone != decentralised / blockchain Blockchain code literally runs in an open source, open memory environment. Which means you can guarantee the execution of code without interference.
- roywiggins 9y agoBut that non-interference comes from exposing all the information it operates on to the public. Otherwise, you wouldn't be able to maintain a consensus. (if you encrypt your data, then nobody else can see it, but you can't do anything with it on the chain and you might as well store it in S3 or wherever)
- zodiac 9y agoTechnically, fully homomorphic encryption exists (and may someday be practical)
- 9y ago
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoFirst, I can't stand these people who qualify their logic based on "My crypto friends say ...", "All my start friends are saying ... ", "All my friends who are building distributed systems say ...", instead of 100% being responsible for their own words. I see them as lazy cowards who takes other people's words and transforms them into attention (a.k.a. retweets, viral posts, media mentions, ad revenue, etc.) Second, some thoughts on this specific argument. This whole thread is based on an assumption that "skilled distributed systems engineer" is an authority when it comes to Bitcoin or blockchain. Except they aren't. I would even go further to say that the very developers who are working on Bitcoin protocol itself cannot be trusted as an "authority". They may be very good at cryptography and coding, but it is very difficult for one individual who has made a career out of a single expertise suddenly become an "expert" in all things combined (economics, coding, cryptography, game theory). Especially the economics part, if you're coming from a programmer background. A lot of programmers seem to THINK they understand how Bitcoin works after reading an economics 101 book, but the thing is, even the economists are never 100% certain about their theories. There's a good reason why there are multiple parties of thoughts in economics. I once read a blog post from a guy who's very well respected in the Bitcoin community who wrote a post about "crypto keynesians" and "crypto austrians", and it was so obvious that he had no idea what he's talking about because he got it completely opposite. The post only made sense if you interpret what an "austrian economist" and "keynesian economist" is on an extremely superficial and shallow level, perhaps reading a couple of blog posts or investopedia articles on that topic. I think people really need to be humble when they talk about this topic because I'm pretty sure it's really hard for one person with narrow expertise--unless she/he is very motivated to learn everything--to understand Bitcoin/blockchain as a whole. This is especially true for those who just have one expertise and never really delved into the rest because they think it's a bullshit technology even before learning about what actually powers it. And I have yet to see a single person who's dived really far into learning everything Bitcoin is made up of and come away thinking this whole trustless ledger thing is a fad and a bullshit. Some may get disillusioned that the current existing solutions don't satisfy what they were promised, but even these people still they understand that this doesn't mean the whole idea of a trustless ledger is a sham. They would only think there's got to be a better solution.
- 9y ago
- DennisP 9y agoThere's room for more choices than that. E.g. you can do transactions off-chain and keep some relevant state yourself, with an exit plan to the public chain in case of cheating. Examples include state channels and Ethereum's Plasma.
- decentralised 9y agoThe blockchain enables a set of use-cases around trust, value exchange and cryptoeconomics. With these building blocks, there are a number of companies working on amazing projects that are truly revolutionary. https://vitalik.ca/general/2018/04/20/radical_markets.html https://vitalik.ca/general/2018/04/20/radical_markets.html
- woah 9y agoThis guy makes a lot of good points, but at heart, this is a false appeal from authority. Every distributed system makes a set of tradeoffs. If you were to design a distributed system with the same tradeoffs as a blockchain (single global state, and very low trust of node operators), you would end up with something that has similar performance characteristics as a blockchain. Arguing that these tradeoffs are not good is perfectly valid. For instance, this guy feels that you should be willing to trust your bank with your money, and Microsoft with your code execution, in return for better performance. Valid opinion. The problem is when he comes in with this hand wavy stuff about how him and his very smart friends think this and that and they are distributed systems engineers so you should listen to them. It’s not a technical question, it’s a basic question of where you want to place your trust, and a distributed systems engineers opinion is just as valid as that of UI designer, a teacher, or a janitor.
- ajkjk 9y agoI don't think that was the point of the article at all. The point is that distributed systems engineers know already about these sets of tradeoffs, and many of the alternatives to them, and with that wider perspective see few, if any, reasons to recommend blockchain. Meanwhile many the people going around hyping up blockchain know very little about the tradeoffs and alternatives, and are definitely _not_ recommending blockchain because it's the right set of choices in each of the tradeoffs. Like - picking randomly - KodakCoin[1], he would argue (and I would agree), definitely did not choose to use blockchain because was the database that made the most sense for their needs. Indeed, it's probably a terrible choice compared to the alternatives. (Except, perhaps, for optimizing for"hype factor" as seems to have worked considering their stock price, in which case the best thing to do might actually be to lie and _say_ you're using blockchain, and then... not.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KodakCoin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KodakCoin
- woah 9y ago> The point is that distributed systems engineers know already about these sets of tradeoffs, and many of the alternatives to them, and with that wider perspective see few, if any, reasons to recommend blockchain. It's not really a technical question. People who like blockchains like them because of that set of tradeoffs. Beyond obvious scams and stupid corporate hype (by most of the same people who misused "cloud", btw), people understand the tradeoffs. I don't think that distributed systems experience qualifies you to do any more than understand the tradeoffs, and these specific tradeoffs are understood well by a very large number of people already.
- onetwotree 9y agoAs part of my job, I often have to convince business folks that they don't need to buy a fucking private blockchain (from IBM of course, because they're old enough to think that no one ever got fired for buying IBM). This is very close to the arguments I make, and adds some excellent, articulate points!
- time0ut 9y agoThis is happening at both of my companies now. I'm almost to the point of telling them to buy it just so they can tell their golf buddies they're using blockchain too.
- onetwotree 9y agoPro-tip: do an "experiment" with blockchain (built in house to keep it cheap) so they can tell their golf buddies they're looking into it. Make sure it's compared to a sane solution, because then they can feel superior for having "insider knowledge" that it's pointless.
- olouv 9y agoWhile the definition is exact, it’s a pretty narrow one. I understand that people are tired with all the hype and naturally want to counter it somehow. But don’t let it blind you, blockchain technologies will deeply change our societies. It’s a trust machine: it creates trust where there is none. Trust being one of the pillar of our civilization, the scope of its applications is wider than you would expect. Edit: thanks for the downvotes... if your confirmation bias can’t handle a contrarian, respectful point of view, i’d seriously question your rationality as a member of this scientific-related community.
- zakk 9y agoIn most situations trust between two parties can be obtained by means of a third party they both trust. That’s how the banking system has worked for centuries. The use case for a blockchain is narrower: it can be used to establish trust between two parties in absence of a trustable third party.
- olouv 9y agoExact, and we have seen how well this third-party trust system worked during the last financial crisis just a decade ago.
- paulgb 9y agoWhich system failure from that crisis does blockchain technology fix?
- olouv 9y agoSudden cascading lack of trust?
- paulgb 9y agoBlockchains can reduce counterparty risk in a transaction, but there's no technical solution to the fact that trust is required between, for example, a lender and a borrower. The idea that you can just sprinkle some blockchain dust and avoid financial crises is naive.
- ThomPete 9y agoThe Blockchain is TCP/IP with History. That's how you think about it and once you do that a huge amount of things open up. Some of those might not make sense to the current cohort of developers, proponents, and critics but the next coming generations will grow up with this normalized and will find plenty of ways to use it. The most underappreciated part of the blockchain is its ability to create a secondhand market (not secondary) for digital assets. This means that digital assets will be able to increase in value if ex-owned by the right person (think an ebook who was owned by Obama. If you think this is far out I urge you to look at the art industry to understand how things with no inherent value gets traded for often insane amounts. Collectors Cards (Crypto Kiddies) this is only the beginning and when I look at the kind of things my son care about it's fairly obvious that digital memorabilia is going to be a huge industry. Digital Identity this is going to be the defacto standard in a few decades, decentralized is the future. So hate it or love it. The blockchain is here to stay and there is nothing wrong with us not having found any real traction for it yet outside the speculation space, it will come because the fundamental properties are sound and useful. It's worth spending many more billions on this to get it to to become the 2nd layer on top of TCP ip on the internet. That's my take on it. Edit: I'm genuinely curious. Why the downvotes? Did I say something wrong?
- CryptoPunk 9y ago>>The Blockchain is TCP/IP with History. Great analogy. A canonical history is useful for preventing double spending, but also any kind of collaborative endeavor. Without a shared history, there can be no consensus on the present state.
- ifdefdebug 9y ago> I'm genuinely curious. Why the downvotes? Did I say something wrong? "The Blockchain is TCP/IP with History" - this is just sound bytes, noise without any substance, technically wrong, and could have triggered most of your readers to stop reading right there and press the downvote button.
- ThomPete 9y agoThe title of the Post starter isn't technically right either so that's hardly a reason to downvote as that's not really the purpose of the articles. Understanding bitcoin isn't about understanding the technology any more than understanding economics is about how you technically print money. Analogies are very important and the analogy I use isn't that wrong and not without substance, in fact, I provide that. I am not the only one who think of it like that https://www.wired.com/2015/01/how-bitcoins-blockchain-could-power-an-alternate-internet/ https://www.wired.com/2015/01/how-bitcoins-blockchain-could-... It wasn't the creator of TCP/IP that created Google, Facebook or any of the other big companies out there and it most likely won't be that either with Bitcoin.
- misrab 9y agoI think people are severely underestimating the value of a single source of digital signing and chronology, as well as the network effects of interoperability. Time will tell ;) also to the point of specific design decisions, there are plenty of models that will evolve including arbitrary protocols on the Filecoin Merkle forest, so I'm not worried about that also find that distributed systems experts tend to fail to see things through the lens of cryptoeconomics, which was nakamoto's fundamental innovation. it's about provable behavioural security
- mrharrison 9y agoI agree. Imagine a frontend developer connecting to the internet and with a couple tools like truffle and his crypto wallet, that dev will immediately have access to so much information and logic through smart contracts via one interface, that it blows my mind. It's still young but it's going to be ubiquitous and pervasive. At least I'm 90% sure it will be ;)
- dmitriid 9y agoI'm a frontend developer. So let's assume I've connected to the internet with "a couple of tools". Which information and logic (???) are now available to me that were previously inaccessible?
- CryptoPunk 9y agoI don't think they're severely underestimating it. Look at the market capitalisation of cryptocurrencies, and how much is being invested into new blockchain-based applications, via venture capital and token sales.
- spookthesunset 9y agoDo you people just come here to shill bitcoin? This stuff reads like some MLM brochure. Market cap in the crypto space is a joke. It is super easy to manipulate and poeple (like you) fall for it.
- kmc059000 9y agoI was recently at an "Emerging Technology" conference for emerging technologies that was targeted at non-technical entrepreneurs and innovators. 90% of the conference was focused on blockchain, while the remaining was focused on AI. During the entire conference, blockchain was being touted as a silver bullet for many problems, and many of the people at the conference ate it up. The best anecdote to summarize the conference was a speech by IBM where they covered a project which they did with major retailer to track a supply chain. The speaker mentioned some impressive results which caused a noticeable people around me to literally say "wow". However, they did not once mention specifically how blockchain was the cause of these results or give reasons why blockchain was superior. From what I could tell as an engineer, the entire application could have been built without blockchain. I was surprised at how blockchain was being touted as the next technological revolution (and very light on the details) and was concerned at how quickly the other attendees accepted blockchain as it was being sold. I left the conference thinking that it would only be a matter of time before blockchain would be touted as a silver bullet in the larger community due to conferences like these (although I am sure they've been happening for a while, and this was my first exposure). It will not be long before a large number of software projects will be based on blockchain needlessly, and/or the engineers will be arguing with management why using blockchain is a mistake.
- systoll 9y agoOr the engineers will all agree that any apppend-only linked list is a [degenerate] kind of block chain.
- zby 9y agoYeah - that is how it works! Blockchain can be solution to anything - you just need the definition of blockchain to be broad enough. It is an empty signifier.
- Chathamization 9y agoThat reminds me of this IBM press release[1]: > IBM, Walmart and Tsinghua University have piloted the use of blockchain to trace food items, including pork in China and mangoes in the U.S., as they move through the supply chain to store shelves. Recent testing by Walmart showed that applying blockchain reduced the time it took to trace a package of mangoes from the farm to the store from days or weeks to two seconds. [1] https://www-03.ibm.com/press/us/en/pressrelease/53487.wss https://www-03.ibm.com/press/us/en/pressrelease/53487.wss
- fgoldberg 9y agoOnly some projects have utility in the blockchain Actually, some of the are Augur or Cryptocup.io
- xmly 9y agoI am a distributed system engineer. I worked for aws... I agree with that bitcoin blockchain is only specific for electronic payment system. But its design concept is quite interesting, could make quite huge impact.
- leifg 9y agoThese are all very excellent points. I would go even further: “The only viable application of blockchain is cryptocurrencies” (and cryprocurrencies have a whole different set of problems). By arguing that there is only a “narrow set of use cases” you open the door for the counter argument “yes, but MY blockchain startup is not bullshit”. I isually use the argument “show me the increase of profit margin specifically by using blockchain technology”. I so far have not gotten a satisfying answer.
- snarf21 9y agoI think there are also use cases that revolve around using a blockchain as a public database and API for the transfer and security of data. Obviously, you could do this without using blockchain IF you could get the top 20 players in vertical X to agree on what that looks like. However, using "blockchain" as an excuse to get the project funded and get buy-in from those same top 20 players so they can talk about blockchain at the next board meeting is an enabler of practical problem solving. Sometimes you have to take the path of least resistance.
- Scarblac 9y agoI was recently asked to give a short presentation on "what is blockchain" at a session with government agencies who wanted to formulate a position on whether they should do anything with blockchains. And my conclusion was almost exactly the same as this post: blockchain is part of a set of specific technologies you need to solve the very specific problem that Bitcoin solves. Another thing without which Bitcoin wouldn't work is the PoW stuff. If your requirements are different, then many of those other technologies are still relevant but blockchain is not. And if you are not a digital coin, your requirements _are_ different.
- tbtok 9y agoThere's only one use case for blockchains: creating ecosystems. Solving a customer's problem is typically not something you do on your own, you need to collaborate in ecosystems. Having one company dictating what rules and technologies are in effect in the ecosystem is risky (e.g. ecosystems created by Amazon or Facebook). A blockchain democratises the collaboration, at the cost of efficiency. So at its core it's a governance technology, and a trade-off between efficiency and security of your ecosystem. Blockchains are just a technology. The point is to look at use cases that are now viable because of the ecosystems we create.
- Moodles 9y agoIt's interesting how blockchain became so incredibly hyped though isn't it? Something to do with money (bitcoin) and some new technology perhaps? I wanted to find out what was going on, so I literally applied for a bunch of blockchain jobs just so I can talk to these people on the phone to see what they're all about. I end up asking really basic questions like: "So why are you using a blockchain instead of a normal database?" or "What problem are you actually trying to solve?" It is actually embarrassing; I feel like I'm being abrasive on the phone by asking such truly basic questions, yet they always seem so startled by these kinds of questions and assume I'm somehow incredibly intelligent and perceptive to ask these basic questions. Generally what happens is as follows. Some business MBA type people watch a TED talk or read in the FT that blockchain is the next big thing, so they go out and look to hire "blockchain evangelists". Evangelists is the word they often use, and that sounds about right because it is just like a religion sometimes. Then I only end up talking to the business people about these projects, because that's all the people they have. I won't name them, but I've had conversations with huge firms or startups that both equally talk utter nonsense. One large firm told me that they're working on "permissionless and permissioned blockchains for everything from auditing to wine". While for a small startup I once asked: "why are you using a blockchain for this instead of just having a database?". The answer I got was "well... our customers aren't really technical people...". I told them perhaps they should look at something like Google's certificate transparency rather than blockchains, and they echoed back to me "Oh we are definitely looking at certificate transfer!" (Transfer, not transparency.) It's astonishing. To summarize, huge firms tend to have people who just want to get paid so they always say yes to whatever the clueless MBA person asks, while startups tend to mostly know it's bullshit but go along anyway because there is a lot of $$$ involved, particularly with ICOs.
- thinkingemote 9y agoI really like the idea of phoning up the recruiters to find out more about a technology! We have a Blockchain meetup group in my city, however its mainly about cryptocurrency investments than any actual blockchain technological innovation.
- Moodles 9y ago
- aje403 9y agoOn the bright side, we can stop calling it a scam and start calling it a religion soon
- pknerd 9y agoThis happens with most of the technologies. Remember the days when AJAX was introduced? every other site was being ajaxified. Tech companies were promoting it as if something very unique arrived in this world. Later it was found that Microsoft was using it in outlook for long time, it's just they failed to coin the term for it. Same seems with blockchain and as usual IBM is at it's best to cash this hype for enterprises who are already customer of their products one way or other, specially Middle east countries.
- XR0CSWV3h3kZWg 9y agoThe shortest I have been able to explain it as: If you want an append only log with arbitrary (including malicious) actors then use a blockchain. Otherwise you may want to avoid the huge costs associated.
- zilchers 9y agoI've found my life is a lot happier and I'm a lot less frustrated if I replace "blockchain" with "distributed database" in my mind any time these types of discussions come up. Technically they're different, but what is actually potentially revolutionary about everything happening right now isn't the hash chain, it's the idea of moving apps to distributed databases, self contained databases and away from the database tech of old. This could apply to consumer apps, enterprise apps, pretty much anything. When I think about it that way, I'm much more ok with the broad overuse of the term blockchain.
- johnx123-up 9y agoAs original link is not available, posting the content from Google Cache for future reference Thread by @clemensv: "I've talked to a lot of distributed systems engineers (who build cloud-scale stuff) from across the industry about blockchain. While most pl […]" I've talked to a lot of distributed systems engineers (who build cloud-scale stuff) from across the industry about blockchain. While most platform folks I talked to are perfectly happy to help with frameworks that help selling product or services, ... ... and some even rode the crypto wave to make some hay, I have a hard time finding people in the distributed systems platform community who believe that blockchain is even remotely as significant as the hype wants to make us believe. Engineers at the center of the industry understand the qualities of append-only logs, understand signatures and non-repudiation, and understand consensus protocols. They understand that those are a few building blocks from a large toolbox and that there are choices for each. A "blockchain" is a specific composition of specific choices for these building blocks that's suitable for a fairly narrow set of use-cases. The blockchain-specific consensus models are tailored to (a) all-around lack of trust and (b) convergence to a singular global log. Convergence to a singular global log with many candidate writers and many replicas makes it hard to reach consensus and for that consensus to be propagated; PoW or PoW+PoS (cleverly) solve that by being intentionally slow. The PoW lottery is probabilistically set up so that a singular mining winner can emerge and its winning block can be propagated throughout the network before another miner finds a competing solution (there can be many valid ones). The enabler for that is a time window. The tradeoff the "nobody is trusted" blockchain model makes, is that it literally trades trust for time. It's slow by design. Giving consensus forming ample time is foundational. (I'll be happy to hear arguments that prove the contrary). Once parties trust eachother to faithfully collaborate, the existing consensus models that we all use to build hyper-scale cloud systems become applicable and those can resolve even complex and contested consensus problems in a few milliseconds, largely gated by network latency. Even if there's no all-around trust, there's often a neutral party that can supervise a transaction of two parties that don't trust eachother, but who each trust that party. "Sidechains" and "Private permissioned blockchains" are playing that trick. However, once there's a trusted neutral party, that trusted neutral party can already establish non-repudiation by forcing authentication/authorization along with a content signature and only ever allowing appends. With any regular old database that the neutral party maintains. The world's economy today is built on the very principle that accounting records are both safe from deletion and immutable in digital accounting systems. There's a clear sense of order. They are written to audit logs for non-repudiation proof. The cryptographic chaining of records is a good idea to strengthen the immutability of the ledger as a whole, but it's not really superior to holding a ongoing full copy of the ledger in safe escrow. A signature chain can be done on any existing database. The single global log requirement and therefore the global consensus problem completely falls apart in all cases where the problem is partitionable (FWIW "sidechains" are partitions). Turns out, that's true for most problems, otherwise nothing would ever scale. Once you can use partitions, the consensus scope shrinks to the scope of the partition. When you transfer money from your bank account, the intial scope is just your bank, with the initial transaction to a clearing account. (FWIW, a "sidechain" is a clearing account). Easy. For those familiar with (shall I say "classic"?) distributed systems architecture, it's amusing to see things like "sidechains" with local trust relationships emerge, because they are nothing but a reaffirmation of the partitioning principles foundational for a functional economy Yes. The combination of decentralized operation, variable trust, and non-repudiation is very attractive. The world already works like that. There are easily 15,000+ banks globally and countless more businesses that maintain various ledgers. That's hardly "centralized". "Centralization" is not when 15000 organizations are federated such that you can transfer funds between them. Yes, you need a banking license and audit in the local jurisdiction to be a bank. Because, as we see, some people are happy to separate other people from their funds. The specific combination of well-understood architectural building blocks that make up "blockchain" is very well applicable, but nearly exclusively applicable to all-around trustless global ledger accounting problem (e.g. "coins"). Any other set of requirements is likely better addressed using a different combination of elements from the broad toolset that exists across the distributed systems platform landscape today. /fin PS: I'm not an ideolog on this matter. If you're convinced that you need a blockchain, I'll surely help with the communication path if asked. I have the finest shovels. Clemens Vasters 🇪🇺 (@clemensv)