5 ms·
Assuming that the digitization is done diligently, committing to long-term maintenance of the originals would be borderline hoarding.
by zokier 9y ago
Assuming that the digitization is done diligently, committing to long-term maintenance of the originals would be borderline hoarding.
- ambentzen 9y agoIf that is the case, lets take a picture of the Mona Lisa and shred the damn thing. All that maintenance and security is just a waste, right?
- chrisseaton 9y agoI don't think that's really the same thing. The Mona Lisa was painted directly by the creator's hand and there is value in maintaining the physical structure of the painting because there is something there beyond a physical image. In a video the media - the original film - is already just a copy of the original performance. Unless you are interested in the history of the physical media for it's own sake because it's unusual in some way I don't think it's the same thing. Is the media even the original negative that was in the studio? I don't think so.
- frou_dh 9y agoThe equipment to "play" original paintings is ubiquitous, i.e. eyeballs.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoWell, ask the same question about a mediocre portrait picturing someone of no [recorded/remembered] societal note by an artist no-one knows anything else about and I'd say "absolutely". Take pictures, make them available to the public, give the original away - use the remaining 99% of the upkeep costs for something else. When a robot/printer is able to make a perfect replica of the Mona Lisa down to the brush strokes, and we can experience it in VR without even needing the replica, the answer to your question might change for most works too.
- lou1306 9y agoHigh-res scans of sculptures are already a thing [0]. Just send the polygon mesh to a 3d printing and presto, you get your own David by Michelangelo. However, painting would be waay more difficult, especially in cases (such as Van Gogh) where the artist deliberately applies thick layers of paint. (I find the idea of intentionally destroying the originals to be ludicrous, but hey, more future-proofing is always good) [0]: http://graphics.stanford.edu/papers/dmich-sig00/ http://graphics.stanford.edu/papers/dmich-sig00/
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoPolygon printed plastic is nothing like chiselled marble, and that's going to be super hard to replicate because of the random variability. What is it about original artwork that makes it so important as to need eternal preservation?
- lou1306 9y ago> What is it about original artwork that makes it so important as to need eternal preservation? In David's case, maybe the fact that Michelangelo was able to carve it out of a fragile and partially sculpted block that at least two other great artists refused to use. It's an engineering feat at least as much as an artistic one.
- Koshkin 9y ago> shred the damn thing If we did that, what would we have lost? Just curious...
- GhostVII 9y agoThe value of the Mona Lisa is in the physical object. The value of the broadcast archives is the information they store. So storing the archived in a different format makes them more valuable, but storing the Mona Lisa in a new format removes the only thing giving it value.
- dustycowboy 9y agoNo, digital preservation is much harder than most people think. Digital media degrade too. Hard disks, optical media and magnetic tape all degrade over time. Paper and film are fairly durable. They can be preserved without any maintenance for quite a long time. Format obsolescence means that it can be hard to read old files. Sometimes, you need to track down a precise version of a program. The more tricky issue is that sometimes a file can render, but incorrectly on more modern versions. Also, digital files require specialized software to read, whereas paper documents are immediately readable. Film is also readable to a certain extent without equipment. Digital files might be deemed useless at some point in the future and dumped in the trash. Or there might not be enough money to transfer the files to a new medium.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoDigital files can be duplicated, hashed, have redundancy logically built in. Analogue files render incorrectly too; surfaces deteriorate - media rots, oxidises, decays. I've got digital files from last millennium that have survived better than analogue ones - both written text and images. For the most important I've kept logical and physical redundancy (but not yet needed it); much harder to do with bulky physical media. Libraries in my UK city, and across the UK, have been closed rapidly in the last few years - the materials are generally dumped/sold, but the data from all of them could be held in a small box (computer) with multiple redundant backups for the cost of a couple of magazine subscriptions. For one librarians wage this could all be easily shared with the entire web. We, or at least I, am keen to hang on to some artefacts. But a lot of what we keep seems to be primarily useful for navel gazing.
- evgen 9y agoIn this case we are not talking about paper or film, but old analog video and audio tape. This is reel-to-reel audio and quad or u-matic analog video tape. It suffers from even more degradation issues than digital files as you need to maintain the original medium, have no error correction layers, and are faced with an increasing rarity of the specialized equipment needed to read the data. There is also no additional data that advanced techniques will be able to pull from the original low-fidelity source.