6 ms·
Study suggests drunk people are better at creative problem solving
- lokopodium 9y agoThis sounds right, but for me the lucid problem-solving window is too short to be useful. Then I get sleepy and irritated.
- oOo0oOo 9y agohttps://www.xkcd.com/323/ https://www.xkcd.com/323/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- haZard_OS 9y agoGiven just how many variables are at play and how imprecise the categories of problem-solving are, a study with a sample size of 20 is...unconvincing.
- misja111 9y agoSo the benefit of being slightly drunk is that it removes your focus, so that you might find creative solutions which until then where outside of your radar. I guess that's true, but don't you get the same effect by having a long walk or a good night's sleep?
- foota 9y agoI'm confused, how would getting a night's sleep decrease focus?
- hobofan 9y agoDuring your waking day, when you think about a problem you start tackling it with a specific strategy and accumulate thoughts (assumptions) regarding those strategies. Even if you discard them over the course of your day, you are still biased/focused towards that train of thought. A good night's sleep which takes your mind out of conscious thought then resets/defocuses your mind again and you are more receptible to new ways of tackling the problem. (All of the above is just vague anecdotal evidence, and I have no idea if there is any scientific basis for any of it.)
- keithpeter 9y agoThe Psychology of Invention in the Mathematical Field by Jacques Hadamard, himself a mathematician is not scientific but a good source of anecdotes and systematic attempts at introspection. I find that 'stepping away' from the details after immersion for a few days and allowing the pieces to re-align themselves does seem to pay benefits, even with the mundane and practical problems I need to solve. I agree with the grandparent post that alcohol is not the only de-focusing agent around.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoRelated: I was reading somewhere yesterday (reddit?) about hypnogogia and how creative types used the gap between sleep and wakefullness to tap the minds creative/artistic thought. Basically a light version of using drugs for creative stimulation: instead of creating the altered state, tapping the altered states that are already present at certain times.
- tachyonbeam 9y agoNot necessarily the sleep itself, but I've had many good ideas while trying to fall asleep, when I wasn't actively focusing on anything. The default mode network is thought to be involved in creative thinking, and it's most active when you're not actively focused on a task: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Default_mode_network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Default_mode_network
- droidist2 9y agoHmm, actually this reminds me of the 4am creativity boost I've experienced and then heard mentioned again on Studio 60 ("4 A.M. Miracle") where they say it "erodes your internal sensors."
- socrates666 9y ago... that sounds like a bad thing.
- manicdee 9y agoOnly on about day three when you are trying to straighten up the computer screen which is wonky in directions that don’t exist.
- droidist2 9y agoWhat about showering? What's that about? Is it the water, or just standing naked in a small room?
- cconcepts 9y agoMy confirmation bias is telling me that this is definately true.
- Maarten88 9y agoJust after science made clear there is no safe amount for drinking alcohol, we get this study, feeding us a new feel-good / excuse story for drinking. Maybe I'm being cynical, but who paid for this research?
- MrBuddyCasino 9y agoYour cynicism is warranted: „Federal Agency Courted Alcohol Industry to Fund Study on Benefits of Moderate Drinking“ https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/17/health/nih-alcohol-study-liquor-industry.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/17/health/nih-alcohol-study-...
- xor1 9y agoCynicism is always warranted IMO.
- fauigerzigerk 9y agoIn terms of vested interests your cynicism may be warranted, but that doesn't mean both claims can't be right. There is no safe level of automobile use either. But using a car can be useful and worth the risk for many.
- DennisP 9y agoIt's such a small study, it probably didn't need a sponsor. They got 20 college students, gave them some vodka, and administered a simple standard test.
- polskibus 9y agoMad Men is a whole TV series devoted to this hypothesis.
- Hoasi 9y agoThe best advertising copywriters are old drunks, that is just a fact.
- jasonm23 9y agoBest way to rephrase the post title... Brutally honest people are better at creative problem solving.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThank you for this. This resonates with me. I don't drink, but I'm too truthful to be good. I'm also good at creative problem solving.
- polskibus 9y agoI hope Google et.al. will attempt to replicate this finding on a larger scale internally. Imagine whole SV jumping on to that bandwagon!
- megaman22 9y agoThe quest for the Ballmer Peak is a dangerous endeavor.
- ultim8k 9y agoWhy do people need excuses for doing things they enjoy? I'm fed up with studies that say drinking makes you creative, coffee makes you smarter and chocolate makes you live longer or whatever.
- keithnoizu 9y agoBallmer's curve strikes again.
- vinayms 9y agoI don't drink, smoke or do narcotics, so I have no first hand account to agree or disagree with the veracity of this study. However, what I have experienced is sleep deprivation (not insomnia but self induced sleep deprivation because there is just not enough time to do stuff) makes me creative. I find solutions that are innovative, out of the box, laterally thought etc to problems that keep bugging me (I don't mean just programming or software problems). The strange thing is, the solutions come out of nowhere, like a divine inspiration or something. And just like being drunk, the sleep deprivation, at least to me, causes noticeable loss in physical strength, makes me irritable and generally less socially convivial, causes gas, heart burn and bad breath, even shows signs of the dreaded ED, but the benefit of solution epiphany makes me want to go through it often. I know its bad for the health, so, now that I am over 35, I use it quite sparingly, only to problems that I estimate are really worth it. The epiphany thing doesn't need sleep deprivation and there are several 'aha moments' in the normal state. I am sure most people who routinely ponder on problems have had this experience. But the quality of solutions and the thrill it provides makes the Sleep Deprived Solution Epiphany (tm) quite a stimulating and almost spiritual experience. I feel refreshed and more confident in my abilities after an episode.
- cloakandswagger 9y agoHaving just ventured over from the topic about the beneficial effects of psychedelics, I can't help but notice in the comments how the potential benefits of psychedelics are taken as indisputable fact while a similar article about alcohol is met with skepticism and denial.