8 ms·
It looks like the entire thing is made of chipboard and planks of wood? Is it a temporary building? How long does that last?
by chrisseaton 9y ago
It looks like the entire thing is made of chipboard and planks of wood? Is it a temporary building? How long does that last?
- Jakob 9y agoI’ve asked myself the same question. It seems to come down to cheaper, earthquakes, faster and easier to build and modify.
- adventured 9y agoA house like that will easily last over a century if you take care of it and do routine maintenance. Obviously that's assuming it's not destroyed in a direct hit by a tornado or a once in a century nearby massive earthquake (such a risk applies to a super tiny fraction of all US housing). A friend of mine purchased a hundred plus year old wood house. The standards back then were non-existent, boards placed wherever, seemingly constructed stupidly in every possible regard, and it managed over a century regardless through routine maintenance. Keeping in mind that's starting from ~1900. Starting from the standards today, you should easily get over a century. Use a metal roof, replace it every 40-60 years depending, and just take care of it.
- megaman22 9y agoThe thing old houses like that have in their favor is that the timber they are built out of is usually better quality than anything you could possibly buy today. Consequently a lot of things could be significantly overbuilt in a way you can't do today. My house is 1880s vintage, and it's sorta post-and-beam, with 10x10 beams making up the frame, and double layers of 12" to 30" wide pine floorboards. You can't even begin to find lumber like that today, unless you've got a stand of high quality timber that's been saved out and not cut already, and a sawmill to do custom sawing.
- netzone 9y agoWell, you could probably find it. You definitely had more of the really large trees in North America as far as I know, historically anyway. Today, building something with massive sturdy timber would likely not be much cheaper (if at all) than just building a concrete box.
- maxerickson 9y agoYeah, there's plenty of big trees left too. Stuff just gets cut smaller because no one wants to pay for extra size. There's really no reason to use huge beams for house style construction. Decent wood is incredibly strong.
- ghaff 9y agoI live in about a 200 year old house that's kinda sorta post and beam but nothing like 10x10s. And some really wide floor boards. When I had to do a major renovation I got some wider floor boards but they're still a lot thinner than some of the ones already in the house.
- shimon 9y agoAnd conversely, the thing that today's houses have in their favor is that there's a ton more engineering knowledge and testing applied to the materials and construction. They will last a very long time, and they will do better at resisting leaks, staying level, and operating efficiently. Of course, at any time there are many poorly-built houses being made - it's not fair to compare only the old houses that have survived with the cheapest of current homes. And there are probably some "miracle materials" today that will be found to have big problems in practice, from lower-than-expected lifetimes to significant safety risks (c.f. polybutylene pipes, asbestos, lead paint). Personally I enjoy living in a 125yo home. It's balloon-framed, and the joist spacing is inconsistent, and if you replicated this structure with modern lumber it would probably be dangerous. With 1890s-era lumber, it's just a little off-kilter. :)
- newnewpdro 9y agoNot all wood frame homes are created equally. This house seems to be employing OSB everywhere anything wider than a 2x4 is needed. I assume most of the criticism being voiced is in response to the OSB, not of the wood frame. Something as common as a burst water pipe (there's snow on the ground in the video) is likely to cause severe structural damage to this home due to the liberal use of OSB, particularly in the joists. OSB is a relatively modern invention, none of the history you mention is relevant to its application.
- bornonline1 9y agoMost mass builds are built like this
- astura 9y agoPardon my ignorance but what are "mass builds?"
- dharma1 9y agoTimber frame houses will last a long time if properly maintained. The main source of decay is water or condensation getting into the structure and causing rot/mold - if you make sure that doesn't happen, the houses last for 100+ years
- iguy 9y agoAnd perhaps you can add another zero to that if you're careful: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stave_church#Norway_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stave_church#Norway_2
- glenneroo 9y agoDon't forget about Termites! Whenever I fly into LA with friends from Europe, I have to explain what all the striped "circus tents" are.
- tzahola 9y agoNo, it's just how houses are build in the US.
- SmellyGeekBoy 9y agoMany new builds in the UK too, sadly.
- tzahola 9y agoAt least there’s less chance of a hurricane there, though I wonder how they protect the wooden structure from the year-round damp climate.
- erikb 9y agoThis is how Americans build houses. And they sell them more expensively than the massive houses we build in Europe.
- nmeofthestate 9y agoThe timber parts of houses built in the UK look pretty much the same as this - eg engineered joists and OSB sheathing. I'd be surprised if these kinds of products (lighter and cheaper for the same strength) aren't used in at least some other parts of Europe.
- newnewpdro 9y agoWhat's being done in the video appears to be on the extreme low end of the budget spectrum. The use of OSB joists is not what I would consider the national norm today. Joists I believe are typically built from dimensional lumber of the Douglas Fir variety. OSB is usually used in the sheathing alone, which can easily be replaced when needed (OSB can't get wet). On higher quality builds, plywood is used for the sheathing. I've never seen a home with OSB joists, but most of the homes I've seen under the skirt of were built between the 1950s-80s. Over time the average build quality has certainly diminished. OSB usage continues to increase despite its obvious problems. It's another casualty of population growth. Consumer goods are made of plastic, and your homes are increasingly made from glued together woodchips.
- CydeWeys 9y agoEngineered joists aren't "chipboard"; they're stronger and more expensive than dimensional lumber of the same size, and you can run utilities through them without compromising strength to the same degree. They're typically used because they can lessen the need for supports, allowing larger rooms and fewer columns. See here for more information: https://www.thisoldhouse.com/ideas/lesson-modern-framing-materials https://www.thisoldhouse.com/ideas/lesson-modern-framing-mat... Chipboard is made from sawdust and is completely different in load-bearing ability.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> Engineered joists aren't "chipboard" Not the joists. The flat panels he's making the floors and walls from - they're chipboard, or OSB https://www.quora.com/What-is-a-chipboard https://www.quora.com/What-is-a-chipboard. There doesn't seem to be anything solid in the house at all - no brick or stone.
- CydeWeys 9y agoThe concrete foundation seems pretty solid to me. Why does there need to be brick or stone? An all wooden building does better in earthquakes than a masonry building, as one example benefit. Another is that it's cheaper.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> Why does there need to be brick or stone? I guess there must be no need at all, since Americans are happily building and living in these houses. It's just so odd to people in countries where you are used to all four walls in every internal room being a foot of solid brick to think you would build houses out of what looks like sticks and not-much-more-than-cardboard. It seems so temporary. What did the three little pigs teach us? But as I say this seems to work fine for the Americans so it must be great in practice.
- CydeWeys 9y agoThe OP video is from a Canadian FYI, so it's not just Americans. Why would all four walls in every internal room need to be a foot of solid brick? That's so wasteful, and a nightmare for retrofitting with additional utility services. I get that you are used to it, but custom isn't a valid reason for things to be done a certain way. We need to go back to first principles. What's the best way to build a house? Well, in North America, wood is widely available, cheap, and builds a strong house that's resistant to earthquakes. Why would you use anything else? Also keep in mind that farmed wood is carbon neutral, while concrete and bricks are not. And it's not temporary. Wooden houses will easily last centuries. Given how quickly technology is changing anyway, how long do you really need a house to last? Even one century is probably more than enough. Also consider that the average length of home ownership is 13 years; why does it matter what happens seven owners down the line after you're already dead? Also, the moral of the three little pigs fairy tale is that hard work and dedication pay off, not that literally brick is the best construction material (it's not).