3 ms·
How easily you can fly a plane without any training on that plane isn't really relevant here, is it?
by wtallis 9y ago
How easily you can fly a plane without any training on that plane isn't really relevant here, is it?
- jacquesm 9y agoIt would seem to be a pretty good proxy for 'easier'.
- empath75 9y agoNot really. Riding a bike is probably easier than driving a car but if you never ridden a bike you’re not likely to just be able to pick one up and go with it.
- jacquesm 9y ago> but if you never ridden a bike you’re not likely to just be able to pick one up and go with it. All my kids disagree with you.
- tossaway1 9y agoSeems like a weird place to brag about how gifted your kids are.
- jacquesm 9y agoRiding a bike is nothing special here, if my kids are gifted so is the rest of the neighborhood.
- Twisol 9y agoWhile the plural of anecdote is not evidence, I may as well pitch mine in: I hit practically every parked car in the neighborhood trying to learn how to ride my bicycle. So the original point rings pretty true for me.
- ghaff 9y agoAnd I absolutely did not find it easy to learn to ride as an adult--and I'm still not good enough at it to ride on a road.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoNo balance bike or stabilisers or gyroscopic wheel hubs? They just got on a bike and rode without falling off or hitting anything? I'd say that's incredibly rare.
- jacquesm 9y agoWell, it isn't where I live. Kids from about 1-3 years old get these little 'walker bikes' that have no sidewheels or anything (no chain or pedals either), they use those to learn balance, then after that they get their first bike (age 3 and up) which they usually can ride on right away. By the time they go to grade school they can cycle with the best of them. Learning how to cycle at a much later age is far harder.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoYeah, that's what I know if as a balance bike. Once mastered moving to a pedal bike is much easier because you've done the balance bit. We did that bit by removing the pedals and lowering the seat. Once they can cruise then stick the pedals on, adjust the seat, and they're away ... but that's not just "getting on a bike", that's a progression of training. The thread parent said "never picked up a bike", you transmuted that to "used a training bike and then picked up a full one". Not pertinent to the thread but the flaw in this technique (balance bike) with my kids has been they learn to brake with their feet and that instinct is hard to break.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Zak 9y agoPeople don't always mean a single thing when they say "easier". I think philg is using "easier" to mean that the workload is lower, while you're using "easier" to mean that the skill level required is lower.
- exelius 9y agoModern jets are actually pretty easy to fly, as long as nothing goes wrong. To the point that when Mythbusters tested that “guiding a passenger through landing the plane when the pilots die” myth, they interviewed ATC who said something along the lines of “that would never happen, but if it did it’s like 2 buttons to engage the landing autopilot and we could easily do it over the radio.” Apparently some subset of flight attendants are trained on basic flight ops for this kind of situation. When things do go wrong, you still need a pilot experienced in the way that aircraft works or non-problems can turn into a catastrophe. AF447 was the latest reminder of that... so you are right that the amount of skill required is greater.
- Zak 9y agoThere have been several experiments done for youtube videos where an untrained person is talked through a landing, sometimes without the benefit of ILS autoland. The latter is... not always successful. I wonder if someone used to simpler aircraft might have done better at identifying the problem in AF447. Any pilot should know that given full power, an unknown airspeed, a nose-up attitude and a high descent rate that the airplane is probably in a stall.
- exelius 9y agoThat was part of the conclusion of the definitive piece of journalism about the crash: Air France had a habit of training pilots fresh up on a jumbo jet, accumulating the required flight hours in a certified simulator (the “company babies” referred to in the article). Part of the confusion was that under “normal law” (typical flight computer rules), that jet literally cannot stall due to pilot input. Thus they dismissed the stall warnings as erroneous because they assumed the flight data was unreliable in some way. Indeed, once the more senior pilot (who flew light aircraft) was on the bridge, it didn’t take him long to figure out what was going on... and once he did his ability to think coherently broke down because he knew they were in a high speed stall and probably going to die any moment.
- coatmatter 9y agoAt risk of joining a buried tangental thread, I don't think it is a good analogy. Anecdote: In my software flight sim experience (I know I am not a pilot), I've had a better initial success rate with the heavier planes than I have with the light ones. Did I fluke it? Probably. But then again, I've learned some tricks on a bicycle that are widely seen as more difficult to learn than learning to ride a bike but I don't think they were that hard to learn in hindsight. Anyway, we are so into hypothetical territory now that I'm not going to further embarrass myself with more comment on this. Is learning two or three new programming languages for a programmer harder than learning a single new programming language as a novice?