6 ms·
I don't know why people were downvoting this. GDPR outside of the EU (for purely non-EU entities) is a non sequitur there are zero internal processes to make i
by dogma1138 9y ago
I don't know why people were downvoting this.
GDPR outside of the EU (for purely non-EU entities) is a non sequitur there are zero internal processes to make it work.
Lets take the most basic example the GDPR does not apply in a vacuum it's enforced and supported by Data Protection Agencies (DPA) in each member state which are responsible to ensure that companies in those member states comply with EU regulation like the GDPR within the context of local laws and regulations.
The DPA is responsible for the application of the GDPR within it's member state (and it's power is limited to that member state only but the GDPR does have a few venues for applying a local DPA directive across member state lines) it's also responsible for handling complaints in that state and it provides directives and advice to both law makers and the industry.
If I'm a UK company and need to deal with the GDPR (till Brexit do us part) I work with the ICO which is the UK Data Protection Agency. While other DPA might affect me the ICO is my primary source of both advice and enforcement and any issues that might originate in another DPA would still pass through the ICO.
Now I am a company in don't know where lets take Argentina I want to sell to EU customers which DPA do I answer too? which DPA to I ask for advice? How do I arbitrate complaints filed against me and to which DPA do I prove I handled data disclosure requests in a manner compliant with the GDPR? which DPA would know my local laws to ensure if my application with the GDPR was complaint with local data retention and lawful access laws?
In fact other than going through my own state/trade department and organizations what venue do I have as a non-EU resident and a non-EU entity to any EU services and resources.
The question to all of this is none as a non-EU company there is fuck all you can do even if you want to comply with the GDPR.
- morgante 9y agoYup. It's crazy to me that this law is going into effect without even such basic questions being answered.
- cdancette 9y agoYou should use more punctuation, your writing is very hard to read and understand (as a non native speaker)
- dogma1138 9y agoYeah sorry writing on an iPhone is a makes it a bit hard.
- dspillett 9y ago> UK company and need to deal with the GDPR (till Brexit do us part) Brexit will make little or no difference unless you refuse to deal with EU citizens in any way the involves you having access to their PII or storing any information about them (including traces of their activity in your product/app/site. GDPR will be carried over post-brexit, and even if it is later revoked by act of parliament and not replaced by something equivalent you'll still need to deal with it if you want to trade with EU citizens. If the UK refused to play ball and somehow blocked us from the punishments for non-compliance we will face inconvenient sanction by other means. GDPR isn't perfect (is any regulation?) and their are certainly significant questions to be answered from the PoV of people operating outside the EU, and even some issues that may still require more clarity for those entirely operating here, but I wholeheartedly welcome it (UK citizen here, FWIW) despite being a data specialist and therefore having a bad nervous-twitch reaction to any idea of a non-soft delete operation!
- dogma1138 9y agoThat was a joke, the ICO will continue post Brexit I have no problems from the UK. The GDPR isn't perfect it's just none workable for companies that are not in the EU.
- trumpeta 9y agoI'm not a lawyer, but I would think your Argentina company can be in one of 2 states: 1. You have a subsidiary in EU, in which case that is who will get fined or will have to deal with the DPA where it is registered 2. You don't, in which case the EU can not fine you?
- morgante 9y agoI don't think any of this is entirely clear, but from my understanding it seems like the EU wants to apply GDPR even if you don't have an EU presence. In practice, I doubt that they'd get the US to enforce judgements. But it might mean that I can never risk going to Europe again lest I risk having a default judgement enforced against me for one of my businesses.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIf your store front is accessible to EU based citizens then you have an EU presence.
- dogma1138 9y agoNo if you aren’t a legal entity in the EU you have no presence in the EU. If you would push for this the only thing that would happen is that companies would stop accepting orders from the EU. If this is going to be the definition expect a lot of store fronts to be closed to EU residents following May 25th or more likely the first time this precedence will be set in court.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIt seems a direct parallel of being tried for copyright infringement in USA when you have an offshore website - like O'Dwyer who had to bribe himself out of being extradited from UK to face charges of copyright infringement in USA. He'd never been there, didn't have servers there, and was acting legally in his jurisdiction of residence. Similar things happened with USA's actions on Silk Road, KAT, with Kim Dotcom, and I'm sure many other legal situations I'm not aware of. EU is seemingly extending logical contact to be equivalent to entry to a jurisdiction as USA appear to have established is desirable as a facet of inter-national application of law in the internet age. I much prefer the extension of jurisdiction in protection of member states citizens rights than in the service of media conglomerates.
- Spearchucker 9y agoYou use the legislation to guide your internal processes, systems and employee/user education. You ask your legal counsel for advise. Other than what you'd normally do anyway, you'd provide evidence of disclosure only to the DPA that asks. The DPA doesn't care about your local laws - seek local legal counsel instead. To a developer used to systems thinking this should not be rocket science. Most of it is just good practice. Kim Cameron came up with the laws of identity many years ago, which the GDPR is surprisingly similar to.
- dogma1138 9y agoDPA cares for local laws the GDPR does not trump local EU legislation. What court do you use to appeal a complaint or a fine? There are no processes at all for a non-EU entity to function within the GDPR and saying it’s not rocket science isn’t going to change that.
- Spearchucker 9y agoIf the ICO (UK) issued a fine, you wouldn't appeal in Spain, would you? Because of course you respond to the DPA that issued the fine or complaint. Am I not understanding your question?
- dogma1138 9y agoWe’re not talking about EU companies or entities but non-EU ones. In case of the EU you have your own local DPA other DPA local courts and high courts to appeal too and or work with. As a non-EU entity you get nothing.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoYou get the courts that the person you're servicing uses. Like when you sell to someone in a particular country and have to abide by their sales and tax laws.
- 9y ago
- vageli 9y agoSo, given that there's no DPA in the US (as far as I'm aware, there are also none in China, India, Australia, etc), how would the GDPR be enforced against an entity with no physical presence in the EU?
- dogma1138 9y agoOn paper it can’t. In practice since the EU expects EU entities to essentially mandate GDPR compliance form their non-EU partners in order to be complaint it’s is pretty simple at least for ecommerce. PayPal could tell you you must comply to accept payments form the EU and likely in the same manner they handle everything which means no guidance, benchmarks or clear directions and it would be up to you to figure it out. By PayPal I don’t mean just PayPal but any other payment processor or service provider which you are dependent on.