3 ms·
This competition is a prosecutor's fallacy (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosecutor%27s_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosecutor%27s_fallacy), especial
by minimaxir 9y ago
This competition is a prosecutor's fallacy (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosecutor%27s_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosecutor%27s_fallacy), especially since the definition of "toxicity" in this problem is 100% arbitrary.
Also, about the required input fee:
> I am offering a free $10,000 of my own money. If you really believe that you can win, then obviously $500 won’t deter you at all.
Since we're talking about statistical modeling, the rational argument would be that a person would only participate if expected value of winning the competition is greater than the input pot. A ~5% chance of winning, given the time investment and opportunity cost involved, isn't compelling enough to risk it. That's why Kaggle competitions are free.
- lucb1e 9y ago(Edit: When I wrote this comment, the parent comment only contained what is now the first paragraph. I didn't know about the entrance fee.) And yet I agree with the author. I also hear about toxic posts and the terrible community, but I do not experience it myself. Having people try to put a finger on it would be good. When the $10k is to be paid is indeed unfortunately unclear, but I do like the competition, and I do hope that people that have experienced it will try to quantify it, even if they can't meet the 10% requirement.
- IshKebab 9y agoHe does address this: > An independent panel that both you and I agree upon will define what it means to be “toxic”. But the author is right so there's zero chance of anyone taking him up on this offer.
- KirinDave 9y agoThat's a non-answer though. That process point alone means no prize need ever be rewarded. If you actually wanted to get results from this, you'd have this panel selected in advance so that people could just the fairness of the panel before engaging. Not allowing for post-engagement "Ha ha I demand Milo Y. is on my panel and he thinks this is fine to say to a woman." Of course that's just one of many red flags.
- AcerbicZero 9y agoI believe this is addressed in the "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence" section. If Stack Overflow is anywhere near as toxic as some people have suggested, this would seem to be a reasonable method of encouraging people to prove it. One of the often repeated comments of several popular conservative "speakers" (Shapiro, although I think I've heard something similar from Peterson, Crowder, etc.) is that if you present proof of a specific problem they would be happy to work with anyone and everyone to resolve it. A generous interpretation of the author could be that they want to see Stack Overflow succeed, and by addressing this potential issue directly they can fix it, if it does exist at all.
- KirinDave 9y agoWho anywhere has suggested that Stack Overflow is 10% rape and murder threats? This is an absurd standard that is being advanced. Of course I can't prove that. I never wanted to. The author is using a straw man so potent he can comfortably put a lot of money behind it.
- TedPetrou 9y agoWhy is your reading comprehension so bad?
- KirinDave 9y agoOh I'm sorry, did you NOT set a threshold of 10% and then say, and I quote, "In an internet filled with people wishing you were dead or raped (see YouTube comments sections), Stack Overflow is a saint." Sorry for drawing the obvious conclusion: that that's where you draw the line. Maybe, Ted, just maybe... no one needed your opinion, your shoddy poll, your patronizing fake bounty, your bait and switch methodology, or your Dawkins-style rant about how people should be grateful they aren't the direct victims of violence. Maybe you had nothing positive to add, and you're feeling clap-back because what you did add was so bad even Stack Overflow walked back from you.
- whack 9y ago> "The following demonstrates the fallacy in the context of a prosecutor questioning an expert witness: “the odds of finding this evidence on an innocent man are so small that the jury can safely disregard the possibility that this defendant is innocent”.[1] The fallacy obscures that the odds of a defendant being innocent given said evidence in fact depends on the likely higher prior odds of the defendant being innocent, the explicitly lesser odds of the evidence in the case that he was innocent as mentioned, as well as the underlying cumulative odds of the evidence being on the defendant." Care to explain how this fallacy is related to the above competition?
- grenoire 9y ago5% chance of winning? Where does that number come from, 500/10,000? That is not a 'chance of winning.'
- minimaxir 9y agoSorry, chance of winning assuming if winning was a independently random event, which in this case may not be accurate (although you could make an argument if the odds of winning are better or worse than 5%)
- grenoire 9y agoYou must realise that the chance of winning is independent of the 'entry fee' for this game. You could argue of a ROI or something similar in terms of decision making for entry, but that still has no effect on your chances.
- TedPetrou 9y agoI lowered the donation to $50. I think I would be comfortable with quite a liberal definition of toxic as 10% is a high threshold.