7 ms·
That's not really what you should take from that. K&L Gates is in the same building as the company I work for, despite multiple mergers 2 decades past retireme
by dogma1138 9y ago
That's not really what you should take from that.
K&L Gates is in the same building as the company I work for, despite multiple mergers 2 decades past retirement the Gates name is still on the door and it's not because of Bill.
William Gates is a very accomplished individual and a true philanthropist not many people would be schlepping through Africa in their 80's and 90's, especially people of his stature.
1976 (when Bill was 20) would be about 10 years after W. Gates co-founded his law firm and while for sure that they were well off that time I don't exactly know if they would be classified as "wealthy" especially by SV standards.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_H._Gates_Sr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_H._Gates_Sr.
My take on this is that if anything this proof that good parenting is important, there are plenty of other wealthy lines where the children do not amount to anything but managing not squander their heritage and fortune.
Don't get me wrong growing up in an upper middle class family or higher does have a lot of benefits it allows you to have the potential benefit of better education and values and it allows you to take risks that less fortunate individuals may not be able.
However I don't see anything that would prove that someone's success will change their children's future other than to give them a bigger bank account (which cannot be dismissed on it's own ofc).
- walshemj 9y agoBill came from old money
- dogma1138 9y agoThat is debatable especially when you think old money e.g. Rockefeller etc. His dad was hard working from the get go, didn't dodge the WW2 draft like plenty of "old money" people did and worked his arse off to achieve what he did. As for Bill again I don't see anything where his "came from so called old money" badge would've contributed to his success considerably beyond what an upper middle class family could. His actions outside of Microsoft also speak greatly to his character and go well beyond the typical SV billionaire or even the "typical" philanthropist. I think the gates case is unique in terms where you have 2 very accomplished parents both Mary Maxwell Gates and William H. Gates Sr. which were accomplished on their own regardless if they were old money or not.
- krageon 9y agoNowhere in this post do you successfully make the case that he's not old money. You may have demonstrated that he didn't fall victim to many of the tropes that his contemporaries did, but the fact remains he had (a lot) more than most people would at any point in time (including opportunities and contacts). I still remember the moment when Bill Gates switched from being the "Microsoft guy" (during those times sort of akin to the new Satan) to being the "philanthropist" that he is now. I'd say it's been a very successful bit of public relations for him if this is how you see him now.
- dogma1138 9y agoI don't understand why do I need to prove he isn't "old money" old money is a pretty defined term unless you want to use it in the most ambiguous way. Both of his parents worked (and unquestionably very hard) for a living and while lived a comfortable life it wasn't one of some extreme affluence. His parents is what we would for the most part consider upper middle class or "working rich" it's not like Bills childhood could be a backdrop to a scene in "all the money in the world" or anything similar. I've also never considered Gates to be a Satan or anything of the sort regardless of Microsoft's practices I've always have had an admiration of him as well as many other successful people.
- walshemj 9y agoIts a bit more subtle than that you need to look at the signifiers and not just $$ Bill has a generational qualifier for example and look at his family background and where he went to school.
- mjfl 9y agoI wouldn't say Bill was old money. Old money is where neither you nor your parents need to work for a living due to the success of some ancestor. Bill Gates was upper middle class, not old money, and even so is that really necessary and sufficient cause for his success? Like other posters here, I know many people more privileged than Bill Gates was and have done little to nothing with their lives, therefore coming from his parent's level of wealth is not even close to sufficient for success. There are also certain people who have made it to his level of wealth from more humble origins, notably John Rockefeller and Andrew Carnegie but more recently Jeff Bezos, who was middle class, therefore it is not necessary to come from Gate's parents level of wealth either. If something is neither necessary nor even close to sufficient for success, how can you dismiss someone's success as due to it?
- hfdgiutdryg 9y agohow can you dismiss someone's success as due to it? I don't think it's being dismissed as due to it, so much as it's acknowledging the near-necessity of it to attain success. Gates went to a high school where the parents pooled money in order to buy mainframe time for their kids. Gates was seeing a therapist, which helped him focus and mature faster. He had the support to start a fairly wild venture with a friend. Gates is incredibly intelligent, focused, disciplined, and was in the right place at the right time. If I were in his shoes, I wouldn't have succeeded. Not because I lacked the resources, but because I'd have found the idea of writing a BASIC interpreter to be boring and wouldn't have seen it through. But I also probably wouldn't have had access to the technology necessary in the first place...
- eeZah7Ux 9y agoThis has very little to do with good parenting and better education and not much to do with wealth. People coming from a powerful, influential, well connected families have countless opportunities to start business or get into politics or anything else. In many countries in the world any random 20-years-old trying to talk to IBM would be laughed at. Research has shown that parents social connections are the most significant factor shared by today's billionaires.
- dogma1138 9y ago>In many countries in the world any random 20-years-old trying to talk to IBM would be laughed at. I think that may say more about the US than it goes about proving your point. People greatly over estimate the level of power and influence the Gates had when MSFT was formed, everything I've read about them shows that both Bills parents were remarkably accomplished people. When you think about old money and the rich and powerful organizing a divestment campaign against the apartheid in SA like his mother did isn't the first thing that comes to your mind. Out of all of the examples of "Wealth begets Wealth" the Gates are probably the worst one I can think off.
- ganeshkrishnan 9y ago>Out of all of the examples of "Wealth begets Wealth" the Gates are probably the worst one I can think off. On his Reddit ama he himself said that his upbringing contributed a lot to his success. Also this doesn't say more about US but more about confidence and ' smoke and mirrors show' while starting out.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dogma1138 9y agoOf course his up bringing contributed to his success but that doesn’t mean it was the money. His parents were exceptionally successful and not just financially this can have a huge impact on the value system of the child especially if the parents are involved in education and parenting which in Bill’s case they were.
- ganeshkrishnan 9y ago> K&L Gates is in the same building as the company I work for, despite multiple mergers 2 decades past retirement the Gates name is still on the door and it's not because of Bill. You are disagreeing with him but just adding to his points. If my father had a company with his name inscribed on a building I would have had some connections for my own business. Instead pop struggled to put food on the table and barely owned a flower pot Rags to riches are fairy tales. Reality is different. Even Elon musk's father is a millionaire
- NicoJuicy 9y agoIsn't it his mother who raised him? Elon Musk also left South Africa to start in the USA, where he succeeded. I guess: genetics + parenting > rich people background Also, i think there is one generation in between poor and rich. This is as fast as it goes: 1st generation: Poor 2nd generation: wealthy (mostly through entrepeneurial or hard work) where they explore investments. Mostly started a SMB or choose a profession with a lucrative income. 3rd generation: extremely rich: good investment decisions or a 0,01% company ( worth 100 million's). Getting from 1 to 3 in one step is almost impossible. You need the stablility from the 2nd generation to get to the 3rd ( getting investment loans, contacts, ...) and the opportunity to "hit for the stars" multiple times.
- giantsloth 9y agoHis mother is a rich successful model. What poor person has the means to move to another country and start a tech company. How are you so massively illogical and incoherent in your ability to think?
- NicoJuicy 9y agoYour statement seems to reasonate with me: 2nd generation : wealthy. Wealthy =/= rich, it doesn't exclude rich people also. He could start a software business without a lot of parents money. Elon earned 22 million with Zip2 and they started it with angel investors. It's claimed that his father also provided $28,000 for starting it. ( that's peanuts) I said: You need the stablility from the 2nd generation to get to the 3rd ( getting investment loans, contacts, ...) and the opportunity to "hit for the stars" multiple times. Getting money from angel investors is summarized under: "getting investment loans". You probably didn't read what i was saying: From poor to wealthy to rich. Elon did this. I never claimed that he went from poor to rich. I think my ability to think is better than your ability to read.
- giantsloth 9y agoYou are implying that poor people are a result of poor parenting, this is beyond stupid. Poor parenting is a result of poverty. It is massively difficult to parent well when you are in financially dire situations constantly, surrounded by other people who are also in dire financial situations, and sending you kids to massively underfunded public schools.
- j45 9y agoEmphatically agree. No child picks which family they are born into, let alone the circumstances, or the cycles they will have to break in any socio-economic bracket.
- dogma1138 9y agoNo one implied any such thing and there is a difference between being poor due to lackluster parenting / childhood and not growing up to be Bill Gates. Families that nurture the value of good education (as in knowledge not a piece of paper) and hard work would quite likely have more successful children this is especially true when you can afford to lead by example rather than just yell do your homework.
- hyperpallium 9y ago"Less fortunate" has always read as a straight euphemism to me for "poor" - you've elicited its true, literal meaning for me for the first time. It shows how grossly unfair the "fortune" of the wealth of parents' is... and it's becoming less and less fair over time. More than ever, I think it's essential, that as much as possible we move towards ensuring everyone starts with the basics. Health, education... We can't control parenting, but we can create conditions for it. It's not just fair for the individual, but fulfilling the potential of all makes for a better nation. This would not affect the people already at the top within a nation... except through the contest between nations. Those that do not nuture their human resources will be replaced by those that do. This is how the USA rose to dominance... and this is how it falls.
- dogma1138 9y agoIt's not even a question that money helps but the question is how much and how. It's also a question of what type of success were talking about as there are plenty of people from both less successful and more successful (pre MSFT) family lines that followed in their fathers/mothers footsteps rather than making it on their own. If you are fortunate enough to live in a good/upper middle class home which values hard work and education and bestows it on you I'm not sure how much additional wealth and or power would be a factor if you are breaking on your own. Both Bill's parents were very successful and hard working individuals with remarkable achievements I would even go out and say that his mother likely was more accomplished than his father considering the time and circumstances. So at least in this case I wholly stand behind my assertion that how his parents lived had much more impact on Bill than their bank account. P.S. I'm pretty sure that both Gates agree with you here is Sr. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w_JjmBhsk64 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w_JjmBhsk64 (short) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IcE0L4tG3o4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IcE0L4tG3o4 (long). And this isn't new he's been advocating for higher taxation, more accessible education health care etc. for as long I can find speeches or opinion/editorial pieces by him.