6 ms·
The housing shortage is a completely self-inflicted wound. Like Prop 13, it benefits current owners at the expense of their children and other newcomers. And e
by epistasis 9y ago
The housing shortage is a completely self-inflicted wound. Like Prop 13, it benefits current owners at the expense of their children and other newcomers.
And even when housing can be built, it is overly expensive due to insanely conservative zoning requirements. A great explanation of just how awful it is in LA is here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/LosAngeles/comments/6lvwh4/im_an_architect_in_la_specializing_in_multifamily/ https://www.reddit.com/r/LosAngeles/comments/6lvwh4/im_an_ar...
And SF and the Bay Area have been even worse than LA at building housing.
Crazy conservative (in the sense of "no change allowed") people dominate all the planning meetings, which control what can and can not be built. Meeting code and zoning is not enough, you have to convince the extreme ends of your opponents to get anything built.
- siculars 9y agoThese boards should all take a field trip to places like NYC and Tokyo where the buildings are tall and the density is high. I have no sympathy for these self inflicted wounds.
- tux1968 9y agoWell, they're not seen as wounds by the people who are causing the problem, they're seen as victories.
- timr 9y ago"These boards should all take a field trip to places like NYC and Tokyo where the buildings are tall and the density is high." I lived in Japan, and I live in New York. Tokyo is mostly low-rise buildings. Outside of a few areas in the center of Tokyo, the city is a sprawling mass of 1-5 story buildings. The vast majority of New York (outside of Manhattan) is the same. Even in Manhattan, most of the residential neighborhoods are under ten stories. Silicon valley can clearly stand to increase density, but it doesn't help to misrepresent what density looks like.
- pkaye 9y agoA lot of the new housing I've seen in SV has been 3 story condos, townhouses and apartments. Is what is being proposed higher density than this or just more of it?
- timr 9y agoI can't possibly generalize across all of the bay area, let alone the entire state of California. I can speak with confidence about SF: the eastern third of the city (the part everyone always wants to "build up") is already pretty dense, by any standard. Building skyscrapers is not making housing cheaper, just taller. Meanwhile, the western two-thirds (the parts nobody ever talks about) are like McMansion suburbia. The general problem with this debate on HN is that everyone gets fixated on a select few areas where 20-something nerdbros want to live and go drinking (e.g. the Mission), and imagines turning it into some vision of Tokyo out of Blade Runner, when the real solution is that we should be building more 3 story condos in Sunnyvale. If you wanted to make the bay area resemble Tokyo as it actually exists, you'd cover every flat part of the bay in 1-5 story buildings, and connect it all by excellent transit. It has little to do with skyscrapers, as such.
- epistasis 9y agoI'm not sure where you're seeing that type of discussion on HN. But this bill was precisely the thing that would have opened up the Avenues in SF without touching the eastern side very much. And totally agreed on 4/5 stories everywhere; those are what can be built with less expensive wood construction, and what really increase density. High rises and sky scrapers are usually brought up by the NIMBYs as a straw man to argue against.
- timr 9y ago"I'm not sure where you're seeing that type of discussion on HN." Everywhere. The comment I originally replied to (upthread) has a delusional vision of New York and Tokyo, and "the problem" is (ostensibly) that the bay doesn't look like that. Any facts that are inconvenient to this narrative will be downvoted into invisibility. "But this bill was precisely the thing that would have opened up the Avenues in SF without touching the eastern side very much." While I sympathize with the stated goals, this bill was little more than grandstanding by Weiner. It never had a prayer of becoming law. You probably couldn't pass a rule like this in San Francisco itself, let alone the entire state.
- oppositelock 9y agoI'm a home owner and YIMBY here who shows up at city council meetings in support of more housing. You would be shocked just how horribly selfish existing home owners are. Very common statements are that "I bought here because I liked the town and I don't want it to change", or "I have my house already, I don't want more people here", etc. It's awful. We're slowly losing everyone in Mountain View except dual tech income people who won the stock option lottery, houses are out of reach for most everyone. What does get built via ABAG (Association of Bay Area Governments) mandates is generally rental housing, and rents are astronomical. This kind of short sightedness is disgusting, and people don't seem to realize that nice, high density areas didn't just spring up in their dense form, they were allowed to evolve over time. CA also has a lot of red tape anyone can invoke on any construction project to drown it in bureaucracy for years. The only people willing to fight against the bureaucracy are giant developers who develop large lots into cookie cutter developments. It's a giant mess driven by greed and stupidity.
- majormajor 9y agoSo on one hand you have people happy with the neighborhood they live in and not wanting change; on the other hand you have people not happy and wanting change. Why is one group more "horribly selfish" than the other? Especially if you think there's a bubble, you don't want to change the character of the place for a short-term problem. Why is "build more in one place" a more natural answer than "let tech companies geographically diversify themselves in response to pricing pressure"? Especially given an area that's kind of a natural disaster SPOF.
- epistasis 9y agoBecause the same people that complain about new people were once new people. Also, they do not get the right to decide where people live. That's fundamentally entitled, selfish, and greedy attitude. And since they don't get to control where people move in the United States, they don't actually get to stop change. Change still happens whether they want it or not. Nobody has the right to stop others from interacting, or renting, or anything like that.
- zkms 9y agoThe sole purpose of those boards existing is to inflict those very wounds, which are not "self-inflicted" because the people who compose those boards are homeowners and the people hurt by the wounds tend not to be. Homeowners benefit from the ability to obstruct/delay/deny others from building more housing, because it makes them a frighteningly huge amount of money by making their property worth more. Morally yes, these people ought to be told to go pound sand; the very fact that there's legal authority to prevent dense/tall housing from being built is abhorrent, but it's the function of those boards (and everything else is secondary) -- to "increase property value" by artificially restricting what other people can do with their own property.
- st26 9y agoIs it abhorrent that the owners in a neighborhood can choose to come together as a collective and influence the neighborhood they all live in? If yes, is it also abhorrent when a group of workers at a company band together to influence the working conditions they all work under?
- epistasis 9y agoThis is shifting the question from an interesting one to an uninteresting one. Collective influence is not abhorrent, but the direction that they influence things certainly can be. When segregated neighborhoods collectively influenced which races could buy houses, was that abhorrent? I think we would all agree. When neighborhoods for neighborhoods watch groups, or clean up a playground, or build community by throwing block parties, they are doing great, not abhorrent things. Conspiring to keep others out is usually abhorrent though.
- rofrol 9y agoIt was a good question. Workers want good working conditions, home owners good living conditions.
- zkms 9y ago> Is it abhorrent that the owners in a neighborhood can choose to come together as a collective and influence the neighborhood they all live in? Nothing wrong with it! If some people in a neighbourhood want to buy up a parcel of land to prevent housing from being built there, there's nothing wrong with that. The issue sorta crops up when you start dictating what (structurally-sound) buildings others get to build on their own land. If you want to reject private property altogether and go to some centrally-planned economic system then you've got a lot of work to do because even the fucking USSR was better at building housing than US cities are today.
- jayd16 9y agoAs an LA local, I'm not sure I share your sentiment against high quality building codes.
- epistasis 9y agoI think you misunderstand, I'm not against high quality buildings, nor high quality building codes. I'm against the terribly restrictive parking requirements, but those are not high quality.
- sumobob 9y agoWouldn't you rather just set some base standards for construction and let people choose where to live? Greenspace rules, parking spot regulations all seem to stifle growth. I would gladly pay for an extra spot, and I'm sure developers would build more monthly garages a la NYC.
- epistasis 9y agoExactly, these overly restrictive codes and zoning are just a few people inflicting their exact life style on others. It's super hard to convince all those single family home owners at meeting that I actually like density, and choose to live in the densest part of my city because I like it. I'm not alone, there are a lot of us! But others prevent us from living in our preferred way for no good reason.
- __david__ 9y agoI understand you like dense housing, but not having a car in LA severely limits where you can work. The nice places to work are not clustered in downtown (which is all you could realistically do if you had not car). The greater LA area is very car centric, and I'd find it hard to believe you'd find it convenient to live in LA proper and commute to, say, Anaheim (or even Brea) without access to a car. Not building parking spaces in LA would be denying the realities of living there.
- sumobob 9y agothanks for sharing that link, I had read it a long time ago and was recently looking for it.
- test6554 9y agoI trust that all the leaders are also homeowners.
- jcoffland 9y agoProp 13 limits increases in property taxes. It's removal would do little to ameliorate the housing shortage. Sure it might push some old people out of their homes and there by free up a few houses but it will increase the cost of ownership and therefore the cost of housing. This would benefit only very rich new comers. Why would we want that?
- st26 9y agoIt might not fix the shortage, but could be expected to increase mobility, such that people can move to a different part of the bay when they change jobs, or downsize or upsize when life changes. That's at least a step towards addressing a shortage.
- jcoffland 9y agoThat's a pretty weak argument against Prop 13.
- st26 9y agoI'm not making the argument to repeal prop 13. It's been made many times, better than I could ever make it. Only a google away.
- himom 9y agoProp 13 isn’t good or bad, it’s ugly. It was supposed to protect poor and elderly people from losing their homes. The problem is, only a certain generation got it. It’s led to significant stagnation of housing for middle-class retirees. Prop 13 needs to be extended to all persons perpetually under a certain income or over a certain age for their primary residence. The other issue is new housing construction supply, which while providing new living spaces, reduces demand also impacts open space. Maybe folks don’t remember the valley when there were fewer buildings. Heck, I remember a corn and pumpkin field across from the middle school I went to in south San Jose that’s now yet another soul-less strip-mall. The Valley needs to balance concerns of open space/urban sprawl, building height/ ascetics, traffic/transport, property values, non-tech workers unable to save for retirement and homelessness.
- malloryerik 9y agoWhat would happen if California enacted a pretty serious land value tax? For example, what if California replaced its income tax (and also its 1% property tax) with a land value tax? Land value tax means a tax on the market value of the land, but not on the value of the buildings, only the land is taxed. So imagine two neighboring plots of land in an expensive urban area. The plots are identical except that one has a single family home with a lovely vegetable garden, and the next plot has a ten-story apartment building. Both plots would be taxed the same amount, because the tax is not on the buildings, it is only on the land. With a tax like this, the owners of the single family home would have an increased incentive to develop their land, or sell it and move to an area more suited to single family homes. Another apartment building could then go up, helping to alleviate the housing shortage. What's more, replacing the income tax would incentivize the creation of more jobs.
- epistasis 9y agoLVT is a really popular idea with most YIMBYs. If you were to be heard uttering such policy ideas on NextDoor, you'd probably be added to a list so that they can do background on you to dig up at future meetings, or attempt to discredit you. In any case you'll probably be called a shill for greedy developers. Happened to me! California local tax policy is extremely regressive. High sales tax as a replacement for extremely low property taxes adds greatly to wealth inequality.
- namlem 9y agoProperty tax isn't exactly great for fixing inequality either. Poor municipalities can't raise enough from property tax to fund infrastructure or schools.
- epistasis 9y agoThe problem with schools there is tying funding to a tiny geographic area, rather than over wider ones. That's the de facto state of the Bay Area where there are tons of tiny and disconnected municipalities. Whether those municipalities raise money via sales tax (hugely regressive) or property tax (less regressive), that structural problem will remain for schools.
- colordrops 9y agoThe elephant in the room that everyone is ignoring is that we could add infrastructure to make denser areas nice to live in, such as the amazing public transportation system in Japan, but trillions of dollars are being wasted on military excursions, paid for through taxes and inflation that should have gone to public infrastructure.
- masonic 9y agoCrazy conservative Essentially every level of government (including planning commissions) in every Bay Area and L.A. basin city in control of these things is under one-party rule... and it's not a remotely conservative party.
- astrange 9y agoDo you think city planning commissions are partisan? I'm pretty sure they follow the will of their constituents who show up to meetings - and if you've ever been to one, those people are rich, white-haired, and big fans of the status quo.
- epistasis 9y agoParty politics have almost nothing to do with politics at this local level. And there's nothing stopping people from having very conservative views about local matters but progressive views for others on the larger stage. That is quite frequent in California: progressive views are held until it affects personal advancement. And the same is quite true for conservatives in other parts of the country, values are held until they get in the way of personal advancement. (E.g. abortion bans are just for other people, but I'm a good person and in a hard situation so it's ok if I get one, but I'll be out protesting next week.)