3 ms·
> 3. The end-product of science is not truth, it is explanations of observations. Those observations can (indeed must) include non-reproducible ones. Sometimes
by lordnacho 9y ago
> 3. The end-product of science is not truth, it is explanations of observations. Those observations can (indeed must) include non-reproducible ones. Sometimes the explanation of non-reproducible results is "experimental error" or "delusion" or "we just don't know." But non-reproducible events are nonetheless within the purview of science.
Yes and no. I think you have to have predictions in there somewhere. That's why your celestial mechanics is science: whatever the movement is, you were able to say what it was going to be beforehand, even if it only happened once.
As for explanation, that is not necessarily so simple, either. Sure, a lot of things seem to make more sense with a theory, but not every theory makes sense. A lot of stuff in fundamental physics is predicted by the equations, but in what sense are the equations explanations? "Shut up and calculate" comes to mind.
- pas 9y agoShut up and calculate means that "sure, that's a nice toy model, but show that it reproduces the standard model", and also "sure, nobody really understands why the model is that way, but it works, so shut up and use it". And also, shut up and come up with something falsifiable (in our lifetime).