4 ms·
I feel like this has the same promise as self driving cars - raise the floor for the quality of service while also experiencing random unexplained failures that
by TaylorAlexander 9y ago
I feel like this has the same promise as self driving cars - raise the floor for the quality of service while also experiencing random unexplained failures that its human supervisors fail to notice in time.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dboreham 9y agoBased on my experience watching doctors (good ones) trying to diagnose "weird things", they are just manually executing an expert system algorithm anyway. They aren't doing what an engineer might expect -- working from a basic understanding of how the body works and looking for plausible explanations. They're instead simply pattern matching against a database of facts.
- nradov 9y agoA lot of diagnostic skill in complex cases is based on clinical intuition developed over many years of practice. That's qualitatively different from an expert system executing defined rules against facts.
- dboreham 9y agoYou'd think, but honestly in my experience it wasn't like that. An expert system would have done as well, or better. Possibly my experiences were colored by the cross-specialization nature of the issue -- specialists seem reluctant to engage any thinking outside of their area, I found. Like a software engineer would never consider that the problem they're investigating is caused by memory bits flipping randomly.