3 ms·
The largest reason for the high construction costs is probably union featherbedding and contractual mismanagement [0]. There's no indication that The Boring Co
by jcranmer 9y ago
The largest reason for the high construction costs is probably union featherbedding and contractual mismanagement [0].
There's no indication that The Boring Company is capable of meaningful cost reduction in this regard. The actual cost of physical material in constructing tunnels is a relatively small cost of the project (note that most of the cost in a subway isn't the subway tunnels themselves, it's the subway stations). The only meaningful idea I've seen about cutting costs from The Boring Company is recovering TBMs, which strongly suggests there's no sense of why tunnels themselves cost money [1].
If Musk just talked about being able to build tunnels cheaper, even transit enthusiasts would have a hard time bringing themselves to care. But between Hyperloop and his underground road conveyance thingy, it's quite clear that he has no idea how to build any high-capacity transit [2]. It seems as if he cares far more about "how do I get me from A to B most effectively" rather than "how do I get a million people from A to B most effectively," and moreover, that he doesn't even realize that those are different questions that necessitate different answers.
[0] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-construction-costs.html?hp&action=click&pgtype=Homepage&clickSource=story-heading&module=photo-spot-region®ion=top-news&WT.nav=top-news https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-...
[1] TBMs are largely unrecovered because it costs too much to recover them. You can't back them up without risking geological stability of the above ground, and digging a cut-and-cover shaft to reach them is quite expensive.
[2] On fixed-guideway systems, the capacity is largely dictated by station dwell time and switch fouling time, which governs the minimum headway between adjacent consists. Consequently, you need high capacity through consist to get any meaningful capacity. But the Hyperloop pods and the road sleds both envision ultra-low consist capacity, consequently killing total throughput. Incidentally, higher speeds also reduce capacity.
- SteveGregory 9y agoI disagree. I think the Boring Company FAQ addresses both labor and station costs fairly directly. Labor: they want to increase automation so there are fewer workers needed, and tunnel faster so they can pay for fewer hours of work. Stations: they do not want to make expensive subterranean stations, and instead just want small stations at the surface. People have questioned the throughput, but I think throughput appears reasonable if 1 car can leave every 0.5 minutes vs a normal station in which 10 cars leave every 5 minutes
- windlep 9y ago> Labor: they want to increase automation so there are fewer workers needed, and tunnel faster so they can pay for fewer hours of work. Musk has not had a great track record of reducing costs by increasing automation. See: https://www.theverge.com/2018/4/13/17234296/tesla-model-3-robots-production-hell-elon-musk https://www.theverge.com/2018/4/13/17234296/tesla-model-3-ro...
- jcranmer 9y ago> Stations: they do not want to make expensive subterranean stations, and instead just want small stations at the surface. This is essentially saying "let's save money by cutting costs on the cheap part of the project and increase the most expensive part of the project several fold." The cost of a bored tunnel is largely dictated by its length (essentially, length determines how much infrastructure you need--cabling, shielding, drainage, etc.; cross-section determines the scale of this infrastructure) [1]. A car elevator access shaft is going to be a very time-consuming vertical cut via excavators, where depth is going to be the driving dimension in cost. Of course, throughput comes back to bite you: how long does it take cars to make it up and down the elevator shaft? A vehicle elevator might make 1 foot per second, or somewhere in the region of a 4 minute round trip per vehicle if the tunnel is 100 ft deep [2]. A regular highway lane has a capacity of ~2000 cars per hour, so you need 266 elevators to fill and empty it [3]. Of course, the capacity of rapid transit is ~20,000 people per hour in the same tunnel space, so you really need over a thousand elevators. When you take into account acceleration/deceleration lanes for well over a thousand elevators, is that really cheaper digging than a dozen cavernous stations? [1] Cutting the diameter of a tunnel in half does not cut its construction costs by 75%, more like 25-50%. Construction costs are closer to linear in diameter than linear in cross-sectional area. [2] The other really, really big omission in the FAQ is the lack of discussion of the consequence of depth. Vertical circulation is already a tricky issue with what we construct today, and the space-hungry nature of SOV-centric design compounds the problem tremendously. 100 ft is sort of the highest level I'm assuming is in play here, since that's about as high as you can go without running into the sewers and extant mass transit lines. Going deeper of course makes the vertical circulation numbers even worse. [3] This assumes that you only build one elevator to service both directions.
- nradov 9y agoTBMs are frequently recovered and extracted now. http://metrotunnel.vic.gov.au/construction/building-the-tunnels-and-stations/tunnel-boring-machines http://metrotunnel.vic.gov.au/construction/building-the-tunn...
- unethical_ban 9y agoCould you get a glossary or thesaurus for your notes?
- jcranmer 9y agofeatherbedding: jobs without responsibility, so they're basically solely to give someone a paycheck TBM: Tunnel Boring Machine, the main piece of equipment in building deep tunnels cut-and-cover: a way of building tunnels that consists of building a trench and then putting a roof over it fixed-guideway: basically, anything that's a railroad or has similar constraints (such as a monorail) switch fouling: fouling a switch means to have a train over it so that you can't change which direction it goes to headway: time between successive consists. 5min headway means one train arrives every 5 minutes consist: a set of cars that all move together as a fixed unit I think that's all the terms that people might not immediately understand.
- sah2ed 9y agoTIL featherbedding ~= sinecure