2 ms·
Well, everyone can point to their favorite problems in society. If you choose political polarization, loneliness, atomization and despair, this mix can suggest
by joe_the_user 9y ago
Well, everyone can point to their favorite problems in society. If you choose political polarization, loneliness, atomization and despair, this mix can suggest a society "coming apart" and might suggest social media could be a big of this by polarizing dialog, idea bubbles and "lack of real connections".
The thing is this picture kind of comes apart if you notice a lot of the polarizing dialogue comes from mainstream with dynamic that's been accelerating for many years, that atomization similarly increased significantly as described by Robert Putnam in Bowling alone and blaming things like the opioid epidemic on social networking is fairly absurd (factors like the loss of high paid industrial jobs and destruction of community are clearly more to blame than Facebook, however you might apportion the overall blame).
Moreover, the growing wealth disparity in this country is the elephant the behind a lot of these factors.
I'd note that the current wave of anti-Facebook rants seem to have appeared after the Cambridge Analytica "scandal", which allowed a parade of haters to appear with a variety of complaint; Facebook helped Trump win, Facebook sharing annoys because I don't want to engage with people's political rants.
https://thebaffler.com/latest/cambridge-analytica-con-levine https://thebaffler.com/latest/cambridge-analytica-con-levine
- ghostcluster 9y agoHow would elimination of advertising fix online communication platforms. It isn't the ads that is causing the groupthink and polarization, but the abundance of choice in things to follow and voices to listen to. Do you suggest restricting the speech of people online? The polarization and groupthink is even present on online platforms that have no ads whatsoever, like Wikipedia and, to an extent, Hacker News.
- michaelt 9y agoThe theory is: Funded by advertising -> commercially incentivised to get as many users as possible and keep them on the site as long as possible -> optimise structure/design/layout/activity feed/suggested content/notifications to do that -> online communication problems. For example, Facebook controls the algorithm that decides which posts appear in your news feed, the order of them, the real name policy, which other users see your posts, and when you receive notifications; Reddit controls which content appears on the front page, the ease of sign-up, and the default subs; Youtube controls which video auto-plays next, and the content and ordering of videos on the homepage, and so on. All of them also have hired moderators, reporting mechanisms, automatic spam filtering; and policies on things like bots, how bans work, what sort of content is allowed/banned, pornography, hate speech, copyright infringement, and so on. So for example, in the pursuit of growth and engagement, companies might turn a blind eye to thousands of bots propping up their user numbers; or promote content that made people angry or mislead them; if doing so produced the best engagement metrics. There's also the problem of funded by advertising -> incentivised to improve ad targeting -> incentivised to push the boundaries on user privacy. I think we're only beginning to see the consequences of this.
- psyc 9y agoI agree with you. My intuition says the culture war is a proxy for a class war, somehow, although I readily admit I can't yet formulate this rationally in much detail. I'm in my forties, and from my point of view, gender and race relations had been on a clear uptrend up until about 5 years ago. The continuous gender and race baiting on social media appears to be almost entirely driven by a certain stripe of feminist, who are able to project all their struggling in life onto white men, who are approximately as economically disadvantaged as they are in the big picture. Young people are hallucinating 'nazis' and 'fascists' everywhere, meanwhile real neo-nazis and fascists almost never make any appearance in these mudslinging debacles. It all seems tragic to me. People opting for small tribal solidarity over broad class solidarity.