7 ms·
Myths about prostitution
- stretchwithme 16y agopeople trade all kinds of things for all kinds of things. We need to leave people be. should prostitution be regulated at all? I think that should be left at the local level. And I mean very local. It should be possibile for neighborhoods to ban it when most people don't want it and keep it legal where people are ok with it, right in the same city. I believe many people try to control things like prostitution, drugs and gambling because they do not wish to be around it or have it devaluing their property, not because they wish to control what everyone else is doing. We need to find ways to let them do this and still preserve the freedom of others.
- pavel_lishin 16y agoI'm all for requiring sex workers to test themselves for STDs, and requiring them to disclose any that they do have. Kind of hard to dismiss that with "caveat emptor" - I know there are instant HIV tests, but what about everything else?
- stretchwithme 16y agoAnd I support the right of you and your neighbors to do exactly that in your neighborhood.
- flatline 16y agoWait - you're saying that a district could legalize prositution and claim to screen for STDs without centralized regulation and oversight? Caveat emptor indeed...
- mseebach 16y agoWait - you're saying that a man should be able to pick up a random street-walker and be right to expect that congress has made sure she's properly tested for STDs? /sarcasm Such schemes would likely come as "labels" that the district or individual sex workers buy into, provided that they comply with the regulations set up by the label. Some labels might gain a reputation for being stricter and cleaner then others, other might be cheaper and "good enough".
- stretchwithme 16y agowrong. The United Nations is even more centralized, so it will do a better job. At least until the United Federation of Planets is formed. :-) jk. You're right about labels or brands. It works for every other product.
- Psyonic 16y agoTrue, but its not that simple. Don't forget about knock-offs. It may be hard to fake an iPhone, but its not too hard to fake clothing, and I can't imagine it will be too hard for a prostitute to fake a "clean" badge to increase her hourly rate, if its worth her while.
- stretchwithme 16y agoI think people know that and wouldn't rely solely on a prostitute's word, especially when there are other legal certification services. Would you buy a electrical appliance that was not certified by Underwriter's Laboratories? Or buy a car that had no crash test rating from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety? Would you take the word of a car company that "oh, we don't need that stuff. we done tested it ourself." It seems humans do know how to solve safety problems without coercion, at least when allowed to. There is no reason to believe prostitution is any different.
- rjurney 16y agoSee: Public health. The federal government, and even 'world government' have been wildly successful in this area. As a result, the quality of human life has dramatically improved.
- stretchwithme 16y agono, I said its up to each district what they do. If they wish to avail themselves of some certifying authority they can certainly do that. And yes its buyer beware. As it always is when you decide to have sex. When things people want are illegal, they are LESS safe. There is no visibility, no legal liability, very little incentive to build and protect a brand name. Alcohol was a lot less safe during prohibition. And the crime was very dangerous as well. Legalization is much safer and its rare that people die from the manufacturing and distribution of alcohol today.
- philwelch 16y agoAlcohol is strictly regulated by all levels of government.
- stretchwithme 16y agocentralized decision making is less effective anyway. Human intelligence is distributed for a reason. No central authority has even half the facts you do about your own situation and a tiny fraction of the self interest at stake that you do.
- knowtheory 16y agoIt's worth noting that this op-ed is by Sudhir Venkatesh, who is also mentioned prominently in a chapter of Freakonomics. So, given his background he probably actually does know what he's talking about!
- jseliger 16y agoYeah -- his book Off the Books: The Underground Economy of the Urban Poor is pretty good: http://www.amazon.com/Off-Books-Underground-Economy-Urban/dp/0674030710?ie=UTF8&tag=thstsst-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957 http://www.amazon.com/Off-Books-Underground-Economy-Urban/dp... . He's a very interesting guy, and I'm not surprised that he's decided to look at prostitution more carefully because it's pretty hard to argue that high-end prostitutes are being exploited or whatever. When I say high-end, think Belle de Jour: http://belledejour-uk.blogspot.com/ http://belledejour-uk.blogspot.com/ , who is compulsively readable and hilarious.
- brc 16y agoThe most interesting part of the Freakonomics chapter is that modern day prostitues suffer from the worst kind of competitor - one that gives away the product for free. The chapter points out that, 100 years ago, something like 20% of men lost their virginity to a prostitute, whereas now it is something like 2%, because most men are likely to find a woman who is willing to have sex with them without any sort of long term commitment.
- bediger 16y agoAnd none of these myths were about the economic side of that business, which is what I half-expected from that author.
- jakarta 16y agoBut the author is a sociologist.
- Mz 16y agoWhen I decided to get divorced, I had a number of women tell me I could not do that, I was too sick and I needed his money. I felt that said more about their lives than mine, but it also anecdotally agreed with a remark I read once that "there is more prostitution in marriage than outside of it". Unless/until society finds a way for men and women to have financial parity of some sort, quite a lot of women will continue to trade sex for money on some level, whether it fits the legal definition of prostitution or not. To me, the attention prostitution gets really just misses the mark.
- wheaties 16y agoEven if there were as many women as men who were homeless or broke and conversely fantastically wealthy you're still going to have women trading sex for money. If there's a demand for something, someone, somewhere will figure out a way to monetize it.
- Mz 16y agoUm, I don't quite understand. Is that supposed to be a rebuttal? I don't really care if people trade sex for money. I think if a woman freely chooses that route, so what? If a woman makes a conscious decision that she would rather take cash in hand from many men instead of a roof over her head and food on the table from one man, so what? As I said, I think that focus really misses the mark.
- danparsonson 16y agoI read wheaties' reply as being a response to your comment that > Unless/until society finds a way for men and women to have financial parity of some sort, quite a lot of women will continue to trade sex for money on some level which seems to suggest that a lack of financial parity is the driving force behind women choosing to trade sex for money. The response was that, even if financial parity were achieved (i.e, if there were as many homeless, and also hugely rich women as there are men), women would still trade sex for money. See http://denisdutton.com/baumeister.htm http://denisdutton.com/baumeister.htm which was linked on here recently for another viewpoint on the debate over financial disparity between the sexes, which you may find interesting.
- sahillavingia 16y agoAs an anecdote prostitution is legal in Singapore - a country recognized as being very strict - and it works well. People trade things for other things. Guys pay for dinner. That's not considered immoral. In general, prostitution will happen anyways, so no matter what you believe you might as well make it regulated and as safe as possible - and taxed!
- sudonim 16y agoInteresting wikipedia article http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_Singapore http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_Singapore Singapore gets a bad rap for being extremely strict. I grew up there and was aware of prostitution but never realized it was legal.
- sahillavingia 16y agoIt definitely does, but I absolutely love it. A lot of people complain about ridiculous fines for things like littering, but really the fines are never going to effect you (you don't litter, right?! - at least in Singapore where trash cans are every five feet), so the higher the fine the less violations = awesome, safe, clean streets.
- hugh3 16y agoOne myth I've heard a bunch of times from anti-prostitution campaigners is that something like two thirds of prostitutes enter the industry before the age of 14, or something equally ludicrous-sounding. I don't know where that number comes from, but it surely can't be right.
- matwood 16y agoThe problem with illegal prostitution and drugs for that matter is that since they are illegal a lot of other illegal activities come along with it. In the case of prostitution you have kidnapping, violence, and forcing people into underage sex (and from what I've read most prostitutes start very very early by being forced into it). If the girl is already doing something illegal and gets beat by her pimp what is she going to do? Pimps prey on this thought that there is nothing she can do. Drugs are similar in that by making them illegal you bring in gangs, guns, and even move violence. If someones pot dealer screws them over what is their only recourse? Violence. You also have the violence of territory to sell on, etc... IMHO, the illegality of things like drugs and prostitution actually causes the social effects to be worse then if they were legal.
- GFischer 16y agoI agree that social effects are probably worse, but making prostitution legal doesn't solve all of them - after all, underage prostitution will always be illegal (I hope) and probably rightly so, and that's one way into all those illegal activities. Here in Uruguay, prostitution is legal, yet we do have problems with minors being pressed into prostitution, and also the sex export trade, where women are more or less kidnapped and sent to Europe (Italy and Spain mostly)
- jhamburger 16y agoI doubt that it's true in America but the vast majority of prostitutes live elsewhere. For a poor person living in the 3rd world, you're probably not going to secondary school so you end up starting your "career" a little earlier. Also, consider differing ages of consent.
- beilabs 16y agoProstitution is 100% legal here in Australia so long as a number of rules are followed. No soliciting near churches / residential areas. It's safe, the workers are protected by law, they declare and pay their taxes. The brothels pay their taxes, local services are improved as a result. It's a no-brainer, those who want the service can get it in a safe manner, those who do not still benefit from the taxes that are paid.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]