4 ms·
> China is the pro-trade side. They'll be willing to make concessions, do the work, etc. It's the beijing consensus now, not washington. China isn't pro trade
by adventured 9y ago
> China is the pro-trade side. They'll be willing to make concessions, do the work, etc. It's the beijing consensus now, not washington.
China isn't pro trade per se. They're pro export, in the old mercantilist sense. They've spent the last 30 years heavily restricting trade access into and within China by foreign entities.
They'll amass around a $900 billion to $1 trillion trade surplus with the EU over the five years 2015-2019. For the US of course it's even worse, closer to a likely $1.7 trillion over that time.
Here's how the China trade illusion works (and the West keeps falling for it for some reason):
Have vast, rigid restrictions on market access that few to none of your big trading partner nations have. Use an endless variety of means - some subtle, some beligerent - to thwart foreign entry and competition with domestic businesses (whether state owned or entirely private).
When caught behaving badly or not living up to promised standards (eg for the last two decades re the World Trade Organization), promise to improve, drag your feet, buy more time, make subtle improvements, tout those improvements while moving backwards on other things. All the while your actual goal is to get big enough to not have to ever play nice.
While you do all of that, pretend you're in favor of free trade. Tout that you are, yell it from the roof tops. It doesn't matter if you actually are, it doesn't matter what the actual condition of trade access is on the ground, what matters is that you act as the face of free trade through the process of touting it. It's all about buying more time by sowing confusion over what the real picture is and what's actually occurring (are they liberalizing, are they not, are they going to?).
Then one day in the near future you wake up and have a $30 trillion economy with little to no need of the imports from the EU or US. You also no longer need their capital at all. The foreign traders and investors can see themselves out if they disagree.
> Imagine a Chinese company operating in the states, with an a fully imported senior management and all "c-level" discussions in chinese. I dunno.
All foreign corporations are free to do exactly that in the US market. The sole practical consideration is being able to speak English to interact with the wider economy. If Toyota or Nintendo want to run their US subsidiaries with imported talent, they can do so. There are probably no large economies that have been more welcoming to foreign companies and imports than the US over the last 30 or 40 years. We let Toyota come in and kick Detroit's ass, and that was at a time when Detroit still had immense political power. Picture China allowing Google to do the same to Baidu right now.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>the West keeps falling for it for some reason The west acted as if mercantilism basically couldn't work. Ricardian theory of comparative advantage was elevated to near-religion status in the 90s and early 00s. China not opening up fully was seen as an aberration that would ultimately only harm China rather than a potential long term threat. That was the prevailing attitude among policymaking circles (you can see this attitude reflected by checking old issues of The Economist). Ultimately the fact that lots of profit could be made out of managed Chinese trade kept western countries from reacting in a sensible, self-interested manner.
- wwweston 9y agoI got some lessons in that religion in the early 00s, and think it's still gospel in a lot of circles (I certainly know a few vigorous proponents). Is there a school of thought that's superseded the Ricardian theory?
- barrkel 9y agoMercantilism still doesn't work, but like most bad things in capitalism, the corrections can take so long they may not be worth the pain they cause. The idea is that we take advantage of China's willingness to make stuff for us (west) cheaply while they grow their exports, then when they try to raise prices, we switch away. The risk is the switching costs are expensive.
- pm90 9y ago>Here's how the China trade illusion works (and the West keeps falling for it for some reason): Plainly, its because most Western Governments (especially in the US) are heavily influenced by business interests via lobbies, PAC's etc. And Businesses simply want to use cheap labor in China to improve their bottom lines, even if that means the labor force in the US suffers as a result. They do not give a shit if China reneges on its WTO promises or destroys other Western companies. Sometimes the kind of skilled labor force or logistical supply chain is simply not present in the US, or is too expensive to implement in the US.