8 ms·
This is not how a lot of EU countries function - which is why there's friction there. The American "You are a criminal for life and will eternally be punished!"
by izacus 9y ago
This is not how a lot of EU countries function - which is why there's friction there. The American "You are a criminal for life and will eternally be punished!" attitude is clashing with an EU mindset of being able to start a new life. Permanent records are hugely damaging for persons livelihood in these cases.
- 282883392 9y agoCan you not change your name in the EU? Seems like someone changing their name would be able to solve some of these issues.
- izacus 9y agoWhy should you be forced to do that? I mean, you're assuming two things: - That people who want their data removed are criminals. That's hugely not the case. Does a teenager who was plastered all over social media / newspapers have to change his/her name because someone targeted abuse at him/her? - Even if they were jailed for a transgression, they paid their part to the socienty. For serious transgressions, the authorities keeps tabs on them. For non-serious things, why does it matter? They paid their part.
- halflings 9y agoGP is not assuming anything. Literally the first paragraph in the post: > The man, who has not been named due to reporting restrictions surrounding the case, wanted search results about a past crime he had committed removed from the search engine. Any example of somebody being abused/targeted and Google refusing to remove them from search results? The only cases where they fought back were people trying to hide their criminal record (most often politicians, white collar crime).
- dx034 9y agoIn some countries that's very hard to do. But why should you? If you committed a crime and spent your time in jail, why shouldn't you get a second chance? There are certain jobs that you cannot take depending on the crime you committed (esp working with children) but for most jobs it should be absolutely irrelevant if you committed a crime in the past.
- pjc50 9y agoThis depends on the country. UK? No problem. France? Extremely difficult: https://www.wikiprocedure.com/index.php/France_-_Change_Your_Name_(Deed_Poll) https://www.wikiprocedure.com/index.php/France_-_Change_Your... You need to convince a judge that you have a "good reason". France has only recently loosened its restrictions on what names people are allowed to have.
- ben_w 9y agoVaries by country. Germany normally forbids changes except by marriage/divorce (I think), while the UK doesn’t really have legal names, just lots of databases run by people who want an official-looking document before they update anything (and even then my university will just refuse to reprint degree certificates with a new name).
- TomMarius 9y agoI (an EU citizen) want to keep my right to think whatever I want about a criminal - and that includes looking at or keeping records. I feel like this 'right to be forgotten' hurts my safety - I don't want to forget that someone murdered someone or raped someone, these things are unforgettable and definitely unforgivable - and I want to know about them, and I want employers to be able to look them up.
- sorokod 9y ago"I feel like this 'right to be forgotten' hurts my safety" A few years ago you had no such facility at all - how did you manage?
- TomMarius 9y agoI was feeling less safe, that has improved. Why go back in time?
- izacus 9y agoBecause it hurts innocent people.
- sorokod 9y agoIs it possible that your feeling is entirely subjective and not backed by any statistics ?
- EpicEng 9y agoGood thing we don't write law based on feelings. Were you _actually_ less safe? I highly doubt it.
- rootlocus 9y agoIf anything, you were probably feeling safer without being connected 24/7 to all the problems in the world. I'm really skeptical you were more afraid of strangers because you couldn't access public records about them.
- downandout 9y agoYeah, I think that the EU is right in this regard, and I wish a similar principle existed in the US. But I was surprised that the EU court in this case ruled against one person simply because he served a 4 year sentence. His case was more than a decade old, and it was non-violent and non-sexual. It seems like an inconsistent application of this principle. Sentences are often based on the amount of money involved. So while embezzlement by a CEO at a small company may well result in smaller losses and shorter prison sentences, the intent and conduct is exactly the same as a similar case at a larger company. If the smaller company CEO has a right to be forgotten, so does the larger one.
- moomin 9y agoIf you read the article it was a bit more nuanced than that. The one who had the right to be forgotten denied had a track record of misleading people about his conviction. The court (rightly, in my view) took this behaviour as evidence that his conviction remained relevant in a way that it was not for the other person (described as showing remorse). They didn’t just measure the length of the sentence. IMHO, this is an encouraging, nuanced development. There has to be a balance between protecting people against serial offenders and rehabilitation.
- briandear 9y agoWhy not attack the publication rather than the card catalog?
- kafquaesque 9y agoRequiring the publication to make the change is more feasible. In a hypothetical defamation situation the courts in the US have made this costly to do. In a conviction scenario Google search results can prevent people from being employed. I had a relative of a friend which had a published DUI which made it difficult for him to seek employment years after the issue. Employers have the ability to find criminal convictions and decide whether or not to hire an individual. Almost everyone googles people prior to contact.
- 9y ago
- jasode 9y ago>Permanent records are hugely damaging for persons livelihood in these cases. I agree and I'm not debating the harm that can be done. (My comment got many downvotes so I assume they think I believe felons should never be given a 2nd chance.) No, my comment is specifically about the framework for arguing. I'm saying that phrases such as "forgive" and "pay debt to society" are unconvincing since society has never universally believed that. Consider even the EU country like UK where Google lost this case. If UK truly "forgives" crimes after a felony sentence is served, why do they have a sex offender registry? The parent I responded to is apparently based in Canada. Canadian border officers have denied Americans with prior DUI felony convictions from entering the country. That's another example of not being "forgiven". Also, Canada is another country with a sex offender list. If we want to debate the "harm" to felons, then let's debate that. Do not use "forgive" in the text of the argument because it just leads to an inconsistency. Jail time is about punishment, not forgiveness.
- hahainternet 9y ago> why do they have a sex offender registry? We have a Violent and Sex Offender Register: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violent_and_Sex_Offender_Register https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violent_and_Sex_Offender_Regis... It is not public, it exists to facilitate Police intelligence.
- jasode 9y ago>It is not public, it exists to facilitate Police intelligence. The "police intelligence" gives a misleading impression. Non-police residents can inquire about felons on the list because of Sarah's Law.[1] In other words... "If I molested a child and served my 10 year prison sentence, I'm not truly _forgiven_ if people can check if I'm on a sex offender registry." Therefore, don't use "forgive" as the framework. It should be clear that society really doesn't forgive and allow people a clean slate. If serving jail truly meant the "debt was paid to society", felons wouldn't be put on that list after jail was completed. Many defendents refuse a plea bargain of "guilty" because they don't want to be put on that list. To them, the lifetime sex offender list is worse than the jail sentence. It's an ongoing debt that's never repaid. [1] https://www.gov.uk/guidance/find-out-if-a-person-has-a-record-for-child-sexual-offences https://www.gov.uk/guidance/find-out-if-a-person-has-a-recor...