10 ms·
Russia’s move to block Telegram another attack on online freedom of expression
- chupasaurus 9y agoTelegram would be blocked in Russia by court decision made today at 8:33 UTC, so this article is a bit outdated.
- rqs 9y agoWell, at least Russian pretends they had court. Go slightly south, there is other country that blocked Telegram long ago without notify anybody.
- d6de964 9y agoIf a state actor asked me to give them my keys, I'd be really afraid if I didn't comply. There's always the possibility your own country could request the same thing and act as a proxy.
- hnarn 9y agoThe BBC stated 25 minutes ago (from this posting) that the block has started to take effect. >The Russian government has started to block messaging app Telegram, according to reports from the local news agency Tass. >Russia's media regulator had sought to block the app because the firm has refused to hand over encryption keys used to scramble messages. >Telegram had missed a deadline of 4 April to hand over the keys. http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-43752337 http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-43752337
- edhelas 9y agoCentralized, proprietary solution so easy to block. What did you expect?
- ComodoHacker 9y agoCentralized =/= easy to block, let alone proprietary. They've said they were preparing for that, so let's see.
- tinus_hn 9y agoNow only if we can get them to block Twitter..
- Dzugaru 9y agoNever thought I would see such xenophobic comments on HN. This is really sad.
- ealhad 9y agoMaybe it’s from a Russian who doesn’t like Twitter?
- tinus_hn 9y agoOr maybe from someone who doesn’t like Russian twitter bot armies that try to destabilize the rest of the world? I’m pretty confident the Russian twitter users who provide meaningful content will manage to evade a block.
- slig 9y agoCan you share a source for "Russian Twitter bot armies" that can "destabilize the rest of the world"? Also, if that was the case, I'm pretty sure a state actor (you know, the one with the supposed "bot army") wouldn' get blocked since it's state itself you wish would block Twitter.
- tinus_hn 9y agoThat would be even better because then Twitter can easily distinguish Russian state interference (everything from Russia that isn’t blocked) and handle it as they wish.
- nmbr213 9y agoYou think government-run bot armies would comply with government issued ban? Oh boy.
- ryanlol 9y agoThis is a PR stunt for Telegram. It’s not the first time Russia pretends to fuck over the Durovs.
- y_molodtsov 9y agoCan you unfold please? That still sounds as a conspiracy theory.
- ryanlol 9y agoTelegram was developed in the VK offices in St. Petersburg and is deliberately implemented in a manner which allows the operators to intercept the vast majority of the chats on the platform. Durovs have spent years pretending to live in exile from Russia, despite regularly spending time in the country. What exactly sounds like a conspiracy theory? https://twitter.com/ChristopherJM/status/910186197598838784 https://twitter.com/ChristopherJM/status/910186197598838784 https://twitter.com/Bershidsky/status/910169626989953024 https://twitter.com/Bershidsky/status/910169626989953024 The theory that Telegram isn't controlled by Kremlin sounds far less credible to me.
- keldaris 9y ago> deliberately implemented in a manner which allows the operators to intercept the vast majority of the chats on the platform. Could you elaborate on this please? Are you just referring to the fact that the default settings don't enforce encryption or is there more to it?
- rando444 9y agoI believe this person is referring to the fact that Telegram uses their own encryption scheme instead of one of the more common standards. In this scenario, while the encryption has never been broken, it is theoretically possible that the creators designed the encryption in such a way that knowing certain values would allow you to decrypt the communication. This essentially allows the people that know the "secret" to be able to crack the communication, while the users remain under the impression that everything is private. He's further suggesting that this "move to block telegram" is a stunt to try and promote the idea that their encryption is not currently breakable (in a bid to foster more adoption of the platform). While there's no proof of any of this, personally I feel it's still within the range of plausibility, and raises further questions about why they would target only telegram and not other encrypted messengers .. We don't know all of the details but it feels that there is more to this move than what is being presented.
- roryhughes 9y ago> Russia’s media watchdog to block the messaging app Telegram for its refusal to share users’ information with the government Wondering if whatsapp is unblocked because it already is sharing users' information?
- ryanlol 9y agoWhatsapp is unblocked because blocking it would not significantly benefit Russian intelligence operations overseas.
- TheForumTroll 9y agoYou should seek work in Whatsapp's PR department. You sound just like them.
- giancarlostoro 9y agoCause for them to use it overseas it needs to be unblocked internally (to Russia)? Russia can always "whitelist" some applications for government officials too. Or y'know not rely on third-parties and roll their own solution, not like Signal's protocol isn't open sourced.
- ryanlol 9y agoI don't understand the point you're trying to make. Blocking Telegram helps Russian intelligence operations by making it appear like as if the Russian government did not have access to the vast majority of conversations over Telegram.
- giancarlostoro 9y agoYou were on about WhatsApp.... I mentioned Signal, Telegram does not use Signal's protocol.
- anovikov 9y agoYes, every messenger operating in Russia has to share users' information.
- bjoli 9y agoWhy hasn't Telegram implemented domain fronting? Did they really have so much hubris that they thought this would never happen?
- y_molodtsov 9y agoApple and Google will likely comply and delete the app in their Russian stores in any case.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- SXX 9y agoThey would just blacklist IPs or whole subnets. How would domain fronting help exactly if even US cloud providers surrender under Russian government threats? Other service called Zello avoided blocks by changing IP addresses on AWS until Russian government gave command to block 13,5M of Amazon IPs [1]. On next day Amazon simply forbid them to change IPs. [1] https://torrentfreak.com/russia-asked-isps-to-block-13-5-million-amazon-ip-addresses-to-silence-one-app-180331/ https://torrentfreak.com/russia-asked-isps-to-block-13-5-mil...
- zzzcpan 9y agoThe idea behind domain fronting is to make blacklisting unfeasible. It's kind of like Zello changing IP addresses, except you also happen to share those IP addresses with a lot of popular internet services. So, in order to block domain fronting the government would have to pressure a whole bunch of large foreign corporations with CDNs to patch their tech to forbid domain fronting.
- SXX 9y agoNo, they wouldn't need to pressure anyone. They'll just ban whole subnets of CDNs that are not used by any services popular in Russia. And cloud providers and CDNs that have large customers from Russia will just give up like Amazon just did. After all it's just a business for them and they not going to lose clients just to fight against censorship.
- TheForumTroll 9y agoI'm getting tired of all the Russia bashing. Sure Russia does a lot of bad things but it smells a lot like someone wants everyone to look elsewhere. Russia blocks Telegram while the US splits cables and installs snooping devices between data-centers, use secret courts, monitors everyone, etc. Why do we pretend Russia is such a problem when a lot worse stuff happens closer at home every single day?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DmitryOlshansky 9y agoNot a single piece of interesting facts in the post. And Telegram still works as of right now. As the proverb goes: “Undue strictness of Russian laws was always compensated by it being optional to follow them.”
- sschueller 9y agoAccording to the BBC[1] it is being blocked now. [1] http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-43752337 http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-43752337
- y_molodtsov 9y agoThe court order was issued a few hours ago, they will block it shortly.
- csydas 9y agoI would question that. Rutracker is supposed to be blocked by order of Roskomnadzor, but many isps here still are able to reach it. This happened almost a year ago so it's not a matter of propagation, it's just poor or lack of enforcement. Telegram is also exceptionally popular here, so I have trouble believing it will stick or do anything in the first place.
- y_molodtsov 9y agoWell, it's blocked by all the ISPs I have in any place. Generally Telegram will be blocked, and which is more imprortant, they will likely remove it from the app stores in Russia.
- amaccuish 9y agoStill unblocked for me, but got the VPN at the ready... Removal from the app stores would be much more effective, at least on iOS.
- f311a 9y agoI doubt because every ISP must install a special hardware (Revizor) manufactured by Roskomnadzor, which constantly checks blocked resources inside ISP network. If you don't block all the resources you will get fined. And there is a huge fine if you will try to trick this system.
- zpetrov 9y agoI'm from Russia. Let me be honest. I personally and many my friends do support blocking Telegram. We are full of this freedom-related bullshit. There is no freedom in the Internet. Currently we share our private information with CIA. We don't like it, but that's OK. Everybody still uses Facebook, Gmail, etc, etc. But when Russian Federal Security Service whats to access user's private data, everybody starts screaming. Shut up already.
- MichaelMoser123 9y agoReally? They can put you in for a wrong repost, doesn't sound so swell.
- zpetrov 9y agoNope. In Russia you can post whatever you want as long as you don't cross the law.
- eukgoekoko 9y agoNice try, lieutenant Petrov https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=ru&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&u=https%3A%2F%2Fmeduza.io%2Ffeature%2F2016%2F03%2F21%2Freposty-ot-politsii-layki-ot-fsb&edit-text= https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=ru&tl=en&js=y&prev...
- zpetrov 9y agomeduza.io? That's a silly anti-Russian site, which is sponsored by criminal Khodorkovsky. Nice try. https://www.kp.ru/daily/26577/3593566/ https://www.kp.ru/daily/26577/3593566/
- jabot 9y agoThat is true for china, iran and saudi arabia as well...
- y_molodtsov 9y agoThat's true. Thankfully the Russian laws allow to classify almost anything as extremism or insult against any social group, so that's not a problem.
- seba_dos1 9y agoJust use XMPP already, we really don't need all this IM fragmentation again, and as a bonus you won't be blocked.
- anthonybsd 9y agoWait a second. XMPP is the very definition of IM fragmentation with thousands (millions?) of servers segregated by region, organization, etc. How is that helpful for coordinated communication?
- edhelas 9y agoFragmentation != decentralisation. All those XMPP servers are talking to each others, so doesn't matter where you have your account you'll be able to reach the rest of the network. Emails are working the same way
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- seba_dos1 9y agoMy server hosts only three people including myself, each one on its own domain, yet I can talk with everyone else on any other server transparently, without any issues. And even if I decide not to host this server anymore, I can easily switch to another, import my roster and still talk to the same set of people. So, answering your question: very helpful.
- leadingthenet 9y agoWhy not something more modern, like Matrix?
- Boulth 9y agoBecause XMPP is modern too? Even Matrix' own FAQ [0] about that is full of notes that "now XMPP does that too". [0]: https://matrix.org/docs/guides/faq.html#what-is-the-difference-between-matrix-and-xmpp https://matrix.org/docs/guides/faq.html#what-is-the-differen...
- tuyguntn 9y agoFor Telegram haters, this means Telegram actually cares about your privacy comparing to WhatsApp, Messenger and any other IM working in Russia without problems. Anytime US government asks to share data, WhatsApp can provide it, as they probably did in Russia (guessing of course)
- r3bl 9y agoUmmm... there is no encryption key for WhatsApp and Messenger to hand over. That's what end-to-end encryption means. Now WhatsApp could theoretically push a malicious update, but there is no way Signal could even theoretically hand over the encryption keys, because the entire freaking point of their product is for them not to have a copy of those keys. Since Telegram isn't end-to-end encrypted (outside "secret chats"), they do have a private key that decrypts all the messages, since they only encrypt in transit. Therefore, there is a private key to hand over to the government.
- oarsinsync 9y ago> Since Telegram isn't end-to-end encrypted they do have a private key that decrypts all the messages, since they only encrypt in transit E2E encryption refers to transit encryption. The encryption is between two end devices, rather than decrypted (and re-encrypted) between clients and servers. It has no bearing on data stored at rest on the end device, and I have no idea what either WhatsApp, Signal or Telegram does to the data at rest.
- mtgx 9y agoI'm not a fan of Telegram the app due to the fact that it doesn't enable end-to-end encryption by default, but this is an interesting post by Durov, from today: > The power that local governments have over IT corporations is based on money. At any given moment, a government can crash their stocks by threatening to block revenue streams from its markets and thus force these companies to do strange things (remember how last year Apple moved iCloud servers to China). At Telegram, we have the luxury of not caring about revenue streams or ad sales. Privacy is not for sale, and human rights should not be compromised out of fear or greed. http://t.me/durov/76 http://t.me/durov/76 Remember Telegram recently raised a whopping $1.7 billion from a coin offering. It's also the reason I've been begging Signal to do something similar for over a year now. Cryptocurrencies can provide the liquidity open source projects need, and it can also help them stand against oppressive governments. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-03-30/telegram-raises-1-7-billion-in-coin-offering-may-seek-more https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-03-30/telegram-...
- r3bl 9y ago> It's also the reason I've been begging Signal to do something similar for over a year now. Aren't they in the process of doing that with MobileCoin[0]? I know the whitepaper is pretty sparse on information, but according to the last paragraph in the whitepaper[1], it's designed to integrate with IM platforms, and, according to the only tweet from their Twitter profile[2], there is no ICO at the time. [0] https://www.mobilecoin.com/ https://www.mobilecoin.com/ [1] https://www.mobilecoin.com/whitepaper-en.pdf https://www.mobilecoin.com/whitepaper-en.pdf [2] https://twitter.com/mobilecoinone/status/960359924562739200 https://twitter.com/mobilecoinone/status/960359924562739200
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- textor 9y agoI cannot imagine anyone here on HN arguing in good faith in favor of crackdown on encrypted messenger "because terrorists". This is retarded and illiterate, and the same goes for gun analogies. I get that many Americans are concerned with gun violence, but at least here you ought to be able to try to not think with your hindbrain, and instead consider whether your concern has any relevance. Normally that should be enough. Let me elaborate, though. First, there's extremely little chance of uncovering any "terrorists" or any major criminals by investigating the extant chats: competent lawbreakers delete incriminating messages as soon as possible or communicate in secure chats to begin with, and would do so especially if Telegram showed signs of cooperating with FSB. There would, however, be a guaranteed influx of falsely accused. VK is a good example: there are cases when people are incriminated for inciting hatred because of something like a closed album with Nazi caricature memes, on the grounds that "everything on VK is public"; there were multiple trials for reposted messages. And so on. Most of this is simply due to some random asshat spook trying to furter his career by hauling in a lot of "extremists" and surpassing average "productivity". This is both inhumane and not economical. More importantly, encryption is not analogous to guns because guns are hard to manufacture and even harder to conceal, but software is different. You can easily create your own encrypted messenger and nullify whatever efforts the government is putting in suppressing current platforms. Signal Protocol is open source, you know. Blocking Telegram would merely speed up the transfer of terrorists to their own networks, and/or increase the popularity of platforms which would not even shut down the channels with terroristic propaganda (something Durov actually does). There is no replacement to actual investigation, to fieldwork, to international cooperation, to training of competent agents and infiltrators. This is hard and risky, it's so much more easy to vantonly gather data, threaten average citizens with your overreach and pretend to save the day. Well, let me remind you that Boston bombing did not rely on any sort of encryption. FBI received hints from FSB and interviewed Tamerlan way before the event; Dzhokhar’s Facebook was insanely suspicious. They failed to notice the threat. If the intelligence cannot successfully work with open information like this, what more could they gain from Telegram?
- gingercoin 9y agoIt seems that Telegram starts crowdsale ICO http://crowdsale-telegram.org http://crowdsale-telegram.org
- slezyr 9y agoAnd registered their domain in Russia? They're smart... Or scammers. Off cause it's scammers.
- justpasserby007 9y agoOh, my. Just now I've seen second biggest federal news channel reporting on the issue and... and advertising TamTam messenger (created less than 6 months ago) or "even a better alternative" -- ICQ, both of which, surprisingly, are products of Mail.ru group. That is __really weird__.