5 ms·
Unsurprising, but luckily only applicable to the US however undoubtedly will be referred to on other trials in other economies. We've always had the 'gig' econ
by ggm 9y ago
Unsurprising, but luckily only applicable to the US however undoubtedly will be referred to on other trials in other economies.
We've always had the 'gig' economic problem.
It's maybe me but I don't get it. Treating employment as subcontracting tilts benefits massively to the employer and reduces unionisation. It's anti worker. It's retrograde. It's going to increase dependencies on state benefits due to the lack of savings, depressed lifetime income and absense of 401 self funded retirement.
- hardwaresofton 9y ago> It's maybe me but I don't get it. Treating employment as subcontracting tilts benefits massively to the employer and reduces unionisation. It's anti worker. It's retrograde. It's going to increase dependencies on state benefits due to the lack of savings, depressed lifetime income and absense of 401 self funded retirement. Yes. However the venn diagram of people who know/learned this, and people who are willing to change it, and those who have influence requisite to make change do not overlap enough at present. I get most surprised that this is the steady state of things in a large supposedly democratic republic like America -- if the country was reckless in hopes for growth and selling Special Economic Zones and stuff OK, there's clearly a large problem maybe even a short-sighted goal issue (oh they're trading worker's lives for short term maybe long-term economic growth), but that just isn't the case with the US.
- collyw 9y agoEven as a fairly educated decently paid software engineer I got screwed over by a somewhat similar situation.. I took a job where I was paid through an international company (well 3/4 of my pay was that way, and the rest was a normal contract) here in Spain. When I saw my pay go in before taxes it looked significantly more than what I had seen before, and I though I was doing well out of the deal. Of course I had to pay all the taxes anyway. It was only a year later when I got changed to a full Spanish contact I started checking numbers (to make sure they were equivalent) that it occurred to me that I would only have been getting 1/4 of the pension payments before then, which in Spain is a significant amount. I doubt most Uber employees are seeing noticing anything like that (though to be fair I have no idea how those extra are paid in the US).
- LanceH 9y agoIt's anti-worker, except for those who wish to work who would otherwise be outside the workforce. In this case, there is no employer of one-off drivers. Cities with medallions are deliberately anti-worker to all but a few.
- db48x 9y agoBeing a contractor does not automatically put you in a bad position relative to your client, because you can negotiate the details of that contract. As a result it can be both lucrative and extremely rewarding. Of course I'm sure Uber will simply not agree to any modifications of their standard contract, but they do have competitors that the drivers could go to. Oh, and contractors should always set up an individual 401k; it has the same tax benefits as you'd get as an employee, and then some.
- jon_richards 9y agoI think the primary issue is that Uber provides incentives in the contract for "employee-like" behaviour. Imagine an extreme case where minimum wage is $8/hour and I'm offering a contracting job that comes out to $0/hour before incentives. If people work 8 hours a day on the schedule I want and do everything else that employees have to do, I give them $4/hour. Now most of my workers will be just as good as employees, but at half minimum wage. They say "I'm working like an employee, I should get minimum wage." I say "They have all the freedom a contractor has, they aren't employees." Sure, in this scenario there are still people happy to work an hour here and there and earn the $2/hour or whatever it comes out to, but this isn't about whether those people exist or in what proportion. This is about the people who feel compelled by Uber's incentives to treat themselves as employees of Uber without receiving the legally mandated protections and benefits afforded to employees. This also isn't about supply/demand, the free market, and whether people want to work for that $4/hour or not. The fact that we have minimum wage in the first place is proof that the country has made a decision to not leave employment terms to natural equilibria.
- roenxi 9y agoThe situation is an interesting case of economic realities quietly trumping political ideology. Uber thinks they are offering a reasonable deal. The people doing the work obviously think that it is the best deal they have available. The government is going to need to stamp down pretty heavily to stop that, because the actors in this situation have no particular incentive to change anything.
- pessimizer 9y ago> It's maybe me but I don't get it. Treating employment as subcontracting tilts benefits massively to the employer and reduces unionisation. It's anti worker. It's retrograde. It's going to increase dependencies on state benefits due to the lack of savings, depressed lifetime income and absense of 401 self funded retirement. No, you get it.
- pjc50 9y ago> tilts benefits massively to the employer and reduces unionisation. It's anti worker. It's retrograde. It's going to increase dependencies on state benefits due to the lack of savings, depressed lifetime income and absense of 401 self funded retirement. Yes. At this point we have to assume it's intentional.
- icebraining 9y agoluckily only applicable to the US Not even that, it's only binding in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. This ruling is mostly inconsequential, in my opinion; it's mostly a formality to get to the Third Circuit.
- collyw 9y agoOtherwise known as a race to the bottom.
- NicoJuicy 9y agoIn Europe, UberPOP is considered a transport company and not an IT service company which has different rules.https://tweakers.net/nieuws/137241/eu-hof-lidstaten-mogen-uberpop-verbieden-zonder-dit-te-melden-bij-commissie.html https://tweakers.net/nieuws/137241/eu-hof-lidstaten-mogen-ub...
- manigandham 9y agoBut that's the fundamental issue, it's not actually employment. Why does everyone seem to ignore that the job of "professional driver" already exists so anyone who does want full-time employment can already do it? Every single driver I've ever asked (in 1000s of rides taken over 7 years) has always said they prefer the freedom of being able to work when and where they want. Students, retirees, stay at home parents, and others who specifically do not want to have a FT job.
- leg100 9y ago> Every single driver I've ever asked (in 1000s of rides taken over 7 years) has always said they prefer the freedom of being able to work when and where they want. Students, retirees, stay at home parents, and others who do specifically do not want to have a FT job. I always hear this line about the sheer variety of backgrounds of the drivers, and that an Uber job is a way to collect a bit of extra cash. That they have something going on that is far more preoccupying, and that the Uber job is a mere sideline. In my experience, 9 out of 10 Uber drivers in London are 25-60 years old, from East Africa or the Middle East, and do the job full time if you include working for other mini cab companies. It's their main occupation. Might well be different elsewhere and probably is, but I can see why Uber might prefer to push a certain story that doesn't reflect reality.
- manigandham 9y agoJust because you do something full-time doesn't make it full-time employment. I'm sure there are people who use these options as their main occupation but would still rather have the flexibility instead of showing up to work on a schedule because, as I said, there are actual jobs available if they want that.
- gowld 9y agoA part time job is still a job.
- skate22 9y agoI was in france several months ago and i canceled my uber & paid the driver the same price in cash. The driver was a nice guy, struggling to make enough.
- amelius 9y agoSounds good, and I feel more people should do this. But how often can you cancel a ride before you get banned from the platform? Also, are there any negative consequences for the driver when a ride is canceled, even before the start of the ride? I can imagine that Ueber can detect when driver and client are within talking distance (from cellphone GPS coordinates), so they can detect and penalize this form of "gaming".
- skate22 9y agoIm honestly not sure how they prevent people from trolling. There might be a cancelation fee for repeat offenders. One uber driver told me that he estimates that uber takes half of the fare. I wish there was a platform for drivers to pay a low monthly sub, but get to keep 100% of ride fares.
- gowld 9y agoApplicable only on one District, not the whole US.