4 ms·
To be clear, the only conclusion here is this program was the wrong approach for the audience it targeted. Diet, exercise and personal responsibility still do
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
To be clear, the only conclusion here is this program was the wrong approach for the audience it targeted.
Diet, exercise and personal responsibility still do matter. This program was not able to get the target to embrace such things.
That said, there must have been some successes. Who were those? And why? Why was it effective? How can that be replicated and scaled to effect more?
Moi? I suspect too much was targeted at the kids and not enough at the parents. The parents do the shopping. They do the cooking. The kids, by definition, follow the lead of the parents. The kids adapt and conform to the nurture provided to them. Not to sound harsh but how often do to see a (pardon me) chubby kid and then see the parents are similar or worse?
Put another way, I'm willing to bet there was no change for the parents' weight / habits either; in turn no change for the "culture." And so it persists. This is what humans do. We conform to the norms around us.
- laumars 9y agoI have a vaguely related personal anecdote on this topic: back when I was a school kid I experimented with vegetarianism for ethical reasons. I quickly realised it made no difference so long as I was still at school because my parent bought the same food and cooked the same quantities of meat. All that happened was my Dad got an extra helping of steak or whatever. Ultimately kids might have some control over what they eat at school (depending on school dinners etc), but you're absolutely right that they have little control over what they eat at home. (or rather they'll be given the option to eat what the family eats or cook their own dinners - which no normal teenager is ever going to do week in and week out if there is already an easier option going) I do also completely agree with you about leading by example with regards to exercise etc.
- GCU-Empiricist 9y ago>Diet, exercise and personal responsibility still do matter. As an aging former military member it seems like personal responsibility is becoming more and more a foreign concept. I'm saying this not to kvetch but to get peer perception on the thought.
- ams6110 9y agoThe report agrees with you: The health behaviour of young children is largely influenced by parents. While promoting healthy eating and activity at school is probably helpful, it’s not enough. A conclusion of "probably helpful" is not strong enough to spend public education dollars on, at the expense of other academic instruction (there are a fixed number of minutes in a school day, and if you're not teaching healthy eating you can be teaching something else). Not to mention that what was taught for the past few decades (lots of grains and cereals and no fat) was flat-out wrong and probably contributed a lot to the obesity problems we have today.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoYes. Thank you. I wanted to make sure the perception it was the program that failed, not the tools. Thanks.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Balero 9y agoI feel this view is massively overblown in media. Do I read stories about people blaming others for their problems, showing no personal responsibility? Absolutely, all the time, especially in mass media. Day to day, people I know, people I overhear. people I talk to , show lots of personal responsibility. Sure they might skip the gym, or eat some cake. But they take responsibility for that, and themselves at large. Frankly its easier to sell newspapers or get views by talking about someone we can look at and say "Wow, I know I skipped the gym today, but I'm not that bad", than to hear an altogether more boring story of the 99% that are basically the same as ourselves.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoOk. But the percentage of adults who are overweight or obese is somewhere around 70%. If we presume 10% is not preventable - that is they have a med condition - then what of the other 60%? Who is feeding those people? Who is forcing them to the sofa? I understand it's not that simple (e.g., gut bacteria has been tied to weight control). None the less i know people who had what I would consider serious med issues (e.g., cancer) and made no change in lifestyle. Yes, I'm generalizing. I apologize. But the obesity rate doesn't match well with self responsibility.
- acdha 9y agoAlso a lot of that’s locked in by structure. If you buy a house in an American-style suburb, your kids are going to be spending a lot of time sitting in car seats and commute times tend to cut into the time needed to cook healthier foods at home. A kid can’t decide to move and in many cases it’s really hard to use alternatives: either neglect or deliberate attempts to discourage pedestrians mean that there’s very little in walking distance and often not even sidewalks or road crossings which don’t require substantial detours. It may or may not be safe / conducive to cycling but the safety culture is such that a lot of habits are set by the time they’re old enough to do that independently in their late teens.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoI agree. But knowing this, soda shouldn't remain the house drink of choice. Occasionally I glance at other ppls' carts at the supermarket. Let's just say a lot of bad choices are being made.
- nradov 9y agoIt's really a shame how some parents are essentially torturing their children by overfeeding, even though it might not really be intentional. In severe cases the results are as harmful as physical or emotional abuse. Child Protective Services agencies need to get involved. In extreme cases it might be necessary to temporarily take away custody and put the child in foster care. But for most parents with obese children I think some mandatory classes on childhood nutrition and fitness could be a good start.