9 ms·
A school-based obesity prevention programme was ineffective
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ada1981 9y agoWithout addressing the underlying developmental trauma this kind of program is going to be very hard to do effectively.
- megaman22 9y agoBreaking news! Schools can't fix suboptimal family life. My mum is a special ed teacher in a poor, rural, redneck corner of New England. Many of the students on her caseload only get anything approaching decent food from the school lunch program. Their broken, mixed up, drunk and drugged out parents can't even keep their own shit together, let alone bear the responsibilities of raising a child. Not surprisingly, if tragically, the child suffers.
- smackay 9y agoReading this I was shocked, shocked I tell you to learn that cookery courses for adults and healthy eating "challenges" were ineffective. Actually if you take the numbers at face value then perhaps the intervention made the problem worse - there was a comment yesterday about how short-bursts of extra activity actually made people less active outside their regular exercise times. So the premise of the study seems to indicate that the problem is largely one of education - I guess that's why they dropped this onto the school system. Instead of playing with a few guinea-pigs on a small scale maybe it's time think to think about the big picture: 1. Get all the crap out of the food supply. 2. Put an end, permanently with threat of severe sanctions, to all the fear-mogering in the media that frightens parents into keeping their kids indoors. 3. Deal with small-scale, crime, bullying, availability of drugs, etc. etc. that keep kids inside in front of the games console or TV instead of getting outside. 4. Create spaces were kids can go outside. 5. Get away from schools being places where kids sit on their asses for 6+ hours a day. For example in today' physics lesson on electro-magnetism we are actually going to biuld a 50m maglev track. OK so this is a bit unrealistic but it would be a hell of a lot more fun and everybody would be a lot more active. ... etc. etc., rant, rant. In other words, the solution to a complex problem which is poorly understood is probably a whole range of solutions to create an environment where obesity simply is not possible. But that would take a huge amount of money, a huge amount of political will, a lot of creative thinking and a general re-wiring of a large number of attitudes and expectations.
- cies 9y ago> 1. Get all the crap out of the food supply. Additional taxes may do, it helped for smoking. Slap the same tax on sugar, (processed) animal products, oils. And make a VAT exempt on whole plant foods. That combined with updated nutritional education will save millions.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoOoops - I had a different definition for 'crap'. Maybe we should instead use a scheme that lets people choose their own food, like a free market or something...
- adrianN 9y agoThat doesn't sound like an effective way to combat the obesity crisis.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoIts consistent with American values (personal freedom etc). So often the idealist jumps straight to "Lets make people do it my way, uh, the right way! With restrictive intrusive laws! Or raids! Or some other totalitarian tool! Because that'll work!" I understand its hard to see folks making choices that diverge from my personal sense of what's optimal. But it is a cost of living in a free society.
- cies 9y agoYou're making up stawmans, nobody's talking about that. Just some extra taxation like with cigarettes. We're discussing ideas on how to get a hold on the obesity crisis. I suggested some extra taxes. Yes some gov't regulation. You suggested me to use the free market, but food is already on the free market. So I fail to understand what you are actually suggesting. At the same time you say "get rid of the crap", while not defining how to do so (without gov't regulation accordin to your own preferences) and without defining what in your eyes crap then means... Please make a real argument. And why should any solution be "consistent with American values"; obesity in the US is VERY CONSISTENT with American values. Maybe to turn the tide on it we have to look in a diff direction.
- cies 9y agoFrom the web page: """ What did this study do? [...] * an additional 30 minutes of physical activity each day * a family cooking workshop each term * in collaboration with local Aston Villa Football Club, three sessions of coaching in physical activities and two on preparing healthy meals, with weekly activity and healthy eating “challenges” * information sheets about staying active during the holidays, with signposting to local facilities """ So 1.5/4 points about diet, and the rest about exercise. Thus mostly focused on exercise. While diabetes is known to be preventable/reversible by primarily diet. Specifically by removing processed foods (that includes oils, refined starches and sugar) and animal(-derived) products (as they are high in saturated fats), while adding lots of whole plant foods. And not only for cooked meals, but for all meals and snacks. Seems to me they've been trying to optimize the wrong parameters. Just my 2ct.
- ForRealsies 9y agoWell the government isn't about to starve 6 year old kids to increase their insulin sensitivity, what do you expect? Mandating kids to do <activity> is 100x easier than mandating parents NOT to do something.
- arkh 9y agoAnd the diet part is about healthy (at the time) meals. Just learn to count calories, how much you need and avoid excesses. Bad food in small portions is better than huge amounts of healthy calories.
- SCHiM 9y agoResearch is not yet clear, but not every calorie is the same! The combination of nutrients in food can have a large effect on the efficiency of nutrient extraction in your stomach and gut. For example, when you consume alchol and a meal afterwards your body will store more fat than if you'd just taken a (slightly larger) meal. This is because your body will prioritize burning the acetate and alchol over anything else (including carbs, fat and protein). Other foods or chemicals might have effects on the resource burning allocation of your body.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoIneffective?! It was positively corrosive. My growing Iowa farmboys were starved nearly senseless. We sent lunches thru elementary school (which they were stigmatized for bringing) but in middle school they had to use the provided meal service. Nearly passed out by 2PM, they struggled thru till they got home and we could put 1000 calories in them to tide them over until supper. This program was phenomenally clueless and ill-conceived. Instead of patronizing inappropriate low-calorie choices (which drove students to hoarding dingdongs in their lockers), how about providing plentiful good food? That might have had a positive effect. {edit: I thought they were talking about the federal school-lunch initiative, sorry}
- maxerickson 9y agoDoesn't the federal school lunch program mostly just provide funding for low income students? I think a requirement to eat the school provided meal would probably be local stupidity.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoRural community. Not a lot of resources or facilities. No place to put a lunch from home (no refrigeration/storage). Not stupid, practical. The school lunch program feeds anybody who shows up. Nothing to do with income.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe federal school lunch program is predicated on income. That's basically all it is, a system for providing funds to schools with low income students. It comes with things like minimum standards for the meals, but I don't think it comes with a limit on how much food each student can be served.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoEvery school in Iowa has a lunch program, even the wealthiest. Its subsidized of course, but for everybody. True low income can get you a waiver, like many other government programs, but the lunch is available to all. There is absolutely a limit on food.
- internetman55 9y agoUnfortunately I doubt there are any good solutions to this. People become obese because their lives are too fucked up to care for themselves properly. If your parents are weak, you're at high risk of being obese. If too many bad things happen to you at once you're at risk of being obese. Kind of fucked up to think of society as fucked up hunger games where if you fuck up the bodies of you and your loved ones are mutilated by this condition but that just seems to be how life works
- Djvacto 9y agoJust some quick napkin math: In 2015 the US Defense spending was estimated around $598 billion. [1] In 2014 we spent $12.7 million on the school lunch program. [2] By reducing the defense budget a little under 5%, we could triple the school lunch program. Reduce it a little under 9%, and we can spend 5x more on school lunches. I'm not sure of the exact numbers behind an individual school lunch, but from what I know about personal cooking, you can probably spend 5x more and have menus put together for kids that are way healthier than the "Pizza Dippers" I remember. I'm also not sure if school lunches are sold at a profit, but here's what I found related to that [3]. Assuming they are, do they really need to be, especially if the federal government can subsidize it more? What's really needed is a societal change with how food is treated. Someone else mentioned a tax on sugar and processed foods, which could help. But another big step would be trying to teach students about nutritious food and living a healthy lifestyle. Of course, it's difficult if the school is the only place they see this, but I don't think it would hurt to have more outlets for healthy living in a student's life. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_... [2] https://www.cbo.gov/publication/50737 https://www.cbo.gov/publication/50737 [3] http://markbittman.com/health-vs-profits-in-school-lunches/ http://markbittman.com/health-vs-profits-in-school-lunches/
- adrianN 9y agoYou're off by a factor of 1000, I think.
- maxerickson 9y agoIt's the school lunch "million", which should be $12.7 billion. (so all the percentages are reasonable)
- zajd 9y agoThe problem isn't how food is treated, it's Americans unwillingness to use tax dollars to help poor people(even children). Foods got nothing to do with it, it's the same with their school supplies, technology, quality of education, etc.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoTo be clear, the only conclusion here is this program was the wrong approach for the audience it targeted. Diet, exercise and personal responsibility still do matter. This program was not able to get the target to embrace such things. That said, there must have been some successes. Who were those? And why? Why was it effective? How can that be replicated and scaled to effect more? Moi? I suspect too much was targeted at the kids and not enough at the parents. The parents do the shopping. They do the cooking. The kids, by definition, follow the lead of the parents. The kids adapt and conform to the nurture provided to them. Not to sound harsh but how often do to see a (pardon me) chubby kid and then see the parents are similar or worse? Put another way, I'm willing to bet there was no change for the parents' weight / habits either; in turn no change for the "culture." And so it persists. This is what humans do. We conform to the norms around us.
- laumars 9y agoI have a vaguely related personal anecdote on this topic: back when I was a school kid I experimented with vegetarianism for ethical reasons. I quickly realised it made no difference so long as I was still at school because my parent bought the same food and cooked the same quantities of meat. All that happened was my Dad got an extra helping of steak or whatever. Ultimately kids might have some control over what they eat at school (depending on school dinners etc), but you're absolutely right that they have little control over what they eat at home. (or rather they'll be given the option to eat what the family eats or cook their own dinners - which no normal teenager is ever going to do week in and week out if there is already an easier option going) I do also completely agree with you about leading by example with regards to exercise etc.
- GCU-Empiricist 9y ago>Diet, exercise and personal responsibility still do matter. As an aging former military member it seems like personal responsibility is becoming more and more a foreign concept. I'm saying this not to kvetch but to get peer perception on the thought.
- ams6110 9y ago
- rossdavidh 9y agoParticipation (permission to measure BMI) was around 60%. That seems like a pretty low rate, and it is not too hard to imagine that parents who know their child has a BMI problem might be more likely to not want it measured, for fear of stigmatizing them or their child. So, while I don't doubt that a program of this sort might not be the answer, I don't think their data is sufficient to prove it one way or the other, unfortunately. I would expect you need well over 90% compliance/permission to measure before you could say that. Disclosure: I am not a statistician (and I would love to hear from one about this issue).
- btcindivist 9y agoFor a country that is so weighed down by the health issues around obesity, it's quite weird taxes/incentives based on calorie per gram isn't anywhere in sight. The savings from not having to take care of so much sick people would be enormous. It's clear from the situation that the free market choices are suboptimal. Who wants to suffer through most of their life and die early? Yet these choices are still made. If you can't educate, then tax fairly and force them to make the right choices.
- ams6110 9y ago> Who wants to suffer through most of their life and die early? Apparently the fat people. Otherwise they would change their eating habits. Why do we want to force people to live some way they don't want to live? It won't work, and it will just flush more tax dollars down the drain.
- btcindivist 9y agoI'm pretty sure taxing by calorie density would make things better. There's no cost in doing that, it would just shift people to eat less calorie dense food like fruits, vegetables and leafy greens. The main problem is that the current laws, taxes and infrastructure are heavily optimized to produce calorie dense foods. Another is that people like some of those foods on a regular basis in their diet, so they might complain. I would say this would cost more in political points than in real money.
- slothtrop 9y agoOffer free cooking and nutrition coaching for low-income families. They're the ones with kids most likely to subsist on junk. Presumably if it proves to be effective, the gains will eventually extent to the hold-outs in the middle-class. I would observe as much at the supermarket on the regular in an area I once lived in, heartbreaking to see.
- Double_a_92 9y agoThey wouldn't go to such a coaching because of ignorancy. Most people are not low-income for no reason... If they really wanted the internet is full of freely available information.
- slothtrop 9y ago>Most people are not low-income for no reason... Low-income workers are as such because they're "ignorant"? Uh.. Why this would work is that free delicious food isn't likely to be turned down. I think people are often creatures of habit and feel intimidated by cooking, along with (as you suggest) disinterest. You don't just teach the mechanics and call it a day, they can walk away with a cheap delicious food and see how easy it is to put together. Ultimately also easier on their wallets than a cart full of 2L soda bottles, frozen pizzas and chips.
- tweedledee 9y agoFat shaming is pretty effective. It worked on me and others in my peer group. I don't like being fat and I don't like being around people who are fat. It's unhealthy and unattractive and represents, to me, a lack of control and discipline. I look at someone who can't give up Sugar the same way as someone who can't give up cocaine, as a person who needs help. Possibly in the form of an intervention.
- mark_edward 9y agoCite a study
- tweedledee 9y agohttps://www.liebertpub.com/doi/abs/10.1089/chi.2014.0062 https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/abs/10.1089/chi.2014.0062
- mark_edward 9y agoHow do you get fat-shaming from "peer and parental encouragement"?
- rmdashrfroot 9y agoThe hard truth where sometimes our feelings _need_ to be hurt early on to save our health (despite all of this modern social acceptance of unhealthy, irresponsible people who lack the self control to put the sugar down and consume less calories daily).