7 ms·
As a consumer I really dislike subscription services, they quickly add up to a lot of money. I can see how it works for businesses but by definition that means
by tonyedgecombe 9y ago
As a consumer I really dislike subscription services, they quickly add up to a lot of money. I can see how it works for businesses but by definition that means its not so good for me.
- rahimnathwani 9y ago"I can see how it works for businesses but by definition that means its not so good for me." That seems to assume that transactions between businesses and consumers are zero sum games. It's possible for something to be good for a business and good for you. For example, I subscribe to The Economist. It's good for me (cheaper than buying individual issues, and cheaper that suitable-quality alternatives) and good for them (up-front payment, lower distribution costs).
- amelius 9y agoBut parent was speaking specifically about parent.
- duggan 9y agoI think it's pretty reasonable to read the parent as making a general assertion about subscription models from a consumer's perspective, particularly as they began their comment with, "as a consumer" rather than "as tonyedgecombe." It's all well and good to say "well, I just mean for me, personally" but I'm not sure it's adding to the public discourse without any further qualification.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThat works because they didn't lock the subscription yet. Compare subscription to Netflix vs. buying a movie on a DVD (and maybe ripping a personal backup copy). The former is a subscription - you stop paying (maybe because of financial emergency), no movie. The latter is a one-time purchase, after which you keep the thing you bought forever (so when shit hits the fan, you still can cheer yourself up with your favourite movie. I know I definitely prefer buying over renting/subscribing. Businesses prefer the reverse. It's a conflict of interest.
- rahimnathwani 9y agoI was using The Economist as an example of a general point: just because something is good for a business, it doesn't follow that it is bad for consumers 'by definition' (as claimed by the commenter to whom I replied).
- martin-adams 9y agoHowever, with Netflix, if you do have disposable income again in the future, then you can restore you position exactly. But if you had to sell your DVD collection due to a financial emergency, the cost of replacing it is greater. It doesn't work with things like cloud storage. Stop paying, you lose your data. It also assumes that Netflix in this example wont go out of business. The mental model is what is different. I pay X per month for Y value per month. Rather than, I pay X now for Y value forever. I may not use that Y value now, I may use it in 12 months time (for example, I still have DVDs in sealed packaging because I thought I needed the value up front). Then I use Audible where I subscribe for X credits and once I use it on a book, I can use it indefinitely. I like that middle ground.
- dhimes 9y agoHowever, with Netflix, if you do have disposable income again in the future, then you can restore you position exactly. If the business is still around.
- coheeman 9y ago>However, with Netflix, if you do have disposable income again in the future, then you can restore you position exactly. But if you had to sell your DVD collection due to a financial emergency, the cost of replacing it is greater. You could also never sever your Netflix subscription and still lose access to your favorite movie because their licensing agreement ran out. Even in your example, ownership wins out because you have the -option- to sell your residual assets in a financial emergency. There's nothing you can resell with your Netflix subscription money since you're just paying for the temporary privilege to watch a movie you don't own that might not be there tomorrow.
- Silhouette 9y ago
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoTrue, it's just that most of the time it isn't good for me.
- Arqu 9y agoI have a completely other sentiment from the top post, and a good part of my friends circle as well. I work as a developer and the business model is much clearer to me. The thing is to distinguish a service and a product. Buying a game, I expect a 1 off purchase and to own it. However if I want to have access to all the games in existance for a flat monthly fee like 50$ per month, thats a completely different story, and there's strong reasoning behind it. To run a service it perpetualy costs money so one off doesn't cut it. Either you have to pay an upfront cost of the lifetime value (which would be way to expensive) or you have to keep buying "DLCs" since the cost so far doesn't cover the furhter development. Also Dropbox and services alike might be cheaper to host for yourself, like many other things in life - car repair or home improvements, but that only cuts it if you are savvy enough in that particular trade. Thats the first part where it adds value - it simplifies things a lot. The second part is the ecosystem of integrations and sharing, and this goes to many other services as well. I usualy host my own for a large majority of services since its low volume use a free or small instance on any cloud provider does the work, however I still have Netflix, GSuite, Drive, Play Music and a range of others since they give to me more value than just doing it myself or are not worth the time effort. Also as a software engineer by trade I really hope more people start understanding that if you want baddass apps and games which constantly update and run on online servers, it has to cost money perpetually and you have to either pay for a subscription, look at ads, or have a freemium type of model to support the cost and eventually earn a couple bucks.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cecja 9y agoTo be honest the main problem for me is I gladly pay 10$ for Spotify or Netflix but I just can't bring myself to pay 8$ for a todo app or 10$ for Dropbox when my hosting with 500GB and the ability to run my own cloud costs 4.99$. Most of the time it's just to much for just the convince. Besides I despise apps like Dropbox or Evernote that nag people I share stuff with to sign up for their service.
- taneq 9y agoOr even spend the $8 on a thumb drive which goes on your keyring and will store 32GB or whatever that you'll have with you literally everywhere for the foreseeable future.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoThat’s not really comparible to a cloud service that provides 1TB of storage and allows me to access my files from anywhere, or delegate access to others.
- pavlov 9y agoFor this reason I feel that SaaS services that fall in the $10-$30 bracket are problematic. The price is too much for consumers who compare it to Netflix, whereas for businesses it's often ridiculously small and effectively leaves money on the table. I like Discourse's pricing model: https://www.discourse.org https://www.discourse.org Their plans start at $100 / month, which is not a problem for real businesses. For everyone else, the software is full open source and it's reasonably easy to install on that $5/month cloud server instance. The "free or $100+" model conveniently eliminates the support hassle of $10 / month users who typically are the most clueless and demanding.
- osrec 9y agoInteresting. Do you think they miss out on a fair amount of customers at that price point?
- 9y ago
- st26 9y agoI would be happier to subscribe if <minor little tool> cost $0.50/mo instead of $10/mo. I only have room for a few $10/mo bills. But companies don't seem to be willing to drop below perhaps $5/mo.
- savanaly 9y agoWell of course, who wouldn't rather pay fifty cents than ten dollars for something? The question is really rather how can the average business survive after its revenue stream falls by 95%? They don't have volunteers staffing the offices and writing the articles.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fundamental 9y agoWith payment processor fees as well as per-user support fees (e.g. if a user asks a question), going to $6/year doesn't seem sustainable even if you have the market size which could provide a huge user base. For many projects they also have to keep in mind that their user base is not endless, so when it begins to saturate they need to have a reasonable income.
- ghaff 9y agoNot that it's easy to make money in mobile but there are apps that sell for a low number of dollars and they don't even necessarily have in-app purchases. I think it's more akin to micropayments albeit on a different scale. Personally, I'm very resistant to subscriptions. I don't want to be managing 50 $0.50/month subscriptions for this that and the other thing. Just too much mental energy to deal with.
- fundamental 9y agoIs that an entirely fair comparison? Personally I don't have the same expectations for a product where I have an ongoing subscription vs a one time purchase (i.e. ignoring the scale of $ I'd expect differences in support/ongoing development/community platforms/etc). Perhaps that's a minority view however.
- scarface74 9y agoWouldn't it be just the opposite? If something is good for a business that creates a product you use, and a subscription makes it worthwhile to keep producing that product, that seems like a win-win.
- fbelzile 9y agoAgreed. I have no problem paying for subscriptions when warranted (content such as Netflix, utilities, etc...) The issue I have is when this model is applied to certain software that doesn't directly provide added value over time (like Office 365 or Photoshop). When I purchase software, I want the ability to clearly compare the available features (value) vs the cost at that specific time. This is why Sendy (https://sendy.co https://sendy.co) received my business over MailChimp (https://mailchimp.com https://mailchimp.com). The software I sell is also a pay-once model and I feel much happier knowing my customers are getting good value for their money.
- taytus 9y ago>The issue I have is when this model is applied to certain software that doesn't directly provide added value over time As a professional photographer, Photoshop does provide value over time for me and my colleagues. Why would you pay for something that you don't use? I honestly don't understand what the problem is, if something doesn't add value, then why would you pay for it?. I don't see a real "issue" here.
- Domenic_S 9y agoHe said added value over time in exchange for a subscription. Photoshop has value, that's why it's being purchased; GP is saying that the subscription doesn't add anything additional, which I kind of agree with for a program as mature as PS. It's a lease vs. buy calculation -- one site who did the math says: > However, once you get past the two year mark, all bets are off—the subscription is more expensive than buying, even if you plan on upgrading every two years. https://lifehacker.com/5904416/rent-vs-buy-is-adobes-creative-cloud-subscription-cheaper-than-buying-photoshop https://lifehacker.com/5904416/rent-vs-buy-is-adobes-creativ...
- patorjk 9y agoIf you just wanted Photoshop and not the cloud storage, your best bet would be the Photography plan, which is $10 a month and includes Photoshop and Lightroom. Placing the data in Excel, and assuming someone were to take the $585 Amazon price for Photoshop and upgrade every 2 years, it would take 14 years before that was a better deal than using the subscription plan. If you assume the $700 price tag, it takes 25 years. However, it only takes 3 years if you use the student plan numbers (though as a side note, it looks like the subscription plan is the only way to get Photoshop now).
- parliament32 9y agoAs a consumer, I think I'm starting to prefer subscription services. They ensure the company continues to provide good service, with the threat of customers leaving if they don't. Adobe's switch to the subscription model for Photoshop/Lightroom is an excellent example. I'd much rather pay $10/mo for both (plus a bunch of cloud storage) than a few hundred bucks outright (especially considering that we had to re-purchase the software anyway roughly every two years when a new version came out anyway). The subscription model is much cheaper for me, I don't have to decide between $$$ and new features anymore, and it guarantees Adobe will continue to provide support and updates to the software. The added benefit is that suspending a subscription is quite easy (away for vacation for a few months, busy semester at school, etc etc). The downside is, of course, is that subscription software can look artificially cheap but can add up quickly.
- Domenic_S 9y agoAdobe's Creative Cloud is a bad example (compared to say Netflix or Spotify) because the plan is annual, but paid monthly. The photography plan is $120/year, but they let you in effect finance the fee at 0% by letting you pay $10/month. $10/month is more palatable to many than $120 all at once, but it nullifies the threat of customers leaving. https://www.adobe.com/creativecloud/plans.html https://www.adobe.com/creativecloud/plans.html
- dingaling 9y agoThe other downside being that if you stop paying, or Adobe stops providing, you can no longer work natively with your PSD and DNG files. That's a huge business risk. And as searching for 'Creative Cloud suspended' shows, it's not theoretical.
- parliament32 9y agoDNG is an open format: "Use of the file format is royalty-free; Adobe has published a license allowing anyone to exploit DNG, and has also stated that there are no known intellectual property encumbrances or license requirements for DNG. Adobe stated that if there were a consensus that DNG should be controlled by a standards body, they were open to the idea." See also: http://www.barrypearson.co.uk/articles/dng/products_y7.htm http://www.barrypearson.co.uk/articles/dng/products_y7.htm
- CM30 9y agoAs a consumer, I dislike them because they take away control with the buyer/user. If you buy a product in the traditional sense, that's it, you own it and you can (mostly) do whatever you like with it. Resell it, trade it, modify it, keep using it after whatever DRM system is taken down... you get the choice there. The subscription trends seem like an attempt to sidestep that and remove people's freedoms so companies can dictate how their products are used. The mentioned price thing is definitely bad too though.