9 ms·
Lessons on Bubbles from Bitcoin
- lvturner 9y agoI'm pretty new to trading concepts and financial markets so I may very well be missing something obvious... but from what I can make out, both CBOE and CME futures are cash settled, so you can't actually "short" bitcoin on them, just a derivative. Further, the total volume of contracts for March works out at somewhere around 0.01% of Bitcoin's total market cap, maybe I'm missing something, but this just doesn't seem like something that could be held responsible for BTC dropping from 20k to ~7k - the only impact I could see it having is a psychological value, but then, Bitcoin has had futures from both BitMEX and OKCoin for quite some time (fee concerns and institutional accessibility aside) with significantly higher volumes.
- darawk 9y agoYa, this article doesn't really make sense in this particular case as an explanation for Bitcoin's behavior. Though in general I do agree that shorting is important for the health of a market, this Bitcoin bubble played out exactly like every other Bitcoin bubble, and in all those previous cases shorting was as difficult as its ever been (which, actually has never been that hard, to be frank - people always insist that shorting Bitcoin is so hard, but it's not at all and never has been).
- empath75 9y agoThe only markets where you can short bitcoin are sketchy overseas exchanges with low volumes and a history of problems both depositing and withdrawing money. No serious investor is going to be putting money in bitfinex or whatever to short bitcoin.
- gruez 9y ago>The only markets where you can short bitcoin are sketchy overseas exchanges probably because no reputable country's SEC equivalent would let that happen >low volumes bitfinex is one of the largest exchanges by volume >a history of problems both depositing and withdrawing money. if this is happening, it's not happening with any of the major exchanges that support margin trading. any time depositing/withdraw issues appear on an exchange, prices quickly deviate from the rest of the market as the supply of fiat/crypto diminishes.
- hapnin 9y agoYou can short Bitcoin on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange: http://www.cmegroup.com/trading/bitcoin-futures.html http://www.cmegroup.com/trading/bitcoin-futures.html
- lvturner 9y agoBut you can't... the future is a derivative of Bitcoin, not actual Bitcoin.
- nosuchthing 9y agoThe Bitmex and Bitfinex futures markets are settled in BTC and it's been blatantly clear that someone (most likely the exchange operators) are consistently manipulating the futures market (most likely to wipe out margin traders who don't know better) with short squeezes that return back to the norm within hours. https://i.imgur.com/LpgnksQ.png https://i.imgur.com/LpgnksQ.png CBOE and CME futures being cash settled is a joke, and removes any incentive for the risk associated with the long position actually acquiring BTC, further proving the large traders just want to play with the tool for speculative market volatility and not actually facilitate using or acquiring the asset itself. https://medium.com/@bitfinexed/latest https://medium.com/@bitfinexed/latest
- 21 9y agoIt's not the exchanges who are behind those spikes. Source: someone who is working on a bot doing that kind of things And because of the way the market works, there is no need to coordinate with anyone else doing it (ie: those spikes are self synchronizing) Those "manipulations" also happen in the traditional markets (forex, ...), but due to liquidity and general sophistication they are much harder to spot, and dangerous to do if you don't know what you are doing (dangerous from a financial perspective, they are perfectly legal).
- nosuchthing 9y agoIt's not the exchanges who are behind those spikes. Please. If anyone is in a position to gain the most from market manipulation like that, it's the exchanges and there's a bucket list of evidence and malicious behavior from Bitfinex that would make it very surprising if it was some random outsider causing these types of movements. Bitfinex and Bitmex margin trading volume has increased significantly and for the exchange operators have access to (1) order book + margin call data (2) ability to falsify trades and capital due to no audits With those, it becomes insanely trivial to set some bait let the fish bite and simply drain the water or pump it back in on a whim because the order book is just a database and there's no accountability or auditing to keep the market exchanges honest.
- 9y ago
- nsainsbury 9y agoIs analysis of the crypto market and the price of various coins even possible? A lot of articles seem to approach the price of coins as something that can be rationally discussed, however at the same time we all know the market is a) unregulated b) has wash trading going on and c) is heavily dominated by a handful of actors. I mean, hell, even think about the enormous power the completely unregulated exchanges hold - they could literally behind the scenes be betting against you on any single trade using knowledge you don't have. In such a market the price of any coin may not even be set by a plurality of participants. It can be set by a single motivated participant who's motivations cannot be divined (except maybe the single driving motivation: make more money for me and fuck everyone else). If you're trading in the crypto space today, you're crazy - you're sitting down for a card game expecting there to be fairness and rules, but there aren't any. The dealer can stack the deck however they want and change the rules of the game while you're playing, etc.
- 21 9y ago> In such a market the price of any coin may not even be set by a plurality of participants. Since you can take/give physical delivery of the coin that is not entirely true. Meaning that if you force the price to an unsustainable level (either too high or too low), other smart people will definitely take the other side of the trade.
- nsainsbury 9y agoNot when the buyer and seller are one and the same person. There's extensive evidence to suggest wash trading, as it's known, is endemic in the crypto space.
- nostrademons 9y agoIt's worth remembering Ben Graham's 1949 parable on Mr. Market: https://www.fs.blog/2013/11/mr-market/ https://www.fs.blog/2013/11/mr-market/ Basically, every market is basically an insane, irrational, manic-depressive, uncaring business partner who gives you the option to buy his share or sell yours every day, as long as market hours are open (in the age of cryptocurrency, this is 24/7). You are under no obligation to take the transaction, though. If you believe the price is too high, sell. If you believe the price is too low, buy. If you don't believe anything, hold. Crypto and the stock market are no different in this regard. The short-term price is equally irrational in both. (There's pretty good evidence that wash trading is endemic in the stock market as well - wasn't Goldman Sachs caught taking both sides of a transaction in the 2009 financial crisis? And many derivative strategies explicitly rely upon being both long and short at the same time.) The difference is that stock market investors have mostly figured out how to value stocks on fundamentals: the intrinsic value of a stock is all the discounted value of all future cash flows accruing to the equity investors. The intrinsic value of crypto is zero, unless, of course, it manages to replace the dollar as the world's reserve currency, in which case its intrinsic value is infinite, or more accurately the dollar's value is zero. Your estimate of the fundamental value of a cryptocurrency should be based on your assessment of the likelihood that it will replace the dollar as currency.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- paulpauper 9y agomore usual weak analysis from Bloomberg, which has become another showcase for mediocre internet writers OK..I proclaim myself the most enthusiastic person ever about bitcoin. Now why isn't the price at 20,000. By the author's logic it should be. The price fell from $20k to $6k . that is evidence that shorting is not necessary for prices to fall a lot. look at beanie babies..same thing...no short seller was needed there either. If widgets are selling for $200 dollars and no one one wants to pay $200 , then prices fall or no widgets are sold.
- strken 9y agoYou haven't bought at $20000, so your optimism is irrelevant. If you continued to buy at any market rate under $20000, then the market rate would rise towards $20000 until you either went bankrupt or bought out every seller less optimistic than you, at which point you would no longer be the most optimistic buyer.
- eksemplar 9y agoYou can short bitcoin, and many have during the crash from 20 to 6.
- f_allwein 9y ago> The housing bubble is another example where betting against the asset in question was extremely difficult. Interesting - while you can sell your shares in company X, you wouldn’t sell your house because you think the market might go down. On the other hand, if there were futures options on the housing market, would that help to lower prices?
- dredmorbius 9y agoREITs.
- kgwgk 9y agoYou can sell your house and move to a rented one, some people do that when they think the market will go down.
- DSingularity 9y agoI think the actors in crypto have no shame. I love crypto, love the potential of the tech -- but does anybody doubt that coinbase, bitfinex, kraken, poloniex -- all the exchanges just flat out robbed people? When the narratives aligned they pumped/dumped. Then they have no shame. Poloniex gets bought up. Coinbase/gdax announce venture capital arm. Its almost like they sucked too much money selling hopes and dreams to consumers, and now that SEC is watching closely they cannot keep pump and dumping the market. Just look at the volume drop. Honestly, the democratized/decentralized characteristics everyone promotes is a bunch of bull until someone shows me a way democratically bootstrap ownership without total failures like Satoshi owning 20,000,000,000$ worth of BTC or a couple of whales owning 50% of the ETH supply because they bought when it was worth pennies and after BTC went up 10-1000x. This whole thing seems to just be another means for wealth transfer.
- adventured 9y agoThe Satoshi example isn't very interesting until or unless those coins start moving. Short of that, over time he has done the broader Bitcoin community a tremendous service by restricting the maximum potential supply of sellable coins. His position, and that it will likely never be dumped, has acted as an anchor of some stability. It's a vast supply of coins that the market doesn't have to worry about torpedoing the price. Seeing as it appears to be permanently locked up, and the market very clearly believes that, the market is distributing his value to other Bitcoin holders (equivalent to destroying those coins). If those coins had been fully distributed, the condition of the Bitcoin market would be that much worse presently.
- wz1000 9y agoOf course, the condition of the Bitcoin market would have been much better if Satoshi had set a hard limit of 1 bitcoin instead of 21 million.
- csomar 9y agoI can agree and discuss the wealth transfer mantra on the crypto scene today. But what does exchanges have to do with that? They, supposedly, don't have any stake at any coin. They make money with trading volume. I assume, a reasonable one will understand that it is in their best interest to have the market grow instead of spike trading volume on pump/dump events.
- tim333 9y agoWhile I see their hypothesis that the decline in bitcoin from 20k to 6k was related to the introduction of the futures market there are lots of details that seem iffy. For example: Bitcoin had many crashes in previous years The dotcom boom had a fine boom and bust in spite of there being a futures market The US housing bubble also did a big boom and bust without a good futures market or way to short houses (yeah I know some people kind of did by proxy in The Big Short but it was hard) "price will be set by the most upbeat buyer" is kind of wrong. The price will be set by dealing between the largest buyers and sellers. If people are selling millions worth at $6k some guy who thinks its worth $100k but who only has $1000 to invest isn't going to move the market You've been able to short bitcoin on BitMex since 2015, though using crypto rather than fiat
- pietrod 9y agototally trash, an average people can check real influence of that "futures" thing by himself here: http://cfe.cboe.com/cfe-products/xbt-cboe-bitcoin-futures http://cfe.cboe.com/cfe-products/xbt-cboe-bitcoin-futures there is actually more volume in cash on localbitcoin in a rural village in India in an hour than there in a whole day... ps, also to short something you need to borrow the asset and pay for the time of the borrowing, this is bitcoin is really difficult, because pricing can be really high, holding means covering you from the risk of losing next "bubble", if you lose that for a miserable 1%/day you are losing all the point of that asset basically, so these things can happens only in the naive minds of wall street traders than don't have a real model for bitcoin yet, but just go on bitfinex and see by yourself if it's good to you to borrow bitcoin to people who want to short, as i say before, everything in this space can be checked, this old people with they old analysis are just extremely boring and meaningless.
- csomar 9y agoShorting futures doesn't require borrowing bitcoin. You usually also get paid on it (though recently the market has been on backwardation, so you pay). But the cost is kind of upfront.
- factsaresacred 9y ago> Was this a coincidence? Maybe. Most likely. Here's Arthur Hayes, CEO of Bitmex, explaining it: > "The short pressure at its logical maximum emanating from the CME and CBOE contract holders is meaningless. Therefore, the effect on the broader market in actual flows is negligible. The contracts mainly bolster traders’ bullish sentiment....In terms of trading volume, BitMEX continues to blow both of these contracts out of the water. In the year to date, the BitMEX XBTUSD, XBTH18, and XBTM18 products traded a combined $53.14 billion versus CME and CBOE combined Bitcoin futures volume of $4.48 billion. BitMEX is 12x more liquid." And: > "The large financial institutions do not own Bitcoin in large quantities, if at all. They are hamstrung by KYC/AML concerns surrounding Bitcoin. That means that if they wanted to sell Bitcoin, they would need to borrow it from a credible counterparty. Hey, Cumberland Mining, can we borrow $100 million of Bitcoin?......Assuming banks borrowed Bitcoin with the intention of shorting it, they would need to sell it on an exchange. Given the skittishness that inhibits counterparties globally from placing large amounts of capital on an exchange, I highly doubt any compliance department at a bulge-bracket bank would approve opening an account. > Let’s suspend reality and assume they allowed trading desks to open accounts on the largest Bitcoin spot exchanges. The maximum the desk could make is 100% if Bitcoin went to zero. But, if the market instead face-ripped them by 50% on a $100-million position, that loss would reach the global head of trading and of the investment bank. > If you were the line executive that green-lit that trade, you would lose your job. You shorted Bitcoin, and lost a huge sum of money. That would make it into the financial press; you and your bank would be ridiculed."
- csomar 9y ago> The maximum the desk could make is 100% if Bitcoin went to zero. That's an interesting statement coming from someone whose exchange allows x100 leverage. You can make more than 100% of your initial investment if you leverage more.
- lifty 9y agoYou can do that fairly easy when you are trading on a 10k account. It is more difficult with a 100 million account when you are a bank.
- mathgenius 9y agoVolume traded on CME futures has been insignificant until about two weeks ago [1]. Click on the chart icon and look at the volume bar graph. Each contract is worth 5 BTC. Looks like they are doing about 10,000 BTC per day now. So I don't agree with this article at all. CBOE bitcoin futures is much smaller, but they are also doing about 2500 BTC per day [2]. [1] http://www.cmegroup.com/trading/equity-index/us-index/bitcoin.html http://www.cmegroup.com/trading/equity-index/us-index/bitcoi... [2] https://markets.cboe.com/us/futures/market_statistics/daily/ https://markets.cboe.com/us/futures/market_statistics/daily/
- pc2g4d 9y agoCan futures really affect the price of Bitcoin when they're settled in USD?