3 ms·
So your contention is that structural oligopolies (or markets with monopolistic competition) should not be regulated? That's nowhere in my argument. I merely p
by joe_the_user 9y ago
So your contention is that structural oligopolies (or markets with monopolistic competition) should not be regulated?
That's nowhere in my argument. I merely pointed that government grant monopolies pretty much automatically should be regulated since they are virtually extensions of government fiat already ("we" give Comcast etc a monopoly on placement on phone poles and similar stuff, we should get something for that) and that this situation isn't comparable to monopolistic competition.
If you're curious, I think actual private companies should be regulated when their actions involve negative externalities [1] in their production process - chemical companies should not be able to dump toxins into rivers, broadly greenhouse gases should be limited, etc.
One might argue that Facebook selling people's data to the highest bidder is another kind of negative externality. I would argue that a better outcome is consumer education, gradually people learn whatever they post online has a significant risk of being public. Similarly, it's better for people to learn not to be manipulated by simple schemes than to imagine a firewall against the manipulations of evil people. Just consider that a firewall against manipulations of evil people would let in the manipulation of "good people", right? Perhaps that's the whole idea.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality
- rayiner 9y ago> we" give Comcast etc a monopoly on placement on phone poles and similar stuff, we should get something for that) and that this situation isn't comparable to monopolistic competition. Comcast doesn’t have a monopoly on placing things on utility poles. Poles are mostly owned by power companies or the local phone company, and those entities are required to lease pole space to everyone at non-discriminatory rates.