6 ms·
You know what's interesting? A Decentralised media platform used to be huge and actually is still huge: Torrents. There's a huge community that consumes media
by mrtksn 9y ago
You know what's interesting? A Decentralised media platform used to be huge and actually is still huge: Torrents.
There's a huge community that consumes media that's not hosted anywhere particular and there are apps like Popcorn Time that offer viewing experience almost as good as Netflix.
The problem, of course, is that up until now there was no way to reward the creators and almost all the media consumed on Torrents is illicit copies of copyrighted material that don't bring direct benefits to its creators.
It is a huge topic in the blockchain community to find a way to reward content creators and we see early attempts that may or may not succeed at this.
Another issue is the "Averagisation" of the content. The moment that you make a content that advertisers might find controversial you risk losing your reward for that content so advertising financed media fails to capture anything beyond the mainstream entertainment. This has another unfortunate outcome, which is that people who don't want to get a direct reward for their content but hoping to be rewarded with political influence can afford to continue producing content that tends to be extremist(veganism, left and right politics, racism, conspiracy theories - you name it). So we end up with extremely light content that's something between product unboxing and funny videos not touching any sensitive topic and extremely edgy content that depicts the world as black and white and if you are not one of us you are one of them. Your average monetised content on Youtube is extremely light and your average popular non-monetised conted is extremeley heavy.
At this time you'll find that these new decentralised platforms are full of the extremist's stuff, as it is just another platform to spread their influence but in the long run, I believe that they will be diluted and will offer a platform where non-extremist but alternative cultures can flourish.
- realusername 9y agoYou have people trying to mix cryptocurrencies and torrents as well to achieve this exact purpose. The two main ones I know are Upfiring (https://www.upfiring.com/ https://www.upfiring.com/) and VTorrent (http://vtorrent.info/ http://vtorrent.info/)
- ctraynor 9y agoCan you give a bit more detail on the term "Averagisation", couldn't find much about it from a quick google. What you describe sounds more like polarization.
- mrtksn 9y agoI just coined that word, but you are right that it is polarisation in a sense that it's either too light or too heavy. However, what I mean by "Averagisation" is that all the content begins to look like the previous one and as the trend is to drift either to the most monetizable or most politically extremist. I wouldn't call this polarisation because these are not polar opposites. The "nice, advertisers friendly" content is not polar opposite to the extremist content, they co-exist without any conflict. So, the content becomes more from the same, just they are in two categories.
- catamorphismic 9y ago"Uniformization" sounds like a better fit, if we are searching for a more conventional word.
- mrtksn 9y agoMaybe. I just don't want to use a well-established word to tag a new phenomenon because people can start judging the situation by the wider meaning of the word "Uniformization" or maybe different people will understand something different. Instead, I coin a word and proceed to explain it. I find that using words with precise technical definitions or words that are jargons is dangerous in an informal context.
- lmm 9y agoSounds analogous to Stross' concept of a "beige dictatorship" in politics.
- gr33nman 9y agoOr “Homogenization”
- bitxbitxbitcoin 9y agoI think this is the more established term.
- 9y ago
- hjek 9y ago<s> Such a big problem with people hoping to be rewarded with political influence. Even Paul McCartney has been diluting Youtube with extremist videos[1] about veganism. </s> [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NnNFryHonQo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NnNFryHonQo
- mrtksn 9y agoI think I just triggered a Vegan :) I have respect for Vegans despite being a huge meat lover. What I mean by extremism is that Vegans are extreme and controversial form certain philosophies and eating habits and those serious about Veganism more often than not claiming that people who eat meat are murderers and should be treated as such, framing this as "Us the spotless goodies vs them unredeemable baddies". In my books, that's extremism. But hey, I get your point and I'm more than excited about lab grown burgers so we can have all the meat we want without harming the animals.
- acjohnson55 9y agoI think you may be conflating vegans in general with extremist vegans. Perhaps most normal vegans simply don't create YouTube content.
- logfromblammo 9y agoVegans are already extremist vegetarians. Extremist vegans are extremism squared.
- bloak 9y agoWe already have Quorn burgers and they're great. The problem with going vegan isn't burgers; it's decent cheese, and milk to put in my tea. And something to replace eggs in cake. And something to make boots out of if veganism is to go beyond food. I hope these problems will be solved one day. We can't stop animals from getting harmed. They harm each other in the wild in terrible ways. All we can do is keep our own hands and mouths clean and avoid trashing the environment with livestock farming on an industrial scale.
- Shoue 9y agoYou also (unintentionally?) shed light on a potential link between cryptocurrency rewards and piracy authors. Given the progress in the Confidential Transactions world, e.g. RingCT and Bulletproofs, which could – whether you think this is bad or not – significantly incentivise pirates.
- cornholio 9y agoYou certainly don't need blockchains and distributed databases to reward creators, centralized solutions like Patreon work perfectly fine. If you want Netflix style monetization, that is not a technical problem but a social one, Netflix relies on the concept of copyright. Any community that does not respect copyright will switch to the free alternative, leaving voluntary donations as the only monetization option. Maybe there is a blockchain niche where content is offered freely but ad supported, with the experience painless enough not to motivate users to switch to the ad-free alternative. The revenue would then be necessarily modest, but would be redirected to the creators almost in full, compensating the massive Youtube cut.
- koonsolo 9y agoI don't agree with your Netflix story. Most people don't prefer free, they prefer convenience. Spotify almost works properly as a centralized platform because almost all music is on there. But I know a few albums that aren't, and it's too bad. For Netflix, I have a subscription. But guess what I do when I want to watch the latest Walking Dead or Game of Thrones. I want it convenient, preferably legal, but most of all convenient.
- ghaff 9y agoHow is subscribing to HBO inconvenient? It's a combination of price and convenience. There's some upper limit to the monthly price you (and everyone else) is willing to pay for content.
- rusk 9y agoWell for me, in my jurisdiction HBO just simply isn't available. That's hands down about as inconvenient as you can get. In jurisdictions where it is available it's often only available as a part of a larger cable package. If you're signed up with another provider that's pretty inconvenient also. There is a well worn cartoon on this topic that sums up the position of many quite well [0] [0] http://theoatmeal.com/comics/game_of_thrones http://theoatmeal.com/comics/game_of_thrones
- rectang 9y ago> It is a huge topic in the blockchain community to find a way to reward content creators and we see early attempts that may or may not succeed at this. What of the "information wants to be free" faction which is indifferent or hostile to the idea of content creators being rewarded? I expect there continue to be polarization where most creators of commercially viable content remain within establishment channels despite all their problems. Both hand economic power to distributors over creators, but only the upstarts pursue the ideological delegitimization of creators.
- pjc50 9y agoI don't think the faction is "hostile to the idea of content creators being rewarded" per se, but people are hostile to content middlemen being rewarded, and they're hostile to what I call "content prevention services": the real work of MPAA et al is not in distributing content, but in preventing content from being distributed.
- rectang 9y agoThey're fine with content creators selling t-shirts, but they are hostile to the idea of creators being compensated for the distribution of their creations, or having any control at all over the propagation of their work -- because that necessarily constrains the ability to copy "information" at will. The big winners in a world without copyright are ISPs, who achieve instant vertical integration of both content and distribution -- facilitating end-user lockin to their portals.
- pjc50 9y ago> that necessarily constrains the ability to copy "information" at will. Well, yes. The alternative would have been to give the music and video industry a total veto over all consumer electronics, including computers, all operating systems, all content manipulation software, and so on. This would also have included repeated charges for moving media between devices and premiums for certain types of use; setting a song as your ringtone would cost several dollars, for example. There would be no Spotify and no Netflix. There might not be a Youtube, but if there was it would be impossible to watch it on Linux using only Free software. There might be iPods, but you'd have to re-buy all your music for each device. There might not even be videotapes. The end-user lockin would be at absurd levels. The only middle ground is a scorched no-mans-land.
- grdeken 9y agoHave you looked into LBRY?
- amelius 9y agoPerhaps the biggest problem with Youtube is discoverability. Youtube's algorithms determine what you will see next. How is that solved on the decentralized platforms? How does discoverability work, what assumptions does it make, and can it be "gamed"?
- Sabinus 9y agoWhy does the algorithm have to show you what content to watch? Just have it a good search and tagging system and the user will figure out what they need.
- macintux 9y agoSurfacing content you don't know you want is something an algorithm can be quite good at. I don't know that I would have ever discovered HISHE, for example, without it.
- PeterisP 9y agoA search system cannot replace a recommender system and vice versa, they are very different use cases with very different needs. For any type of media, whether it's songs/bands on a music streaming service, video content on youtube, or even complementary goods in an online store, a good recommender system can and will suggest things that I would never have thought of (because I didn't know it existed) and thus could never have found with any search or tagging system. How do I search for a song that's similar to those that I listened just now (and genre tags don't really work, they're far too broad, subjective and inaccurate) and that's explicitly not one of the songs which I remembered and just heard already?
- sparkzilla 9y agoIt depends what you mean by "discoverability". YouTube's algorithmic search may surface related videos, but what if you want to discover other views of a topic, for example, a timeline of all the news, including videos, on a topic[1]? That's not really a decentralization problem, more of a curation problem. http://newslines.org/the-slow-readers-club/ http://newslines.org/the-slow-readers-club/
- 9y ago
- eaenki 9y agoSince when not eating meat and animal derivatives is considered extremist? I actually find this very same sentence to be extreme..ly.. stupid.
- bonesinger 9y agoThis is exactly what TRX (Tronix) cryptocurrency is trying to achieve. They want content creators on their blockchain to distribute content and want to reward them with coin as payment. https://cryptocurrencynews.com/altcoin/tron-trx/ https://cryptocurrencynews.com/altcoin/tron-trx/
- kafquaesque 9y agoVegans are not that extreme—some people do it for religious reasons (i.e. Hinduism), some for health reasons, and some due to their moral beliefs. Maybe you are referring to the extreme actions by the vegan recently?
- jayd16 9y agoBitcoin and bit torrent suffer from the same decentralization problem. Centralization will always be cheaper or the system will fail to sustain itself. Either these systems are not profitable to participate in and no one bothers, or it is profitable at which point it will be dominated by key players that either participate in the network or simply launch a centralized competitor. Specialization leads to cost cuttings and the large actors increase their quality, margins and market share squeezing out the decentralized players. The one caveat to this is that torrents are cool because its a system that can arguably edge cache better than CDN locations but with today's low upload speeds and pings for consumer connections it seems the CDNs do win.
- paool 9y agoNot exactly what you had in mind, but checkout Joystream. https://joystream.co https://joystream.co You basically get paid in crypto (Bitcoin Cash) for seeding torrents. Inversely, you can also pay BCH to get "high priority" speeds. as for a platform to reward content creators, check out https://yours.org https://yours.org